Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I really don’t want my kids at the same school

165 replies

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:12

This isn’t very easy to write about and I’m sure I’m going to invite a certain amount of criticism but I would genuinely appreciate advice and support here.

Ever since my youngest has been of an age to have her own mind (so maybe 18 months ish?) I’ve found my children really difficult together. I had a thread yesterday about chaotic pickups which makes my children sound utterly uncontrollable, but the thing is they really aren’t like this when separate. They are pretty nice apart but together not so much.

I am really, really worried about my youngest starting school next year because at the moment she copies everything her older brother does. This morning, for example, he spilled a drink on his top on the way out so I told him to take it off in the car and I’d run in the house and get him a fresh one. Came back outside and DD is sitting in the car with her top off. It is literally everything. I can just imagine if he does something silly at school she’ll copy him.

I honestly wouldn’t have had two if I’d known it would be like this but obviously it is too late to do anything about that now. However, I can at least manage the situation by keeping them separate as much as possible.

It is logistically difficult but not impossible.

OP posts:
Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:01

What if you decide to drop her first and she refuses to get out the car because she knows her brother goes to a different school well what if she does? Confused What if she has a tantrum now because he’s at one school and she’s at preschool? What if she does that tomorrow? I mean, I know it sounds like I’m being awkward - I’m just not sure planning things based around ‘what if DD has a tantrum’ is a particularly sensible course of action!

But isn't this what your issue was about? The reason you want to send DD to a different school is because of her behaviour. Now you are saying you aren't basing it on that!

If you are unhappy with the school then move them both.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:04

@Moonnstarz , I was / am feeling very anxious about sending DD to the same school as DS because together their behaviour isn’t great. I don’t like parenting them together. Arguing over ‘well what if she does this or what if she does that’ well equally, what if she does something else or something else? Really, it is pointless, I have no idea what you’re driving at to be honest.

I am not thrilled with the school but am also unconvinced it’s different anywhere else. I also don’t want to move a child who is settled and happy when is quite reasonable.

OP posts:
MissingMeadow · 07/11/2026 21:07

Are you not happy with the school because you feel judged?

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:10

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:04

@Moonnstarz , I was / am feeling very anxious about sending DD to the same school as DS because together their behaviour isn’t great. I don’t like parenting them together. Arguing over ‘well what if she does this or what if she does that’ well equally, what if she does something else or something else? Really, it is pointless, I have no idea what you’re driving at to be honest.

I am not thrilled with the school but am also unconvinced it’s different anywhere else. I also don’t want to move a child who is settled and happy when is quite reasonable.

But the thing you are worrying about may not happen in school. That's what is confusing and where the thread then seems to be getting muddled.
As someone else pointed out you seem to be focusing on your DD as the main cause (wishing you had never had her) while ignoring the fact your son is older yet still does the same behaviours.
I am not sure what exactly you want now, other than people to say do send them to different schools. But to me that isn't going to address the issue as surely as soon as they see each other the behaviour you worry about at the moment could still happen, plus all of this will cause you extra work in terms of two school drops while being a solo parent (so will be impossible to be in both places at the same time so will cost you too in putting one child into breakfast/after-school club each day which may be harder on one salary).

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:11

Someone else has mentioned the judgement. No, I don’t think so. Or if I do, it’s in relation to things I ultimately cannot control anyway. I am mostly not thrilled (I wouldn’t say ‘unhappy’ exactly) with extremely poor communication. That is my main bugbear, but I do wish to keep things amicable so keep that to myself. I do of course wish DD had not chosen sports day, the nativity and a teacher meeting to have meltdowns however …

OP posts:
Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:12

What does extremely poor communication actually look like?

Sometimes parents have wildly unrealistic expectations compared to a private nursery.

thisismeithinkorisit · 07/11/2026 21:12

surely the period when they're in school is the period when they're not actually together?? even a hook assemblies etc., she'll be sat in a row further ahead, the teacher will tell her to turn round if she's looking for him etc.

Edenmum2 · 07/11/2026 21:12

They’ll be in different classes and would barely see each other. I think sending them to different schools would be wild. How would you explain it to them?

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:13

@Moonnstarz when I say I wish I had not had her it is not that I’m looking at her and wishing she did not exist. It is more a logical fact that I feel my capacities are overstretched; she is my youngest, had I stopped at one she would not exist. I love her dearly. But if I was to go back and never have met her yet somehow know how gruelling and relentless life has turned out to be, I am not sure I would have decided to have another child. Hopefully that explains a little more clearly what I mean.

OP posts:
Booboobagins · 07/11/2026 21:14

My kids never got on. They went to the same school fir a lot of time and it was OK, they just fought at home.

I hope you land on tge best solution fir you - being at diff schools will need collection planning and they may be clashes with the dates of school.events too - nativity, Caroles, sports day, parents evening etc...

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:14

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:12

What does extremely poor communication actually look like?

Sometimes parents have wildly unrealistic expectations compared to a private nursery.

They do yes. But I would rather not get into that, as it does not really matter. I was just answering somebody’s question.

OP posts:
RancidRuby · 07/11/2026 21:15

I’m not reiterating the other thread, you did by saying you were going to leave
your DD in the car at pick up as a consequence of her behaviour. Any consequences for your son for his behaviour?

I don’t like the way DD gets whipped into a frenzy over nothing or the way DS is sidelined.

I’ve felt increasingly that you favour your DS over your DD over the course of the thread, but this just confirms it. That doesn’t make you a monster, I think most of us if we’re honest would admit that sometimes we prefer one child
over the other (and vice versa), but you really do need to get a handle on yourself with regards to this. It’s not fair to your DD to only punish her when she’s behaving in a developmentally normal manner AND it’s not just her behaving badly. It won’t do your DS any favours either.

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:16

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:14

They do yes. But I would rather not get into that, as it does not really matter. I was just answering somebody’s question.

OK but if you think a school is so bad, why are you sending your one child there let alone 2?

I would genuinely explore your thoughts with a therapist.

3yos are supposed to be dicks!

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:19

I don’t think I favour ds particularly. Dd has hit a very difficult stage but ds is just as capable of behaving in a stupid way as well. It is one thing to challenge someone but this ideally should be supportive as well. There have been periods I’ve found DD much easier than DS and periods where the reverse has been true. I think very generally, broadly speaking, your older child often is ‘easier’ because they are more capable, which obviously isn’t the younger child’s fault!

OP posts:
BCBird · 07/11/2026 21:19

Is there anyone else who could take the school run to give you a break?

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:21

@Pobblewob because <sigh> as I’ve explained a few times now, ds is very settled there, had friends and strong relationships with others. I don’t wish to sever that and so I keep my annoyances to myself. I don’t think yanking children out of schools willy billy is wise and I also don’t think it would be any better anywhere else. Sometimes, it really is ‘out of the frying pan into the fire!’

OP posts:
Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:22

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:11

Someone else has mentioned the judgement. No, I don’t think so. Or if I do, it’s in relation to things I ultimately cannot control anyway. I am mostly not thrilled (I wouldn’t say ‘unhappy’ exactly) with extremely poor communication. That is my main bugbear, but I do wish to keep things amicable so keep that to myself. I do of course wish DD had not chosen sports day, the nativity and a teacher meeting to have meltdowns however …

All those events where she had meltdowns are pretty standard events for little siblings to get fed up and act up. Perhaps she is the only younger one there but this is not unusual. Sitting for a Nativity show can be long and boring. Even in school our KS1 children can be up and down like yo-yos asking for the toilet - more because they want a break than actually needing to go. Same with a teacher meeting. It's not interesting. This is why at parents evenings some schools suggest that children should not attend unless childcare is not possible, or some put out toys to welcome children and younger siblings so they have something to do while the adults talk.

BenjyGreyRabbit · 07/11/2026 21:25

The reason I asked whether you'd had much experience with children prior to having your own is that you seem to be reacting quite strongly to some typical behaviour. I have a friend who had two children close in age, then waited a long time to have another. It was honestly very reassuring when she would say things like, "Oh, I remember DS1 doing that at this age, he got over it" or whatever.

I know you were just using it as an example, but your DD imitating her brother by taking her top off doesn't seem like a terrible thing at all. I probably would have laughed and possibly taken a picture of the shirtless pair. I realise there have probably been other incidents where the results of DD copying DS have been more serious, but I'd really let the small stuff slide.

Since you're a single parent, that definitely must complicate things. Is their dad an involved parent? Could he do the school run sometimes, if his work schedule would allow it? It might help to break some of the habits the children have got into, and you could support each other (assuming the relationship with your ex is amicable).

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:25

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:21

@Pobblewob because <sigh> as I’ve explained a few times now, ds is very settled there, had friends and strong relationships with others. I don’t wish to sever that and so I keep my annoyances to myself. I don’t think yanking children out of schools willy billy is wise and I also don’t think it would be any better anywhere else. Sometimes, it really is ‘out of the frying pan into the fire!’

There's a difference between keeping annoyances to yourself, and thinking somewhere is so bad you won't send another child.

What happens if the other school turns out to be amazing? Would you Move DS to level the playing field?

Logistically you'd be paying for childcare for at least one child round the others school run.

I also don't think moving kids around schools is wise. But I also think sending 2 kids to different schools without extremely good reason is unwise.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:26

@Moonnstarz it was a bit tongue in cheek which is why I said ‘I wish …’ I don’t necessarily think she did anything hugely wrong, it’s just one of those things, but I am a little aware that nearly every time she’s had closeish contact with someone at the school she has been acting up a bit Smile

OP posts:
Cattywillow · 07/11/2026 21:26

I don’t think making things more difficult for yourself is a good solution. As other posters said she will grow out of it. Once at school she’ll become less interested in copying her brother. To give you hope, my youngest was a terror when I had to drag him around after his older siblings. I was also self conscious because he’d be throwing a fit any time I tried to get him anywhere or keep him quiet. He grew out of it very suddenly when he started school and became a very law abiding and delightful little boy and is still so now that he’s a teen.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 21:27

@Pobblewob you do realise I posted in a bit of a panic and have responded to the kind and supportive posts? You’re acting as if it’s set in stone this is what I’m doing rather than a rather panicked post at the end of a terrible week.

OP posts:
DoLallyTapMum · 07/11/2026 21:28

as someone who has currently got 5 kids in 5 schools (through no choice of ours). My elder three step-children were deliberately seperated by their mom and it made bonding for them even harder as they had no shared experiences of school to discuss. This was particularly hard with their ASD sibling as he didn’t communicate about his school and they had never been there so couldn’t discuss it.

We now have 1 in a SEND school, the two high school kids are year 7 and 11 and eldest didn’t get into first choice school but younger one did, one still in primary and one is in nursery. I would not advise this but it is temporary and my primary and nursery child will both attend the same primary and linked secondary as their year 7 sibling.

The shared experience of siblings having been to the same schools is important for their bond and later experiences in life and even if sometimes their bickering and copying is difficult they need to build a relationship and shared experiences (assemblies, teachers over the years, school events and trips) are important for that. They’re not the most important thing, obviously, which is why one of our children is in a SEND school, but they are significant.

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 21:30

I would also say some of this is second child syndrome. For some reason the second child with a lot of people I know is often the crazier version!

My favourite year group so far as a TA was one that was a majority of second children. The class were completely nuts! But they were all amazing! I think for some it gives them some kind of extra confidence...plus knowing their sibling was in the school may have reassured them.

Obviously this isn't true for all second children before anyone comes at me.

Bananarice · 07/11/2026 21:30

Op, if you can manage taking them to different school, working and being single parent. Then do it.

It is ok, to think that a particular school doesn't suit siblings. If you think it will be beneficial for your dd it will benefit her, to attend a different school and you could accommodate it, then do it.