Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
CatkinToadflax · 14/11/2026 18:51

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 18:46

The system absolutely does not work perfectly for my child. I also don't agree that stripping away benefits without any other plan in place to help disabled people is going to give them a fulfilling life.

Completely agree.

morningspa · 14/11/2026 18:52

TigerRag · 14/11/2026 18:20

Hmmm, £86 a week, no pension, no rights to holiday, etc or work full time (I've yet to meet a carer doing the minimum of 35 a week to get carers allowance) and get things like a pension, holiday and money that they can actually live on? I know what I'd choose

I have a friend who was a teacher. She had to give up her job to care for her disabled child. She's had to beg for help. I'm sure she'd rather have a healthy 15 year old who doesn't go to bed with the fear of dying from seizures who can talk and do everything a 15 year old does

Yes., I see your point.

There are many scroungers in amongst those that actually need and deserve the help like your friend.

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 18:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 18:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What has a question like that got to do with this thread?

SleeplessInWherever · 14/11/2026 18:58

AirborneElephant · 14/11/2026 18:28

But we can’t keep ignoring the problem and supporting a broken system which is actively harming so many just in case or even because changes will impact on your children. Surely you understand that?

These changes won’t impact my son. Certainly not initially. He won’t be impacted by the proposed EHCP reviews either.

We’re in the “fortunate” decision that he’s “too disabled” to fall into most of these changes. Yay us, right?

We’re just not all selfish.

There are families who struggle just as much as we do, for different reasons and with different types of level of disability, but still struggle.

The system is not set up for disabled people to work, without adjustments that many employers will not make

I run a recruitment agency, and represent a woman who is diabetic. That’s her only need. Diabetes. Qualified and wonderful at what she does, but needs guaranteed breaks at guaranteed times so she can monitor her insulin and take any relevant actions.

You wouldn’t believe how difficult it is to find her work. For that one reason. Because employers (in this case schools) would rather have someone who doesn’t need that, who doesn’t need to pop out for 5mins every couple of hours. Who isn’t going to potentially go into diabetic shock.

Employers aren’t going to suddenly start installing ramps, making sure they have hearing loops where they don’t already, etc etc. They’re not going to give people more or extended breaks for whatever reason. Or appointment time that is higher than their other staff.

They’re going to take the easy route, and employ someone with less “complications.”

It’s not people who the general public consider “profoundly disabled” that will miss out. Not for a long while.

It’s the “SENbetweeners”, the physically disabled, and those with significant MH issues, who also matter.

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 19:03

SleeplessInWherever · 14/11/2026 18:58

These changes won’t impact my son. Certainly not initially. He won’t be impacted by the proposed EHCP reviews either.

We’re in the “fortunate” decision that he’s “too disabled” to fall into most of these changes. Yay us, right?

We’re just not all selfish.

There are families who struggle just as much as we do, for different reasons and with different types of level of disability, but still struggle.

The system is not set up for disabled people to work, without adjustments that many employers will not make

I run a recruitment agency, and represent a woman who is diabetic. That’s her only need. Diabetes. Qualified and wonderful at what she does, but needs guaranteed breaks at guaranteed times so she can monitor her insulin and take any relevant actions.

You wouldn’t believe how difficult it is to find her work. For that one reason. Because employers (in this case schools) would rather have someone who doesn’t need that, who doesn’t need to pop out for 5mins every couple of hours. Who isn’t going to potentially go into diabetic shock.

Employers aren’t going to suddenly start installing ramps, making sure they have hearing loops where they don’t already, etc etc. They’re not going to give people more or extended breaks for whatever reason. Or appointment time that is higher than their other staff.

They’re going to take the easy route, and employ someone with less “complications.”

It’s not people who the general public consider “profoundly disabled” that will miss out. Not for a long while.

It’s the “SENbetweeners”, the physically disabled, and those with significant MH issues, who also matter.

This! They also need to accept that many ND people will not be able to do face to face work, presentations, socially network etc but they don’t. That is the reality.

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 19:06

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 18:56

What has a question like that got to do with this thread?

Autism has been discussed extensively on this thread. Are you denying this?

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 19:09

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 19:03

This! They also need to accept that many ND people will not be able to do face to face work, presentations, socially network etc but they don’t. That is the reality.

Change is coming to the welfare budget. Why?

With AI, many neurotypical people will soon be joining the neurodiverse in a reliance on some kind of state support.

Most of you know this, even if you fear it or would rather pretend it’s not so.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 19:10

Itchthescratch · 14/11/2026 18:28

University is an investment and everyone, including disabled people, should be looking at the return they get from this which will almost always be realised through working. It's simply too expensive to go just to fulfil an academic interest or because it's enjoyable.

The idea that someone who can never hope to pay back the money it costs to go to university should go just because is bonkers. We can't afford these kinds of follies for anyone, disabled or not.

By your lights, hardly anyone should go to university. Nurses shouldn't. Scientists shouldn't. Engineers shouldn't. Because all those careers rely on people doing absolutely vital work for levels of pay that mean no, they will not pay back their loans. The person developing the next treatment for cancer may very well be someone who doesn't earn enough to ever pay back their student loan.

This kind of shortsighted money focused view embodies everything that is wrong in the UK and worse in the US. Money is absolutely not everything.

Beyond that, university teaches transferable skills. My DS has a degree in marine biology, but finding work in that field as a disabled person hasn't worked. He now works as a junior data person in the NHS. In his first three months, he identified productivity patterns that saved his organisation close on half a million pounds. It is unlikely that he will ever pay back his loans, because hey - disabled, only able to work part time. And yet he is generating monetary value. Your simplistic view of the world is in need of adjustment.

pointythings · 14/11/2026 19:12

morningspa · 14/11/2026 18:52

Yes., I see your point.

There are many scroungers in amongst those that actually need and deserve the help like your friend.

Again, a statement requiring substantiation. Let's see the data.

Kirbert2 · 14/11/2026 19:21

SleeplessInWherever · 14/11/2026 18:58

These changes won’t impact my son. Certainly not initially. He won’t be impacted by the proposed EHCP reviews either.

We’re in the “fortunate” decision that he’s “too disabled” to fall into most of these changes. Yay us, right?

We’re just not all selfish.

There are families who struggle just as much as we do, for different reasons and with different types of level of disability, but still struggle.

The system is not set up for disabled people to work, without adjustments that many employers will not make

I run a recruitment agency, and represent a woman who is diabetic. That’s her only need. Diabetes. Qualified and wonderful at what she does, but needs guaranteed breaks at guaranteed times so she can monitor her insulin and take any relevant actions.

You wouldn’t believe how difficult it is to find her work. For that one reason. Because employers (in this case schools) would rather have someone who doesn’t need that, who doesn’t need to pop out for 5mins every couple of hours. Who isn’t going to potentially go into diabetic shock.

Employers aren’t going to suddenly start installing ramps, making sure they have hearing loops where they don’t already, etc etc. They’re not going to give people more or extended breaks for whatever reason. Or appointment time that is higher than their other staff.

They’re going to take the easy route, and employ someone with less “complications.”

It’s not people who the general public consider “profoundly disabled” that will miss out. Not for a long while.

It’s the “SENbetweeners”, the physically disabled, and those with significant MH issues, who also matter.

Exactly.

Initially, I don't think it would impact my son either. Same with the EHCP changes too but I can absolutely see in the future that it will be the expectation for my son to work because he doesn't have a learning disability. I'm not at all against it as long as he gets the correct support and reasonable adjustments and I just don't see that happening as well as someone willing to hire him.

skylarkrise · 14/11/2026 19:36

pointythings · 14/11/2026 19:10

By your lights, hardly anyone should go to university. Nurses shouldn't. Scientists shouldn't. Engineers shouldn't. Because all those careers rely on people doing absolutely vital work for levels of pay that mean no, they will not pay back their loans. The person developing the next treatment for cancer may very well be someone who doesn't earn enough to ever pay back their student loan.

This kind of shortsighted money focused view embodies everything that is wrong in the UK and worse in the US. Money is absolutely not everything.

Beyond that, university teaches transferable skills. My DS has a degree in marine biology, but finding work in that field as a disabled person hasn't worked. He now works as a junior data person in the NHS. In his first three months, he identified productivity patterns that saved his organisation close on half a million pounds. It is unlikely that he will ever pay back his loans, because hey - disabled, only able to work part time. And yet he is generating monetary value. Your simplistic view of the world is in need of adjustment.

Nurses didn’t used to go to university and went to college at 16

its a shame now that they end up with a huge debt and can’t find employment easily

pointythings · 14/11/2026 19:44

skylarkrise · 14/11/2026 19:36

Nurses didn’t used to go to university and went to college at 16

its a shame now that they end up with a huge debt and can’t find employment easily

Nursing has changed enormously. What nurses used to do, healthcare assistants do now. If you knew anything at all about what is now expected of nurses, you would understand why they need that level of education.

BIossomtoes · 14/11/2026 19:45

skylarkrise · 14/11/2026 19:36

Nurses didn’t used to go to university and went to college at 16

its a shame now that they end up with a huge debt and can’t find employment easily

Nursing is a completely different profession now. I seem to remember that the minimum age for nursing training was 18.

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 19:47

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 07:55

Autism diagnosis rates are 1-2.3% . Fogarty has pointed out that we have been a diagnosis lead society ie you can’t get help without diagnosis. So young people can think what they like but unfortunately but without diagnoses it’s hard to get anything.

It also isn’t blackmailing to highlight the impact of withdrawing of support needs that is a reality that many families are living with and you will see on paed wards,A&E, crisis up and down the country. The impact of unsupported need has been highlighted by the government’s own reports.

The Fonagy review highlighted that unsupported need cause manageable difficulties to escalate into severe crises and the impact of leaving needs unsupported spans individual wellbeing, public services, and the wider economy. When early, accessible help is unavailable, everyday struggles and mild distress escalate into severe, complex mental health conditions. Because people are left to cope alone on multi-year waiting lists, services often only intervene when an individual reaches a breaking point or emergency. Leaving neurodevelopmental or mental health needs unaddressed undermines a person's relationships, education, and ability to sustain secure employment. The review notes that the consequences of rising, unsupported mental distress ripple outward into families, schools, workplaces, and the wider economy.

The NHS ADHD task force highlighted how undiagnosed and unsupported ADHD alone costs the country £17 billion a year!

Just ripping away PIP as a knee jerk collective policy is hugely dangerous. Nobody is being looked at individually and there is literally nothing in place to replace it or likely to be for a very long time.

Edited

Yours is a very thoughtful considered post, on a subject that (happily) I know very little about. I have a child who is severely dyslexic (inherited) but also very switched on. I would be horrified if he wanted to be diagnosed so that he could claim benefits.

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 19:50

Ott3r · 14/11/2026 19:03

This! They also need to accept that many ND people will not be able to do face to face work, presentations, socially network etc but they don’t. That is the reality.

Plenty of jobs don't require that kind of personal interaction. I've spent my entire working life of over 40 years avoiding it, including being a finance director of a manufacturing and design export firm, and for the last 25, running my own small business. I've never done a presentation, never done social networking, and honestly can't remember the last time I met a client face to face - probably at least 18-24 months ago, the last phone call I had would have been around six months ago. I even managed to avoid most of our previous jobs' Xmas parties.

Employers need to start realising that it simply doesn't work for everyone, and employees (potential employees) need to look for careers/jobs that don't require a lot of personal face to face interaction if they can't do it. It certainly doesn't mean that someone won't be able to work for their entire working age period.

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 19:51

pointythings · 14/11/2026 19:44

Nursing has changed enormously. What nurses used to do, healthcare assistants do now. If you knew anything at all about what is now expected of nurses, you would understand why they need that level of education.

You don't need to go to Uni to get "that level of education". You could train/learn in lots of other ways. Trouble is that successive governments have, wrongly, concentrated on degrees, and turned their backs on the other avenues for training/education.

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 19:52

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 19:09

Change is coming to the welfare budget. Why?

With AI, many neurotypical people will soon be joining the neurodiverse in a reliance on some kind of state support.

Most of you know this, even if you fear it or would rather pretend it’s not so.

Where is the money coming from to pay ever more and more people not to be economically productive? It's simply not going to happen.

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 19:56

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 19:52

Where is the money coming from to pay ever more and more people not to be economically productive? It's simply not going to happen.

How’s this for starters.

The Treasury is wargaming the introduction of an AI tax in the event of widespread job losses.

Civil servants have been tasked with analysing a range of economic consequences that could stem from the rise of the technology, including labour market disruption and a subsequent drop in tax receipts.

No 11 and the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology are working with academics and experts under a new AI Economics Institute, set up in June by Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, to understand the opportunities, risks and “inform government policy”.

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 19:58

ReviewAlternatives · 14/11/2026 17:01

It could be the circumstances we have now. More pressure, the schooling system, employment instability, higher cost of living and deteriorating public services.

Seriously, the stakes were much much higher before there was a welfare state. You earned your keep or went on the parish... to the workhouse, where you would have been allotted mandatory work. Failure to comply would have meant you did not eat.

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 20:02

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 19:56

How’s this for starters.

The Treasury is wargaming the introduction of an AI tax in the event of widespread job losses.

Civil servants have been tasked with analysing a range of economic consequences that could stem from the rise of the technology, including labour market disruption and a subsequent drop in tax receipts.

No 11 and the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology are working with academics and experts under a new AI Economics Institute, set up in June by Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, to understand the opportunities, risks and “inform government policy”.

Considering we can't properly tax overseas based firms at the moment, I fail to see how relying on an AI tax would work, as by definition, because they're AI, they're computer based, so literally could have head offices, data centres, etc anywhere on the globe. As I say, we can't properly tax the likes of Amazon, Google, etc at the moment, so I can't see how we'll tax them more if they start to rely more on AI - they'll just locate themselves in tax havens. Using VPNs, it will be difficult for tax authorities to know where the customers are located, especially seeing as it's relatively easy to open bank accounts in other countries, so Fred in Bradford could use a foreign bank account and a VPN to buy services from Google, and the HMRC would have no way of knowing where he was located nor how to tax him. I don't think people realise how easy it is - i.e. I get very cheap Spotify subscription by using a vpn and buying via their Indian site - no tax to UK's HMRC!

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 20:04

@BeckyAMumsnet (or other mod)

If you are going to delete posts, at least have the decency to explain to the poster why you have done so. Pathetic.

Rustybike · 14/11/2026 20:07

Badbadbunny · 14/11/2026 20:02

Considering we can't properly tax overseas based firms at the moment, I fail to see how relying on an AI tax would work, as by definition, because they're AI, they're computer based, so literally could have head offices, data centres, etc anywhere on the globe. As I say, we can't properly tax the likes of Amazon, Google, etc at the moment, so I can't see how we'll tax them more if they start to rely more on AI - they'll just locate themselves in tax havens. Using VPNs, it will be difficult for tax authorities to know where the customers are located, especially seeing as it's relatively easy to open bank accounts in other countries, so Fred in Bradford could use a foreign bank account and a VPN to buy services from Google, and the HMRC would have no way of knowing where he was located nor how to tax him. I don't think people realise how easy it is - i.e. I get very cheap Spotify subscription by using a vpn and buying via their Indian site - no tax to UK's HMRC!

Show me the incentive, and I will show you the outcome.

You will be amazed at how innovative Labour can be when it comes to raising tax (perhaps you wont).

johnworf · 14/11/2026 20:10

TigerRag · 14/11/2026 18:20

Hmmm, £86 a week, no pension, no rights to holiday, etc or work full time (I've yet to meet a carer doing the minimum of 35 a week to get carers allowance) and get things like a pension, holiday and money that they can actually live on? I know what I'd choose

I have a friend who was a teacher. She had to give up her job to care for her disabled child. She's had to beg for help. I'm sure she'd rather have a healthy 15 year old who doesn't go to bed with the fear of dying from seizures who can talk and do everything a 15 year old does

I've had to give up my job to look after my autistic and disabled son. The £86 I receive each week in carers allowance is nowhere near what I could earn but if I went to work and carers looked after him, how much would that cost the state?

I'm honestly sick of bloody having to fight for everything. It's exhausting. Not everyone is milking the system.

Papyrophile · 14/11/2026 20:12

Where is the emoji to signal "I am appalled" @MNHQ? I think a disapproval thumbs down would be good.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread