Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:21

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:16

Sure but they don’t take into account the people who are not. Same with university loans just because someone’s parents are wealthy it doesn’t mean they’re bankrolling their child.

This boils down to not having the balls to do something about the people getting PIP for adhd, anxiety, mild autism and now physically disabled under 25s are being punished

The suggestion seems to be that those who are deemed genuinely unable to work, with the most profound or limiting disabilities, will still be supported just via different funding.

Probably the same funding just with a different name, in reality.

It seems to be more about those difficulties that some people see as less deserving, or less valid.

The public opinion has changed. But mainly around mental health and ADHD etc, we don’t see as much around throwing the physically or profoundly disabled to the wolves.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:22

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:56

But we can’t all assume the emotional and non-practical attitude of ‘the mother’ of the person making the threats. It’s not callous, I’ve had severe MH issues and so have my family.

I have read your ableist opinions and I do not believe you have suffered from severe mental illness ever in your life.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 10:23

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:18

And what about the list of benefits your children have had? From the time you got prenatal care to their birth to the free education. The fact your children were lucky enough to need less does not mean other children were not let down.

Paid for via work… I work…

Are we about to play the game of ‘I don’t understand the difference between somebody who is/isn’t a net contributor and somebody who never works and lives off the system’?

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:25

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:21

The suggestion seems to be that those who are deemed genuinely unable to work, with the most profound or limiting disabilities, will still be supported just via different funding.

Probably the same funding just with a different name, in reality.

It seems to be more about those difficulties that some people see as less deserving, or less valid.

The public opinion has changed. But mainly around mental health and ADHD etc, we don’t see as much around throwing the physically or profoundly disabled to the wolves.

It’s because we all know multiple people who are taking the piss (especially if you’re under 35) you’ll know mutiple people claiming PIP because “ADHD, anxiety, autism” (the mild type of autism where one just has slightly quirky interest)

It’s frustrating over 25s as described above will still continue as fine while under 25s with actual life limiting disabilities will be under more scrutiny

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:35

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 10:23

Paid for via work… I work…

Are we about to play the game of ‘I don’t understand the difference between somebody who is/isn’t a net contributor and somebody who never works and lives off the system’?

Most ´long term claimants’ have worked and contributed. It is very rare for a person to be too profoundly disabled to work their entire life. I am sure you agree these people require support? Otherwise you are advocating eugenics by neglect of the most vulnerable.

In addition the parents of profoundly disabled children also work. So why are you begrudging them the support their children need when your children have the support they need?

For many disabled people, they can work with support- you want that support ripped away so they cannot work. Again, most of these people will have worked just like you but were less lucky in life and acquired serious disabilities due to accident, injury or disease.

You could be hit by a car and suffer life changing injuries today that make you unable to continue working. Do you want to be told you are not a net contributor and so are not due any support? How long would your savings last at the rate of UC and no help for your disabilities? Would you be ok with draining all your savings, all your pensions, perhaps even being forced to sell your home due to lost earnings and higher living costs from being disabled making it impossible to pay the mortgage and live? You might have incapacity assurance, but do you know how hard it is to actually get the company to pay out? Claims are often rejected and fighting the company can be expensive and time consuming, even if your injuries did not include a brain injury as is common in car accidents but would make it impossible for you to coherently appeal.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:36

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:25

It’s because we all know multiple people who are taking the piss (especially if you’re under 35) you’ll know mutiple people claiming PIP because “ADHD, anxiety, autism” (the mild type of autism where one just has slightly quirky interest)

It’s frustrating over 25s as described above will still continue as fine while under 25s with actual life limiting disabilities will be under more scrutiny

I think in reality people are sick of what they deem to be taking the piss.

But unless you live in someone else’s brain or body, you can’t possibly know how they’re affected by their ADHD, autism or MH.

There’s an increasing amount of people deciding that they wouldn’t be affected, or that they wouldn’t require support, so that means those that do must be taking the piss.

But it’s all relative, IMO. I can’t claim to know whether someone does struggle with their ADHD or autism, so I don’t pass judgement on their worthiness for support.

I do have a profoundly disabled child, and I don’t particularly look forward to having to justify that even more than I already do.

But I wouldn’t use that as a reason to give others less support, I’ll just have to suck it up and fill in the new paperwork instead of the reams we have now.

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:41

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:36

I think in reality people are sick of what they deem to be taking the piss.

But unless you live in someone else’s brain or body, you can’t possibly know how they’re affected by their ADHD, autism or MH.

There’s an increasing amount of people deciding that they wouldn’t be affected, or that they wouldn’t require support, so that means those that do must be taking the piss.

But it’s all relative, IMO. I can’t claim to know whether someone does struggle with their ADHD or autism, so I don’t pass judgement on their worthiness for support.

I do have a profoundly disabled child, and I don’t particularly look forward to having to justify that even more than I already do.

But I wouldn’t use that as a reason to give others less support, I’ll just have to suck it up and fill in the new paperwork instead of the reams we have now.

I think adhd is a load of bullshit and even if it wasn’t how is giving one hundreds of pounds a month going to help them? (Except in the way it would help anyone) . I have a cousin with autism who can’t make friends because he can’t socialise normally is extremely lonely and isolated. To see social butterfly’s with perfectly normal lives talking about their autism and pip does piss me off

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 10:42

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:59

All that happens is the demands increase until empathy burnout happens, and it is happening. Any more finger pointing at hard working people for not handing over yet more money is only going to result in a very fucked off workforce. People don’t care about the name calling any more.

I absolutely agree with you.

We are already there.

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 13/11/2026 10:46

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:35

Most ´long term claimants’ have worked and contributed. It is very rare for a person to be too profoundly disabled to work their entire life. I am sure you agree these people require support? Otherwise you are advocating eugenics by neglect of the most vulnerable.

In addition the parents of profoundly disabled children also work. So why are you begrudging them the support their children need when your children have the support they need?

For many disabled people, they can work with support- you want that support ripped away so they cannot work. Again, most of these people will have worked just like you but were less lucky in life and acquired serious disabilities due to accident, injury or disease.

You could be hit by a car and suffer life changing injuries today that make you unable to continue working. Do you want to be told you are not a net contributor and so are not due any support? How long would your savings last at the rate of UC and no help for your disabilities? Would you be ok with draining all your savings, all your pensions, perhaps even being forced to sell your home due to lost earnings and higher living costs from being disabled making it impossible to pay the mortgage and live? You might have incapacity assurance, but do you know how hard it is to actually get the company to pay out? Claims are often rejected and fighting the company can be expensive and time consuming, even if your injuries did not include a brain injury as is common in car accidents but would make it impossible for you to coherently appeal.

Yep. I worked for 25 years (with congenital health conditions/disability) before I needed more support after a stroke. I do think some posters think they are immune to accidents or life-changing events that might see them one day needing the safety net they are so keen to tear up.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:46

It's not just about giving money to CAMHS. It is more important to remove or more realistically trying to reduce the stressors that tip people into poor mental health in the first place
Removing stressors is exactly what has got us where we are. The more you reduce stressors, the worse people are at coping with them. This why we now have so many kids, becoming NEET, with no resilience at all. How can they build any trust in their ability to face stressors when all they've experienced is people removing them teaching them that stressors are always very bad things to face.

There will always be stressors in our lives. We need to learn to manage them, and built such resilience that many of those stressors are so embedded in normal life that they are no longer stressors.

Take someone who is scared of driving on the motorway. They decide to avoid it at all cost. They don't need to drive on them. Years go by. They then move, start a new job and their commute would be 20 minutes Vs 1 hour using the motorway. They are totally scared though so take the country roads. The prospect of driving on the motorway is a huge stressor in their lives.

Or they could have told themselves that they had to face their fear. Start with short travels, with a passenger raft makes them comfortable, at a quiet time. Increase how often they do it, the distance etc...until they do it alone. 2 months later, they are okay with it. 1 year later, they no longer see is as a stressor, just a normal day to day event.

Its so sad that so many parents think they are being great parents by removing stressors from their kids life when they are actually doing great damage doing so.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:49

I worked for 25 years (with congenital health conditions/disability) before I needed more support after a stroke. I do think some posters think they are immune to accidents or life-changing illnesses that might see them ne day needing the safety net they are so keen to tear up
I've never heard anyone claiming they would support a system that was there to help those with sudden significant disabilities such as following a stroke.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:50

Why is no one questioning the support for the perfectly abled work shy unemployed and underemployed?

There are 1.3 million abled people not working
There are 3.1 million abled people working but getting UC top ups

UC is at £96 billion with a fraud (taking the piss) rate of 10%
Disability spending is at £77 billion with a fraud (taking the piss) rate of less than 1%

Going after the people actually faking disabilities will get us at most £770 million, but going after the people making false UC claims will get us £9,600 million (£9.6bn)

The only reason the government are targeting disability is because 99% of claimants ARE disabled and getting the support they are ENTITLED to therefore they are too ill/weak to fight for justice. They cannot set up huge protests in the streets of London. Which is what would happen and worse if the government dared to touch UC for the abled work shy.

TigerRag · 13/11/2026 10:50

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:25

It’s because we all know multiple people who are taking the piss (especially if you’re under 35) you’ll know mutiple people claiming PIP because “ADHD, anxiety, autism” (the mild type of autism where one just has slightly quirky interest)

It’s frustrating over 25s as described above will still continue as fine while under 25s with actual life limiting disabilities will be under more scrutiny

But you wouldn't get pip because of a diagnosis. I double you'd even get an autism diagnosis for having "quirky interests"

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:51

Oh come on. Loads of young people with autism and ADHD say it's clear their parents and grandparents are undiagnosed. I have been reading for years it rubs in families
People who yet managed to get on with day to day life with no extra support. People who adjusted, with efforts, to the demands of adult life. So what has changed?

ThingsAreNotWhatTheyWere · 13/11/2026 10:52

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:49

I worked for 25 years (with congenital health conditions/disability) before I needed more support after a stroke. I do think some posters think they are immune to accidents or life-changing illnesses that might see them ne day needing the safety net they are so keen to tear up
I've never heard anyone claiming they would support a system that was there to help those with sudden significant disabilities such as following a stroke.

The problem is that any crude and poorly thought out changes (cuts) WILL affect those with greater disabilities, unless great care is taken.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:53

The only reason you and the government are targeting disability is because 99% of claimants ARE disabled and getting the support they are ENTITLED to therefore they are too ill/weak to fight for justice
Entitlement is only defined by the criteria and threshold set. If these are reduced, those people are suddenly no longer entitled. If you increase it, more people, currently not deemed in need, will become so.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:54

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:41

I think adhd is a load of bullshit and even if it wasn’t how is giving one hundreds of pounds a month going to help them? (Except in the way it would help anyone) . I have a cousin with autism who can’t make friends because he can’t socialise normally is extremely lonely and isolated. To see social butterfly’s with perfectly normal lives talking about their autism and pip does piss me off

I’ve got a child who essentially can’t speak, and I’m still not pissed off that other people have autism that presents differently or doesn’t affect them socially in the same way.

I could be pissed off that other people’s autistic kids have words at all, nevermind whether they can use them within social contexts etc.

What would be the point? Doesn’t make my kid any less disabled. It’s an outlook I just don’t get.

ADHD can absolutely be debilitating. It can affect your ability to sleep, to use executive functioning, to arrive anywhere on time, to cope with the anxiety it can induce. It’s definitely real, and it definitely can have an impact. It’s certainly not just “bullshit.”

I don’t see how supporting anyone to live a full, or at least fuller, life would be something worth begrudging.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:55

The problem is that any crude and poorly thought out changes (cuts) WILL affect those with greater disabilities, unless great care is taken
Anyone who thinks they should receive benefits believe their disability is great enough to be entitled.

That's the problem, if you let people with a personal interest in the matter, they will inevitably set the bar low.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 10:57

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:54

I’ve got a child who essentially can’t speak, and I’m still not pissed off that other people have autism that presents differently or doesn’t affect them socially in the same way.

I could be pissed off that other people’s autistic kids have words at all, nevermind whether they can use them within social contexts etc.

What would be the point? Doesn’t make my kid any less disabled. It’s an outlook I just don’t get.

ADHD can absolutely be debilitating. It can affect your ability to sleep, to use executive functioning, to arrive anywhere on time, to cope with the anxiety it can induce. It’s definitely real, and it definitely can have an impact. It’s certainly not just “bullshit.”

I don’t see how supporting anyone to live a full, or at least fuller, life would be something worth begrudging.

I think your last sentence assumes that neuro-typical people are living a ‘full’ life. Many are not - they are struggling too, without any support.

We have reached this point for a reason, after all.

BluebellBeth · 13/11/2026 10:57

CandidLurker · 13/11/2026 08:22

I do agree that mental health is clearly variable. However the question for me is whether long-term cash benefits should be paid for conditions (physical ones too) that are very treatable with drugs e.g. anxiety and depression. I know that some people sadly have drug resistant depression but these are in the minority.

the issue there is that for those under 18 it's virtually impossible to get meds. CAMHS won't prescribe them, especially if their anxiety is autism related, they say well it's part of the autism so tough luck basically! It's difficult to get meds off CAMHS for anything tbh and if you have autism they often write everything off as that and refuse any meds or therapy, so young people are just left. Pip goes from age 16 so theres a gap where they literally can't get meds.

Ive seen someone post about how parents want CAMHS help for minor stuff, but there is NO proper early help for MH difficulties. This is part of the problem and needs to be heavily invested in to improve things.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:58

ADHD can absolutely be debilitating. It can affect your ability to sleep, to use executive functioning, to arrive anywhere on time, to cope with the anxiety it can induce. It’s definitely real, and it definitely can have an impact. It’s certainly not just “bullshit.”
It is definitely not bullshit. It also doesn't mean the only life available to you is one of living with your parents, never working, never properly socialising for the rest of your life, not that the only way to do so is by others, IE. The system, government, agencies etc.... doing it for you.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 10:59

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:51

Oh come on. Loads of young people with autism and ADHD say it's clear their parents and grandparents are undiagnosed. I have been reading for years it rubs in families
People who yet managed to get on with day to day life with no extra support. People who adjusted, with efforts, to the demands of adult life. So what has changed?

Actually many of them did not manage to get on in life or adjust. There is a strong link between these disabilities and chronic unemployment, suicide and criminality when they go undiagnosed into adulthood.

We are bewailing the fact that today many in their 20s are unable to work due to these disabilities.

In the 1990s, many would have been forced to turn to crime to survive. The support we give them is a direct causal factor behind the significant drop in major crimes, (eg domestic burglary, vehicle theft, interpersonal violence) by as much as 70% to 80% in England and Wales on steady downward arc through the 2000s, 2010s, and 2020s.

Which do you think costs society more?

I will tell you- crime

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:59

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 10:54

I’ve got a child who essentially can’t speak, and I’m still not pissed off that other people have autism that presents differently or doesn’t affect them socially in the same way.

I could be pissed off that other people’s autistic kids have words at all, nevermind whether they can use them within social contexts etc.

What would be the point? Doesn’t make my kid any less disabled. It’s an outlook I just don’t get.

ADHD can absolutely be debilitating. It can affect your ability to sleep, to use executive functioning, to arrive anywhere on time, to cope with the anxiety it can induce. It’s definitely real, and it definitely can have an impact. It’s certainly not just “bullshit.”

I don’t see how supporting anyone to live a full, or at least fuller, life would be something worth begrudging.

Because our taxes pay for it and your child could be affected by crackdowns because other people take the piss. My cousins autism is mild and he has never had a real friend he’s in his 20s and has never had a girlfriend he’s never had a job (although he applies all the time but no where will hire him because his autism makes him seem “weird”). He actually dosent get pip.

Then I know mutiple people claiming pip for autism when they have blossoming social lives, careers, even marriages and kids? Just how has their autism affected them and why does it warrant being given hundreds of pounds a month.
and yes I know I’m not “in their head” but no one’s in anyone’s head we’ve all got our own shit

plasticplate · 13/11/2026 11:00

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 10:25

It’s because we all know multiple people who are taking the piss (especially if you’re under 35) you’ll know mutiple people claiming PIP because “ADHD, anxiety, autism” (the mild type of autism where one just has slightly quirky interest)

It’s frustrating over 25s as described above will still continue as fine while under 25s with actual life limiting disabilities will be under more scrutiny

People with severe life limiting conditions are already subject to a lot of scrutiny. This will just be a different form. My adult son is severely autistic with complex needs but I still have frequent run ins with gatekeeping professionals and I doubt that will ever change.

LiberteLynx · 13/11/2026 11:00

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 10:53

The only reason you and the government are targeting disability is because 99% of claimants ARE disabled and getting the support they are ENTITLED to therefore they are too ill/weak to fight for justice
Entitlement is only defined by the criteria and threshold set. If these are reduced, those people are suddenly no longer entitled. If you increase it, more people, currently not deemed in need, will become so.

Yes, and the threshold was set high and since 2010 has only been raised leaving many who need support without it.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.