Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
EasternStandard · 14/11/2026 20:17

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 19:56

How’s this for starters.

The Treasury is wargaming the introduction of an AI tax in the event of widespread job losses.

Civil servants have been tasked with analysing a range of economic consequences that could stem from the rise of the technology, including labour market disruption and a subsequent drop in tax receipts.

No 11 and the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology are working with academics and experts under a new AI Economics Institute, set up in June by Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, to understand the opportunities, risks and “inform government policy”.

That’s something I suppose. I’ve thought for a while the drop in tax receipts due to AI is a bit threat.

skylarkrise · 14/11/2026 20:25

pointythings · 14/11/2026 19:44

Nursing has changed enormously. What nurses used to do, healthcare assistants do now. If you knew anything at all about what is now expected of nurses, you would understand why they need that level of education.

I have some idea but it’s still a valid point

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 20:28

EasternStandard · 14/11/2026 20:17

That’s something I suppose. I’ve thought for a while the drop in tax receipts due to AI is a bit threat.

It’s real, and it’s here.

Labour will probably deploy it once they can no longer use the 14-years of Tory governments, or the Straits of Hormuz, or the 1929 Wall St Crash…

EasternStandard · 14/11/2026 20:29

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 20:28

It’s real, and it’s here.

Labour will probably deploy it once they can no longer use the 14-years of Tory governments, or the Straits of Hormuz, or the 1929 Wall St Crash…

They do need to war game it because income tax could really drop.

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 20:36

EasternStandard · 14/11/2026 20:29

They do need to war game it because income tax could really drop.

They will simply continue to go after ‘wealth’ as opposed to income.

You do not want to be long assets.

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 20:39

frozendaisy · 14/11/2026 12:18

Everyone should apply to whatever benefits they are entitled to.

And everyone should use all the legal tax breaks they are entitled to as well.

And who do you imagine is going to pay for all of this? I would really appreciate reading your detailed answer.

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 21:03

Going to university gives you so much more than job prospects....

Seriously? If you are deeply interested in your course study material, I agree wholeheartedly. If you want to escape your home town for three years of party elsewhere, probably not.

I went to uni 50 years ago so I am not part of the discussion but I have young relatives who are in that age group. My nephew was fairly scandalised by one overheard conversation among his flatmates, young women, talking about how many men they could fuck on a single night out. Six or seven apparently.

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 21:11

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 20:07

Show me the incentive, and I will show you the outcome.

You will be amazed at how innovative Labour can be when it comes to raising tax (perhaps you wont).

I don't think they have the intellectual capability.

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 21:19

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 21:11

I don't think they have the intellectual capability.

I’m not sure that greed and envy requires any intellect.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 21:34

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 21:03

Going to university gives you so much more than job prospects....

Seriously? If you are deeply interested in your course study material, I agree wholeheartedly. If you want to escape your home town for three years of party elsewhere, probably not.

I went to uni 50 years ago so I am not part of the discussion but I have young relatives who are in that age group. My nephew was fairly scandalised by one overheard conversation among his flatmates, young women, talking about how many men they could fuck on a single night out. Six or seven apparently.

Thank you for your anecdata. Your nephew appears to have been singularly unfortunate in his flatmates - neither of my DC nor any of their friends share his experience.

And whatever you study, if you work at it and take it seriously, it will give you skills you can use in the workplace. Research methodology, scientific writing, data analysis are the really obvious ones. My DS uses the data analysis skills he learned at uni in his job every day, hence the identified cost savings.

Your little anecdote is once again typical of those who argue purely in black and white terms - university as the hallowed halls of study, or university as a 100% partying waste of time, with nothing in between.

OonaStubbs · 14/11/2026 21:44

What is the point of a legal guarantee of a job or training? Surely it just means kids can piss about in school and do no work and cause trouble because they know they're guaranteed to have something to go to after leaving school? And what value is there in job experience or training that is guaranteed? It will mean less than nothing.

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 22:25

pointythings · 14/11/2026 21:34

Thank you for your anecdata. Your nephew appears to have been singularly unfortunate in his flatmates - neither of my DC nor any of their friends share his experience.

And whatever you study, if you work at it and take it seriously, it will give you skills you can use in the workplace. Research methodology, scientific writing, data analysis are the really obvious ones. My DS uses the data analysis skills he learned at uni in his job every day, hence the identified cost savings.

Your little anecdote is once again typical of those who argue purely in black and white terms - university as the hallowed halls of study, or university as a 100% partying waste of time, with nothing in between.

For some people, university is a poor investment. 50% of Gen Z view their university degrees as a bad investment. Data already showed that 25% of people were financially worse off as a result if going to university and this was before the huge downturn in graduate employment.

University must be viewed in a dispassionate and objective manner like all investments. If you're disabled and unlikely to work in a field that will make your degree pay off due to the limitations associated with your disability then you should think long and hard about whether a degree is a good idea. Ultimately you could end up saddled with a lot of debt for a long time and it's almost cruel to pretend otherwise.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 22:34

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 22:25

For some people, university is a poor investment. 50% of Gen Z view their university degrees as a bad investment. Data already showed that 25% of people were financially worse off as a result if going to university and this was before the huge downturn in graduate employment.

University must be viewed in a dispassionate and objective manner like all investments. If you're disabled and unlikely to work in a field that will make your degree pay off due to the limitations associated with your disability then you should think long and hard about whether a degree is a good idea. Ultimately you could end up saddled with a lot of debt for a long time and it's almost cruel to pretend otherwise.

Firstly, the word 'some' is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

Secondly, you are like pp ignoring the value of transferable skills.

Thirdly, like pp you are thinking solely in terms of money.

Fourthly, student loan debt doesn't work in the same way as 'normal' debt. As I hope you well know.

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 22:57

pointythings · 14/11/2026 22:34

Firstly, the word 'some' is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

Secondly, you are like pp ignoring the value of transferable skills.

Thirdly, like pp you are thinking solely in terms of money.

Fourthly, student loan debt doesn't work in the same way as 'normal' debt. As I hope you well know.

  1. 'Some' is substantiated by the statistics I provided. We aren't talking about insignificant numbers of people here!. I note you have used no statistics in your posts and instead relied on vague notions of transferable skills and woolly non-financial measures.
  1. Everyone understands how transferable skills work. Nobody is pretending that the only way a degree can be value for money is if you get a job in the exact same field that you studied. The point is though, that even accounting for transferable skills, the data and statistics I have already quoted suggest that university isn't a great investment for lots of people.
  1. Every single prospective student should have money at the forefront of their mind when deciding whether to go to university unless they are wealthy enough that the money spent is insignificant to them. The idea that you should go to university because it's enjoyable or interesting just isn't viable anymore, for the State or the individual. We need to see a clear return on investment otherwise the money can be spent more effectively elsewhere. University for university's sake isn't what taxpayer money should be spent on.
  1. I do understand this but this opens up a whole other can of worms regarding whether we should be offering loans to people that have no intention or ability to pay them off. It's also true that people that earn the median wage would still be paying off £30k over their lifetime before the debt is written off. It's not insignificant sums for those that are average earners.
Noras · 14/11/2026 23:49

BeLemonMoose · 14/11/2026 09:08

@Ott3r are you really saying autism leads to diagnosable mental health conditions? Because that's not what we see with older people. Plenty of older people with autism diagnosed or undiagnosed manage fine.

That seems remarkably uninformed. There is a significant close relationship as an example between schizophrenia and ASD.

When my son was having conversations with bundled we were really worried and had this checked out. It’s just self soothing and a stim thankfully.

My son’s pip is used for professional weekly counselling. We would not be doing this if he was fine. He’s not fine and rapidly deteriorates without counselling. If you walk down a road and your son begins to bang their head on a stone wall in front of passing traffic, oblivious to the pain they are inflicting, the impact on passers by and the distress to their family members - you will realise that ASd mental health issues are significant. It’s classed as normal ASD behaviour not a discrete mental health issue. This along with constant expression to die or kill themselves comes with the territory. It’s all stressful for staff, teachers and PA and safeguarding issue as everyone has to make sure that there is no plan.

hibernatinghedgehog · 14/11/2026 23:53

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 18:44

The system isn’t working for children like hers as pointed out and evidenced by recent government reports which highlighted in no uncertain times how the system has and is letting down mentally ill autistic young people massively. It’s a national disgrace how much children like ours have been treated and then having often been left to get times worse and harder to treat they want to take the only support such young people have with no safe guarding or individual scrutiny. It’s appalling.

Why have you assumed @Kirbert2’s DS has autism? Other disabilities exist.

