Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Badbadbunny · 13/11/2026 14:27

@LiberteLynx

Btw, increasing support does not mean handing out cash.

I agree.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:30

You're saying clinical psychologists aren't experts in mental health? Wow
I'm saying they not medical experts, that's correct. Psychologists are not doctors. They don't medically treat patients with mental health. They can't medically diagnosed people. Surely you know that if you are the expert you claim to be.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:31

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 14:22

@LiberteLynx but extra benefits is not the solution. First of all it's about parents reducing childrens access to social media

Social media is only one of a multitude of factors influencing mental health. Suggesting otherwise is misleading. It helps nobody to indulge in simplistic thinking, whether that be 'more benefits ', 'cut benefits ' or 'it's social media '.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:38

On the basis of evidence available to us we cannot conclude that overdiagnosis is occurring at scale, particularly given the gaps in population prevalence data and data reporting. However, if present trends continue we are clearly entering a phase in which the balance of risks is changing, from previous merited concerns with under recognition and underdiagnosis, towards an increased risk of misdiagnosis and overdiagnosis, which are becoming increasingly important considerations for policy and service delivery

@pointythings , this is what the report states. I actually do like this report. It doesn't say at all what you are claiming! It says it can't reach a conclusion because of lack of data and reporting, not because it isn't happening. Indeed, he then states that over diagnosis is a society risk!

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:40

People like me? What do you mean by that?
People who think they know 'the facts'.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 14:42

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:24

Going to read at least the summary on the link I sent?

Yes, happily.

Edit: Whilst I am doing so, can I ask how you would propose funding the increasing welfare budget?

pointythings · 13/11/2026 14:44

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:30

You're saying clinical psychologists aren't experts in mental health? Wow
I'm saying they not medical experts, that's correct. Psychologists are not doctors. They don't medically treat patients with mental health. They can't medically diagnosed people. Surely you know that if you are the expert you claim to be.

That is why, once you are in secondary care, you see a MDT which usually includes a psychiatrist. This doesn't mean a psychologist is unable to test and screen for mental illness. Can't formally diagnose does not mean 'hasn't a clue'. Otherwise we wouldn't bother with psychology at all. Mental illness isn't simply a matter of the mechanics of the body. Psychiatrists handle the things that require medication and make the diagnosis. Treatment is usually more than just medication. Once again: beware simplistic thinking in complex circumstances.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:45

And here it comes out of the mouth of your psychology expert:
There are strong concerns about the consistency and quality of ADHD and autism assessments being carried out by independent providers, and the financial incentives associated with assessment activity. Independent providers now carry out more than half of all NHS-funded ADHD assessments and more than a third of autism assessments. Spending on independent-sector ADHD provision has risen by around 252% in 3 years, with a projected overspend of £164 million across the areas analysed alone (see reference 18). Yet this large and fast-growing use of public money is running without consistent oversight, transparency or quality assurance - commissioners often cannot see what they are paying for (chapter 12). This is not acceptable

I do like him 😄

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:47

Can't formally diagnose does not mean 'hasn't a clue'
Your words, not mine! I have a master in psychology, just didn't apply for the PhD! Psychologists are massively useful and essential. However, as you now admit, they can't diagnose....which was my argument!

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 14:53

@pointythings This jumped out at me.

The risks of misdiagnosis and overdiagnosis increase where:

  • an individual’s difficulties overlap
  • assessment quality varies
  • data is withheld
  • thresholds are applied inconsistently
  • diagnosis becomes the principal gateway to support
SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 14:53

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:45

And here it comes out of the mouth of your psychology expert:
There are strong concerns about the consistency and quality of ADHD and autism assessments being carried out by independent providers, and the financial incentives associated with assessment activity. Independent providers now carry out more than half of all NHS-funded ADHD assessments and more than a third of autism assessments. Spending on independent-sector ADHD provision has risen by around 252% in 3 years, with a projected overspend of £164 million across the areas analysed alone (see reference 18). Yet this large and fast-growing use of public money is running without consistent oversight, transparency or quality assurance - commissioners often cannot see what they are paying for (chapter 12). This is not acceptable

I do like him 😄

I like these bits:

"On the basis of evidence available to us we cannot conclude that overdiagnosis is occurring at scale."

"The rising numbers coming forward for assessment have not been accompanied by any fall in severity or impairment – those now presenting are no less affected than those identified before."

"People are seeking answers and support for very real problems, and they are not the problem. The problem is a system that leans too heavily on diagnosis as the route to help and cannot keep pace."

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 14:57

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:21

In fact, a smaller % of the population are claiming disability benefits compared to ten years ago after adjustment for age
Oh please provide your sources! Even AI comes states that in England and Wales, working-age disability benefit claims grew from nearly 3 million (1 in 13 people) in 2019 to about 4 million (1 in 10 people) by March 2025 and Child DLA recipients in England and Wales nearly doubled from 333,000 in 2013 to 682,000 by 2023, largely driven by increases in learning difficulties, behavioural disorders, and ADHD.

Transition into adulthood benefits, shorter assessment period and COVID are in no way the main reason for this ridiculous increase.

Transition into adulthood benefits, shorter assessment period and COVID are in no way the main reason for this ridiculous increase.

You misunderstood. It is not transition into adulthood benefits but the transition of adults from DLA to PIP. It is also not a shorter assessment period, but a shorter award period.

All children and adults used to claim DLA. Since 2016 when PIP was rolled out, DWP have been transitioning the millions of adults on DLA to PIP. The transition requires everyone receiving DLA to submit a claim for PIP and be assessed as if they were a new claimant as the PIP criteria are much more strict. The transition was paused during Covid. Post Covid immense resources were diverted to transition adults on DLA to PIP. They are still not done.

DLA awards were typically longer and included life time awards. PIP has shorter awards and no lifetime award (until they recently added a light touch review) requiring more frequent re-assessments of disabled people. For example, if you have 10,000 people on 10 year DLA awards that drives only 1,000 extra claims per year, but if you have transitioned them to PIP and only given them a 3yr award, that drives an extra 3,333 claims per year for the exact same number of disability benefit recipients.

Covid has definitely worsened the general health of the population and this has been exacerbated by underfunding the NHS, especially mental health provision. It is not rocket science to realise a pandemic of a virus that has long term effects of damaging multiple organs and systems would drive an increase in sick people. Or rocket science to realise that wait lists and lack of access to timely healthcare causes minor health issues to worsen into disabling major health problems. The increase in the mortality rates for all ages in the UK shows this.

In addition, reporting the number of disability benefit claims is cheeky because 59% of new disability benefit claims are disallowed as of early 2026, up from 40% in 2024. What matters are the number of disability benefit awards.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 15:00

So the conclusion is as expected: no evidence that overdiagnosis is happening. It might happen due to current assessment systems being not fit for purpose and muddied by perverse financial incentives. The link between diagnosis and support isn't helpful. People's problems are real.

As I keep saying: complicated. I have never argued that change isn't needed. It is. But simply taking people's support away will not help. Any solutions will involve investment in people, health and education, regulation of social media, system change, but in from employers and a change in attitudes towards disability. There are no quick fixes.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 15:00

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 14:53

I like these bits:

"On the basis of evidence available to us we cannot conclude that overdiagnosis is occurring at scale."

"The rising numbers coming forward for assessment have not been accompanied by any fall in severity or impairment – those now presenting are no less affected than those identified before."

"People are seeking answers and support for very real problems, and they are not the problem. The problem is a system that leans too heavily on diagnosis as the route to help and cannot keep pace."

I write in all seriousness.

If the taxpayer is continually hammered, there will be a MH crisis amongst them, too. Many are are breaking point.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:04

pointythings · 13/11/2026 15:00

So the conclusion is as expected: no evidence that overdiagnosis is happening. It might happen due to current assessment systems being not fit for purpose and muddied by perverse financial incentives. The link between diagnosis and support isn't helpful. People's problems are real.

As I keep saying: complicated. I have never argued that change isn't needed. It is. But simply taking people's support away will not help. Any solutions will involve investment in people, health and education, regulation of social media, system change, but in from employers and a change in attitudes towards disability. There are no quick fixes.

How does getting higher benefits support young people with less severe ADHD or autism?
It traps them as they get as much in benefits as minimum wage.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 15:05

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 14:40

People like me? What do you mean by that?
People who think they know 'the facts'.

It is clear I know alot more of the facts than you do. You are using AI to give you the wrong data. An increase in claims does not correspond to an increase in the % of people on disability benefits after adjustment for age (which also includes adjusting for the increased SPA). You did not even know the difference between an assessment period and award period or that PIP is relatively new benefit rolled out by the Tories to cut disability benefits by replacing DLA for adults and applying a much higher threshold through stricter criteria.

You said too evidence is being compiled like we do not already have millions of pages worth already including UN investigations from 2016 and 2024.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:07

Pip has been around for 13 years so not that new.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 15:09

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 15:00

I write in all seriousness.

If the taxpayer is continually hammered, there will be a MH crisis amongst them, too. Many are are breaking point.

There already is a MH crisis, it just has not happened to you personally. Yet you want to cut support for those just like you who have already been affected by it.

https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/england-experiencing-pandemic-mental-health-crisis-2026a100056k

England is in the throes of a mental health crisis of “pandemic proportion,” the Royal College of Psychiatrists (RCPsych) has warned, with many people unable to access help when they need it.
The situation has “spiralled out of control,” the college said, with patients increasingly only able to access care at crisis point because services are overwhelmed and underresourced.
RCPsych president Dr Lade Smith described the situation as “atrocious” and warned that the longer the scale of the challenge was ignored, the harder it would be to overcome.

In England in 2024-2025, 4.1 million people were in contact with mental health services, up 56% from 2.6 million in 2016-2017, according to NHS data. The number of children and young people in contact with services rose by 118%, from 500,000 to 1.2 million over the same period.

England Experiencing ‘Pandemic’ Mental Health Crisis

The Royal College of Psychiatrists says services are overwhelmed, underfunded, and forcing patients to wait until crisis point for care.

https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/england-experiencing-pandemic-mental-health-crisis-2026a100056k

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:10

And where are you getting that the proportion of people claiming disability benefits has decreased? That is the opposite of what I am reading.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 15:11

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 15:00

I write in all seriousness.

If the taxpayer is continually hammered, there will be a MH crisis amongst them, too. Many are are breaking point.

I believe you. I am one.

I’m not an additional rate tax payer, in fairness, I’m at the top end of higher rate.

I’m well aware that it’s difficult, and that my pounds don’t stretch as far as they used to etc.

But that’s not the fault of the disabled or vulnerable, and welfare reform will not put money back in your pocket.

I won’t receive more salary because Bob isn’t getting PIP for his MH, it’ll go somewhere else the government sees fit.

So either people have different tax spend priorities - fair enough, I happen to think we should prioritise disability funding and wouldn’t like to see it redistributed.

Or, as is the case with some of the comments here - it’s spite. Some people don’t want others to have the support regardless of whether their own income would change or not, and it’s not within me to have that attitude.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:13

@LiberteLynx that article says the numbers seeking help has soared. That does not actually mean mental health is worse. More and more people are seeking medical help for the sadness and anxiety of everyday life.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 15:13

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:07

Pip has been around for 13 years so not that new.

It was rolled out in 2016 for new claimants and they started to transition the 2+ million adults on DLA to PIP. These 2 million are being counted among the increase in PIP claims numbers published by the government. There are still over 100k adults on DLA not yet transitioned to PIP.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 15:16

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:04

How does getting higher benefits support young people with less severe ADHD or autism?
It traps them as they get as much in benefits as minimum wage.

  1. Where did I say young people with minor conditions should get more benefits? I didn't. My DS, who gets PIP and has major disabilities (for which he gets the PIP) as well as autism and depression (which puts him on the list of 'those' young people even though it isn't the grounds for his award) works. He would tell you working is key to his life. Bug he is still, and always will be, disabled.
  1. You don't get PIP for mild conditions.
LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 15:17

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:13

@LiberteLynx that article says the numbers seeking help has soared. That does not actually mean mental health is worse. More and more people are seeking medical help for the sadness and anxiety of everyday life.

Sorry that is bullshit and I know that because part of this MH crisis is a significant increase in suicide attempts and completed suicides as well as deaths from accidental drug overdoses. You do not get this pattern from people seeking help for everyday issues all of a sudden. Too if you look at the age groups, it is the young people 16-24 and also the 45-54 showing the sharpest increases in mental illness, suicide and drug overdose deaths.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 15:18

@LiberteLynx some people are never transitioned to pip such as those approaching state pension age or over it.
And pip started in 2013.
And since 2013 1.3 million adults in total have been transitioned from DLA to pip according to DWP stats. So please share your source that gives very different figures

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.