Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
caringcarer · 13/11/2026 01:18

Pinkytartany · 12/11/2026 22:44

Just curious where does he get the £250 from? Is he on PIP?

Sounds like it might be from UC.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 05:07

caringcarer · 13/11/2026 01:12

If your DD get £500 a month surely getting her therapy would be a really good use of her pip.

Maybe read the whole thread

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 05:11

NorthernJim · 12/11/2026 23:26

Then a lot of people have been misdiagnosed.

Wow so you have professional expertise and knowledge re the diagnoses of every person with autism and ADHD in this country.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 05:20

Pinkytartany · 12/11/2026 22:59

yes I helped a friend apply for PIP and it's shocking how they used the fact she works against her and the fact she had been to college.

It was like oh you've got qualifications and you've had jobs working in an offices and shops before and you work now - albeit from home - so you don't need PIP.

So instead of helping her stay in work they've actually used it to penalise her. No wonder such a small proportion of PIP recipients are working. Because they tend to reject the ones who claim while working.

They also use people being able to drive against them too but interestingly enough didn't count it in my friend's favour that she was unable to drive despite trying. It's like they just strategically use evidence against people unless you can rock up and say don't work, don't do anything, didn't bother with college and so on.

Edited

Not how it works at all.

My daughter has masses of very strong evidence including a very robust EHCP which is hugely useful for PIP as regards illustrating care and support needs. Her PIP application and EHCP highlight very clearly education settings and her battle to get an education , qualifications and goals re work. Her battle to learn to drive, attending college or goals for eventual work have not been used against her at all,quite the reverse. We update them with everything in detail.

LoisGriffinskitchen · 13/11/2026 05:31

AirborneElephant · 12/11/2026 20:35

Why? It’s the truth. It absolutely has to be recognised that benefits are paid for by other hard working humans, they don’t just appear from some magic money tree.

It’s the “charity” part. How dare you? I’ve rarely claimed benefits apart from 2 years suppprting my disabled son. He is 23, he isn’t your “charity” case, he’s a human being who would quite like to go to work one day but is just not ready yet. Think 23yr old with a young 13yr old style brain. He’s not ready, he’s been assessed as such by both the DWP and an organisation which supports young disabled adults into work.

.So until he can work he will be claiming benefits or I will on his behalf. He’s not your charity case. He claims the benefits he is entitled to. Would I give 50% of that up for properly funded services? Yes.

However, my son has support from two parents, many youngsters do not have this. What about them?

“Charity” ….revolting comment from you.

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 06:16

Perhaps I am missing something, but it appears that the Milburn report will simply recommend changing the name of some of the benefits like UC / PIP for under 25s, but not really significantly changing the amounts handed out.

Meanwhile, it increases upfront spending by 6bn to pay for employment support coaches etc, (presumably more unionised public sector jobs). With undefined savings to come in a decade. And with undefined sanctions for those who don’t participate?

And it does nothing to address the much more significant and growing spending (and abuse) on welfare for over 25s upwards. And nothing on addressing some of the root causes which include Labour’s higher employment taxes, minimum wage and increased regulations etc…

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 06:17

LoisGriffinskitchen · 13/11/2026 05:31

It’s the “charity” part. How dare you? I’ve rarely claimed benefits apart from 2 years suppprting my disabled son. He is 23, he isn’t your “charity” case, he’s a human being who would quite like to go to work one day but is just not ready yet. Think 23yr old with a young 13yr old style brain. He’s not ready, he’s been assessed as such by both the DWP and an organisation which supports young disabled adults into work.

.So until he can work he will be claiming benefits or I will on his behalf. He’s not your charity case. He claims the benefits he is entitled to. Would I give 50% of that up for properly funded services? Yes.

However, my son has support from two parents, many youngsters do not have this. What about them?

“Charity” ….revolting comment from you.

Isn’t it just. We’re late 50s and nobody in our family has claimed benefits bar CB ever. Always worked and paid good taxes. It’s not our fault or our child’s fault that they had the misfortune to be born with a disability needing support and help from the state. We didn’t choose it and would give anything for her not to need PIP.

Gooseinthewood · 13/11/2026 06:35

HeyUpDuckie · 12/11/2026 07:29

It needs fixing before they do this. Mild adhd and autism doesn't exist either, you either have it or you don't. The fact they don't understand that says everything. They're will be kids from sen schools unable to work caught up in this.

Terminology is wrong but the principle correct. With a boom in diagnoses there are a lot of people who have a diagnosis but function.

I have ADHD ( medicated) and Asperger's. I have a well paid career.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:04

Gooseinthewood · 13/11/2026 06:35

Terminology is wrong but the principle correct. With a boom in diagnoses there are a lot of people who have a diagnosis but function.

I have ADHD ( medicated) and Asperger's. I have a well paid career.

Need hadn’t changed the review stated that, diagnosis is no less severe. People previously shut out of the diagnosis process such as women, girls and people of colour are now more able to access diagnosis. The Fogarty review noted that the underlying population - level prevalence of autism appears broadly stable. Both autism and ADHD have historically been under diagnosed in this country.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 13/11/2026 07:12

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 18:01

My dd has an EHCP so clearly those not shut out of the system at 4 don’t own need. There is no such thing as mild autism, it needs to have a significant impact on life to be diagnosed.

In some ways I agree with you but it seems people are being diagnosed and it doesn't seem to affect them too much.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:13

DontBuyAnotherBook · 13/11/2026 07:12

In some ways I agree with you but it seems people are being diagnosed and it doesn't seem to affect them too much.

Says who?

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:16

What utter nonsense, parents don’t cause trauma.EDS, OCD, depression, self harm, suicidal idealisation etc are often linked to autism and adhd which are genetic. Parents are not equipped to treat significant mental illnesses, many so called professionals aren’t!
This is the exact attitude of many parents who won't accept that they could possibly be the cause of their kids problems.

You really can't see how parents can be the source of a young adults' depression? If a parent failed to teach them that there is hope in the future, more rewarding activities than playing online games, give then the opportunity to experience the sense of pride.

As for other conditions, they might not not be the cause, but they are the reason they are not managing them. ADHD? They are so many ways to learn to adapt, fing the right medicine, recognise the impact it has on others.

The majority of these conditions are not significant mental health conditions. You clearly have no idea what a serious MH disease is. It's nothing like what most NEET experience, thankfully.

All this is parenting. A concept that so many parents absolve themselves of.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:21

The Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism (chaired by Professor Peter Fonagy) emphasised that people with these conditions face genuine, substantial challenges and that current delays in support are making their difficulties worse.

It also noted how people with these conditions often experience bullying, exclusion, poorer physical and mental health, and major barriers to everyday life.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 13/11/2026 07:28

Rustybike · 13/11/2026 06:16

Perhaps I am missing something, but it appears that the Milburn report will simply recommend changing the name of some of the benefits like UC / PIP for under 25s, but not really significantly changing the amounts handed out.

Meanwhile, it increases upfront spending by 6bn to pay for employment support coaches etc, (presumably more unionised public sector jobs). With undefined savings to come in a decade. And with undefined sanctions for those who don’t participate?

And it does nothing to address the much more significant and growing spending (and abuse) on welfare for over 25s upwards. And nothing on addressing some of the root causes which include Labour’s higher employment taxes, minimum wage and increased regulations etc…

Yes - you are missing something, but to be fair to you, that’s because this isn’t the full report—the 200-page review isn’t published until Tuesday. However, I do think you’re wrong to categorise it as rebrand: there will be some young people who whose financial support will be significantly cut (hence some of the worry from parents on this thread).

You’re right that the projected net savings take nearly a decade and that employment support would cost over money upfront - but any realistic, long term solution to this problem is going to take investment, and IMO pretending otherwise is why this hasn’t been tackled effectively before. As for over-25s, Milburn’s was always 16–24s—adult disability reform is being handled by a separate review under Sir Stephen Timms due later this month.

Finally, I agree that the minimum wage and NI raises will have exacerbated the problem, but the trend of rising NEETs pre-dates those changes, so they can’t really be defined as “root causes”. The IFS report is interesting on thjs: https://ifs.org.uk/news/recent-fall-youth-employment-approaching-decline-seen-during-covid-and-2008-financial-crisis
Having said that, I do hope (and expect TBF) that the full report will include support for employers. And I do agree with you that the root causes need to be tackled - but what I think that actually means is better preventative health care, better mental health support, education reforms etc etc.

So, we’ll have to see what the full report says! This has been such an ongoing problem, and is so complex to tackle so I’m very much hoping they’ll be a degree of cross party support around the recommendations.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:31

The Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism (chaired by Professor Peter Fonagy) emphasised that people with these conditions face genuine, substantial challenges and that current delays in support are making their difficulties worse
And? This doesn't mean that parenting has no role in creating or failing to manage these conditions?

It also noted how people with these conditions often experience bullying, exclusion, poorer physical and mental health, and major barriers to everyday life
Exactly! So come on parents, do more to teach your kids how to manage these conditions.

If your child has ADHD, it is even more important to help them focus. So don't put them in situations of over stimulation. These children need even more than others some quiet times, to be taught how to listen and respond to the question asked, to slow down their speech etc...this is not the role of a professional, it's the exact skills parents should be teaching their kids.

Itchthescratch · 13/11/2026 07:34

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:16

What utter nonsense, parents don’t cause trauma.EDS, OCD, depression, self harm, suicidal idealisation etc are often linked to autism and adhd which are genetic. Parents are not equipped to treat significant mental illnesses, many so called professionals aren’t!
This is the exact attitude of many parents who won't accept that they could possibly be the cause of their kids problems.

You really can't see how parents can be the source of a young adults' depression? If a parent failed to teach them that there is hope in the future, more rewarding activities than playing online games, give then the opportunity to experience the sense of pride.

As for other conditions, they might not not be the cause, but they are the reason they are not managing them. ADHD? They are so many ways to learn to adapt, fing the right medicine, recognise the impact it has on others.

The majority of these conditions are not significant mental health conditions. You clearly have no idea what a serious MH disease is. It's nothing like what most NEET experience, thankfully.

All this is parenting. A concept that so many parents absolve themselves of.

Studies have consistently linked challenging home environments to higher level of impairment from conditions such as ADHD. This can literally make the difference between someone receiving an ADHD diagnosis or not, or qualifying for benefits. Arguably the single biggest factor the influences a child or young persons home life is their parents. We need to get out head of the sand. The science is all there.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:35

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:16

What utter nonsense, parents don’t cause trauma.EDS, OCD, depression, self harm, suicidal idealisation etc are often linked to autism and adhd which are genetic. Parents are not equipped to treat significant mental illnesses, many so called professionals aren’t!
This is the exact attitude of many parents who won't accept that they could possibly be the cause of their kids problems.

You really can't see how parents can be the source of a young adults' depression? If a parent failed to teach them that there is hope in the future, more rewarding activities than playing online games, give then the opportunity to experience the sense of pride.

As for other conditions, they might not not be the cause, but they are the reason they are not managing them. ADHD? They are so many ways to learn to adapt, fing the right medicine, recognise the impact it has on others.

The majority of these conditions are not significant mental health conditions. You clearly have no idea what a serious MH disease is. It's nothing like what most NEET experience, thankfully.

All this is parenting. A concept that so many parents absolve themselves of.

Oh I think I do know what serious mental illness is like as I have more than one child battling serious conditions involving care and support at the highest level. Well and truly got the t shirt - and multiple professionals saying it is not the fault of us as parents.

There is a reason we have a Dynamic Support Register. People with autism are at huge risk of ending up in impatient.

Autism and ADHD come with difficulties that have a significant impact on life hence the link with mental illness. People with autism and ADHD and those with both are significantly more likely to experience mental health conditions compared to the general population. There are high rates of co-occurring mental health challenges. Up to half (or more) of individuals with ADHD or autism experience an anxiety disorder, such as generalised anxiety, social anxiety, or obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).Roughly 50% of autistic people experience clinical depression at some point in their lives, and major depressive disorder is also elevated in individuals with ADHD. Studies indicate that bipolar disorder and certain personality disorders are multiple times more prevalent in neurodivergent populations than in neurotypical controls. Having both autism and ADHD (AuDHD) often increases the risk further compared to having either condition alone. Sleep disorders, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD—often linked to chronic sensory overload, burnout, or social trauma), and eating-related struggles are also more common.

Navigating environments, schools, or workplaces that are not designed for neurodivergent brains leads to chronic stress, sensory overload, and exhaustion. Hiding or suppressing autistic or ADHD traits ("masking") to fit in takes a heavy psychological toll over time. Many face misunderstanding, bullying, discrimination, or difficulties forming and maintaining relationships. [Struggling with time management, organization, or emotional regulation in ADHD can result in recurring cycles of perceived failure and negative feedback from others….

None of that is the fault of parents but conditions young people are born with.

Maybe educate yourself a little .

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:35

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:31

The Independent Review into Mental Health Conditions, ADHD and Autism (chaired by Professor Peter Fonagy) emphasised that people with these conditions face genuine, substantial challenges and that current delays in support are making their difficulties worse
And? This doesn't mean that parenting has no role in creating or failing to manage these conditions?

It also noted how people with these conditions often experience bullying, exclusion, poorer physical and mental health, and major barriers to everyday life
Exactly! So come on parents, do more to teach your kids how to manage these conditions.

If your child has ADHD, it is even more important to help them focus. So don't put them in situations of over stimulation. These children need even more than others some quiet times, to be taught how to listen and respond to the question asked, to slow down their speech etc...this is not the role of a professional, it's the exact skills parents should be teaching their kids.

You can’t parent away autism and ADHD.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:36

Cahms is really for diagnosed mental health problems. Because of the many demands on their services the most severely mentally ill young people are not getting the service they should be getting. That's where the focus should be.

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:37

And I do agree with you that the root causes need to be tackled - but what I think that actually means is better preventative health care, better mental health support, education reforms etc etc
All these have been tried, over and over and over.

Cahms funding has increased with inflation or just about. Referrals however have increased by 10% annually in the past 10 years.

The root cause is exactly where the problem is, and the problem is worse every year because you can't tackle parenting with just money. It's a societal issue. The focus however needs to shift from the children to the parents.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:38

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:35

You can’t parent away autism and ADHD.

No but you can mitigate.
The harsh reality is parents and grandparents have these conditions and do work.
It usually rubs in families. But the older generations do work and the younger ones claim they can't. That is the reality

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:39

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:37

And I do agree with you that the root causes need to be tackled - but what I think that actually means is better preventative health care, better mental health support, education reforms etc etc
All these have been tried, over and over and over.

Cahms funding has increased with inflation or just about. Referrals however have increased by 10% annually in the past 10 years.

The root cause is exactly where the problem is, and the problem is worse every year because you can't tackle parenting with just money. It's a societal issue. The focus however needs to shift from the children to the parents.

Rubbish! Parents are not causing autism or adhd and the huge amount of significant difficulties that come with both.

Pinkytartany · 13/11/2026 07:39

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 05:20

Not how it works at all.

My daughter has masses of very strong evidence including a very robust EHCP which is hugely useful for PIP as regards illustrating care and support needs. Her PIP application and EHCP highlight very clearly education settings and her battle to get an education , qualifications and goals re work. Her battle to learn to drive, attending college or goals for eventual work have not been used against her at all,quite the reverse. We update them with everything in detail.

I am glad that didn’t happen to you, but I saw the decision letter (PA4?) and yes they did repeatedly use the fact she works against her. And the fact she has went to college and held “responsible jobs” were cited alongside the zero points scores as reasons she is capable. We have looked into it and many other people have had similar outcomes.

So yes that is how it works for some people apparently . Even if it shouldn’t.

No, I didn’t say they used the battle to drive against her actually. My issue was they glossed over it, instead of citing it as supportive of her claim. So they had selective focus on the things she could achieve.

But I’ve heard when reading stories onljne that other people who can drive had it used against them.

It’s gone to mandatory reconsideration now so we’ll see.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:40

Passaggressfedup · 13/11/2026 07:16

What utter nonsense, parents don’t cause trauma.EDS, OCD, depression, self harm, suicidal idealisation etc are often linked to autism and adhd which are genetic. Parents are not equipped to treat significant mental illnesses, many so called professionals aren’t!
This is the exact attitude of many parents who won't accept that they could possibly be the cause of their kids problems.

You really can't see how parents can be the source of a young adults' depression? If a parent failed to teach them that there is hope in the future, more rewarding activities than playing online games, give then the opportunity to experience the sense of pride.

As for other conditions, they might not not be the cause, but they are the reason they are not managing them. ADHD? They are so many ways to learn to adapt, fing the right medicine, recognise the impact it has on others.

The majority of these conditions are not significant mental health conditions. You clearly have no idea what a serious MH disease is. It's nothing like what most NEET experience, thankfully.

All this is parenting. A concept that so many parents absolve themselves of.

Agree.
Serious mental health conditions are young people with psychosis for example. Severe mental health conditions have as much stigma attached to them as they always had. But support is worse because of parents making demands for their children whose issues can be managed by good parenting.

Ott3r · 13/11/2026 07:40

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:38

No but you can mitigate.
The harsh reality is parents and grandparents have these conditions and do work.
It usually rubs in families. But the older generations do work and the younger ones claim they can't. That is the reality

Err the vast majority don’t the figures re unemployment and underemployment for people with autism and adhd are massive.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.