Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Rustybike · 13/11/2026 13:54

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:49

GPs are far from experts in mental health. Moreover, they have an incentive to want the number of diagnoses to come down because of the process of shared care. Medication for ADHD consists of controlled substances. These require an annual health check.for the person taking them, which has cost and workload implications for a surgery. Proper funding for shared care would mitigate this enormously. Let's see some surveys that incorporate the scenario where shared care is funded and staffed, and see if we get the same answers.

It appears you wish to ignore data which is contrary to your view.

Firstly, you sought to rely on the findings of one man, then you sought to rely on an assertion that you have worked in mental care, and now you would seek to diminish the role of GPs.

Forgive me, if I do not accept your arguments.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 13:55

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 11:48

You do realise that we aren't two different species? That disability isn't some absolute binary and that its actually on a continuum with very few people occupying either end and the vast majority of us sit somewhere in the middle. Fifty percent of people have a long term health condition in the UK and a third have a formally diagnosed chronic condition.

In this context it's pretty easy to understand why we need to have a high threshold for health and disability related benefits otherwise the majority of us will qualify for them. If the available resource isn't increasing accordingly then that means there is less available for those with the highest needs and that relatively few people will be funding an unsustainable bill.

25 percent of the population is disabled. Virtually everyone will either have a disabled loved one or be disabled themselves. It's highly likely that most of us will become disabled if we live long enough. Many people will struggle with their health before they get to that point. Ableism isn't the same as wanting a sensible and sustainable threshold implemented. It isn't a 'them' and 'us' scenario except it seems for some people that can't accept nuance and the fact that disability and struggles are a lot more widespread than they like to imagine. If you accept that disability and health related issues are normal and common then we need to allocate resource sensibly based on this and this includes limiting those that can access expensive benefit and support.

The threshold is already very high. There is no evidence it is too low or too easy to receive disability benefits. The problem is you are not accepting this fact.

Kirbert2 · 13/11/2026 13:56

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:51

But some evidence is. So a diagnosis helps

A diagnosis can count as evidence but that alone isn't going to do much without other evidence as a diagnosis doesn't automatically get you any points on PIP.

So benefits aren't for anyone with a diagnosis as pp said.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:57

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:50

Why do you not think GPS may simply have the best interests of their patients at heart?

Some health issues require specialist input. GPs cannot be experts on everything. One GP in my surgery has a specialist interest in mental health and has focused on it in her professional development. Her referral rates for mental illness, including ADHD, are higher than in the rest of the practice. Because she has expertise and knows what is best for her patients. Other members of the practice redirect patients to her.

The bar for referrals to specialist care is high.

OonaStubbs · 13/11/2026 14:03

Honestly I'm just sick of it. The benefits system is an out of control monster that is causing more problems that it solves at this point. It actually makes people incapable of working and getting on with life, that would be perfectly fine if they just got out there and worked and dealt with the problems that life throws at you.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:04

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:57

Some health issues require specialist input. GPs cannot be experts on everything. One GP in my surgery has a specialist interest in mental health and has focused on it in her professional development. Her referral rates for mental illness, including ADHD, are higher than in the rest of the practice. Because she has expertise and knows what is best for her patients. Other members of the practice redirect patients to her.

The bar for referrals to specialist care is high.

Her referral rates for mental health will be higher as patients with more serious mental health issues will be encouraged to see her.

People who have greater expertise often make less referrals iif given the same patients as they are better able to pick out those who really need a referral. Whereas those with less expertise will refer more borderline cases.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:06

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 12:48

Yes, and the threshold was set high and since 2010 has only been raised leaving many who need support without it
How do you explain such a huge increase in request for assessments? It can't be just explained by 'oh I didn't know I could claim benefits'.

If autism is indeed mainly genetic, there is no reason why there should be such a significant increase in just a few years.

The reason why so many more people are claiming is because people have learnt what assessors are looking for and so what to write on the form.

There was a recent thread about a disabled lady who was managing her symptoms, working FT, going to the gym three times, but was limited by how much she could do due to fatigue. The majority of posters said that she should apply, that she could justify her limitations with X and y arguments etc...to tick the right boxes. And then we wonder why more and more people are questioning the whole system.

Generation Z are so much less employable than previous generations at the same age. Employers prefer to employ older people because they are so much easier to manage.

My DS recently supported a trainee whose just joined the team. He did break the ice by saying that his role was not the most exciting but he would try to describe it as least being as he could. When he asked if they had any questions at the end, they right said no. When he tried to engage and he asked them a question about the experience, their response was 'sorey can you repeat, I wasn't listening '.

And then they wonder why employers are not keen on them!

The increase in PIP assessments are down to three main reasons:

  1. Transition of 16+ from DLA to PIP (still ongoing)
  2. Shorter PIP awards driving more frequent reassessments
  3. Covid long term health impacts

”The reason why so many more people are claiming is because people have learnt what assessors are looking for and so what to write on the form.” This is a inaccurate. In fact, a smaller % of the population are claiming disability benefits compared to ten years ago after adjustment for age.

“The majority of posters said that she should apply, that she could justify her limitations with X and y arguments etc...to tick the right boxes.”
Another myth, Applying for PIP is not a tick box exercise where it is based entirely on your word. I saw the same thread and the majority of posters actually said ofc you can apply, but you likely will not be awarded PIP. PIP requires medical evidence from a doctor, preferably specialist consultant(s) to support everything argued as a limitation.

“Employers prefer to employ older people because they are so much easier to manage.” There was an investigative piece on this where employers admitted they were not hiring recent school leavers or Uni graduates because they did not want the expense of training entry level workers and for many entry level jobs, AI has replaced these jobs. It is not due to Gen Z being unmanageable. The anecdote about your DS and one trainee is not reflective of wider trends.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:07

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 12:08

I wonder what measures are being taken to stop the over-diagnosis of mental health related conditions in the first place?

No such thing as over diagnosis by doctors.
If you mean people self-diagnosing, do not worry they would not get disability benefits.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:10

GPs are far from experts in mental health
Oh the irony!!! They much more experts in m natal health medicine than a professor of psychology who has no medical training whatsoever!

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:11

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 13:54

It appears you wish to ignore data which is contrary to your view.

Firstly, you sought to rely on the findings of one man, then you sought to rely on an assertion that you have worked in mental care, and now you would seek to diminish the role of GPs.

Forgive me, if I do not accept your arguments.

Professor Fonagy was the lead in a large enquiry involving many clinicians, as you would know if you had bothered to read up. He acted as its spokesman.

The review is wide ranging and in depth, covering a great deal more than just the matter of over and underdiagnosis. Here's a link to it: Independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism: final report - GOV.UK https://share.google/oo7nNDTAOlvNiuroq

What experience of working in mental health do you have?

Independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism: final report

Final report detailing the findings of the independent review into the prevalence and support for mental health conditions, ADHD and autism.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-final-report

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 14:11

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:07

No such thing as over diagnosis by doctors.
If you mean people self-diagnosing, do not worry they would not get disability benefits.

Well now, if you see my earlier post - your assertion is evidently incorrect.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:12

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:10

GPs are far from experts in mental health
Oh the irony!!! They much more experts in m natal health medicine than a professor of psychology who has no medical training whatsoever!

You're saying clinical psychologists aren't experts in mental health? Wow.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:13

The threshold is already very high. There is no evidence it is too low or too easy to receive disability benefits. The problem is you are not accepting this fact
The evidence is being compiled right now and will be waiting to be used by political parties to make their argument. People like you are not going to see their 'facts' overthrown.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:14

More than eight in 10 patients referred to adult ADHD services receive a positive diagnosis, GPs in the survey also estimated.

The Pulse survey of more than 800 GPs suggested that, on average, 81.3% of patients referred were ultimately diagnosed with ADHD, based on a midpoint analysis of responses.

Not being funny but this is irrelevant and does not at all indicate any potential over diagnosis of ADHD. It just means that 80% of the time a GP suspecting ADHD is correct.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:15

The bar for referrals to specialist care is high
Not for CBT treatment. As a matter of fact, in many areas, patients can self refer to the service!

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 14:15

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:11

Professor Fonagy was the lead in a large enquiry involving many clinicians, as you would know if you had bothered to read up. He acted as its spokesman.

The review is wide ranging and in depth, covering a great deal more than just the matter of over and underdiagnosis. Here's a link to it: Independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism: final report - GOV.UK https://share.google/oo7nNDTAOlvNiuroq

What experience of working in mental health do you have?

You insist on referring to your work in MH, yet make no mention of the level of seniority, tenure, or how long ago it was etc. Again, data.

And yet, because I have not worked in MH, my opinion does not matter? I am guessing most on this thread have not worked in MH. Do their views not matter, either?

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:18

@Rustybike
The recommendation is the most telling bit of what you posted and does not indicate over diagnosis but a rise in diagnoses:
It concluded economic uncertainty combined with social media was driving an increase in mental health problems among young people and said there needed to be better support in place for all conditions.

The increase in diagnoses is due to an increase in poor mental health and the current support is not good enough. The report is not calling for a reduction in support like the Milburn and Timms reviews are tasked with doing to the point that they will twist a report saying the exact opposite.

Young woman looks out of her bedroom window

Young people are not snowflakes, head of mental health review says

Speaking exclusively to the BBC, Prof Peter Fonagy says being young is much harder now than it was.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cqzrz0z4plk1o

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:20

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:15

The bar for referrals to specialist care is high
Not for CBT treatment. As a matter of fact, in many areas, patients can self refer to the service!

Can self refer in my area.
It's the community mental health team that has a higher bar. Because they support people with diagnosable mental illness.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:21

In fact, a smaller % of the population are claiming disability benefits compared to ten years ago after adjustment for age
Oh please provide your sources! Even AI comes states that in England and Wales, working-age disability benefit claims grew from nearly 3 million (1 in 13 people) in 2019 to about 4 million (1 in 10 people) by March 2025 and Child DLA recipients in England and Wales nearly doubled from 333,000 in 2013 to 682,000 by 2023, largely driven by increases in learning difficulties, behavioural disorders, and ADHD.

Transition into adulthood benefits, shorter assessment period and COVID are in no way the main reason for this ridiculous increase.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:22

@LiberteLynx but extra benefits is not the solution. First of all it's about parents reducing childrens access to social media

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:23

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:13

The threshold is already very high. There is no evidence it is too low or too easy to receive disability benefits. The problem is you are not accepting this fact
The evidence is being compiled right now and will be waiting to be used by political parties to make their argument. People like you are not going to see their 'facts' overthrown.

People like me? What do you mean by that?

Also the evidence has been compiled for decades by numerous charities and nonprofit watch dogs. The UN also has investigated in 2016 and 2024 and written a scathing report on the raised thresholds and prior cuts disability benefits. They called it an attack on the human rights of disabled people.
https://www.disabilityrightsuk.org/news/no-progress-2016-grave-and-systemic-violations-disabled-peoples-rights-un-report-says

Evidence being compiled! As if it has not been in front of everyone’s noses for a decade.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:24

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 14:15

You insist on referring to your work in MH, yet make no mention of the level of seniority, tenure, or how long ago it was etc. Again, data.

And yet, because I have not worked in MH, my opinion does not matter? I am guessing most on this thread have not worked in MH. Do their views not matter, either?

Going to read at least the summary on the link I sent?

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:25

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:22

@LiberteLynx but extra benefits is not the solution. First of all it's about parents reducing childrens access to social media

Need both for the DC not yet suffering mental illness and the older children/young adults who are. Unless you want to write off an entire generation instead of supporting them into better health and employment? Btw, increasing support does not mean handing out cash.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:26

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:20

Can self refer in my area.
It's the community mental health team that has a higher bar. Because they support people with diagnosable mental illness.

You don't get PIP just because you have had a bit of CBT.

Badbadbunny · 13/11/2026 14:26

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:49

GPs are far from experts in mental health. Moreover, they have an incentive to want the number of diagnoses to come down because of the process of shared care. Medication for ADHD consists of controlled substances. These require an annual health check.for the person taking them, which has cost and workload implications for a surgery. Proper funding for shared care would mitigate this enormously. Let's see some surveys that incorporate the scenario where shared care is funded and staffed, and see if we get the same answers.

I thought GP surgeries received additional funding depending on number of patients with certain MH issues, so surely that's an incentive to diagnose more as it generates more income for them?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread