Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not supplying my brother and SIL with breastmilk

362 replies

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · 12/11/2026 09:50

You are absolutely NOT unreasonable to say no. What a strange ask. I know of sitautions where siblings have BF/ provided milk to either neices/ nephews but this is normally (1) offered and (2) in an emergency situation, not just becuase they are tired and don't want to use formula to supplment. Say no, and forget about it.

RampantIvy · 12/11/2026 09:51

I found breastfeeding really hard to establish as well. It took about 12 weeks before it became much easier.

You are right to stick to your guns. Your SIL needs to persevere as not feeding regularly might affect her milk supply.

Just say no.

CarpetofBluebells · 12/11/2026 09:51

They are ridiculous! And rude!

Tulipsriver · 12/11/2026 09:51

I would reply honestly:

"Hi DB, I'm sorry SIL is struggling. I know I don't share very much but I have found breastfeeding very taxing, both emotionally and physically myself. I'm happy to give her some tips but I can't give you any milk. Unfortunately I only have the supply and energy to feed my own baby".

Avie29 · 12/11/2026 09:53

Wow just wow, I don’t think DB or SIL really understand, even if you could pump a few bottles (in my experience pumping is no where near effective even after 6months i could barely get 4oz pumping) that would mean your supply would be low to feed your own baby, tell them to sod off and get some formula you are not a milk machine.

BeardieWeirdie · 12/11/2026 09:53

I had oversupply and could hand express 100ml in 5 minutes and gladly donated 50L to the milk bank. I’d still feel no guilt in saying no to this demand! Having milk from elsewhere is only going to make breastfeeding harder for her. Mum’s job (if she wants to) is to feed baby and dad’s job is to feed mum - she needs to get comfy on the sofa, do skin-to-skin while dad brings dinner and drinks to her, not just demand access to your boobs.

RandomMess · 12/11/2026 09:54

Ironically you may not be able to pump any anyway! I only could in the early days when I was super engorged.

So you could just say as you aren’t able to hand express any it’s highly unlikely you would be able to express and you don’t have the time or energy to commit to trying.

🤦🏼‍♀️

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 12/11/2026 09:56

Its very odd.

I am not even sure your breastmilk would be suitable for a newborn.

For minimum friction i would nod and smile let them send it, do nothing with the pump... then say you tried for HOURS and now you are just EXHAUSTED but you just cant seem to pump a drop (some women cant)

So while you are the best sister / SIL in the world they should never ask again.

MrEdwardElizabethHitler · 12/11/2026 09:56

I bet your brother and father have substantial breastfeeding expertise, and are well qualified to tell from vibes alone whether a lactating woman is able to successfully pump.

Apricothairy · 12/11/2026 09:57

Say no, it could potentially cause supply problems for your baby and her baby, cluster feeding is a thing for a reason

AmicaNemica · 12/11/2026 09:57

I thought the composition of breast milk from newborn to 6 months is different (colostrum/thin vs more fatty?). Prepared to be corrected though!

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:57

It would be.

No!

Mulledjuice · 12/11/2026 09:58

if she is keen to EBF then she needs to pump to build her supply (if she's not able to feed baby directly at the moment). she also needs to keep putting baby to the breast. You pumping would be counter-productive.

Chilihealer · 12/11/2026 09:59

If you’ve never pumped before you might find that a pump collects very little, I could never pump much myself I’d get 8ounces a day in literal drips and drops. Not to mention supply doesn’t work like that, if you are successful pumping you could potentially be taking a feed from your own child until supply increases it can take a few days to fully adjust. If you was a massive oversupplied and had a freezer stash I’d say share but just simply producing more on the spot and pumping just isn’t as easy as it sounds. From a breastfeeding mum and volunteer lactation consultant x

Chunkybabythighs · 12/11/2026 09:59

Her having 'time off' and using your milk would fuck her supply anyway so it's a bad idea, I'd tell them that and say you're not a dairy factory you cheeky shits, course she's tired it's very tiring!!

ShodAndShadySenators · 12/11/2026 10:00

BF can be really difficult to get going properly but there are agencies out there who will help and advise with it, not least the midwives/health visitors who should be visiting to see her anyway. Why isn't she asking for help from them? It's literally their job, not yours!

Plus your milk for your six month old is not the same as the milk that SIL's body will be producing for her newborn, and you are not being unreasonable to say no either way. If you supplement her supply will be affected (and it's SOOO cheeky to ask when there are plenty other options available!)

Pearleen · 12/11/2026 10:00

Wow, that's an absolute cheek. I didn't find bfing hard but I still wouldn't do it for anyone but my dc, no one has the right to your milk and formula is fine if they can't manage it.

MellowSubmarine · 12/11/2026 10:00

That is so completely ridiculous of them.

YANBU at all. I’d be so upset if my parents thought I was unreasonable for saying no to this “easy” request!

Chilihealer · 12/11/2026 10:00

Advice for her would be a Hakka pump on the opposite boob at every feed she should be able to collect extra milk from that

sesquipedalian · 12/11/2026 10:01

Quite apart from any other consideration, BF is a matter of supply and demand. If she uses your milk, then she’ll produce less of her own. You also j ie that if you say yes to this, you’ll end up becoming a sort of wet nurse to DB’s child. Ignore your family: concentrate on your own LO and leave them to sort out theirs. We’ve all been tired with a new baby!!

BusyGreySnail · 12/11/2026 10:01

She's actgually not doing herself any favours either by supplementing if she really wants to EBF. The more she feeds the more she will build her supply. It's different if she can't, or isn't producing a lot of milk, but if it's just because she wants a break from BFing that's likely to make things harder rather than better in terms of supply.

Mischance · 12/11/2026 10:02

If it was easy for you and yu have excess supply then not unreasonable to offer, but in your circumstances it has to be a no. It is quite wrong of them to put you under pressure.

My DD had gallons to spare and shared with a friend who could not bf - but it was a voluntary act on her part.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/11/2026 10:02

Tell her to call the national breastfeeding helpline. Sounds like she needs some support.

Being tired is part of being a parent. Its not a reason to ask someone else to do this for you. In an emergency fine. This isn't one.

fashionqueen0123 · 12/11/2026 10:03

MrEdwardElizabethHitler · 12/11/2026 09:56

I bet your brother and father have substantial breastfeeding expertise, and are well qualified to tell from vibes alone whether a lactating woman is able to successfully pump.

I know this did make me laugh. They said she'd fine it easy? Why dont they have a go themselves to just pump out an extra couple of bottles.

Wait a minute.. why doesnt the mum!

AngelinaFibres · 12/11/2026 10:03

AmicaNemica · 12/11/2026 09:57

I thought the composition of breast milk from newborn to 6 months is different (colostrum/thin vs more fatty?). Prepared to be corrected though!

I thought too. Mine are in their 30s but I seem to remember that breast milk changes according to YOUR babies needs. Not the needs of other people's babies

Swipe left for the next trending thread