Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 11:27

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 11:23

I never mentioned seeing people in Tesco, the people I know are acquaintances I see regularly and a girl I lived with in a hostel who apparently had adhd (we shared the kitchen, bathroom and living room) lived together for two years so yeah I’m not making assumptions about people I met for one minute if that’s what you’re implying

I’m not implying anything.

I’m suggesting that sharing a kitchen with someone doesn’t mean you have an in-depth insight into what they do or don’t struggle with.

I had a nervous breakdown in 2022, I was sleeping 2hrs a night, every night, for months. I’m lucky to be alive.

I worked full time throughout that whole period, and maintained my life around its absolute collapse. Had literally zero time off sick.

You could have spent all day with me and had zero clue. My employees did.

Because like I keep saying, you don’t and can’t know. So maybe judge people less, focus on your own shit, and let the people who do the assessments, and do get the evidence and information, make the decisions.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 11:28

SomersetBrie · 13/11/2026 11:14

Charity is a good word. Given willingly and with love and should be accepted with gratitude.

Do you think the same about the state pension? Child benefit?

Most disabled people either pay taxes or did pay taxes at one time. If they are children/young adults, their parents are tax payers.

If you feel all welfare is charity even if you paid into it, then fair enough.

Technically speaking, welfare is a form of sickness, disability and old age insurance managed at the national level by the government and funded through general taxation. Employers pay into more than individuals do, so take a minute to tell your employer how grateful you are.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 11:28

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 11:23

A school for severe disabilities yeah

Shame it didn’t make you more compassionate.

Or convince you ADHD exists.

Papyrophile · 13/11/2026 11:30

"Being on benefits is a precarious income. Governments change."

And the government will change. The majority of voters, having seen their taxes increased by fiscal drag for a decade while their earnings fail to grow, are likely to choose a governing party who promise to give the welfare budget a good shake up.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 11:33

Papyrophile · 13/11/2026 11:30

"Being on benefits is a precarious income. Governments change."

And the government will change. The majority of voters, having seen their taxes increased by fiscal drag for a decade while their earnings fail to grow, are likely to choose a governing party who promise to give the welfare budget a good shake up.

Edited

You know any savings from welfare cuts are going straight to MoD right? They are not going to cut your taxes or make life any easier for you.

BIossomtoes · 13/11/2026 11:38

Papyrophile · 13/11/2026 11:30

"Being on benefits is a precarious income. Governments change."

And the government will change. The majority of voters, having seen their taxes increased by fiscal drag for a decade while their earnings fail to grow, are likely to choose a governing party who promise to give the welfare budget a good shake up.

Edited

What stopped the Tory government from doing this? The current system was their invention.

Papyrophile · 13/11/2026 11:42

Very true. Too many knee jerk reactions on both sides of the House; my point being that these are huge issues and that cross party support for the Milburn, Timms and social care reviews will be needed to demonstrate that the tide can be turned so people in need get appropriate help when needed. Some of it is likely to be quite robust, even if it is played out over a decade.

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 11:48

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 11:02

True, but in the case of the disabled, the bar is always being set by the abled who often have ableist opinions as is very plain on this thread, other threads, the government reports written on the subject, and the press releases by the Milburn and Timms reviews.

You do realise that we aren't two different species? That disability isn't some absolute binary and that its actually on a continuum with very few people occupying either end and the vast majority of us sit somewhere in the middle. Fifty percent of people have a long term health condition in the UK and a third have a formally diagnosed chronic condition.

In this context it's pretty easy to understand why we need to have a high threshold for health and disability related benefits otherwise the majority of us will qualify for them. If the available resource isn't increasing accordingly then that means there is less available for those with the highest needs and that relatively few people will be funding an unsustainable bill.

25 percent of the population is disabled. Virtually everyone will either have a disabled loved one or be disabled themselves. It's highly likely that most of us will become disabled if we live long enough. Many people will struggle with their health before they get to that point. Ableism isn't the same as wanting a sensible and sustainable threshold implemented. It isn't a 'them' and 'us' scenario except it seems for some people that can't accept nuance and the fact that disability and struggles are a lot more widespread than they like to imagine. If you accept that disability and health related issues are normal and common then we need to allocate resource sensibly based on this and this includes limiting those that can access expensive benefit and support.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 12:08

I wonder what measures are being taken to stop the over-diagnosis of mental health related conditions in the first place?

pointythings · 13/11/2026 12:26

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 12:08

I wonder what measures are being taken to stop the over-diagnosis of mental health related conditions in the first place?

The independent review led by Peter Fonagy concluded there is no overdiagnosis. He's a world leading expert. You are not.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 12:29

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 12:08

I wonder what measures are being taken to stop the over-diagnosis of mental health related conditions in the first place?

Because over diagnosis isn’t happening. You’re unlikely to get anything diagnosis or treatment-wise even if you’re very unwell.

The Fogarty review has found diagnosis reflects real psychological distress, anxiety, and depression rather than a "work-shy" or over diagnosed trend.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 12:32

pointythings · 13/11/2026 12:26

The independent review led by Peter Fonagy concluded there is no overdiagnosis. He's a world leading expert. You are not.

This!

Llttledrummergirl · 13/11/2026 12:36

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 10:04

What end of the contract are long term claimants fulfilling?

This comment is abhorrent.

I have a close relative who had a life limiting condition that was obvious the second they were born.

They were never going to be able to work.

The minimal payment received to keep them housed, fed clean and mentally active is something we should be proud that we provide as a society.

Would you have preferred they were drowned at birth so not to need society support to live?

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 12:39

pointythings · 13/11/2026 12:26

The independent review led by Peter Fonagy concluded there is no overdiagnosis. He's a world leading expert. You are not.

I am as much an expert as you, correct?

There is a risk of people being over-diagnosed with ADHD and autism, an official review in England has found.

Experts said a rise in diagnoses over the past 25 years meant cases now appear to be outstripping the expected number in the population for some younger age groups.

The review called for tougher regulation of private firms offering assessments for the NHS, saying they had concerns about quality and consistency, and a ban on advertising.

It concluded economic uncertainty combined with social media was driving an increase in mental health problems among young people and said there needed to be better support in place for all conditions.

The review - led by leading doctors in the field - was ordered 10 months ago by Wes Streeting after the then-health secretary claimed in an interview that young people were over-diagnosed and "written off".

It looked at people of all ages, but particularly focused on young people and children who have the highest rates of diagnoses.

It is likely to feed into government policies on everything from NHS services and benefits to support for young people who are not in education, employment or training.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 12:48

Yes, and the threshold was set high and since 2010 has only been raised leaving many who need support without it
How do you explain such a huge increase in request for assessments? It can't be just explained by 'oh I didn't know I could claim benefits'.

If autism is indeed mainly genetic, there is no reason why there should be such a significant increase in just a few years.

The reason why so many more people are claiming is because people have learnt what assessors are looking for and so what to write on the form.

There was a recent thread about a disabled lady who was managing her symptoms, working FT, going to the gym three times, but was limited by how much she could do due to fatigue. The majority of posters said that she should apply, that she could justify her limitations with X and y arguments etc...to tick the right boxes. And then we wonder why more and more people are questioning the whole system.

Generation Z are so much less employable than previous generations at the same age. Employers prefer to employ older people because they are so much easier to manage.

My DS recently supported a trainee whose just joined the team. He did break the ice by saying that his role was not the most exciting but he would try to describe it as least being as he could. When he asked if they had any questions at the end, they right said no. When he tried to engage and he asked them a question about the experience, their response was 'sorey can you repeat, I wasn't listening '.

And then they wonder why employers are not keen on them!

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 12:55

The independent review led by Peter Fonagy concluded there is no overdiagnosis. He's a world leading expert. You are not
He's a professor of psychology, not a psychiatrist or paediatrician, so frankly, his research might be very interesting, but it's not medical! I'll put my trust in the actual mental health doctors first.

Heatedblankettime · 13/11/2026 13:01

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 12:48

Yes, and the threshold was set high and since 2010 has only been raised leaving many who need support without it
How do you explain such a huge increase in request for assessments? It can't be just explained by 'oh I didn't know I could claim benefits'.

If autism is indeed mainly genetic, there is no reason why there should be such a significant increase in just a few years.

The reason why so many more people are claiming is because people have learnt what assessors are looking for and so what to write on the form.

There was a recent thread about a disabled lady who was managing her symptoms, working FT, going to the gym three times, but was limited by how much she could do due to fatigue. The majority of posters said that she should apply, that she could justify her limitations with X and y arguments etc...to tick the right boxes. And then we wonder why more and more people are questioning the whole system.

Generation Z are so much less employable than previous generations at the same age. Employers prefer to employ older people because they are so much easier to manage.

My DS recently supported a trainee whose just joined the team. He did break the ice by saying that his role was not the most exciting but he would try to describe it as least being as he could. When he asked if they had any questions at the end, they right said no. When he tried to engage and he asked them a question about the experience, their response was 'sorey can you repeat, I wasn't listening '.

And then they wonder why employers are not keen on them!

Exactly. I have a condition that means I struggle but I am able to work full time (from home)and walk the dog short distances. There are people at the charity for my condition telling us all exactly how we should embellish on the form to make sure we get the benefits.

I am not going to
a) because to me embellishment is fraud
and
b) because I am a high earner and I find it astonishing these benefits aren't means tested - of course they should be.
Benefits should be for the profoundly disabled not for anyone with any diagnosis and a creative touch on an application form

Heatedblankettime · 13/11/2026 13:08

pointythings · 13/11/2026 12:26

The independent review led by Peter Fonagy concluded there is no overdiagnosis. He's a world leading expert. You are not.

But it's not just about the rate of diagnosis it's about what people do with that diagnosis. I am sure that I and most of my friendship group would have an autism/ADHD /Audhd diagnosis if we were growing up as teens over the last decade or so. We all struggled with all kinds of things. But we figured out solutions , navigated school and found jobs that valued our strengths

I know there are some very profoundly disabled people. But the current diagnosis/benefits culture also gives too many people reasons not to try and overcome obstacles

If I wrote out everything I have been through and overcome it would run to many pages. And that applies to most of the successful people I know

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 13:11

Heatedblankettime · 13/11/2026 13:01

Exactly. I have a condition that means I struggle but I am able to work full time (from home)and walk the dog short distances. There are people at the charity for my condition telling us all exactly how we should embellish on the form to make sure we get the benefits.

I am not going to
a) because to me embellishment is fraud
and
b) because I am a high earner and I find it astonishing these benefits aren't means tested - of course they should be.
Benefits should be for the profoundly disabled not for anyone with any diagnosis and a creative touch on an application form

Incredible, thanks for sharing your story, and for your honesty.

Seven in 10 GPs think adult ADHD is ‘overdiagnosed’, including nearly half who think it is ‘very overdiagnosed’, a Pulse survey has suggested.

More than eight in 10 patients referred to adult ADHD services receive a positive diagnosis, GPs in the survey also estimated.

The Pulse survey of more than 800 GPs suggested that, on average, 81.3% of patients referred were ultimately diagnosed with ADHD, based on a midpoint analysis of responses.

A GP from Berkshire told Pulse that of over 1,000 patients they had referred, only one did not receive a positive ADHD diagnosis.
Other responders told Pulse that they perceived the diagnosis rate for those referred to private provider routes was higher than via NHS routes.
September 2026

Kirbert2 · 13/11/2026 13:26

Heatedblankettime · 13/11/2026 13:01

Exactly. I have a condition that means I struggle but I am able to work full time (from home)and walk the dog short distances. There are people at the charity for my condition telling us all exactly how we should embellish on the form to make sure we get the benefits.

I am not going to
a) because to me embellishment is fraud
and
b) because I am a high earner and I find it astonishing these benefits aren't means tested - of course they should be.
Benefits should be for the profoundly disabled not for anyone with any diagnosis and a creative touch on an application form

A diagnosis isn't required to be eligible for PIP (or DLA).

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:44

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 12:39

I am as much an expert as you, correct?

There is a risk of people being over-diagnosed with ADHD and autism, an official review in England has found.

Experts said a rise in diagnoses over the past 25 years meant cases now appear to be outstripping the expected number in the population for some younger age groups.

The review called for tougher regulation of private firms offering assessments for the NHS, saying they had concerns about quality and consistency, and a ban on advertising.

It concluded economic uncertainty combined with social media was driving an increase in mental health problems among young people and said there needed to be better support in place for all conditions.

The review - led by leading doctors in the field - was ordered 10 months ago by Wes Streeting after the then-health secretary claimed in an interview that young people were over-diagnosed and "written off".

It looked at people of all ages, but particularly focused on young people and children who have the highest rates of diagnoses.

It is likely to feed into government policies on everything from NHS services and benefits to support for young people who are not in education, employment or training.

Have you worked in mental health research with Professor Fonagy? I have.

And saying 'there is a risk' does not mean it's happening, especially when a world leading expert says it is not, and that the rise is driven by a rise in mental ill health.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:48

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:46

Incorrect,eating disorders , CPTSD, OCD, self harm….are all serious mental health conditions.

They can be at the severe end.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:49

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 13:11

Incredible, thanks for sharing your story, and for your honesty.

Seven in 10 GPs think adult ADHD is ‘overdiagnosed’, including nearly half who think it is ‘very overdiagnosed’, a Pulse survey has suggested.

More than eight in 10 patients referred to adult ADHD services receive a positive diagnosis, GPs in the survey also estimated.

The Pulse survey of more than 800 GPs suggested that, on average, 81.3% of patients referred were ultimately diagnosed with ADHD, based on a midpoint analysis of responses.

A GP from Berkshire told Pulse that of over 1,000 patients they had referred, only one did not receive a positive ADHD diagnosis.
Other responders told Pulse that they perceived the diagnosis rate for those referred to private provider routes was higher than via NHS routes.
September 2026

Edited

GPs are far from experts in mental health. Moreover, they have an incentive to want the number of diagnoses to come down because of the process of shared care. Medication for ADHD consists of controlled substances. These require an annual health check.for the person taking them, which has cost and workload implications for a surgery. Proper funding for shared care would mitigate this enormously. Let's see some surveys that incorporate the scenario where shared care is funded and staffed, and see if we get the same answers.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:50

pointythings · 13/11/2026 13:49

GPs are far from experts in mental health. Moreover, they have an incentive to want the number of diagnoses to come down because of the process of shared care. Medication for ADHD consists of controlled substances. These require an annual health check.for the person taking them, which has cost and workload implications for a surgery. Proper funding for shared care would mitigate this enormously. Let's see some surveys that incorporate the scenario where shared care is funded and staffed, and see if we get the same answers.

Why do you not think GPS may simply have the best interests of their patients at heart?

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 13:51

Kirbert2 · 13/11/2026 13:26

A diagnosis isn't required to be eligible for PIP (or DLA).

But some evidence is. So a diagnosis helps

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread