Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not supplying my brother and SIL with breastmilk

363 replies

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

OP posts:
Mosaic80 · 12/11/2026 10:25

Absolutely not! This is so unbelievably cheeky. I ebf'd for 2 years first time and 7 months second time but never managed to produce more than 30 ml at a time via the pump and it was such a horrible feeling. I can still remember sitting up at 11pm (the only time I had a gap between feeds big enough to pump) and gathering together 30 ml at a time to try and make up one bottle so I could go somewhere. It'll also affect her supply if she starts supplementing and could cause issues.

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 12/11/2026 10:26

It’d be a hard no from me with polite empathy for how hard it is in the early days and contact details for a lactation consultant. She needs someone to help her with feeding, not to confuse her boobs and her baby’s brand new digestive system with someone else’s milk.

Well done on 6 months of breastfeeding, those early days are very hard and it takes a bit of bloody minded determination to get through the newborn phase.

Theroadt · 12/11/2026 10:26

Say no, but don’t give reasons that they will see as an invitation to unpick/argue. Just say “no, sorry. That isn’t going to work my end”. Rinse and repeat. If they ever bring it up later (as a gripe) : “I didn’t particularly mind being asked, but I said no, as I have every right to do, and I’m not going to discuss it further.”

Johnogroats · 12/11/2026 10:26

Bloody hell! I found BF easy, but pumping was a pain in the arse and took forever. Even if I was minded to help (which I wouldn’t be) it would not have been possible. Seriously rude or at very least thoughtless CFs.

DiNozzoComingBack · 12/11/2026 10:27

I don't think you should give them the milk, no.

I do think however that you are clearly a bit resentful of the fact that they share and so get support but you don't share and so you don't and I don't think that's fair. I suspect that as they did have problems getting pregnant, you just appearing to spontaneously get pregnant would be perfectly reasonable for them to assume it was easy for you. Perhaps it's a bit insensitive to say something, but as someone who has gone through fertility issues while my sister just sort of half heartedly thought about getting pregnant and BAM, she was, I actually get where they're coming from on that.

Pinkflamingo10 · 12/11/2026 10:28

Yanbu. Point them in the direction of the nearest lactation consultant or infant feeding team /la Leche league for support. If they gave 2 bottles of your milk she may hinder her own supply- sounds like her baby is cluster feeding ? They need professional support it sounds like.
if you pumped two bottles of milk today that’s less milk for your own baby. Many breastfeeding women can’t pump anyway especially in high volumes like that, or simply don’t want the faff of pumping. Yanbu.

Error404FucksNotFound · 12/11/2026 10:28

Just tell them no, milk changes as your child gets older and milk for your 6 month old would not be good for a newborn, even if you could pump it for them, which you cant.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 12/11/2026 10:28

@Seloos

For avoidance of doubt its INSANE that your parents are wading in to agree with this.

I feel like there must be massive backstory

FizzyPopLove · 12/11/2026 10:29

If she wants to EBF then she needs to persevere herself.

I would keep up your boundaries with these too as they appear to takers and not shy about it.

rosagarten · 12/11/2026 10:30

You would be doing your SIL a disservice if you said yes. She needs to breastfeed more at this stage to get the milk going. Maybe frame your response in that way or just say no? It is a very strange ask, I have to say.

SpreadsheetLife · 12/11/2026 10:31

This is one of the weirdest things I've ever heard, I would be really shocked if my sister in law asked this of me!!

Also, at six months, if you have not pumped before, it will not be easy to just pump a few bottles - your supply will be established and you would need to artificially create an oversupply with a pumping schedule. I never really pumped regularly and if I wanted to leave my baby for an evening, it could take me two days to pump a full feed!

FlatCatYellowMat · 12/11/2026 10:32

I never managed to pump much, and actively hated the feeling of doing it, so there's no way I would entertain this (and any of the men/non-BFers suggesting it would be easy would be getting a very hard look and the sharp end of my tongue!)

As everyone is saying - it's really tough at first (even when my second took to it easily unlike my first, the afterpains were cripplingly painful), and you have to decide what your own point of supplementing is and if you've reached it, but even if you do reach that point, the solution isn't to blackmail another mother into doing it when she doesn't want to.

TimetoPour · 12/11/2026 10:32

There are so many reasons why this would be inappropriate.
New babies need new baby milk (colostrum)
To establish a good breastfeeding latch it is better to avoid bottle feeding for a short period of time
Her supply will not increase
Your supply will be affected
Its time you don’t have

She needs to speak to her midwife/health visitor or a breast feeding consultant if she is struggling with latch. If she is just tired, she needs to suck it up like every other parent. Sleep between feeds, eat well, babies father can deal with everything else.

What does she think everyone else does? So entitled.

Brickiscool · 12/11/2026 10:33

Pumping is exceptionally difficult. Your body is making the right amount for your six month old. You won't suddenly have two bottles worth in you available on demand. It also won't be the right milk for their newborn. It's a ridiculous suggestion. I pumped for my newborn and it was really hard to get the required amount and I had to top up with formula. I then stopped pumping and bf exclusively. I tired pumping later on to see if it was possible to get a night off and by then I couldn't get anything out via pump. And I was an expert at in in the new born days. So even if you decided to try their crazy request I doubt you'd manage it

Happyjoe · 12/11/2026 10:33

Does she think you're a cow to be milked?!

Absolutely not. Strange request and totally out of line.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 12/11/2026 10:34

Tulipsriver · 12/11/2026 09:51

I would reply honestly:

"Hi DB, I'm sorry SIL is struggling. I know I don't share very much but I have found breastfeeding very taxing, both emotionally and physically myself. I'm happy to give her some tips but I can't give you any milk. Unfortunately I only have the supply and energy to feed my own baby".

This is the best reply

they need to realise they’re not the only people who find things hard and stop being so needy

Hadenough32 · 12/11/2026 10:34

I've ebf 3 of mine and found it a painful slog for at least the first 3 months. Well done for getting to 6 months. Hope you're proud you've stuck at it.
Once you get to 6 months randomly expressing won't get you far anyway. It's the early days that it's easier to pump a large amount before actual needed supply is established. To avoid drama you can always say you tried and it didn't work. Or offer that they can bring baby over and you'll feed them in person... bet that's a hard no thankyou from them 😂

chirrupybird · 12/11/2026 10:35

It is a real cheek, you produce enough milk for your baby (you get into a routine of supply and demand) not enough for two babies and I assume you will be expected to feed hers until they are 12 months or more once you start doing it. I would say sorry no I don't have extra milk I only produce enough for my baby and that's a push, I've never had enough to pump any extra and I can't risk not having enough.

chirrupybird · 12/11/2026 10:36

Hadenough32 · 12/11/2026 10:34

I've ebf 3 of mine and found it a painful slog for at least the first 3 months. Well done for getting to 6 months. Hope you're proud you've stuck at it.
Once you get to 6 months randomly expressing won't get you far anyway. It's the early days that it's easier to pump a large amount before actual needed supply is established. To avoid drama you can always say you tried and it didn't work. Or offer that they can bring baby over and you'll feed them in person... bet that's a hard no thankyou from them 😂

I wouldn't offer to feed their baby they may jump at it, a free wet nurse perfect.

CuteOrangeElephant · 12/11/2026 10:37

WTF no!!

My sister donated some of her milk to my DD, but there is a week between our children and after supplying the local neonatal unit she still had liters in the freezer. And she offered, I didn't ask, because that is just plain cheeky.

Mummyoflittledragon · 12/11/2026 10:37

Wow. What a ridiculous thing to say. I would tell them you struggle to keep up with your baby’s demands. That you spoke to the health visitor in the early days and was advised to keep putting your baby to your breast as often as possible. And suggest she does the same. That supplementation, especially in the early days, will really effect her supply and probably cause her to fail at feeding. You wouldn’t want to be the cause of that, even if you could pump enough. So no. Sorry.

And if you want to basically tell them to eff off, you could suggest that if it’s that important, very rarely dads lactate. There was the case of the Sri Lankan man several years ago. Maybe they could give it a try and see if they’re lucky enough. https://www.facebook.com/whatweseee/photos/colombo-a-38-year-old-sri-lankan-man-whose-wife-had-died-three-months-ago-appear/508375349199524/

And of course she’s tired. She’s just had a baby. It’s exhausting.

Meand2Ls · 12/11/2026 10:37

As someone who has breastfed 2 babies for almost 2 years each and donated copious amount of milk to the milk bank I would be shutting this conversation down so quick

CheeryOP · 12/11/2026 10:39

Say no. Pumping is not easy. I exclusively breastfed both my children without any supply issues and yet I could hardly get any milk when I tried to pump, and that was with an electric pump. Don't underestimate how much time it will take you to pump, as compared to breastfeeding your baby. I gave up in the end because it was taking so much effort to get a small amount of milk and often the baby was rejecting it anyway because he wanted the boob not a bottle.

Sunnyjac · 12/11/2026 10:39

I breastfed all mine but couldn't pump for love nor money. Nothing came out. So even if you said yes it might not work. I found trying to pump an unpleasant experience and gave up very quickly when it was clear it wasn't working. You are not being unreasonable.

UnctuousUnicorns · 12/11/2026 10:40

Tulipsriver · 12/11/2026 09:51

I would reply honestly:

"Hi DB, I'm sorry SIL is struggling. I know I don't share very much but I have found breastfeeding very taxing, both emotionally and physically myself. I'm happy to give her some tips but I can't give you any milk. Unfortunately I only have the supply and energy to feed my own baby".

Or... "No" is a complete sentence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread