Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not supplying my brother and SIL with breastmilk

363 replies

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

OP posts:
SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 12/11/2026 10:40

Hi Brother, sending lots of love to SIL, I remember those early days trying to establish supply and they were just so difficult! I do not pump breastmilk, I feed (DC) from the breast only, and will not be risking jeopardising my supply I fought very hard to establish by trying to add a pump into the mix. Nor would I want to jeopardise SILs breastfeeding journey by supplying milk which could prevent SIL establishing the supply she needs for niece/nephew since she is so committed to EBF this time. Should she find EBF is not for her, please remind her fed is best and if she wants to make the decision to combi feed or formula feed, baby will turn out perfect just like (their eldest).

Or you can simply say "I'm not a cow, dickhead." Either or.

ButtercupYellow26 · 12/11/2026 10:41

You are not a cow. I find that request very entitled and demeaning towards you.
NO and don't ask again.

Allowingthebreeze · 12/11/2026 10:42

Christ almighty. We are now at the stage that people are so entitled they think they can even have something like breast milk provided to them so they don’t have to make an effort.

Maybe doomsday happening tomorrow wouldn’t be so bad after all. We are all doomed anyway.

Anneleesa · 12/11/2026 10:42

No don’t do it. The milk for a new baby is really different to the milk for a 6 month old.

CousinBette · 12/11/2026 10:42

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 12/11/2026 09:56

Its very odd.

I am not even sure your breastmilk would be suitable for a newborn.

For minimum friction i would nod and smile let them send it, do nothing with the pump... then say you tried for HOURS and now you are just EXHAUSTED but you just cant seem to pump a drop (some women cant)

So while you are the best sister / SIL in the world they should never ask again.

Edited

Such a female reply! We need to learn to just say no outright!

ArtieChoke · 12/11/2026 10:44

You providing milk for their baby is counterintuitive, it will make breast feeding harder for Dsis in law

tell her it is hard for 4 weeks, but once she gets to 4 weeks it will likely get far easier and at 6 weeks she will be able to find it much easier

giving your breast milk will upset her milk supply

plus the fact your milk is for your baby and is set up for their needs - so it’s not that beneficial in the long run

plus once you’ve done it once and her milk supply alters - you’ll need to keep doing it

SandyCastles · 12/11/2026 10:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ArabellaFishwife · 12/11/2026 10:45

I can't believe your SIL would have come up with this lunacy. Are you sure it's not just your brother feeling helpless and searching for solutions for something he can't fix himself?
Obviously it's a non starter. And even if you had found breastfeeding as easy as they seem to imagine, that doesn't mean you would have excess supply. I remember having loads to spare with my first, but with my second, in spite of trying to create stores for emergencies and rest, nada.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 12/11/2026 10:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

There was something a few weeks back about AI training. Maybe it’s that

Pinkhatbluenails · 12/11/2026 10:52

So your SIL has a new baby and is tired/upset trying to breast feed. Absolutely normal. What is not normal is her husband passing her request for help to you, his sister and having his parents chirp in when the answer has been negative.

Does your brother have form for being the golden boy, or throwing money at something to make it work? I'm.astounded that he'd order you a bloody pump. The height of laziness.

He should be on the phone to the lactation consultant and sitting his wife on the sofa with blankets, food and drinks. He's probably not though. He's likely doing sod all while the wife does everything.

I'd ignore them as whatever you say will be met with a barrage of abuse or more requests.

Can you tell I have a family who do things like this?

AverageWhiteShark · 12/11/2026 10:55

Arbourimage · 12/11/2026 10:20

I don’t even understand why so many comments are recommending pussyfooting around the issue. You don’t need to tell them breastfeeding is hard, or exhausting, or it’s hard to find for time - just tell them it’s fucking creepy and you aren’t doing it.

Quite. They have two choices here, SIL can persevere with suitable advice and support or they can stop being so bloody precious and go and by some fekking formula. Your answer, OP should be a flat "No" and a suggestion to other family members that they mind their own beeswax and stop using emotional blackmail. Disgusting behaviour.

Peonies12 · 12/11/2026 10:55

Really weird. A newborn needs the milk from the mother as it adapts to their age (or formula obv). The mum isn't doing herself any favours by not feeding, she needs to feed frequently to establish supply. Can you suggest they see a lactation consultant if they're struggling? If she is determined to BF could be worth it. And it is really hard, but i found it became much easier with support and a bit of time.

AutumnOakTree · 12/11/2026 10:55

Yes, breastfeeding is tough and hard and time-consuming, and you’re absolutely not being a cow by refusing to be a cow and providing milk on demand.

GintyMcGinty · 12/11/2026 10:55

That’s the most cf ask I’ve ever heard. yANBU. Tell them to fuck off.

MrMurphysComeuppance · 12/11/2026 10:56

she is struggling fertility struggles

And there it is. People are always 'struggling' and having 'struggles' in these threads.

Welcome to MN OP. Or perhaps you just name changed for this thread, but it's still extremely identifying, isn't it? Don't you worry that your SIL will see this and recognise you bad mouthing her while she's 'struggling' with her brand new baby?

Peonies12 · 12/11/2026 10:56

I never really got any milk from pumping either, despite EBF until about 22 months, and ever time I did try I got mastitis!

Lotsofsnacks · 12/11/2026 10:59

Seloos · 12/11/2026 09:47

My DB and SIL are great sharers of information, and so if you don’t share they just assume everything is easy or alright for you. So the whole family heard about their fertility struggles - absolutely fine to share, but when I announced my pregnancy I was told I was lucky I had it so easy- even though they had no idea.

Now some might disagree but I say breastfeeding is tough. It needs a bit of determination, in the early days I was sore and tired but as it is baby is 6 months and still EBF. I am proud of this but never told anyone how hard I found it.

My SIL has just given birth to her second and after not BF her first really wants this one to be EBF, I had a call from my DB last night saying she is very tired and can I pump a couple of bottles for them… as if I can just produce a couple of bottles on cue!!!

I don’t even have a pump- he said they could Amazon me one.

Am I being unreasonable to say no? My parents and brother are saying I would find it easy and she is struggling and don’t I want what is best for the baby.

Im only just starting to feel I am on the downward slope with feeding after months or gritting my teeth and getting on with it.

Why the hell your parents getting involved, jeez! Just tell them all you don’t get on with pumps, youve tried before. It’s a no.

SIL needs to persevere herself and talk to a lactation specialist if she’s struggling

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 12/11/2026 11:00

CousinBette · 12/11/2026 10:42

Such a female reply! We need to learn to just say no outright!

Yeah but shes 6m pp being harassed by her parents as well as her lunatic brother and sil.... sometimes the path of least resistance is okay.

SandyCastles · 12/11/2026 11:02

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · 12/11/2026 10:48

There was something a few weeks back about AI training. Maybe it’s that

I think it is, because LOADS of posts on here seem genuine (not this one obviously), but then there are things about the story that don't make sense.

Like the going out for Christmas dinner one, the OP has now been asked to cancel her plans and either cook at home for 15 people, or pay for her half sister & family at a cost of £500+ who can no longer go because they can't afford it, she has 'declined' and now she 'supposedly' being accused by her own mother of ruining Christmas for her sisters children, because they can't go to one meal out? .. as if that has happened with absolutely no compromise suggested, at what point does the story get so ridiculous that it is quite obviously made up.

If it is true, then I think AI is far too rigid in it's thinking, it never allows for nuance or compromise, or common sense even, it just seems to pick two sides to an unreasonable argument to get people frothing at the mouth, and let them argue it until the thread runs out of steam.. I wonder what it is learning?

TheFriendlyPotato · 12/11/2026 11:02

I have never heard of this type of request. Ever...

They'll soon be demanding rations from you like your the cruel head of a Victorian orphanage.

Except instead of 'please Ma'am, can I have some more,' it'll be 'have you pumped yet?'

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 12/11/2026 11:03

I am not even sure your breastmilk would be suitable for a newborn.

Cows' milk is better?

SideBob · 12/11/2026 11:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes, people need to be more discerning before diving into threads with sincere advice.

Post is weird AF.

BrilliantBetty · 12/11/2026 11:07

Such a weird request. It’s a shame they have to pressure you regarding such personal things.

BackJustToSay · 12/11/2026 11:09

Cripes. I'd just tell them you're actually struggling to supply enough to your own baby and won't be able to produce extra. You shouldn't really have to but I suspect if you just say no without giving a reason like that they'll keep pushing.