Noras · 15/11/2026 07:43

The Gov is proposing to remove pip and increased UC from all those aged 18 to 25 if they have neurodiversity or non physical disabilities.

In my son’s circumstances I am not sure where he fits on that as he has ASD with complex needs or a neurodiversity disorder. I hope that you can understand percentiles to understand how severe my sons issues are
To recap, my son has motor coordination on the 0.5 percentile ( he needs people to do his chopping , grating and tin can opening) You could argue that’s a physical thing as it’s caused by hypotonia he had since birth
Severe receptive language impairment - he masks that better but the results were consistent whilst tested from age 7 to 15 - he can’t carry 2 pronged instructions I his head. He also has severe pragmatic and semantic impairment 0.75 percentile this means he has a huge misunderstanding of people’s intentions making the World a really really scary place
His executive functioning is extremely low on the 2 and 4 percentile - he struggles to plan how to load his plate at a buffet and how to carry a tray. He can’t plan, respond to or check emails or know what to wear unless his wardrobe is divided into Winter and Summer and we have to frown him TK check the weather forecast.
His working memory is on the 2 and 4 also which man’s he can’t carry information in his head easily os instructions have to be broken down to one instruction.
He has associated bowel disorder - his bowel is stretched in x ray - which means that he struggle to pop and before meds as a child was on all 4 with intense pain weekly having not done a poo for a week - he was also routinely humiliated with fecal overflow and left in soiled pants at junior school
As a toddler he was tube fed - struggled to live / his throat closed up and they wanted to IV feed him luckily he was given a steroid that worked.
This is true ASD / complex needs. Not the big of fear about going out or slight anxiety about talking to people.
This is ASD with normal intelligence not specifically an amazing long term memory that is out of this world and beyond yours and my long term memory. When it comes to historical dates, my son is phononenal . This is why he is at university with a glued PA. He went there after years at life skills college.
My son needs pip because it pays for his weekly counselling to help keep him at university to cope with the overwhelming crowds. He needs it to cover Pa expenses. He has a life time of needs and we has parents have to save for this lifetime fo needs as well but he will he reliant on the state
His needs don’t disappear between age 18 to 25. He is classed unable to work as no employer will want to take him on . His only real and slim chance of employment is to maybe carry on in academia and maybe to get a PHD and get into some form of research maybe.
I offered his services for free last Summer and a community cafe turned him down as did 2 charity shops. They were concerned he would be rude or abusive to guests or he could not talk to customers and manage the till. Only a local historical tourist attraction took him on with a velcroed PA - he worked there before but it was a disaster as he didn’t understand the instructions.
There is no fraud here. My son’s issues come from something you can see. As a baby his low tone was seen on an x ray via a barium swallow with fluid going into his lungs. You can still see my son’s stretched bowls on x ray. You can still see his perforated ear drums that have healed with scarring on both ear drums ( that lower his hearing so he has border line hearing or is deaf when he has a cold)
This is neurodiversity
And frankly if they go against this there is a strong argument to go against all the young adults with cerebral palsy - they often have hypertonia that contorts his body he has hypotonia that leaves his muscles to loose. My son has white matter damage seen on a VEP ( visual evoked potential test showed demylinated white matter damage that led to immaturity of his brain development - which means that he presents young for age - around 13/14 year old I would say)
The Gov are showing huge ignorance in not understanding ND and the physicality of it all.
People with ASD and obvious issues from birth often have a different gait due to sensory fears.
DS has a well developed vocabulary but has ASD speech issues or an ASD stammer that differs form a normal stammer. All these things that are complicated make life very difficult and he needs weekly counselling to cope.

How can the Gov arbitrarily distinguish damage caused by neurological losses of hypotension of muscles that leads to autism as wrong messages are sent back to the brain ( sk the person has no idea where their nose is until older and feels disorientated for years leading to sensory issues : hearing issues that created symptoms of ASD ) and cerebral palsy that creates by hyper tonia ( muscles held too tight leading to physical problems)

CatkinToadflax · 15/11/2026 08:12

@Noras your DS sounds incredibly similar to mine. Mine can’t go to uni and doesn’t have bowel issues but other than that there are so many similarities. Thank you for explaining it so well.

My DS is 21 and his cuddly bear goes with him everywhere. He can’t function without him. They are known locally as “[DS] And Ted”. If Labour wants to strip DS of all his benefits and stick him on the till in Asda (as a random example) then they’re going to need to transform him into a completely different person in addition to creating the role in the first place; incredibly careful training and support; and providing a little uniform for a 25cm bear.

Rustybike · 15/11/2026 08:40

Over the last 20 years the UK has produced around 14 million adults who completed full-time school from age 4 to 18, on average each doing ~14,000 of school hours ostensibly ingesting useful life skills for all that time. And of those 14 million educated adults ~6.5 million did full-time degrees, further adding to their skill sets.

You also have, in addition, ~5 million people completing apprenticeships after school, and ~15 million vocational and further education qualifications outside of university being awarded. Again, that's all in the last 20 years.

We are drowning in education and skills and qualifications. Every government hits the "more training" button in response to economic inactivity and unemployment and it never achieves anything.

The fact is welfare is a lifestyle choice/career for millions of people. In most countries the choice is stark, you either work or emigrate and that's it. In the UK, we have added welfare as a third option, and it has been catastrophic.

Because the fact is we have millions of adults who have completed 14,000 hours of education and then already done degrees or further training but are still not working, and we get low-skilled immigrants instead to do things like care work or even retail - are we really saying those adults with all that training are incapable of doing any jobs without even more certification…

NippyNips · 15/11/2026 08:48

Noras · 15/11/2026 07:43

The Gov is proposing to remove pip and increased UC from all those aged 18 to 25 if they have neurodiversity or non physical disabilities.

In my son’s circumstances I am not sure where he fits on that as he has ASD with complex needs or a neurodiversity disorder. I hope that you can understand percentiles to understand how severe my sons issues are
To recap, my son has motor coordination on the 0.5 percentile ( he needs people to do his chopping , grating and tin can opening) You could argue that’s a physical thing as it’s caused by hypotonia he had since birth
Severe receptive language impairment - he masks that better but the results were consistent whilst tested from age 7 to 15 - he can’t carry 2 pronged instructions I his head. He also has severe pragmatic and semantic impairment 0.75 percentile this means he has a huge misunderstanding of people’s intentions making the World a really really scary place
His executive functioning is extremely low on the 2 and 4 percentile - he struggles to plan how to load his plate at a buffet and how to carry a tray. He can’t plan, respond to or check emails or know what to wear unless his wardrobe is divided into Winter and Summer and we have to frown him TK check the weather forecast.
His working memory is on the 2 and 4 also which man’s he can’t carry information in his head easily os instructions have to be broken down to one instruction.
He has associated bowel disorder - his bowel is stretched in x ray - which means that he struggle to pop and before meds as a child was on all 4 with intense pain weekly having not done a poo for a week - he was also routinely humiliated with fecal overflow and left in soiled pants at junior school
As a toddler he was tube fed - struggled to live / his throat closed up and they wanted to IV feed him luckily he was given a steroid that worked.
This is true ASD / complex needs. Not the big of fear about going out or slight anxiety about talking to people.
This is ASD with normal intelligence not specifically an amazing long term memory that is out of this world and beyond yours and my long term memory. When it comes to historical dates, my son is phononenal . This is why he is at university with a glued PA. He went there after years at life skills college.
My son needs pip because it pays for his weekly counselling to help keep him at university to cope with the overwhelming crowds. He needs it to cover Pa expenses. He has a life time of needs and we has parents have to save for this lifetime fo needs as well but he will he reliant on the state
His needs don’t disappear between age 18 to 25. He is classed unable to work as no employer will want to take him on . His only real and slim chance of employment is to maybe carry on in academia and maybe to get a PHD and get into some form of research maybe.
I offered his services for free last Summer and a community cafe turned him down as did 2 charity shops. They were concerned he would be rude or abusive to guests or he could not talk to customers and manage the till. Only a local historical tourist attraction took him on with a velcroed PA - he worked there before but it was a disaster as he didn’t understand the instructions.
There is no fraud here. My son’s issues come from something you can see. As a baby his low tone was seen on an x ray via a barium swallow with fluid going into his lungs. You can still see my son’s stretched bowls on x ray. You can still see his perforated ear drums that have healed with scarring on both ear drums ( that lower his hearing so he has border line hearing or is deaf when he has a cold)
This is neurodiversity
And frankly if they go against this there is a strong argument to go against all the young adults with cerebral palsy - they often have hypertonia that contorts his body he has hypotonia that leaves his muscles to loose. My son has white matter damage seen on a VEP ( visual evoked potential test showed demylinated white matter damage that led to immaturity of his brain development - which means that he presents young for age - around 13/14 year old I would say)
The Gov are showing huge ignorance in not understanding ND and the physicality of it all.
People with ASD and obvious issues from birth often have a different gait due to sensory fears.
DS has a well developed vocabulary but has ASD speech issues or an ASD stammer that differs form a normal stammer. All these things that are complicated make life very difficult and he needs weekly counselling to cope.

How can the Gov arbitrarily distinguish damage caused by neurological losses of hypotension of muscles that leads to autism as wrong messages are sent back to the brain ( sk the person has no idea where their nose is until older and feels disorientated for years leading to sensory issues : hearing issues that created symptoms of ASD ) and cerebral palsy that creates by hyper tonia ( muscles held too tight leading to physical problems)

Why is he at university if he can't cope at university and probably will never work?

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 09:04

NippyNips · 15/11/2026 08:48

Why is he at university if he can't cope at university and probably will never work?

Wow so now autistic people shouldn’t go to uni or have reasonable adjustments either. This thread just gets better and better!

pointythings · 15/11/2026 09:12

Ott3r · 15/11/2026 09:04

Wow so now autistic people shouldn’t go to uni or have reasonable adjustments either. This thread just gets better and better!

There are a lot of people on this thread who think of everything purely in financial terms. That's a choice. When you call them on it, they start shouting about how 'we can't afford it'. Well, we could - but society would have to change a lot, and for the better. The problem we have is that too many people are addicted to unfettered capitalism. And in that world, the human doesn't matter.

Apotofrealcoffee · 15/11/2026 09:18

pointythings · 15/11/2026 09:12

There are a lot of people on this thread who think of everything purely in financial terms. That's a choice. When you call them on it, they start shouting about how 'we can't afford it'. Well, we could - but society would have to change a lot, and for the better. The problem we have is that too many people are addicted to unfettered capitalism. And in that world, the human doesn't matter.

It would only be for the better for the people the money is spent on. Are you aware of the cost of living crisis and how many working people are living hand to mouth? Nothing is free for them, they don’t get discounted or cheap things or premiums. And yes it’s purely financial because they’re hard restrictions - would you work for free? I take it no?

BeLemonMoose · 15/11/2026 09:18

Not questioning his university place, but someone with such poor memory and executive function would not be capable of a research job.

TigerRag · 15/11/2026 09:18

Rustybike · 15/11/2026 08:40

Over the last 20 years the UK has produced around 14 million adults who completed full-time school from age 4 to 18, on average each doing ~14,000 of school hours ostensibly ingesting useful life skills for all that time. And of those 14 million educated adults ~6.5 million did full-time degrees, further adding to their skill sets.

You also have, in addition, ~5 million people completing apprenticeships after school, and ~15 million vocational and further education qualifications outside of university being awarded. Again, that's all in the last 20 years.

We are drowning in education and skills and qualifications. Every government hits the "more training" button in response to economic inactivity and unemployment and it never achieves anything.

The fact is welfare is a lifestyle choice/career for millions of people. In most countries the choice is stark, you either work or emigrate and that's it. In the UK, we have added welfare as a third option, and it has been catastrophic.

Because the fact is we have millions of adults who have completed 14,000 hours of education and then already done degrees or further training but are still not working, and we get low-skilled immigrants instead to do things like care work or even retail - are we really saying those adults with all that training are incapable of doing any jobs without even more certification…

For reference I'm 37:
When I was at school they acted like your only option after leaving was university. No other options were ever mentioned. They were literally pushing people to apply for university

I absolutely struggled but wasn't offered any other option

I managed (and I use that word loosely) a year at university. I then signed on and begged for help to find a job. There was no help at all. I was then put on the work programme who made my life help and believed that the equalities act didn't apply. (I was sent on courses where nothing was given to me in a format I could read) I decided that I had enough of being treated like rubbish and no amount of complaining solved anything. I then went on to ESA and received a letter saying I was in the support group which meant you didn't need to prepare for work . I received a phone call from the work programme because apparently I was put in the work related group and would I like help getting back to work? Um, no. They were the reason why I was put on ESA in the first place. They promised to stay in touch. I spoke to the job centre as I didn't want anything to do with an organisation who thinks the equalities act doesn't apply to them. (There are exceptions but they don't apply here - it's things like health and safety and not so much now, but if the technology doesn't exist and there's nothing they can do)

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread