Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:42

And suicidal ideation is fairly common. If it's simply a case of life is tough at the moment, I am sad, I don't want to feel sad, but realistically I am not going to kill myself.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:45

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:42

And suicidal ideation is fairly common. If it's simply a case of life is tough at the moment, I am sad, I don't want to feel sad, but realistically I am not going to kill myself.

Not so much when it leads to overdoses, self harm and serious attempts on life.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:45

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:40

Err the vast majority don’t the figures re unemployment and underemployment for people with autism and adhd are massive.

Oh come on. Loads of young people with autism and ADHD say it's clear their parents and grandparents are undiagnosed. I have been reading for years it rubs in families.
I know plenty of older people with pretty obvious what used to be called Asperger's but are undiagnosed. They all work. All of them.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:46

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:40

Agree.
Serious mental health conditions are young people with psychosis for example. Severe mental health conditions have as much stigma attached to them as they always had. But support is worse because of parents making demands for their children whose issues can be managed by good parenting.

Incorrect,eating disorders , CPTSD, OCD, self harm….are all serious mental health conditions.

TigerRag · 13/11/2026 07:47

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 05:11

Wow so you have professional expertise and knowledge re the diagnoses of every person with autism and ADHD in this country.

I obviously don't know every person diagnosed but I've never met anyone who has been misdiagnosed

Why are we only talking about ADHD / Autism? Other disabilities exist too

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:49

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:45

Oh come on. Loads of young people with autism and ADHD say it's clear their parents and grandparents are undiagnosed. I have been reading for years it rubs in families.
I know plenty of older people with pretty obvious what used to be called Asperger's but are undiagnosed. They all work. All of them.

Only 30% are in employment and those that are are often massively underemployed.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:52

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:40

Agree.
Serious mental health conditions are young people with psychosis for example. Severe mental health conditions have as much stigma attached to them as they always had. But support is worse because of parents making demands for their children whose issues can be managed by good parenting.

Good parenting does not stop or manage away serious mental health difficulties, autism or ADHD.

Parents of children with autism and adhd are often highly skilled in managing hugely difficult parenting situations the like of which many lucky enough not to be in that situation will never have to.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 13/11/2026 07:57

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:37

And I do agree with you that the root causes need to be tackled - but what I think that actually means is better preventative health care, better mental health support, education reforms etc etc
All these have been tried, over and over and over.

Cahms funding has increased with inflation or just about. Referrals however have increased by 10% annually in the past 10 years.

The root cause is exactly where the problem is, and the problem is worse every year because you can't tackle parenting with just money. It's a societal issue. The focus however needs to shift from the children to the parents.

I am not denying that in some cases, a challenging home life can exacerbate a young person’s difficulties and make it harder for them to hold down a job. But I personally have not seen any evidence from experts that says parenting is the root cause of the NEET crisis. There is, however, expert evidence (including in the IFS report linked above) that rising mental health needs is a root cause. It isn’t about just giving more money to CAHMS - it is about making sure that support is fit for purpose.

But even if parenting is part of the problem - what’s the solution? It definitely isn’t just to cut young people’s support, tell parents that it’s their problem and then leave them to it.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 07:58

Very disappointed to read this.

“The thing I like about the proposals is that they don’t have a [savings] number attached to them. The second they attach a number I will start to get anxious,” the Labour MP added.

I mean, seriously.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 08:01

@Ott3r, your choice of wording alone show you don't understand what severe mental health is. You might have children with high needs, but that doesn't make you a mental health expert. I have studied psychology at Uni, specialising in mental health, working in mental health hospital. I also worked with children with autism in the early 90s, when only those with genuine severe manifestation got a diagnosis.

Using dramatic word for effect doesn't make a condition more severe or of more need of support.

I absolutely believe that parents can cause autism or ADHD if your account how those disorders are currently diagnosed.

A child who is raised spending hours a day in front of a screen from the age of 2 years old, needs it to fall asleep, who has limited verbal interaction with their parents, who lacks routine, discipline, boundaries, who is subject to constant background noises etc ... is much much much more likely to end up with a diagnosis of autism or ADHD by the time they attend secondary school.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 13/11/2026 08:06

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 07:58

Very disappointed to read this.

“The thing I like about the proposals is that they don’t have a [savings] number attached to them. The second they attach a number I will start to get anxious,” the Labour MP added.

I mean, seriously.

But that’s right, isn’t it? Because as soon as you put on arbitrary number on it, the recommendations become about saving that figure and not about actually fixing the problem.

In the long run, that approach costs the tax payer money because if you take away too much financial support all at once without other kinds of support in place, you risk pushing young people into crisis (and cost shifting into other, more expensive services). There were loads of examples of this in the austerity era - take Sure Start. It was cut in a short sighted, arbitrary way. Evidence later showed that every £1 spent on Sure Start generated £2.05 in total long-run benefits (through reducing strain on other services etc etc). So, cutting it to meet some arbitrary figure cost us all - not just socially, but financially too.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 08:10

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 13/11/2026 08:06

But that’s right, isn’t it? Because as soon as you put on arbitrary number on it, the recommendations become about saving that figure and not about actually fixing the problem.

In the long run, that approach costs the tax payer money because if you take away too much financial support all at once without other kinds of support in place, you risk pushing young people into crisis (and cost shifting into other, more expensive services). There were loads of examples of this in the austerity era - take Sure Start. It was cut in a short sighted, arbitrary way. Evidence later showed that every £1 spent on Sure Start generated £2.05 in total long-run benefits (through reducing strain on other services etc etc). So, cutting it to meet some arbitrary figure cost us all - not just socially, but financially too.

Well, Blunkett has gone on record saying that Cabinet ministers should accept budget cuts to help fund welfare reform, so I hope Burnham listens.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 13/11/2026 08:14

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 08:10

Well, Blunkett has gone on record saying that Cabinet ministers should accept budget cuts to help fund welfare reform, so I hope Burnham listens.

I hope that too - but that doesn’t mean I think there should be an arbitrary figure put on it about how much they should be cut by and by when.

I think to have any chance of the NEET crisis actually being solved, there are going to be some politicians on the left who have to accept some cuts they feel uncomfortable with, and equally, some politicians on the right who have to accept a degree of upfront financial investment, and acknowledge not all the savings will be immediate. I really do hope politicians on both sides of the house are grown up enough to do that.

OneInEight · 13/11/2026 08:17

It's not just about giving money to CAMHS. It is more important to remove or more realistically trying to reduce the stressors that tip people into poor mental health in the first place.

My 2 are two of the lucky ones. They had significant needs at age 10 (both were diagnosed with an ASC) but because, eventually anyway, they received good support via education in one case a special school and in one case via an EOTAS arrangement their mental health improved and they got qualifications and they both have a job. The problem I see it is that the government wants it all ways so they want to remove the support that good EOTAS and special schools can bring because of cost but then ring their hands in horror that they get to 18 have no qualifications and abysmal mental health and rely on benefits.

CandidLurker · 13/11/2026 08:22

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 23:23

I didn't say treatment wasn't available (although that is arguable with the current state of the nhs!). i said MH issues can't always be cured, which you've agreed with.

yes you can have treatment and feel better, but it's not remotely unusual for things to get bad again. To need a different anti depressant, to need to up meds to need a different therapy, to bounce on/off in/out of therapy or treatment. These times can see people become very unwell again.

I do agree that mental health is clearly variable. However the question for me is whether long-term cash benefits should be paid for conditions (physical ones too) that are very treatable with drugs e.g. anxiety and depression. I know that some people sadly have drug resistant depression but these are in the minority.

NightHeron · 13/11/2026 08:24

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:42

And suicidal ideation is fairly common. If it's simply a case of life is tough at the moment, I am sad, I don't want to feel sad, but realistically I am not going to kill myself.

People with borderline personality disorder are 50 times more likely to attempt suicide than the normal population - 5 - 10% do kill themselves eventually.

Two relatives of mine had schizophrenia - both attempted suicide. One succeeded, and the other changed their mind after the overdose and sought help. (There’s a genetic disorder running in my family, before anyone starts blaming parents)

NippyNips · 13/11/2026 08:27

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:42

And suicidal ideation is fairly common. If it's simply a case of life is tough at the moment, I am sad, I don't want to feel sad, but realistically I am not going to kill myself.

I remember a MNer (in her 20s) saying she can't work because every job she has tried makes her feel suicidal. So she expects the taxpayer to provide for her and her son for the rest of their lives apparently.

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 08:28

NippyNips · 13/11/2026 08:27

I remember a MNer (in her 20s) saying she can't work because every job she has tried makes her feel suicidal. So she expects the taxpayer to provide for her and her son for the rest of their lives apparently.

That sounds like a really sad way to live.

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 08:53

OonaStubbs · 12/11/2026 18:38

How did people with Autism, ADHD, depression et al cope before the benefits system started?

By being one of those frightening characters now mostly only encountered in historical fiction:
the eccentric recluse (if lucky enough to inherit somewhere to live)
the village idiot, given menial ad-hoc jobs by kindly neighbours
the mad relative in the attic (if family are around and willing to house them)
the beggar on the streets
the inmate of the insane asylum

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 09:01

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:52

Good parenting does not stop or manage away serious mental health difficulties, autism or ADHD.

Parents of children with autism and adhd are often highly skilled in managing hugely difficult parenting situations the like of which many lucky enough not to be in that situation will never have to.

Good parenting and providing a stable and functional home environment has been scientifically proven to reduce functional impairment related to ADHD and ASD. Conversely the opposite is true for poor parenting and chaotic home environments. What is the difference between sub clinical ADHD/ASD and diagnosable versions of these conditions? The impact the conditions have on daily life. We know parenting and home life hugely influence this, so to some extent yes, parenting can be the difference between these conditions being manageable and unmanageable in a meaningful sense.

Parents of children with ADHD and ASD are not necessarily highly skilled and they often struggle with the same traits their children struggle with which makes parenting far more challenging. There is a genetic element to all of this that means that the parents may well have been parented by a mother or father with the traits as well and so it becomes a generational cycle where biology and parenting combine so that effective parenting hasn't been modelled for many decades and expectations of what it looks like are completely skewed.

Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 09:03

My son has autism and had severe mental health needs arising from it. He has a clinical psychiatrist from cahms who uses the word severe. (He didnt have screens at all btw)

He does require quite intensive parenting and the quality of my parenting does have a huge positive impact and poor parenting could make it worse.

But good parenting involves seeking appropriate support when things fall outside your capabilities.

My parenting alone wouldnt have achieved the results we have had. The psychiatric support, medication, speech and language therapy and occupational therapy were outside normal parenting and esssential to him doing ok.

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 09:04

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 08:53

By being one of those frightening characters now mostly only encountered in historical fiction:
the eccentric recluse (if lucky enough to inherit somewhere to live)
the village idiot, given menial ad-hoc jobs by kindly neighbours
the mad relative in the attic (if family are around and willing to house them)
the beggar on the streets
the inmate of the insane asylum

If the percentage of the population impacted was the same now as it is now then they absolutely wouldn't just be those eccentric characters you list who undoubtedly would have been on the more severe end of needs.

The reality is that most people without severe impairment had no choice but to just get on with it. It would have been difficult and hard but possible. Most of us have people in our families from previous generations who would now be diagnosed with one of these conditions. All of my relatives had jobs and survived. Most married and had children.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:18

SleeplessInWherever · 13/11/2026 08:28

That sounds like a really sad way to live.

We should just call the bluff.

I’m sorry but suicide threats have, in some cases; become nothing more than emotional blackmail.

Unfortunately we can’t tiptoe around every single person that makes a suicide threat.

Apotofrealcoffee · 13/11/2026 09:19

And yes there are a core of youngish, lifelong benefit claimants on here who are very eloquent and opinionated and lucid. But if you challenge the narrative that benefits should continue unchallenged and unquestioned, they launch into the ‘I’ll just kill myself then shall I’ and instigate a pile on from their ‘supporters’ who urge them not to give up and say how nasty you are..

EasternStandard · 13/11/2026 09:23

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 07:58

Very disappointed to read this.

“The thing I like about the proposals is that they don’t have a [savings] number attached to them. The second they attach a number I will start to get anxious,” the Labour MP added.

I mean, seriously.

They might but people are generally are able to work out what a reduction in payment is, even if Labour change the name of it. So I expect when the report comes out it’ll be quickly determined what is lost, paid or gained.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread