Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not supplying my brother and SIL with breastmilk

363 replies

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

OP posts:
EdithBond · 12/11/2026 22:35

BeardieWeirdie · 12/11/2026 09:53

I had oversupply and could hand express 100ml in 5 minutes and gladly donated 50L to the milk bank. I’d still feel no guilt in saying no to this demand! Having milk from elsewhere is only going to make breastfeeding harder for her. Mum’s job (if she wants to) is to feed baby and dad’s job is to feed mum - she needs to get comfy on the sofa, do skin-to-skin while dad brings dinner and drinks to her, not just demand access to your boobs.

This 100%

Your milk wouldn’t be suited to a newborn. Her milk would. If she doesn’t let her baby feed enough it’ll affect her supply.

I EBFed all of mine. It’s tiring and uncomfortable to begin with but you have to persevere and then it gets easier. You need to eat a lot of healthy food (made by other people) and get plenty of rest. Fennel seed tea can help.

TempestTost · 12/11/2026 22:37

I had a lot of supply with my older kids, but I wouldn't have been keen on this .

The main reason being it's not great for her to establish her supply.

I'd also say, use formula if you need to supplement a bit. Or she could try and pump a bottle and leave it with your brother so she could nap.

If there was a real issue with a baby that had a compromised immune system it might be different. But this solution doesn't make much sense.

Pyjamatimenow · 12/11/2026 22:43

Amazon you!? Jesus Christ!! I’ve heard it all now. Not everyone can pump. You’re not Daisy the dairy cow. Cheeky beggars and weird to boot!!

Fortuity · 12/11/2026 22:49

My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy

Just ask each of them precisely what is their source for that information, and ask if they've tried saying the same to your SIL.

SplishSplash123 · 12/11/2026 23:21

Probably nothing to add that hasn't already been said - but definitely YANBU!

I mean, you don't need to give any reasons. Its your body, no is no etc.

They clearly have no idea how breastfeeding actually works and how much hard work is needed in those early weeks to establish supply. Suggest she discusses her "plan" with a local breastfeeding support team, I imagine they would talk her out of it!

Finally, a huge well done on making it to 6 months! I recently weaned my little one after 18 months of feeding, but I still remember that reaching the 6 month mark felt like a huge milestone after enduring a difficult start to the process like you.

rainingsnoring · 12/11/2026 23:24

YANBU at all @Seloos. They are unbelievably cheeky for putting so much pressure on you, even wanting to 'Amazon you a pump'! The comment from your parents are brother about how you would find it easy makes me really cross on your behalf. Your father and brother, who have zero experience of breast feeding, should not be commenting at all.
Apart from all this, it's not in SIL or the new baby's best interest. If SIL genuinely wants to EBF, she needs to put in the required effort, rather than pulling out after a few days because she is tired. Tiredness comes with the territory. Most women find breast feeding hard to establish with their first baby but that effort is usually worth it. She will never establish a supply if she gives up straight away. Also, milk for a 6 month baby is not suitable for a newborn baby.

Sleepyjeans · 12/11/2026 23:42

They're entitled and disgusting. You're not a cow for milking, this is YOUR body. I wouldn't have dignified this with any kind of discussion.

I'd have said "No." and then blocked them both if they asked again.

katepilar · 12/11/2026 23:43

This is so cheeky and bizzare!
How do you even phrase such a request??

DaringShaker · 13/11/2026 00:01

The reasons you give around only having the supply and energy to feed your own baby is more than enough. But for good measure I would also state that it would be against research and reading that you’ve done on breast milk, as the milk that a woman produces for a newborn is very different to the milk that you produce for your baby’s age. They would be depriving their baby of essential fatty elements and colostrum that you are no longer producing. Good luck OP, this is such an outrageous ask.

Laurmolonlabe · 13/11/2026 00:06

sueelleker · 12/11/2026 18:19

Perhaps they're thinking it will be cheaper than buying formula?

This is not a good reason to agree, and incredibly cheeky.

Sleepyjeans · 13/11/2026 00:08

DaringShaker · 13/11/2026 00:01

The reasons you give around only having the supply and energy to feed your own baby is more than enough. But for good measure I would also state that it would be against research and reading that you’ve done on breast milk, as the milk that a woman produces for a newborn is very different to the milk that you produce for your baby’s age. They would be depriving their baby of essential fatty elements and colostrum that you are no longer producing. Good luck OP, this is such an outrageous ask.

Really, she should have given no reasons at all and not entered into any discussion over their strange, intrusive and entitled request. The entire response should have simply been "No" with no further engagement on the topic of any kind.

Izsy · 13/11/2026 00:21

YANBU at all!

Also - If you supply her baby - her own supply will never meet what the baby needs , also if baby is given a bottle (of any milk) bf will become much more difficult for baby and her.

Izsy · 13/11/2026 00:25

Also pumping can be a nightmare and make you really sore.
When I used a pump I was so sore after but had to as I was at work and needed to keep my supply up
to give baby saved bottles.

Anonanonay · 13/11/2026 00:30

Tell them to hire a wet nurse. Cheeky fuckers.

JJWT · 13/11/2026 01:47

What the actual fuck does it take to get 100% on here?! I mean, come on now, seriously?!!

Op, what a shame you're about to develop mastitis.... i hear its painful. Especially if trying to use a pump!

Diblin93 · 13/11/2026 02:42

No. Refuse. You’re not a cow

Sleepyjeans · 13/11/2026 02:47

JJWT · 13/11/2026 01:47

What the actual fuck does it take to get 100% on here?! I mean, come on now, seriously?!!

Op, what a shame you're about to develop mastitis.... i hear its painful. Especially if trying to use a pump!

Men who hate women lurk on the boards, and will hit yabu just for a laugh. Also, some women truly hate other women too.

Zanatdy · 13/11/2026 03:58

Bat shit. She won’t build a supply by resting and using donor milk. She needs to start feeding regularly or pumping regularly. He’s crazy if he thinks you have spare milk, doesn’t always work like that. So entitled. Unbelievably so.

Granville82 · 13/11/2026 04:21

No way! I do worry about pumping as it's now being to separate women from their babies (see other posts here about really awful DH and his family demanding more bottles so they could feed baby), and generally commodotise breastfeeding.

TheUndomesticGoddess87 · 13/11/2026 07:46

I haven't read all the comments but this is just weird. Of course breastmilk will always be the best option for babies and if she wants to persevere then she needs to get support. However, we are extremely lucky to live in a country with access to clean water and steralising equipment so formula is perfectly safe to use and will nourish baby if SIL does not want to continue or needs to supplement. That needs to be their answer not making inappropriate demands on your body.

honeylulu · 13/11/2026 07:57

They are vvv cheeky obviously but it's crazy how people assume it's so easy to "just pump a few bottles of milk". Unless you have an oversupply it's much more complex than that. Plus a lot of women just don't have any success with a pump anyway.

When mine were bf I would express enough milk for my husband to do the late feed. So I could get some sleep and it also made sure they wouldn't bottle refuse when I had to go back to work. But to get enough milk for just that one feed, I would have to express small amounts 3-4 times during the day, carefully timed so I had enough milk for the daytime breastfeeds. It was time consuming, tiring, inconvenient and a pain. I would not have done that for any baby except my own.

jeaux90 · 13/11/2026 08:05

Just say no. No excuses about why.

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 13/11/2026 09:27

This is one of those rare posts that I’m super invested in an update! What have you said to your BIL @OP?

abracadabra1111 · 13/11/2026 09:31

I wouldn’t just be able to donate milk in that way. I pump give or take what my baby feeds on every single day. There may be a slight difference of around 50 to 100ml.

also, I would feel a bit miffed about being asked, my baby was born at 33 weeks after a placenta abruption. I was in absolute agony, waking up from surgery, and was encouraged to start hand expressing. I was so determined and it was absolute hard work recovering from surgery waking up every three hours to hand express a few drops, but I persevered.

Therealjudgejudy · 13/11/2026 09:33

What entitled lunatics you have in your family!!

Shut this down straight away op.