Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it odd how quite a few posters here overlook things about Muslim Gulf states (UAE, Oman, Bahrain etc) which are usually criticised on threads about Islam?

155 replies

Jane3212 · 02/11/2026 00:37

I know MN's not a hive mind but I do think it's odd how you get plenty of posts on here rightly criticising aspects of Islam like attitudes to women or democracy, but then you also get posts lavishly praising Gulf states and ignoring or even denying the disadvantages Islam causes for women there.

I suspect part of it could be that some are only concerned if Islam affects non-Muslim women. Eg. On the recent thread about Oman, there were lots of posts saying how safe it is for women to walk around at night there (I always find this odd as women do risk assault here but most assault is by someone known, not a random stranger at night or otherwise) and downplaying the inequalities faced especially by Omani women behind closed doors (marital rape is legal and custody laws heavily favour men). You hear similar about Dubai often.

Or posts worrying about theocracy and Islam here yet threads on Dubai & similar others praise Muslim theocracies where only male royals rule and democracy is unthinkable. Yes, Dubai & others have a veneer of tolerance and are certainly much freer than many other Muslim countries but that freedom is still within the boundaries of religious laws and falls far more heavily on non-expat Muslim women.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 19:57

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 18:48

I didn’t mention Saudi Arabia.

I used the UAE to illustrate how it might be possible to both disagree and agree with a person / organisation / country on different issues. I certainly haven’t suggested we let another country lecture us. I might equally have said that it’s possible for me to appreciate my friend’s sense of humour, but not like her dress sense, accept her career advice, but not her parenting advice etc. The point is that you don’t have to be aligned on everything.

Someone else pointed it out. I'm an idiot and just didn't read properlym I knew Saudi Arabia had also criticised the UK for not banning the Muslim Brotherhood and my brain filled in the blanks.
The UAE also sponsor dodgy groups. Specifically the Houthis as part of their weird rivalry with Saudi Arabia. But then again America and even the UK have sponsored awful people too in the past so maybe it's hypocritical to criticise. But then that would also make them hypocritical for handwriting about extremists they don't like.
I don't like the Muslim Brotherhood, they are right on the cusp of coming under freedom of speech/freedom of association versus should be banned. I'm not a free speech absolutist but I do think classing groups as terrorist entities is a really big step and should be done as sparingly as possible. It should also be the decision of the government - while foreign students are great if you start letting foreign governments decide who you should/shouldn't ban then where does it end? It's quite a fundamental part of sovereignty. The UAE being very much not a democracy and having a different set of values obviously have a much tighter line on what is and isn't allowed. It's inherent to how they see the role of government. I don't think you can separate that out from the other issues that we might see as human rights abuses/lack of freedom for certain groups because they are based on the same set of beliefs. Which are different to ours but also more to do with how you govern than religion.

CandidLurker · 04/11/2026 20:03

countribution · 04/11/2026 18:04

No countries have banned burkinis.

I looked into this as I think there was an attempt to ban on them on a beach in France some years ago. Apparently they are banned in public swimming pools in France

countribution · 05/11/2026 00:18

CandidLurker · 04/11/2026 20:03

I looked into this as I think there was an attempt to ban on them on a beach in France some years ago. Apparently they are banned in public swimming pools in France

Yes but that doesn't make the statement correct that many Western countries have banned them.

CandidLurker · 05/11/2026 08:22

countribution · 05/11/2026 00:18

Yes but that doesn't make the statement correct that many Western countries have banned them.

But neither is it true to say that no countries have

countribution · 05/11/2026 08:39

CandidLurker · 05/11/2026 08:22

But neither is it true to say that no countries have

There are no countries which have a legal blanket ban in all aspects of life. That is extreme. There are some swimming pools which have banned them as they also do in parts of Dubai and it is based there on a health and safety issue. The issues are wearing clothes that are not suitable in swimming pools from a cleanliness aspect as well as the safety issues involved. I've sat in on meetings about this where issues have arisen in a club. The reasons are far from prejudice or women's rights being violated.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread