Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
SleeplessInWherever · 14/11/2026 17:49

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 17:39

The one I get the most is why don't I just get a job so I can pay for a carer? Like I'd be able to afford to pay a carer.

I also get told often that he shouldn't be in mainstream.

God only knows what job you’d have to have to be able to afford a carer for the hours you put in!

The mainstream argument is ridiculous. There are kids who aren’t suitable for mainstream whatsoever (like mine) and many who are, with support (like yours).

Mines learning to recognise numbers to 20 at the moment, in a mixed Y5/6 class. I can only imagine how bored your son would be if he was put into a school and class like that.

We don’t need to shoehorn all kids with any disability into specialist provision where it isn’t right for them, and not all disability is cognitive.

We’ve seen it on this thread. Assuming all U25s on PIP must be anxious or have ADHD. Most of them will have completely different disability, that isn’t in any way linked to MH or LD.

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 17:49

ReviewAlternatives · 14/11/2026 17:47

It’s odd isn’t it how hiring a carer is so expensive yet carers allowance is such a low amount in comparison, so those saying these young people should be supported by family - they already are - at a very reduced cost to the taxpayer !

I know and if you also get UC, carers allowance is removed from your UC payment.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 17:50

BeLemonMoose · 14/11/2026 14:22

Everybody has mental health.
What you mean us serious mental illness like schizophrenia has a much reduced life expectancy.

Early mental health support can help with more severe mental illness that can become enduring. But a lot of what people experience is either time limited, or to do with shit life circumstances that no support worker or counsellor can change.

You're wrong. People with autism have a reduced life expectancy: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2023/nov/premature-death-autistic-people-uk-investigated-first-time

That isn't directly due to the autism but the autism is absolutely a factor.

A little Googling on this would have helped you be a bit less categorical about this.

Noras · 14/11/2026 17:51

We are looking at this so wrong

Our autistic adult kids could be forced into a gov found job ( hopefully for full time )

Thats 7 hours plus 2 hours a day care.

As well as 7 hours respite.

I was so alarmed that when my DS finished university his PA hours would drop to about 20 / 28 and respite - so in essence he stays home 4 days a week and 3 days at eg volunteer work.

This is marvellous. We get more Pa hours, the workforce and management absorb all the pain, training, hr issues and insurance and all the admin etc.

All those working people want them working - they can have them rants/ talking to themselves/ slamming things down/ rushing off getting agitated and all.

Please do ! I am begging you - where do I sign?

morningspa · 14/11/2026 17:56

Many people claim Carers Allowance simply to avoid going to work.

I have two family members that do this. Obviously, they do end up being the Carer and earn their money but that wasn’t why they applied initially.

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 17:57

SleeplessInWherever · 14/11/2026 17:49

God only knows what job you’d have to have to be able to afford a carer for the hours you put in!

The mainstream argument is ridiculous. There are kids who aren’t suitable for mainstream whatsoever (like mine) and many who are, with support (like yours).

Mines learning to recognise numbers to 20 at the moment, in a mixed Y5/6 class. I can only imagine how bored your son would be if he was put into a school and class like that.

We don’t need to shoehorn all kids with any disability into specialist provision where it isn’t right for them, and not all disability is cognitive.

We’ve seen it on this thread. Assuming all U25s on PIP must be anxious or have ADHD. Most of them will have completely different disability, that isn’t in any way linked to MH or LD.

I know!

Absolutely. He is behind academically and receives additional help but not to the extent where he can't access mainstream education. School is also about socialising and it would just be completely inappropriate for him to be in specialist provision.

I'm all for specialist provision when it is necessary like your son and it should be from Reception, not watching them fall apart in mainstream first when it is obviously not going to be suitable for them.

But some disabled children like my son are absolutely fine in mainstream.

ReviewAlternatives · 14/11/2026 17:58

morningspa · 14/11/2026 17:56

Many people claim Carers Allowance simply to avoid going to work.

I have two family members that do this. Obviously, they do end up being the Carer and earn their money but that wasn’t why they applied initially.

Edited

In that case they are working, as a carer 🤦

OP posts:
morningspa · 14/11/2026 18:00

Noras · 14/11/2026 17:51

We are looking at this so wrong

Our autistic adult kids could be forced into a gov found job ( hopefully for full time )

Thats 7 hours plus 2 hours a day care.

As well as 7 hours respite.

I was so alarmed that when my DS finished university his PA hours would drop to about 20 / 28 and respite - so in essence he stays home 4 days a week and 3 days at eg volunteer work.

This is marvellous. We get more Pa hours, the workforce and management absorb all the pain, training, hr issues and insurance and all the admin etc.

All those working people want them working - they can have them rants/ talking to themselves/ slamming things down/ rushing off getting agitated and all.

Please do ! I am begging you - where do I sign?

But they managed university? What was the point of them going if they do not get a decent job out of it?

pointythings · 14/11/2026 18:04

morningspa · 14/11/2026 18:00

But they managed university? What was the point of them going if they do not get a decent job out of it?

This is typical of people who know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

Going to university gives you so much more than job prospects.

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:05

People always completely derail these conversations with discussions about severely disabled children who obviously can’t work or live independently. It’s very depressing, and just an attempt to shut down any sensible discussion.

There is a real, genuine problem with hundreds of thousands of young people with MILD disabilities or perfectly normal mental health challenges being encouraged by SM and heavily incentivised by the system to exaggerate their symptoms and to lean into the “I can’t” mindset. We absolutely cannot and should not ignore that problem just because some children will never work regardless of what we do.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 18:07

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:05

People always completely derail these conversations with discussions about severely disabled children who obviously can’t work or live independently. It’s very depressing, and just an attempt to shut down any sensible discussion.

There is a real, genuine problem with hundreds of thousands of young people with MILD disabilities or perfectly normal mental health challenges being encouraged by SM and heavily incentivised by the system to exaggerate their symptoms and to lean into the “I can’t” mindset. We absolutely cannot and should not ignore that problem just because some children will never work regardless of what we do.

I haven't seen any evidence of young people with mild conditions getting PIP...And having seen young people close to me go through the system, I really want to see that evidence before I believe your statement.

You're also missing the chunk of people in the middle - disabled people who can work, but not full time. What's the plan for them?

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:12

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:05

People always completely derail these conversations with discussions about severely disabled children who obviously can’t work or live independently. It’s very depressing, and just an attempt to shut down any sensible discussion.

There is a real, genuine problem with hundreds of thousands of young people with MILD disabilities or perfectly normal mental health challenges being encouraged by SM and heavily incentivised by the system to exaggerate their symptoms and to lean into the “I can’t” mindset. We absolutely cannot and should not ignore that problem just because some children will never work regardless of what we do.

Because we can't pretend that it isn't going to have any potential impact on our children or that our children won't be part of any potential collateral damage as the government rarely tends to get it right and can make mistakes.

Not to mention the fact that other conversations within a thread are allowed which has included examples of people not knowing how expensive residential care is or the fact that some people absolutely want to include the more severely disabled too which was an earlier slight discussion when a pp claimed that wasn't at all the case.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 18:18

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:05

People always completely derail these conversations with discussions about severely disabled children who obviously can’t work or live independently. It’s very depressing, and just an attempt to shut down any sensible discussion.

There is a real, genuine problem with hundreds of thousands of young people with MILD disabilities or perfectly normal mental health challenges being encouraged by SM and heavily incentivised by the system to exaggerate their symptoms and to lean into the “I can’t” mindset. We absolutely cannot and should not ignore that problem just because some children will never work regardless of what we do.

Define severe. There are many disabled kids without learning difficulties who can’t work or live independently or who will take a long time to get to work on their journey.

TigerRag · 14/11/2026 18:20

morningspa · 14/11/2026 17:56

Many people claim Carers Allowance simply to avoid going to work.

I have two family members that do this. Obviously, they do end up being the Carer and earn their money but that wasn’t why they applied initially.

Edited

Hmmm, £86 a week, no pension, no rights to holiday, etc or work full time (I've yet to meet a carer doing the minimum of 35 a week to get carers allowance) and get things like a pension, holiday and money that they can actually live on? I know what I'd choose

I have a friend who was a teacher. She had to give up her job to care for her disabled child. She's had to beg for help. I'm sure she'd rather have a healthy 15 year old who doesn't go to bed with the fear of dying from seizures who can talk and do everything a 15 year old does

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:26

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 18:18

Define severe. There are many disabled kids without learning difficulties who can’t work or live independently or who will take a long time to get to work on their journey.

This too.

My son has complex needs that are defined as severe but no learning disability. It isn't completely impossible for him to be able to work one day but he would need so many reasonable adjustments, I'd be surprised if anyone would be willing to hire him.

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:28

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:12

Because we can't pretend that it isn't going to have any potential impact on our children or that our children won't be part of any potential collateral damage as the government rarely tends to get it right and can make mistakes.

Not to mention the fact that other conversations within a thread are allowed which has included examples of people not knowing how expensive residential care is or the fact that some people absolutely want to include the more severely disabled too which was an earlier slight discussion when a pp claimed that wasn't at all the case.

Edited

But we can’t keep ignoring the problem and supporting a broken system which is actively harming so many just in case or even because changes will impact on your children. Surely you understand that?

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 18:28

pointythings · 14/11/2026 18:04

This is typical of people who know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

Going to university gives you so much more than job prospects.

University is an investment and everyone, including disabled people, should be looking at the return they get from this which will almost always be realised through working. It's simply too expensive to go just to fulfil an academic interest or because it's enjoyable.

The idea that someone who can never hope to pay back the money it costs to go to university should go just because is bonkers. We can't afford these kinds of follies for anyone, disabled or not.

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:30

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:28

But we can’t keep ignoring the problem and supporting a broken system which is actively harming so many just in case or even because changes will impact on your children. Surely you understand that?

I don't understand potentially breaking the system more, no. As that is what would be happening if children like mine become collateral damage.

RaggedRocks · 14/11/2026 18:36

pointythings · 14/11/2026 18:04

This is typical of people who know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

Going to university gives you so much more than job prospects.

and if you never get a job, it's completely free

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:37

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:30

I don't understand potentially breaking the system more, no. As that is what would be happening if children like mine become collateral damage.

So because the system works for your children, you are ok with throwing away the opportunity for a fulfilling life for millions of others. Ok. I guess it’s natural to be utterly focussed on your own family but it is also incredibly selfish. And shortsighted because the current rate of “disability” is unaffordable so will lead to really significant cuts in benefits for everyone who needs them unless real changes are made.

TigerRag · 14/11/2026 18:38

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:37

So because the system works for your children, you are ok with throwing away the opportunity for a fulfilling life for millions of others. Ok. I guess it’s natural to be utterly focussed on your own family but it is also incredibly selfish. And shortsighted because the current rate of “disability” is unaffordable so will lead to really significant cuts in benefits for everyone who needs them unless real changes are made.

Edited

But why as ever, must those most in need suffer?

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:43

I don’t think they should. I’ve never said or implied that. Ideally the system should identity those people most in need efficiently and accurately so they can be fully supported. But meanwhile, in the real world….. . What I do think is that we cannot avoid change just because there may be unintended consequences. We change the system to support as many people as we can while remaining affordable. We do our best, but accept that there will be failures.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 18:44

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:37

So because the system works for your children, you are ok with throwing away the opportunity for a fulfilling life for millions of others. Ok. I guess it’s natural to be utterly focussed on your own family but it is also incredibly selfish. And shortsighted because the current rate of “disability” is unaffordable so will lead to really significant cuts in benefits for everyone who needs them unless real changes are made.

Edited

The system isn’t working for children like hers as pointed out and evidenced by recent government reports which highlighted in no uncertain times how the system has and is letting down mentally ill autistic young people massively. It’s a national disgrace how much children like ours have been treated and then having often been left to get times worse and harder to treat they want to take the only support such young people have with no safe guarding or individual scrutiny. It’s appalling.

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:46

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:37

So because the system works for your children, you are ok with throwing away the opportunity for a fulfilling life for millions of others. Ok. I guess it’s natural to be utterly focussed on your own family but it is also incredibly selfish. And shortsighted because the current rate of “disability” is unaffordable so will lead to really significant cuts in benefits for everyone who needs them unless real changes are made.

Edited

The system absolutely does not work perfectly for my child. I also don't agree that stripping away benefits without any other plan in place to help disabled people is going to give them a fulfilling life.

CatkinToadflax · 14/11/2026 18:48

I have fought for my son since the day he was born extremely prematurely. He is now a young adult. There is no way he could ever fill in his own PIP forms or undergo an assessment without having an advocate there with him. Unfortunately due to his multiple disabilities my son will never support himself or live fully independently. I am utterly exhausted from caring for him and advocating for him at every turn and I worry desperately about his future.

I do think there are likely to be some young people on benefits who could find full- or part-time work and help themselves to become less reliant on benefits. But firstly jobs have to be created and employers need to be open to employing young people with little or no experience and with disabilities.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread