Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Milburn review and benefits for 18-24 year olds

1000 replies

ReviewAlternatives · 12/11/2026 07:11

I was just reading about this and have some concerns.

I think a better idea initially would be rather than sinking probably millions into setting a new scheme up the government should be putting that money into CAMHS.

I can see the review mentions support for ‘mild’ ADHD, autism and anxiety but that’s not enough. The whole CAMHS system needs the overhaul and only then with a fit for purpose system should benefit reforms for 18-24 year olds be looked at. To act immediately and include existing claimants is wrong.

AIBU to think this will not work unless they do things the correct way - intensive CAMHS reform initially not during or part of and limited to just ‘mild’ cases of certain issues?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
NippyNips · 12/11/2026 21:52

TempestTost · 12/11/2026 21:38

The absolute first thing that should happen is he should have zero access to video games. He's very likely an addict, rather than having ADHD.

I doubt he is incapable of work and others shouldn't be supporting him.

I know someone with ADHD who throws himself into work, research and study

pointythings · 12/11/2026 21:54

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 21:52

I know someone with ADHD who throws himself into work, research and study

But as always, just because some people with a condition can do something, that doesn't mean everyone with that condition can. Simplistic thinking is not helpful.

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 21:59

TempestTost · 12/11/2026 21:38

The absolute first thing that should happen is he should have zero access to video games. He's very likely an addict, rather than having ADHD.

I doubt he is incapable of work and others shouldn't be supporting him.

It’s a bit chicken and egg. Playing online games all day with poor diet and putting on weight will cause issues over time. A job could break that cycle but left too long it gets harder.

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 22:03

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 21:59

It’s a bit chicken and egg. Playing online games all day with poor diet and putting on weight will cause issues over time. A job could break that cycle but left too long it gets harder.

How is putting weight on relevant, out of interest?

I was obese and employed for most of my adult life.

Until this year, I was 17 stone and in senior management.

Fat people can and do work? 😂

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 22:08

AirborneElephant · 12/11/2026 21:21

Hmm, I don’t agree. Some taxes are the price of living in society, such as infrastructure, police, defence, education. But the payment of individual benefits at the current level is definitely not essential to a stable functioning society, there are many countries around the world just as stable as the uk that pay no such benefits. Higher cash payments given to disabled people compared to other “less deserving” people in particular is not a requirement for a stable society, it’s the reflection of a view of a majority of taxpayers that such people should be cared for. That makes it charity.

Sorry - edited, as posted too soon!

Respectfully, words have meaning and tax doesn’t become charity just because you disagree with how it’s being spent.

Beyond that, I personally do also believe in the concept of social infrastructure - the idea that investing in people’s health, education and training benefits us all - because long-term that gives us a more productive workforce overall, and also decreases the cost on other services by preventing people reach crisis point (which taking all morality out of it, is actually more expensive for the tax payer)

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 22:11

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 21:52

I know someone with ADHD who throws himself into work, research and study

You can throw yourself into work, research and study and still need a lot of help.

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 22:14

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 22:03

How is putting weight on relevant, out of interest?

I was obese and employed for most of my adult life.

Until this year, I was 17 stone and in senior management.

Fat people can and do work? 😂

That’s great. It doesn’t sound like the young person playing online all day is getting much exercise or time outside.

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 22:19

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 22:14

That’s great. It doesn’t sound like the young person playing online all day is getting much exercise or time outside.

No, it sounds like they have a significant mental health condition or barrier.

Because let’s face it, without either of those things, sitting in your room all day would drive anyone up the wall.

I’m just not sure that “also is fat” isn’t just a dig, because it’s likely not why they’re not working.

The reason, by the sounds of it, is a social barrier or MH concern, rather than a weight issue.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 22:36

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 22:11

You can throw yourself into work, research and study and still need a lot of help.

Can you explain to me what issues a person might have and why they would need external help consistently to get over it?

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 22:38

SleeplessInWherever · 12/11/2026 22:19

No, it sounds like they have a significant mental health condition or barrier.

Because let’s face it, without either of those things, sitting in your room all day would drive anyone up the wall.

I’m just not sure that “also is fat” isn’t just a dig, because it’s likely not why they’re not working.

The reason, by the sounds of it, is a social barrier or MH concern, rather than a weight issue.

The pp said putting on a lot of weight. Those conditions below would be concerning for MH and physical health, for a young person.

SuddenDaredJelly · 12/11/2026 22:39

Too many families are stuck in a cycle of low hours or minimal work. Jobseeker benefits alone wont enable you to live without working long term, the two fact patterns that provide access to more are children & disability elements. Child elements less so with two child limit & uc cap, but disability elements in particular are a gateway to a lot, and people get trapped, these are not people with high earning capacity so they can't get a job that would (after tax) replace what they get from benefits even if they wanted to. Add in that they are concentrated in areas of the country with fewer jobs & opportunities & its hopeless. People feel helpless & unable to do more with their lives & its self perpetuating.

Often struggling through challenge makes me people step up and develop strength & resilience they never knew they had - in wars, crises & natural disasters. There are lots of people for whom getting going in work would feel like a huge (insurmountable?) challenge but i truly believe most people have the capacity to rise to that challenge and develop the skills to overcome it and thrive. The structure & achievement become increasingly fulfilling & satisfying, which continue to bolster people's resilience.

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 22:43

EasternStandard · 12/11/2026 22:38

The pp said putting on a lot of weight. Those conditions below would be concerning for MH and physical health, for a young person.

Going out into office and working is good for MH. Getting out for walks even if to the office helps. To get to the office. I need to walk to the station, take train and then walk to office.

Pinkytartany · 12/11/2026 22:44

IwouldlikeanewTV · 12/11/2026 07:51

I have a 20 year old relative who has never worked. Left school with three A levels. Mother subsequently got him ADHD assessed. He plays online all day. Has put on massive amount of weight and as a result of sitting in his bedroom is now developing other issues ie sensory which he never had three years ago. Refuses to attend job interviews, refuses to apply for even the most basic job, refuses to get work experience. He receives around £250 a month for this. He will never work so looks like a life on benefit. At some stage his mother will kick him out. I don’t know what the answer is but the current answer isn’t working.

Just curious where does he get the £250 from? Is he on PIP?

Lifesd · 12/11/2026 22:45

LoisGriffinskitchen · 12/11/2026 20:29

What a revolting comment.

Why it is the truth!!!

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 22:52

NippyNips · 12/11/2026 22:36

Can you explain to me what issues a person might have and why they would need external help consistently to get over it?

Multiple physical illnesses that can fluctuate.

many MH issues can fluctuate and you don't tend to get 'cured'. They're often life long with peaks and troughs.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 12/11/2026 22:53

Lifesd · 12/11/2026 22:45

Why it is the truth!!!

It isn’t the truth, though, because words have meanings and the definition of tax, and the definition of charity are different.

Of course tax payers are entitled to have an opinion on how their taxes are spent, hence why this discussion is happening and why there are so many strong feelings on all sides, but calling tax charity is inaccurate and therefore comes across as inflammatory.

Pinkytartany · 12/11/2026 22:59

mummymeister · 12/11/2026 10:37

Exactly!! the example of the disabled person desperate to work who uses PIP as it was intended to help them stay working and independent is not the majority. and this 20% should be getting more money and not less. Its the other 80% who get a diagnosis privately and use PIP to top up their unemployment benefits so that they can live their life more comfortably. Its a loophole and lots of lazy people are using it because its the way to get more money.

I am on a "gossip girls " forum and post after post this week is "girls I just cant manage on my benefits" to which the answer is always "get yourself on PIP go and see this or that private doctor he will diagnose you" its out there blatant as that.

and all the time the govt is paying for these people to live their best life on my money, they arent spending on increasing opportunities for apprentices or getting young people into their first jobs, or work experience. because all their money is going on Carole from up the road who spends her days gaming, meeting her mates in spoons and getting pissed at the weekends because her made up ADH whatever makes her too anxious to set an alarm and get up on time in the morning.

yes I helped a friend apply for PIP and it's shocking how they used the fact she works against her and the fact she had been to college.

It was like oh you've got qualifications and you've had jobs working in an offices and shops before and you work now - albeit from home - so you don't need PIP.

So instead of helping her stay in work they've actually used it to penalise her. No wonder such a small proportion of PIP recipients are working. Because they tend to reject the ones who claim while working.

They also use people being able to drive against them too but interestingly enough didn't count it in my friend's favour that she was unable to drive despite trying. It's like they just strategically use evidence against people unless you can rock up and say don't work, don't do anything, didn't bother with college and so on.

CandidLurker · 12/11/2026 23:02

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 22:52

Multiple physical illnesses that can fluctuate.

many MH issues can fluctuate and you don't tend to get 'cured'. They're often life long with peaks and troughs.

There are mental health illnesses for which treatment is available. Anti-depressants are very effective for many and some people accept that they just need to be on them for life so they can carry on working, functioning etc. I do see a bit of an issue in the conflict between paying for an NHS which does have treatments available and then people claiming benefits for illnesses that can be effectively treated (not necessarily fully cured) with drugs and other treatments. Certainly to a sufficient level that should enable work of some kind.

Llttledrummergirl · 12/11/2026 23:11

Apotofrealcoffee · 12/11/2026 21:26

Meh. I find a some benefit claimants are actually aggressive, snotty and superior to the very people working to fund their entire life. I think it’s gone too far the other way and a bit of gratitude is in order.

Ahh, the undeserving poor.

They should know their place.

BluebellBeth · 12/11/2026 23:23

CandidLurker · 12/11/2026 23:02

There are mental health illnesses for which treatment is available. Anti-depressants are very effective for many and some people accept that they just need to be on them for life so they can carry on working, functioning etc. I do see a bit of an issue in the conflict between paying for an NHS which does have treatments available and then people claiming benefits for illnesses that can be effectively treated (not necessarily fully cured) with drugs and other treatments. Certainly to a sufficient level that should enable work of some kind.

I didn't say treatment wasn't available (although that is arguable with the current state of the nhs!). i said MH issues can't always be cured, which you've agreed with.

yes you can have treatment and feel better, but it's not remotely unusual for things to get bad again. To need a different anti depressant, to need to up meds to need a different therapy, to bounce on/off in/out of therapy or treatment. These times can see people become very unwell again.

NorthernJim · 12/11/2026 23:26

HeyUpDuckie · 12/11/2026 07:29

It needs fixing before they do this. Mild adhd and autism doesn't exist either, you either have it or you don't. The fact they don't understand that says everything. They're will be kids from sen schools unable to work caught up in this.

Then a lot of people have been misdiagnosed.

Pinkytartany · 12/11/2026 23:29

I think one issue is workplaces not making reasonable adjustments. I work fine from home and only attend the office twice a month. Many other workplaces force people to be in the office regardless despite some people's ND/mental health related struggles with commuting, which is also impacted by how poor public transport is for a lot of people and the absolute nightmare it is to book a driving test in some areas. Or even if they are required to work in the office they could at least offer flexible hours, where possible, so letting them arrive a bit earlier or a bit later so they avoid rush hour. The civil service is really good for that.

NorthernJim · 12/11/2026 23:51

My nephew (16) was diagnosed autistic in primary school, around age 6/7 I think. Admittedly he had a few unusual behavioural things going on. But he grew out of those and matured very quickly as a teenager. He's completely independent, cooks and cleans for himself, does his own laundry, goes out wherever he wants as and when he pleases (travels by himself by bus or train in to town and city). He goes to parties, drinks and smokes (and I suspect weed as well, if not harder stuff). He's had several long term girlfriends and been sexually active since he was 13, has had part time jobs and is currently doing well at college. He even plays in a band and lugs his guitars all over the city by himself to play evening gigs in pubs. He's one of the most self assured, self confident and socially competent 16 year olds I've ever known (and I include myself and most of my friends at that age). By my reckoning he's less neuro diverse than 90% of the young adult population.

So I was a bit surprised a couple of years ago when dsis mentioned to me that she'd started claiming disability living allowance for him. I've no idea what she put on the application, but there's absolutely no higher levels of care or expense over the typical teenage son or daughter. I knew that child DLA expires when the DC turns 16 so I thought that would be the end of it. But dsis mentioned the other week that nephew is now receiving PIP instead, paid directly to him (he's still living at home and not contributing to household expenses at all, his pip money just gets spent on whatever he fancies - mostly energy drinks and cigarettes best I can tell). I was flabbergasted I can't see any way that he'd be eligible or qualify for pip, no idea how they've successfully claimed it.

So yes, I do think the current system must be completely broken. Obviously there are legitimate claimants, but how many other people are completely taking the piss?

Pinkytartany · 12/11/2026 23:58

So yes, I do think the current system must be completely broken. Obviously there are legitimate claimants, but how many other people are completely taking the piss?

Yes it is broken.

But it's swings and roundabouts if you look into how it's broken. The fact is they also reject a lot of genuine claimants, I think they do that as much as they give out to false claimants.

I've read people have had appeals granted or denied after they have died off the illness which had led them to apply. Says it all.

They make a lot of people jump through hoops, often the ones who get it are just the ones who never gave up. Some of those persistent people may genuinely need it, some won't.

caringcarer · 13/11/2026 01:12

Ott3r · 12/11/2026 07:24

18 to 25 are under adult services which is dire. Transition to adult services is dire. Getting treatment is almost entirely crisis lead.

My daughter gets PIP, has several NHS diagnoses and has been hospitalised multiple times at huge cost to the taxpayer. She is bloody amazing and fighting to build a life. We need to pay for therapy to stop her spiralling again and were going to be using her PIP. At £650 for the initial psych consultation and £500 a month therapy I’m not entirely sure what we’re going to do now- wait until she hits crisis and costs the tax payer ££££ in hospital stays I guess.

If your DD get £500 a month surely getting her therapy would be a really good use of her pip.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.