Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I really don’t want my kids at the same school

165 replies

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:12

This isn’t very easy to write about and I’m sure I’m going to invite a certain amount of criticism but I would genuinely appreciate advice and support here.

Ever since my youngest has been of an age to have her own mind (so maybe 18 months ish?) I’ve found my children really difficult together. I had a thread yesterday about chaotic pickups which makes my children sound utterly uncontrollable, but the thing is they really aren’t like this when separate. They are pretty nice apart but together not so much.

I am really, really worried about my youngest starting school next year because at the moment she copies everything her older brother does. This morning, for example, he spilled a drink on his top on the way out so I told him to take it off in the car and I’d run in the house and get him a fresh one. Came back outside and DD is sitting in the car with her top off. It is literally everything. I can just imagine if he does something silly at school she’ll copy him.

I honestly wouldn’t have had two if I’d known it would be like this but obviously it is too late to do anything about that now. However, I can at least manage the situation by keeping them separate as much as possible.

It is logistically difficult but not impossible.

OP posts:
Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 19:50

You’re letting these relatively minor things run completely away in your own head and it’s making you very irrational with your parenting.
Your 3 year old will copy their older sibling, that is normal.
You don’t feel at all comfortable looking after both your children together, I think that’s probably more on you than them to be honest because some of the things you complain and stress about are such run of the mill parenting things.
Your children will be fine in the same school.
Getting them ready and dropped to two different locations 5 days a week will not actually help you.

Have you done anything this weekend to practice being outside in the world with both of them?

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 07/11/2026 19:58

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:48

@SharpNavy , that was me as I clearly say in the opening post, so perhaps I am not the only ‘dim’ one.

As I explained in that thread, reins are a no go because she would refuse to walk (and I am trying to stop her wanting to be carried everywhere) and it is a very narrow pavement. Having her sat down wailing in the middle of a narrow pavement as the other shoots ahead and people are forced onto a road with big SUVs reversing is pretty stupid.

Well, maybe you will find that tour DD’s teacher will be able to manage her behaviour more effectively? DS certainly did things for his childminder he would never do at home because he was copying older kids (in a good way).

MindBlip · 07/11/2026 20:00

I almost didn't understand your AIBU to be honest. If you want to send them to different schools, then just do it. Lots of families do, either because a different school seems like it will suit a child of a different temperament better, or because there's been a house move between siblings starting, or because of how places pan out in a bulge year, say. I'm surprised by the strong opinion on the thread, but if you think different schools are the way forward, I wouldn't give what people here think a second thought. I daresay things will work out OK either way.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:01

@Arbourimage you make it sound like we’re the protagonists of Room. We aren’t sitting in one bedsit or anything 😂 But they haven’t walked on streets / roads much, I believe is what I explained on the other thread.

OP posts:
BenjyGreyRabbit · 07/11/2026 20:02

I think copying an older sibling is very typical for young children. Your DD will probably grow out of that quite soon. (Though it will probably be replaced with another, equally annoying habit. . . 'Twas ever thus.)

If I'm not mistaken, you have posted quite often about your DC in recent months? I wonder whether you had much experience with children before having your own. That isn't a criticism by any means, but it can sometimes seem that minor issues seem insurmountable if one doesn't have the long view of having seen other children go through the same phases and come out the other side.

IMO having siblings attending different schools can certainly work. But I don't know whether it would be a solution to some of the concerns you mention. If you're not really happy with the school your son currently attends, maybe you could move him to the same school you're thinking of for your DD?

Colourfulfeathers · 07/11/2026 20:02

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:28

It is a very small school and there’s a lot of crossover between classes.

I agree that in a larger school it wouldn’t make a difference but when you only have around sixty children in the whole school it’s a bit different in terms of dynamics.

If you think you can deal with different schools runs and it will solve the problem then go for it. I was going to say she will grow up if it but if it is a small school maybe better to have them separate.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:03

And FWIW, this weekend we have done

Ballet class (DD) breakfast in a cafe (DS)
Church (special kids one on a Saturday.)
Vaccination at a pharmacy for DD
Soft play

We don’t sit watching YouTube, I promise.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:16

@BenjyGreyRabbit it’s probably true. It’s just that this particular phase has lasted so long it’s hard not to see it as just how things are for the foreseeable.

OP posts:
Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 20:20

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:01

@Arbourimage you make it sound like we’re the protagonists of Room. We aren’t sitting in one bedsit or anything 😂 But they haven’t walked on streets / roads much, I believe is what I explained on the other thread.

But you aren’t exposing them to normal life, and from your previous post you said you basically only bring them soft play and child centred places. It means your children have no practice being parented outside of the house, for your oldest to be 6 and basically have little experience walking on a pavement with you is quite strange

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:31

@Arbourimage what I said is that I don’t walk around the streets with them. At no point did I state I only took them to soft play; it was at that point I started to suspect you were being purposefully provocative. They have been to soft play today, because the fog has been very strong where we are and I have a cold and tbh wanted to sit down somewhere, but it is hardly the pinnacle of what we do Hmm

If we could move on from my parenting failures in not walking the streets with them then that might be best Smile

OP posts:
NotSureICanDoIt · 07/11/2026 20:34

Why can’t you just hold their hands on the school run? To stop them running away. Am I missing something?

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:34

A whole thread? Smile

OP posts:
junebirthdaygirl · 07/11/2026 20:36

I am a teacher. I have seen kids fight cat and dog as they get out of the car in the morning only to spend the day in school like two angels and then proceed to fight over who sat where in the car at collection time..that's siblings at times. I had a few sisters. We would fight at home over games, toys, jobs etc but not once did we ever fight in school. We knew our place. Unless either of your dc have severe difficulties the teachers will handle it but more than likely it won't even be an issue as they will sense it's not on.

Velumental · 07/11/2026 20:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:40

In all seriousness, I genuinely don’t think it’s remotely helpful for anybody to reiterate the thread from yesterday. I have said that my three year old has hit a particularly mulish sort of stage, and while school runs haven’t always been brilliant it is only in this last week they have felt uncontrollable. My plan after threatening them with this on Thursday is to leave DD in the car on Monday. This isn’t the cruel act some think it is and have occasionally done so in the past when it’s been particularly bad weather. She likes coming to get ds so will hopefully know going forwards that this is a privilege and one that will be withdrawn if she runs ahead or refuses to walk.

As for never walking the streets with the children Hmm this is not quite what I said; what I said was that it isn’t something we have done a lot of. We live on a very narrow country road where cars (and some heavy farm machinery too) go at speed; there are no pavements and no street lamps. Even when visibility is excellent it isn’t a good walking road and because it doesn’t really lead anywhere, to get anywhere you have to drive. And obviously most of the places I drive to with my children are child friendly places. So do we go to farms, preschool, cafes, the woods, national trust places, swimming, yes. Do I get them in the car and drive to a suburban street with the aim of walking around this street, no. I don’t think many people would do this!

OP posts:
Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 20:42

This is bananas.

You've hit a tricky spot with a 3yo.

Apply got the same school and see how it works out fine.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:46

Well, it’s a little more than that isn’t it, @Pobblewob ? She has indeed hit a very tricky spot, but I’ve also disclosed they’ve never been great together and while I do love them very much I can also admit under the cloak of anonymity that had I known life would be this darn difficult I wouldn’t have had her, lovely as she is.

Most of the time, I am conscious of falling them both.

OP posts:
Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 20:49

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:46

Well, it’s a little more than that isn’t it, @Pobblewob ? She has indeed hit a very tricky spot, but I’ve also disclosed they’ve never been great together and while I do love them very much I can also admit under the cloak of anonymity that had I known life would be this darn difficult I wouldn’t have had her, lovely as she is.

Most of the time, I am conscious of falling them both.

Quite honestly, that's a you problem.

Either there's additional needs which you need to learn to parent. Or they're kids that need boundaries, consistency and consequences.

2 kids is hard, but not this hard. Why are you finding it so hard?

Caterina99 · 07/11/2026 20:49

Mine go to a small rural school. Granted we’ve been fortunate that they’ve never been in the same class, as they’re 2 years apart, but they see each other in the playground and at lunch etc.

They can fight like cat and dog at home sometimes. They eat breakfast in shifts because I got so fed up with the arguing. So DD eats first and DS gets dressed and then they swap. They wind each other up in the car all the time.

Theres never been a single issue with them fighting or anything at school. I don’t think they interact that much as they have their own friends. Lots of other siblings in the school and the parents all said they were worried about their kids being in the same class and they’re all totally fine.

Also your DD is 3! A lot can change in a very short time. Surely it would be a logistical nightmare to have to deal with 2 school runs?

RancidRuby · 07/11/2026 20:50

Why are you punishing the 3 year old when she’s less likely to understand why she’s being punished and therefore adapt her behaviour? You should be focusing on your 6 year not doing as he’s told, he’s old enough to be reasoned with and it’s him running off that’s the issue if you look at this whole situation from a safety and behaviour point of view. The 3 year old acting like a completely normal 3 year old having tantrums and refusing to walk isn’t the real problem here, but it seems like you’re hell bent on blaming her for everything.

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 20:51

So if you do send them to different schools, how will this work logistically? Will one always have to go to after school club? Will this not cause even more chaos if you are having to drag one child to another school for pick up or drop off? As I imagine this will add to stress levels. The school run is often what many people dread so trying to get two kids in two different places on time sounds like it would be hard work. Then if you say your DD is particularly difficult is this going to be any easier.
It sounds like you struggle to manage her behaviour now. What if you decide to drop her first and she refuses to get out the car because she knows her brother goes to a different school?
Or you go to drop your son off and she then refuses to leave that school (you currently say she throws a tantrum and won't move).
Yes she might mature but will this not be extra confusing for her as to why she goes to a different school to her brother.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 20:58

Depends doesn’t it @Moonnstarz ? I’d obviously prefer to avoid this but it is possible - perhaps not ideal, but possible. But others have helped reassure me on this front as I think is evident from the thread.

What if you decide to drop her first and she refuses to get out the car because she knows her brother goes to a different school well what if she does? Confused What if she has a tantrum now because he’s at one school and she’s at preschool? What if she does that tomorrow? I mean, I know it sounds like I’m being awkward - I’m just not sure planning things based around ‘what if DD has a tantrum’ is a particularly sensible course of action!

@RancidRuby it isn’t so much about punishment as management. But as I’ve said. I don’t think anything is to be gained by reiterating an entirely different thread here.

Thanks @Caterina99 , that’s very reassuring Flowers

I am probably just a bit shit @Pobblewob Wink I do find it very hard. I don’t particularly like how they behave together (but are mostly lovely children alone) I don’t like the shrieks and the yells that come mere seconds after I’ve left a room, I don’t like the way DD gets whipped into a frenzy over nothing or the way DS is sidelined. It is as I’ve said mostly a feeling that I’m failing them both. That’s a very uncomfortable feeling. But it is done now. I can be honest about the fact I would have made a difference decision had I known then what I know now whilst also trying to do the best I can going forward.

OP posts:
MissingMeadow · 07/11/2026 20:59

I feel like you are building problems up in your mind to be more serious than what they actually are.

She is 3. Tantrums and awkward annoying behaviour is normal. She will change a lot by the time she's starting school.

Single parenting is tough, don't feel judged by people. Ignore them. Your kids love you and need you. Stop stressing about insignificant stuff.

Toddlergirly · 07/11/2026 20:59

It’s normal for 3 year olds to copy, tantrum and test their mum’s patience! Your dd sounds normal.

Pobblewob · 07/11/2026 21:01

Yep everything about this sounds normal apart from the OP reaction.

What order are you in the birth order of your siblings?

I think you should explore your feelings with a therapist.