Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I really don’t want my kids at the same school

165 replies

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:12

This isn’t very easy to write about and I’m sure I’m going to invite a certain amount of criticism but I would genuinely appreciate advice and support here.

Ever since my youngest has been of an age to have her own mind (so maybe 18 months ish?) I’ve found my children really difficult together. I had a thread yesterday about chaotic pickups which makes my children sound utterly uncontrollable, but the thing is they really aren’t like this when separate. They are pretty nice apart but together not so much.

I am really, really worried about my youngest starting school next year because at the moment she copies everything her older brother does. This morning, for example, he spilled a drink on his top on the way out so I told him to take it off in the car and I’d run in the house and get him a fresh one. Came back outside and DD is sitting in the car with her top off. It is literally everything. I can just imagine if he does something silly at school she’ll copy him.

I honestly wouldn’t have had two if I’d known it would be like this but obviously it is too late to do anything about that now. However, I can at least manage the situation by keeping them separate as much as possible.

It is logistically difficult but not impossible.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:13

sprigatito · 07/11/2026 19:09

Stressful, but normal for a younger sibling to copy an older one (and they always seem to copy the most undesirable behaviour). It’s a phase and it won’t last forever! It will probably improve once she’s started school and made some new friends, she’ll be carving out her own identity and her brother won’t be as central to her, whether they’re at the same school or not.

This is a kind and reassuring message. Thank you. I’m not having a great time lately and these nice measured posts really help.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:14

she is very well behaved at nursery and is mostly fine with just me; has moments but for the most part is fine.

older one is lovely alone. It is together we get the wild mania.

OP posts:
Pallisers · 07/11/2026 19:16

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:23

They will sometimes be in the same class but in all honesty it is mostly behaviour in the playground I’m concerned about.

Well if so you'll have the school and teachers who will be responding too. In some ways them being together might get the issue sorted.

SylvanMoon · 07/11/2026 19:17

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:03

And yes. The top is not important. But if for example DS does something stupid in the playground like throw a toy through the railing, kick a ball out of bounds, push someone, she’ll do it too. Because she does everything he does, no matter how stupid as the top thing shows.

As you really have no concrete evidence on which to base you assumptions as to how your DD is going to behave were she in the same school as her brother, merely your current observations as to how she is behaving now, I wouldn't advise you to act on your feelings about how it's going to turn out, especially since logistically it will be a nightmare for you to arrange two drop-offs and pick-ups for presumably the same time. What I would advise you to do is to place your DD next year in the same school where your DS is happily situated. Then step back and observe how it unfolds. As PP have said, their sibling dynamics may drastically change in that environment. If it doesn't, and the school indicates that there is an issue, then consider moving her to another school. But to take such a drastic decision before you've any evidence that it's going to be a disaster is making a cross for your own back that you may not even have ever had to do.

Arran2024 · 07/11/2026 19:17

My children both attended the same infant school but different junior schools, as I realised that my younger daughter would not be a good fit for the follow-on junior school (it was very old fashioned, 90 minutes homework per evening). I sent her to a nearby community school with a more relaxed approach. She had sen and it was definitely the right move. Both schools had different start and finish times so it was completely doable. But I did it for the school, not to solve a sibling issue.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:19

Thanks @SylvanMoon . It probably is stupid. I think it’s just because I remember so conscientiously researching schools for ds and going with the current one because I genuinely felt it was the best choice for him. I don’t now have that same confidence; not saying that’s necessarily the schools fault but it just feels a very different sort of experience.

OP posts:
edwinbear · 07/11/2026 19:19

I’ve just read your other thread OP and see your DD is 3. 3 year olds are a fucking nightmare. It’s no surprise you’re feeling ground down. At that age, mine was absolutely ready for school, she was at nursery but really ready to ‘move up’ so to speak and I think generally acting up a bit out of boredom. I think there was also a bit of copying DS because she actually hero worshipped him a bit, as a ‘big boy’ and was trying to get his approval. It was a draining phase, but it vastly improved once she started school and her world opened up a bit. Obviously that didn’t help in the moment.

For the school run, could she go on a 3 wheeled scooter? You said the pavement isn’t wide enough for a buggy and it’s also a faff for a relatively short walk, but a second hand scooter that lives in the boot of the car might work? If the pavements are busy with other parents she’ll just have to scoot at a snails pace but it will hopefully distract her a bit.

Brideofclover · 07/11/2026 19:20

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:23

They will sometimes be in the same class but in all honesty it is mostly behaviour in the playground I’m concerned about.

It will be the job of the teachers to iron out any issues like this - they’ve seen it all before and an important part of a child’s learning is social skills which really kick in once they’re at school - she will learn. I think you are overthinking this and need to try and relax a bit.

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 19:21

So I would speak to school..you say they will have witnessed DD acting up on the playground. Maybe as someone else suggests ask for DS to be dismissed last so the playground is cleared. You say it's a small school so not too sure how there can be so many cars and overcrowding on pavements, but if you are last to leave then you won't have so many people around.
Staff could also chat to your son about being safe when leaving school, and this could even be a whole class chat for PSHE about staying safe and why do we hold a grown ups hand along with how to cross a road.
I think you need to decide what the consequences are for the behaviour and stick to it...as well as ignoring silly behaviour as currently that gets a reaction. If DD strops on the playground or runs off her options are reins or pushchair. Same with DS, if he really can't listen and runs off with his sister then he needs to also be told he will need reins. Then enforce it.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:23

Thanks so much @edwinbear . I think it’s really got me down as honestly she was / is so lovely, hit a bit of a challenging stage circa 2.5-2 3/4 (nothing too terrible really and she can be a bit whingey) but now she’s hit this really defiant stage. I am addressing it but with the best will in the world it is not easy!

I could consider a scooter but it’s the pavement size that’s a real problem. Even on days where everyone is just walking nicely it can be difficult. I do also think she gets very tired and it comes out in difficult behaviour.

OP posts:
BugJuice · 07/11/2026 19:24

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 18:42

There aren’t really many bigger options @Invisablepanic , and I don’t want to move ds as he’s settled with regard to friendships. It would be a shame. I’m just feeling very self conscious about a few incidents but maybe I’m being silly.

The one thing I always tell myself is that people are far too caught up with dealing with their own kids/lives etc that they don’t actually notice the incidents that stick in our minds (because we’re the ones dealing with them!), and if other people do notice, they tend to just feel solidarity.
Unless they’re some of the MNers on this thread, in which case they judge 😉. But you can confidently ignore them.

Gengha · 07/11/2026 19:24

WilmaaFlintstone · 07/11/2026 18:17

This is silly OP.

What you describe is completely normal for young siblings.

It'll pass as she grows out of it but you cannot avoid it, and nor should you try.

Not sure where it would end to be honest.

This.

my youngest copied everything his big brother did, even when big brother had been told off for it. It’s perfectly normal.

bridgetreilly · 07/11/2026 19:27

I think that it is extremely unlikely that the copying would continue at school. And frankly, I think the teachers are going to be more effective at stamping out the poor behaviour than you have been,

BillieWiper · 07/11/2026 19:30

They won't hang out together at a hool though?

Surely the older one would think it kinda uncool to have the little sibling following them round the playground. The new ones will be encouraged to make friends with eachother.

They'll have their own friendship groups and obviously won't have class together.

But if it's no more effort logistically in any shape or form and both schools are equally good then you don't have to send the little one to the same school. It's not essential. But I just can't see it won't be more hassle.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:31

@BugJuice as I’ve been typing I have thought there have been a couple of other meltdowns or poor behaviour from other kids. I’m probably hyper aware when it’s mine. Not helped by the fact my DD has had two massive tantrums at school events.

OP posts:
RancidRuby · 07/11/2026 19:32

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:10

@RancidRuby i suppose the point is that I don’t want them to be dealing with it; I’d rather they were just the nice children that they are separately. They really do behave together in ways they wouldn’t dream of behaving apart.

You’re catastrophising. You don’t know they’ll behave badly together at school, but even if they do it’s part of the teachers job to deal with behaviour. Let them do their job and you continue do yours by clearly and consistently explaining boundaries to them, putting consequences into place if necessary. I think you’re more worried about peoples perceptions of them, and by extension you, than you are about the actual bad behaviour (which all sounds relatively normal on the whole).

edwinbear · 07/11/2026 19:32

Understood re the scooter. Do you think her ‘big girl’ job could be to carry her brothers book bag safely back to the car? Yes I know he should be carrying his own etc, but to get through this phase, if she has a special job, that makes her feel a bit more grown up, she might react to that?

Flailingaroundatlife · 07/11/2026 19:33

Boreded · 07/11/2026 18:16

They won’t be in the same class 🤷‍♀️

How will you do school runs at different schools, what about appointments like the dentist etc, you’re just making hard work for yourself.

Also she will grow out of the phase of needing to copy him

This. My kids are at a different schools/preschool at the minute. Only 10 mins apart- on the motorway, so not ideal. So 10m to school 1, 10m to school 2, 10m home, but with all the getting out, waiting for the gate to open, saying goodbye etc, it's easily 45m. Also a bit of a faff.

Like lots of PPs have said, surely they'll be in different classes. I doubt they'll see each other. Even nursery kids wouldn't usually have break time with reception.

FoundAUserNameDownTheSofa · 07/11/2026 19:40

My DC are one school year apart and hate each other, wind each other up, one won’t touch something the other has touched etc. I don’t pretend they grow out of it because they’re teenagers now, although they have occasionally had actual conversations recently.

HOWEVER mine were sometimes in the same learning groups at school, and during key worker school they were in the same class, and that was NOT a problem at all, despite the fact they hate each other they are quite different in the classroom.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:43

It’s true @RancidRuby . It is very hard feeling judged. You and them. You don’t want people thinking they are bad children.

Thanks @edwinbear , I’m going to leave her in the car Monday (assuming Ds is in, he has a bad cold) and have told her that I’ll try her again Tuesday. I’m hoping this calms her down. On Thursday they both went charging off at top speed - ds had been in after school club so the pavement was clear, completely ignoring me, laughing their heads off. Then yesterday she refused to walk at all!

OP posts:
edwinbear · 07/11/2026 19:44

Also just leaving this here for you OP - Michael McIntyre trying to do the most basic task of leaving the house with a 6y old and 3y old 😊. Hopefully some solidarity at least.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eC6eHraeMes

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eC6eHraeMes

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:44

@Flailingaroundatlife there is no nursery class, she’ll be going into reception. They will be in the same class this year but then when ds goes into y3 they will be apart.

OP posts:
Burgundyleaf · 07/11/2026 19:45

Sorry I’ve only skim read the thread but I think you need to look at the bigger picture, this is probably a phase and it’s great your kids get along so well (even if it’s craziness when together) I have two boys two years apart who are well behaved alone but crazy together, they went to the same school and now both teenagers are still incredibly close and it’s so lovely to see them together. They never had problems in school, they weren’t in the same class but able to play together at playtimes and they each developed their own group of friends enough it wasn’t a problem. Also don’t underestimate how much easier it is having them in the same school.

coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:46

Thanks @edwinbear have really appreciated your kind and wise input here - really needed it tonight! I think the problem is I’m not totally thrilled with the school generally, the pickups have been horrific this week and together it’s made me feel very fretful about putting it down as my ‘first choice’.

OP posts:
coughing26 · 07/11/2026 19:46

That’s really nice @Burgundyleaf Flowers

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread