Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I really don’t want my kids at the same school

165 replies

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:12

This isn’t very easy to write about and I’m sure I’m going to invite a certain amount of criticism but I would genuinely appreciate advice and support here.

Ever since my youngest has been of an age to have her own mind (so maybe 18 months ish?) I’ve found my children really difficult together. I had a thread yesterday about chaotic pickups which makes my children sound utterly uncontrollable, but the thing is they really aren’t like this when separate. They are pretty nice apart but together not so much.

I am really, really worried about my youngest starting school next year because at the moment she copies everything her older brother does. This morning, for example, he spilled a drink on his top on the way out so I told him to take it off in the car and I’d run in the house and get him a fresh one. Came back outside and DD is sitting in the car with her top off. It is literally everything. I can just imagine if he does something silly at school she’ll copy him.

I honestly wouldn’t have had two if I’d known it would be like this but obviously it is too late to do anything about that now. However, I can at least manage the situation by keeping them separate as much as possible.

It is logistically difficult but not impossible.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:30

@BenjyGreyRabbit i know, it isn’t that in itself that was a bad thing (the taking the top off) i was just trying to show how everything is copied, literally. Ds once ran in the garden and accidentally knocked a plant pot over. I picked it up and she knocked it over again! It’s stuff like that - it’s not that in itself it’s important, just imagining her trying to hang her bag up on his peg in the classroom, taking his water bottle off him, those sorts of things. Maybe she won’t; I obviously hope not!

OP posts:
Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:30

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:27

@Pobblewob you do realise I posted in a bit of a panic and have responded to the kind and supportive posts? You’re acting as if it’s set in stone this is what I’m doing rather than a rather panicked post at the end of a terrible week.

Right so what do you want?

People to tell you it's a great idea?

Or people to point out the obvious that it's bonkers and you're clearly posting at a point of frustration?

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:34

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:30

@BenjyGreyRabbit i know, it isn’t that in itself that was a bad thing (the taking the top off) i was just trying to show how everything is copied, literally. Ds once ran in the garden and accidentally knocked a plant pot over. I picked it up and she knocked it over again! It’s stuff like that - it’s not that in itself it’s important, just imagining her trying to hang her bag up on his peg in the classroom, taking his water bottle off him, those sorts of things. Maybe she won’t; I obviously hope not!

But she will have her own peg which will be much more interesting. At the moment she goes nursery part time, so other than those hours only has him to see as a role model.
When she starts she will have her own peg and book bag, her own drink and lunch. Why will she bother her brother when other new friends are around?!
You don't mention her sad at nursery pining for him so once she is occupied surely she will get on with things.
My kids are consecutive years at school so will have been together for some things when year groups got paired up for activities - I think they were either excited to see each other in the younger years...or actively tried to move away from each other in the older years!

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:36

@Pobblewob why don’t you click on my posts and look at my responses? I really think there’s lots from this thread to take forwards that has been very, very helpful and I have responded thanking posters who have contributed as such sincerely and with real gratitude (as you will know, had you read the thread.)

Many posters have kindly and supportively been helping me explore options. Allowing me a space to disclose my utter despair at my life. I have several new ways of looking at things and an optimism that things will improve that didn't exist this morning. I have been challenged. I have been supported. That is what I ‘want.’ It is also what I have got. From some, of course.

And it may have been missed by some that I am unwell myself, nothing serious but for me low physical health often comes with a bit of a low mood and feeling a bit despairing about the future. People reassuring me does give a sense of hope which as I’ve said, was not there this morning.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:37

She doesn’t pine for him at nursery because he is not there. He is at school, so that’s when difficulties can start. Of course they hopefully will not but they physically can’t at nursery -
he’s not there!

OP posts:
Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:38

My question really is why are you in such utter despair?

Is your poor judgement in this case a symptom of a wider issue?

Do you have support?

RancidRuby · 07/11/2026 21:40

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:19

I don’t think I favour ds particularly. Dd has hit a very difficult stage but ds is just as capable of behaving in a stupid way as well. It is one thing to challenge someone but this ideally should be supportive as well. There have been periods I’ve found DD much easier than DS and periods where the reverse has been true. I think very generally, broadly speaking, your older child often is ‘easier’ because they are more capable, which obviously isn’t the younger child’s fault!

I’m very much being supportive in that I’m trying to give you some constructive feedback based on what you’ve actually said. I’m not having a go at you, my very first post was very gentle and supportive. I’m perhaps becoming more forthright because you seem to be missing the point.

Your 6 year old is coming out of school, chucking all his belongings at you then running off down the road in an unsafe manner. You are grappling with your 3 year old having a tantrum, refusing to walk or running off after her brother making it difficult to keep them both safe. You are worried about your DD starting school and copying your DS behaving badly, you even gave examples of how he might behave badly. Your solution to both of these situations is to focus entirely on your DD and her behaviour - she will be left in the car until she understands it’s a privilege to be allowed out of the car, you are considering putting her into a different school so that she won’t misbehave by copying your DS at his school. She’s 3, I’ll say it again her behaviour is developmentally normal, your son doesn’t have the same excuse yet you seem quite determined not to address that and I think that not doing so will only cause other issues further down the line.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:40

Poor judgement in the choice of school? I don’t think it’s better or worse than any other I could have chosen. But honestly, I am not totally convinced you’re posting to try to help. I’m sorry if I have misinterpreted your intent but your questions are very pointed and loaded and seem to be quite critical.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:42

@RancidRuby yes that happened once and I’ve taken steps to ensure it doesn’t happen again. I can hardly leave my ds in the car, can I?

OP posts:
Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:43

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:37

She doesn’t pine for him at nursery because he is not there. He is at school, so that’s when difficulties can start. Of course they hopefully will not but they physically can’t at nursery -
he’s not there!

But you are only imagining what might happen. As I have said she will have her own classmates to relate to. Even if they do spend some time together a large chunk will be in with her own peers. Yes she might gravitate to him when they are reunited but whose to say that will be negative.
Lots of people have said staff will be there to set boundaries and speak to them if they both misbehave. Surely that's no different than a group of friends that can be silly together and are generally kept apart but when they have continuous provision or out on the playground buddy up.

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:44

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:42

@RancidRuby yes that happened once and I’ve taken steps to ensure it doesn’t happen again. I can hardly leave my ds in the car, can I?

What was his consequence?

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:45

Lost screen time. I am starting to feel as if I am on trial here, just FYI Smile

OP posts:
RancidRuby · 07/11/2026 21:49

This is like banging my head against a brick wall. I’m bowing out. Good luck, OP.

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:54

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:45

Lost screen time. I am starting to feel as if I am on trial here, just FYI Smile

I don't think that's the case, more that many of us think the behaviours are pretty normal and sending them to different schools because of fears of how they might behave together is a very extreme reaction.
It sounds like you have posted about other issues so I think people want to help and wonder if you are struggling, but it's frustrating when people post having already made their minds up and then reject every suggestion offered.
So if you want to send them to different schools then you do you, but I think you need to consider the practicalities of this (also term dates might not match, so if each school uses their 5 inset days on different dates as well as the school holidays you then have 10 other days for sorting childcare. Not sure what your current arrangement is for the school holidays).

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 07/11/2026 21:54

This is really common and I think you're overreacting a bit. My DD very quickly went from the 'disciple' phase to the 'loving her DB while simultaneously abhorring any physical or prolonged contact with him' phase.

Choosing two schools will inevitably be logistically inconvenient at some point - although for balance there may be some good things to come out of it, e.g. a chance of having inset days 1:1 with each child. It's shallow to say it, but I'd also question what other parents might think about you if there's no reason such as SEN to explain your choice. I'm sure I would roll my eyes and nod along to you saying 'It's just so exhausting', but in private I would be thinking 'Get a grip woman - they're controlling your life'. It might make me wary about developing a relationship with you for either me or my children.

Bananacrepewithnuts · 07/11/2026 21:55

Dont bother it's not going to solve a problem ta just going to make your life so much harder having to juggle 2 schools.

X

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:57

@RancidRuby if you can’t take being answered to perfectly politely without huffing off I do agree that is best. At the moment it is a struggle to manage both children, and owing to the obvious fact ds is the one being collected that means whatever arrangement I make for dd - in the car, asking a friend to watch her - means that she’s the one sort of sidelined a bit.

There have been guilt inducing moments in the past where I felt like I loved dd more and bonded with her more than ds. When he was a stroppy three year old and she was a beautiful snuggly baby. Now she is the stroppy three year old and he is a mostly reasonable nearly six year old.

Perhaps when he is a moody preteen and she is a sunny six year old this will switch again Smile Or perhaps not. They will always present different challenges and I can’t always be precisely, exactly fair about things. What I can do is manage situations as best as I can. I need to get ds to come out of school on a civilised fashion and walk to the car. Once I have done that with him tomorrow, I shall do it with them both, on Tuesday. While ds did run ahead a bit in fairness to him he was in my eyesight at all times. It was mostly dd refusing to walk which caused the problem.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:58

Thanks @AtomHeartMotherOfGod . I really hope you are right and trust that you are as others have said similar.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:59

it's frustrating when people post having already made their minds up and then reject every suggestion offered And as you would see if you’ve read my replies, that is not what has happened at all. So perhaps save the frustration.

OP posts:
mindutopia · 07/11/2026 22:04

It sounds to me like they would benefit from the structured environment in school and someone setting boundaries and expectations. It can only be a good thing that they get to practice that together in school.

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 22:05

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:40

Poor judgement in the choice of school? I don’t think it’s better or worse than any other I could have chosen. But honestly, I am not totally convinced you’re posting to try to help. I’m sorry if I have misinterpreted your intent but your questions are very pointed and loaded and seem to be quite critical.

Poor judgement as in you thinking this is a good idea.

I really think you're doing a lot of navel gazing and introspection about relatively normal life events with a 3 and 6 year old.

I hope that life gets easier for you. I hope that you can trust the school and you feel as safe and welcome there as your child does. I also hope you have someone in real life to talk to.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 22:09

You won’t look through my posts and see I have decided to do this, because I think it’s really good idea will you? But I do think you’re trying to take the thread in a direction I do not want so shall we leave it there?

That was a very loaded and rather unpleasant comment @mindutopia , it was a fairly obvious inference that ‘they don’t get it with you.’ Besides, I’m not suggesting home schooling them; whether they go to school or not is not the question, so it just looks like a rather unpleasant comment which is what I think it was supposed to be.

OP posts:
DontBuyAnotherBook · 07/11/2026 22:23

I can't imagine putting yourself through getting to two different schools in a morning for no big reason. It will be such a faff.

70sgal · 07/11/2026 22:24

@coughing26 if your dd copies everything your DS does then my advice would be to focus on your DS’s behaviour. He behaves she’ll copy.

Get that sorted and then sending them both to the same school will be fine.

SuddenDaredJelly · 07/11/2026 22:27

It may be hard to hear this but her behaviour will be different in school (both with & without her brother!) than it is with you.

Teachers have to have clear, consistent boundaries & consequences to teach & maintain control of 30 kids at once. They will ignore the tantrumming & she'll quickly learn its pointless/ineffective at school & wont do it.

Siblings even interact differently at school. My two wind each other up non stop at home, but at school will be fiercely loyal/protective towards each other.