Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
frozendaisy · 13/11/2026 09:26

I think this report has been made with all the right intention of not just accepting that a rising number of young adults are being trapped in the benefits system.

But I don’t think it’s going to work.

Be interesting to see next week if the glaring issues of where will these jobs come from, what actual support if any will be in place? I think they are hoping a lot of “improvements” will be by reducing benefits for the mental health conditions that are not necessarily lifelong. Anxiety and depression, and address ADHD managing strategies.

Being on benefits is a precarious income. Governments change. If you have say a 20 year old right now realistically they have 50 years before pension age. Within 10 years we could, probably will as no Party stays in power forever, have Conservatives back in power. What people think of as guaranteed lifelong money just isn’t in 10 years it could all be taken away, or most of it. Obviously this happens with employment as well, but if you can work, can look for work, you have a sense of control and possibly hope that you might not if you have never had to face the workplace or gain experience with working hurdles.

So I think this report is trying to look at the bigger picture for young adults, looking towards 10, 20 years time not just at savings for the welfare bill right now. But the details on how this will be achieved will be the important bits. NEETs who can and want to work are finding it difficult to find jobs. How are they going to find numerous job mentors and placements with very patient and understanding employers? There will be some of course there will, but the numbers required?

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:30

I do feel though that whatever is offered will be dismissed as secretly some people really do just want a benefits system that will keep them maintained indefinitely. I imagine a lot of people who claim won’t really engage with whatever help is offered and say their mental health is too poor. Time to just pull the rug I think.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:31

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:18

We should just call the bluff.

I’m sorry but suicide threats have, in some cases; become nothing more than emotional blackmail.

Unfortunately we can’t tiptoe around every single person that makes a suicide threat.

I’d rather not gamble with people’s lives.

As a mother, if you are one, would you be comfortable with gambling with the life of your child?

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:36

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:31

I’d rather not gamble with people’s lives.

As a mother, if you are one, would you be comfortable with gambling with the life of your child?

No choice, we can’t afford to let people just live off benefits forever because they threaten to commit suicide.

If an individual doesn’t want to fight for their own life a bit, there’s zero reason I should do it for them. You can’t help people that don’t want to be helped, and I have my own life to lead. If they want to commit suicide that’s their choice.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:39

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:36

No choice, we can’t afford to let people just live off benefits forever because they threaten to commit suicide.

If an individual doesn’t want to fight for their own life a bit, there’s zero reason I should do it for them. You can’t help people that don’t want to be helped, and I have my own life to lead. If they want to commit suicide that’s their choice.

I’ll just check again, would you feel that way if one of your children was making that same threat?

“Go on love, get on with it, I’ve got stuff to do?”

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:42

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:39

I’ll just check again, would you feel that way if one of your children was making that same threat?

“Go on love, get on with it, I’ve got stuff to do?”

You seem to be unable to seperate the attitude of the state toward the individual, from the attitude of the family toward the individual. Of course family wouldn’t say that. But the government isn’t your family.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 13/11/2026 09:42

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 09:04

If the percentage of the population impacted was the same now as it is now then they absolutely wouldn't just be those eccentric characters you list who undoubtedly would have been on the more severe end of needs.

The reality is that most people without severe impairment had no choice but to just get on with it. It would have been difficult and hard but possible. Most of us have people in our families from previous generations who would now be diagnosed with one of these conditions. All of my relatives had jobs and survived. Most married and had children.

I’m not sure how useful this is, in terms of how we fix the NEET crisis now. Once upon a time, there were far more manual jobs that didn't require navigating the kind of bureaucracy and/ or social cues that are challenging for some neurodivergent people. It was also much more common for multi-generational families to live together meaning relatives could work together to support young people’s additional needs. Some of that made it easier for some people to “just get on with it" but there was undoubtedly also widespread poverty (on a scale we’d be, rightly, horrified by today), addiction and institutionalisation. If we actually want to get NEET numbers down in the real world, then I do think we need solutions fit for today's economy and family structures.

pointythings · 13/11/2026 09:43

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:30

I do feel though that whatever is offered will be dismissed as secretly some people really do just want a benefits system that will keep them maintained indefinitely. I imagine a lot of people who claim won’t really engage with whatever help is offered and say their mental health is too poor. Time to just pull the rug I think.

I am perfectly willing to wait until I see the actual report, but it had better not be more of the same.

AnneLovesGilbert · 13/11/2026 09:44

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:31

I’d rather not gamble with people’s lives.

As a mother, if you are one, would you be comfortable with gambling with the life of your child?

The government isn’t anyone’s mother despite the enthusiasm for the state to be brushing children’s teeth and giving them breakfast. That’s very manipulative framing.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 09:45

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:31

I’d rather not gamble with people’s lives.

As a mother, if you are one, would you be comfortable with gambling with the life of your child?

If we have got to the stage where a decision whether to take ones own life, pivots on welfare support, that’s hugely unfair on the state, government, and tax payer.

If people’s lives are that tenuous.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:49

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:42

You seem to be unable to seperate the attitude of the state toward the individual, from the attitude of the family toward the individual. Of course family wouldn’t say that. But the government isn’t your family.

Oh, I’m not. You’re ignoring the link between the two.

You’re not the government. You’re a person who walks among us.

And it’s the attitudes of the people I’m increasingly concerned by.

Government policy and attitude is shaped by the people they represent, by their constituents and by the way public opinion almost demands certain change.

While we have people like yourself advocating for just telling suicidal people to get on with it if they really mean it, telling disabled people to fend for themselves, and telling people to just “do better,” with no help - that’s a concern.

It’s a concern because they will, and IMO are, shaping government decision making. To please and placate people with those views.

So unfortunately, your views matter. Public opinion matters. And increasingly, I think the inhumane are winning.

Take that how you will.

LittleBowSheep · 13/11/2026 09:50

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:36

No choice, we can’t afford to let people just live off benefits forever because they threaten to commit suicide.

If an individual doesn’t want to fight for their own life a bit, there’s zero reason I should do it for them. You can’t help people that don’t want to be helped, and I have my own life to lead. If they want to commit suicide that’s their choice.

I'm not quite sure what your intention is by posting such callous comments on this thread. Are you trying to provoke people or do you genuinely lack any compassion?

Would you honestly have that attitude if it was a member of your family who was threatening suicide? I think not. Therefore I can only assume that you are spouting such bile in order to offend.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:56

LittleBowSheep · 13/11/2026 09:50

I'm not quite sure what your intention is by posting such callous comments on this thread. Are you trying to provoke people or do you genuinely lack any compassion?

Would you honestly have that attitude if it was a member of your family who was threatening suicide? I think not. Therefore I can only assume that you are spouting such bile in order to offend.

But we can’t all assume the emotional and non-practical attitude of ‘the mother’ of the person making the threats. It’s not callous, I’ve had severe MH issues and so have my family.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:58

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:49

Oh, I’m not. You’re ignoring the link between the two.

You’re not the government. You’re a person who walks among us.

And it’s the attitudes of the people I’m increasingly concerned by.

Government policy and attitude is shaped by the people they represent, by their constituents and by the way public opinion almost demands certain change.

While we have people like yourself advocating for just telling suicidal people to get on with it if they really mean it, telling disabled people to fend for themselves, and telling people to just “do better,” with no help - that’s a concern.

It’s a concern because they will, and IMO are, shaping government decision making. To please and placate people with those views.

So unfortunately, your views matter. Public opinion matters. And increasingly, I think the inhumane are winning.

Take that how you will.

Edited

Well, good. I deserve to advocate for myself as much as the next person. I don’t owe my vote to ‘the vulnerable’ when frankly we are all a bit vulnerable these days. The country doesn’t exist as a huge life support machine for a minority who need propping up.

I’m very happy to support people with severe actual disabilities. Anxiety isn’t one of them, not to me.

Everyone has different standards.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:59

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 09:45

If we have got to the stage where a decision whether to take ones own life, pivots on welfare support, that’s hugely unfair on the state, government, and tax payer.

If people’s lives are that tenuous.

All that happens is the demands increase until empathy burnout happens, and it is happening. Any more finger pointing at hard working people for not handing over yet more money is only going to result in a very fucked off workforce. People don’t care about the name calling any more.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:00

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:58

Well, good. I deserve to advocate for myself as much as the next person. I don’t owe my vote to ‘the vulnerable’ when frankly we are all a bit vulnerable these days. The country doesn’t exist as a huge life support machine for a minority who need propping up.

I’m very happy to support people with severe actual disabilities. Anxiety isn’t one of them, not to me.

Everyone has different standards.

Indeed they do.

Llttledrummergirl · 13/11/2026 10:03

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:58

Well, good. I deserve to advocate for myself as much as the next person. I don’t owe my vote to ‘the vulnerable’ when frankly we are all a bit vulnerable these days. The country doesn’t exist as a huge life support machine for a minority who need propping up.

I’m very happy to support people with severe actual disabilities. Anxiety isn’t one of them, not to me.

Everyone has different standards.

And some are clearly lacking in humanity, basic decency and understanding of history and the social contract we have in the UK as a result.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 10:04

Llttledrummergirl · 13/11/2026 10:03

And some are clearly lacking in humanity, basic decency and understanding of history and the social contract we have in the UK as a result.

What end of the contract are long term claimants fulfilling?

EasternStandard · 13/11/2026 10:05

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 09:49

Oh, I’m not. You’re ignoring the link between the two.

You’re not the government. You’re a person who walks among us.

And it’s the attitudes of the people I’m increasingly concerned by.

Government policy and attitude is shaped by the people they represent, by their constituents and by the way public opinion almost demands certain change.

While we have people like yourself advocating for just telling suicidal people to get on with it if they really mean it, telling disabled people to fend for themselves, and telling people to just “do better,” with no help - that’s a concern.

It’s a concern because they will, and IMO are, shaping government decision making. To please and placate people with those views.

So unfortunately, your views matter. Public opinion matters. And increasingly, I think the inhumane are winning.

Take that how you will.

Edited

Given we keep voting to increase debt so it’s now £3trn I’m not sure people are this, it’s more likely we demand spending that isn’t available.

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:06

I had my dc at 16 and moved out at the same time and I remember finding out people over 25 were getting a lot more UC than me. Which felt like a very high age.
Another thing that seems unfair is university loans am I right in thinking they assume everyone’s parents are helping their adult child and give less money based on parents income?
The whole thing is weighted towards assume everyone’s parents are bankrolling them.
PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

TigerRag · 13/11/2026 10:12

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:06

I had my dc at 16 and moved out at the same time and I remember finding out people over 25 were getting a lot more UC than me. Which felt like a very high age.
Another thing that seems unfair is university loans am I right in thinking they assume everyone’s parents are helping their adult child and give less money based on parents income?
The whole thing is weighted towards assume everyone’s parents are bankrolling them.
PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

But generally most under 25s are living with parents

WoolHatEnthusiast · 13/11/2026 10:12

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:06

I had my dc at 16 and moved out at the same time and I remember finding out people over 25 were getting a lot more UC than me. Which felt like a very high age.
Another thing that seems unfair is university loans am I right in thinking they assume everyone’s parents are helping their adult child and give less money based on parents income?
The whole thing is weighted towards assume everyone’s parents are bankrolling them.
PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

Actually, you are right, the university maintenance loan is really interesting lens to view this quasi-adult status that is being proposed around independence and state support.

BIossomtoes · 13/11/2026 10:14

EasternStandard · 13/11/2026 10:05

Given we keep voting to increase debt so it’s now £3trn I’m not sure people are this, it’s more likely we demand spending that isn’t available.

Most of our national debt is due to factors beyond our control.

  • An ageing population and demographic changes will put increased pressure on government spending, notably health care and pension spending.
  • A smaller working population will limit UK’s productive capacity.
  • Stress on finances from geopolitical events, such as frostier relations with China, Russia and the Middle East.
  • Higher energy prices
  • Costs of climate change.
  • Declining tax revenues from petrol in a decarbonising economy.
  • Low productivity growth of UK since the financial crash of 2009
  • Recent boost to debt from the financial crisis and one-off cost of Coronovirus pandemic, which cut tax revenues and required government support for lockdown measures.
uk-productivity-2000-22-trend

UK Labour Productivity Crisis - Economics Help

Labour productivity measures the output per worker in a period of time. Recent graphs/stats. Factors affecting labour productivity and implications for economy.

https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/5887/economics/uk-labour-productivity/

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:16

TigerRag · 13/11/2026 10:12

But generally most under 25s are living with parents

Sure but they don’t take into account the people who are not. Same with university loans just because someone’s parents are wealthy it doesn’t mean they’re bankrolling their child.

This boils down to not having the balls to do something about the people getting PIP for adhd, anxiety, mild autism and now physically disabled under 25s are being punished

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:18

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 19:26

If you sit and make a list of benefits, therapies and other interventions your kids have had, and the cost, I doubt it’ll look like ‘being let down by the country’

And what about the list of benefits your children have had? From the time you got prenatal care to their birth to the free education. The fact your children were lucky enough to need less does not mean other children were not let down.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.