Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it odd how quite a few posters here overlook things about Muslim Gulf states (UAE, Oman, Bahrain etc) which are usually criticised on threads about Islam?

155 replies

Jane3212 · 02/11/2026 00:37

I know MN's not a hive mind but I do think it's odd how you get plenty of posts on here rightly criticising aspects of Islam like attitudes to women or democracy, but then you also get posts lavishly praising Gulf states and ignoring or even denying the disadvantages Islam causes for women there.

I suspect part of it could be that some are only concerned if Islam affects non-Muslim women. Eg. On the recent thread about Oman, there were lots of posts saying how safe it is for women to walk around at night there (I always find this odd as women do risk assault here but most assault is by someone known, not a random stranger at night or otherwise) and downplaying the inequalities faced especially by Omani women behind closed doors (marital rape is legal and custody laws heavily favour men). You hear similar about Dubai often.

Or posts worrying about theocracy and Islam here yet threads on Dubai & similar others praise Muslim theocracies where only male royals rule and democracy is unthinkable. Yes, Dubai & others have a veneer of tolerance and are certainly much freer than many other Muslim countries but that freedom is still within the boundaries of religious laws and falls far more heavily on non-expat Muslim women.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ginkhao · 04/11/2026 10:11

MrsShawnHatosy · 04/11/2026 10:00

I’m absolutely not a “dirty little anti semite” as you so charmingly put it. And yes I do know what Orthodox Judaism is. I just don’t think any religion is, or should be, exempt from criticism in respect of treatment of women.

Yes but you focused in on one. Why? Out of all the possible religions, you chose one stream of one tiny religion. Does it bother you Jews don't get enough flack? And what do you know about how orthodox Judaism treats women?

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:17

think the teachings of Islam are often used to justify child marriage. It’s rare that a girl once married is able to continue her education

The legal age of marriage in Gulf states is 18 apart from Bahrain and Qatar where it is 16. However there is a process in the legal system where if anyone younger than this wants to get married (male or female) they can go to court and ask a judge to authorise it. This would only be granted in exceptional circumstances if it was in the interests of the pair to be married.

Is a girl able to continue her education once married? Yes. If a court granted permission for the pair to be married, continuing their education would probably be part of the deal. Girls in further education who are married? Being married doesn’t stop them being in full time further education either.

Child marriage? In the Gulf you are tracked from the day you are born on a centralised data bank in each country. Every stage of your life is documented as is every administrative process you go through. Marriages have to be certified and reported by the couple as well as the person who performs the marriage. It is the law. A lot of people would have to agree to break the law in order to carry out a forced child marriage. And if in the highly unlikely event it did happen - the girls father and the groom would be jailed for up to 15 years. This is all to do with child protection.

Regarding children being kept out of school. There is a tracking system all connected to the data base I mentioned above and I believe that the latest figures published a year or so ago showed that 24 families had been fined or imprisoned that particular year for depriving a child of an education. A far cry from the exaggerated comments further up the page regarding girls being deprived of an education in Islam.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:20

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:29

I believe they kick you out of the country if you commit a crime.

Isn’t that what people are asking to happen to foreign criminals in the UK?

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:22

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 10:11

Yes but you focused in on one. Why? Out of all the possible religions, you chose one stream of one tiny religion. Does it bother you Jews don't get enough flack? And what do you know about how orthodox Judaism treats women?

Probably a whole lot more in real terms than you think you know about women in Islam.

countribution · 04/11/2026 12:11

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:20

Isn’t that what people are asking to happen to foreign criminals in the UK?

Yeah but here they want to stay !

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 12:23

I haven’t noticed any of this. Anyway, for what it’s worth, I think it’s possible to criticise someone / something on one account and praise it in another. For example, you might criticise a country’s record on women’s rights, but praise its uncompromising stance on extremism or terrorism. The UAE, for example, does not tolerate some of the religious extremists who seem to run amok in Britain, with the result that it has now withdrawn funding for its own students to study at British universities. You’d think that might be a wake up call for our government. You’d think they might ask for a diplomatic chat and implement policies to reassure the UAE (given how lucrative their students are) but no. They have done nothing.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 13:29

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:22

Probably a whole lot more in real terms than you think you know about women in Islam.

Edited

Why don't you enlighten us? What don't you llke about the way women are treated in orhtodox judaism? Let's start with modern orthodox, the majority of orthordox Jews. What bothers you exactly?

JHound · 04/11/2026 13:31

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:17

think the teachings of Islam are often used to justify child marriage. It’s rare that a girl once married is able to continue her education

The legal age of marriage in Gulf states is 18 apart from Bahrain and Qatar where it is 16. However there is a process in the legal system where if anyone younger than this wants to get married (male or female) they can go to court and ask a judge to authorise it. This would only be granted in exceptional circumstances if it was in the interests of the pair to be married.

Is a girl able to continue her education once married? Yes. If a court granted permission for the pair to be married, continuing their education would probably be part of the deal. Girls in further education who are married? Being married doesn’t stop them being in full time further education either.

Child marriage? In the Gulf you are tracked from the day you are born on a centralised data bank in each country. Every stage of your life is documented as is every administrative process you go through. Marriages have to be certified and reported by the couple as well as the person who performs the marriage. It is the law. A lot of people would have to agree to break the law in order to carry out a forced child marriage. And if in the highly unlikely event it did happen - the girls father and the groom would be jailed for up to 15 years. This is all to do with child protection.

Regarding children being kept out of school. There is a tracking system all connected to the data base I mentioned above and I believe that the latest figures published a year or so ago showed that 24 families had been fined or imprisoned that particular year for depriving a child of an education. A far cry from the exaggerated comments further up the page regarding girls being deprived of an education in Islam.

Edited

Interesting that the Gulf states are ahead of the USA in this regard by mandating minimum ages for marriage.

(Also you are wasting your breath. You are talking to people who referred to it being the Islamic norm girls / women to be denied education.)

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 14:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 14:17

JHound · 04/11/2026 13:31

Interesting that the Gulf states are ahead of the USA in this regard by mandating minimum ages for marriage.

(Also you are wasting your breath. You are talking to people who referred to it being the Islamic norm girls / women to be denied education.)

Edited

I honestly don’t do it to enlighten those posters. I do it to counter their nonsense with reality and to make it very clear to others who and what those posters are.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 14:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

😂
As I thought, you don't know what you're talking about.

Because they are not remotely similar and that is exactly why it is totally fine to question Islam and no one is starting posts about orthodox Jewish women.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 14:27

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 11:17

think the teachings of Islam are often used to justify child marriage. It’s rare that a girl once married is able to continue her education

The legal age of marriage in Gulf states is 18 apart from Bahrain and Qatar where it is 16. However there is a process in the legal system where if anyone younger than this wants to get married (male or female) they can go to court and ask a judge to authorise it. This would only be granted in exceptional circumstances if it was in the interests of the pair to be married.

Is a girl able to continue her education once married? Yes. If a court granted permission for the pair to be married, continuing their education would probably be part of the deal. Girls in further education who are married? Being married doesn’t stop them being in full time further education either.

Child marriage? In the Gulf you are tracked from the day you are born on a centralised data bank in each country. Every stage of your life is documented as is every administrative process you go through. Marriages have to be certified and reported by the couple as well as the person who performs the marriage. It is the law. A lot of people would have to agree to break the law in order to carry out a forced child marriage. And if in the highly unlikely event it did happen - the girls father and the groom would be jailed for up to 15 years. This is all to do with child protection.

Regarding children being kept out of school. There is a tracking system all connected to the data base I mentioned above and I believe that the latest figures published a year or so ago showed that 24 families had been fined or imprisoned that particular year for depriving a child of an education. A far cry from the exaggerated comments further up the page regarding girls being deprived of an education in Islam.

Edited

And yet child marriage remains a serious problem in the Muslim world. The gulf states have their own issues with women's rights, especially regarding personal status and freedom. However, more than 30% of women aged 20-24 in Yemen and Sudan were married before 18, 28% in Iraq, 17% in Iran, 16% in Egypt, 14% in Morocco, 13% in Syria. And I won't mention Afghanistan as that's apparently forbidden and you want to forget what's being done there in the name of Islam.
It's a shit show. Yeah, some US states are weird that they still allow it but it's not the massive problem it is in many Muslim countries with minors being maried off (in case they spoil the honour of their families?)

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 14:36

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 12:23

I haven’t noticed any of this. Anyway, for what it’s worth, I think it’s possible to criticise someone / something on one account and praise it in another. For example, you might criticise a country’s record on women’s rights, but praise its uncompromising stance on extremism or terrorism. The UAE, for example, does not tolerate some of the religious extremists who seem to run amok in Britain, with the result that it has now withdrawn funding for its own students to study at British universities. You’d think that might be a wake up call for our government. You’d think they might ask for a diplomatic chat and implement policies to reassure the UAE (given how lucrative their students are) but no. They have done nothing.

The deadliest terrorist attacks this century (and possibly ever) were carried out by men who grew up in, were radicalised in and organised themselves within Saudi Arabia. And who were following a fundamentalist version of Islam that originated in that country and was supported by the ruling authorities because it helped cement their own authority. (9/11 by the way).

I don't have a problem with the UK looking at extremism within it's own borders. We should be thinking about those regardless. But Saudi Arabia is in no place to make any comments quite frankly. And their issue with "radicalosation" applies just as much to democratic groups as to rival theologies/extremist theologies. Because usually theocracies don't like the competition. It doesn't mean they somehow have more of a handle on the situation because of their hardline positions. It would be like China lecturing the rest of the world on its wet markets/laboratory safety measures and saying China would never be so lax. I like China but I wouldn't take such expert criticism to heart. Likewise Saudi Arabia and there fears of British universities.

howaboutapuffin · 04/11/2026 14:58

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 14:36

The deadliest terrorist attacks this century (and possibly ever) were carried out by men who grew up in, were radicalised in and organised themselves within Saudi Arabia. And who were following a fundamentalist version of Islam that originated in that country and was supported by the ruling authorities because it helped cement their own authority. (9/11 by the way).

I don't have a problem with the UK looking at extremism within it's own borders. We should be thinking about those regardless. But Saudi Arabia is in no place to make any comments quite frankly. And their issue with "radicalosation" applies just as much to democratic groups as to rival theologies/extremist theologies. Because usually theocracies don't like the competition. It doesn't mean they somehow have more of a handle on the situation because of their hardline positions. It would be like China lecturing the rest of the world on its wet markets/laboratory safety measures and saying China would never be so lax. I like China but I wouldn't take such expert criticism to heart. Likewise Saudi Arabia and there fears of British universities.

The UAE is a totally different country to Saudi Arabia.

nomas · 04/11/2026 15:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I said Palestinians.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 15:37

nomas · 04/11/2026 15:13

I said Palestinians.

I didnt in my post, only you did. I only referenced Hamas since that is an Islamic movement. So you reply to my post about an Islamic movement carrying out horrific atrocities by saying what its got to do with Islam, it was Palestinians. Bizarre.

Portakalkedi · 04/11/2026 15:40

Isittimeformynapyet · 02/11/2026 02:01

I get the feeling that a certain type of woman is so impressed with the showy, "glamorous" insta/influencer lifestyle and money that they are willing and eager to overlook the small matter of the appalling women's/human rights records of the UAE, especially Du-bloody-bai.

I think the type of woman you describe is not overly burdened with intelligence and knowledge of human/women's rights etc.

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 15:41

So to reiterate. Hamas is an Islamic movement and it's insane to claim otherwise .
Ok mumsnet???

TheRoyalEyeroll · 04/11/2026 15:50

ginkhao · 04/11/2026 14:20

😂
As I thought, you don't know what you're talking about.

Because they are not remotely similar and that is exactly why it is totally fine to question Islam and no one is starting posts about orthodox Jewish women.

I’m not sure what you mean by ‘I don’t know what I’m talking about’ as I haven’t mentioned Judaism apart from saying a previous poster probably knows more about Judaism than you do about Islam.

And you’re correct. I don’t know anything about it apart from a couple of very basic things. And even if I did know anything about Judaism, I wouldn’t reply to your attempts to draw people into a twisted discussion because, unlike you, I will never contribute towards anything that could cause racial or religious hatred between people.

I hope this reply to you is clearer than my
last one.

Oh, and I don’t know where you’re from, but if you’re genuinely concerned about girls and young women, perhaps your time would be better spent championing their cause in your own country. I’m pretty sure there would be plenty for you to do there. Not that I’m going to quote figures from a selection of western countries regarding the plight of young girls and women in so many of them. See you, see you, wouldn’t want to be you.

Obeseandashamed · 04/11/2026 16:03

Holidayed in the Maldives and saw lots of Far Eastern (Chinese etc) women dressed in full body coverings by the pool as they worry about sun exposure yet burkinis are banned in a lot of western countries! There are some legitimate concerns to be had but a lot of things are just dressed up racism.

countribution · 04/11/2026 18:04

Obeseandashamed · 04/11/2026 16:03

Holidayed in the Maldives and saw lots of Far Eastern (Chinese etc) women dressed in full body coverings by the pool as they worry about sun exposure yet burkinis are banned in a lot of western countries! There are some legitimate concerns to be had but a lot of things are just dressed up racism.

Edited

No countries have banned burkinis.

Genevieva · 04/11/2026 18:48

Persephonia1966 · 04/11/2026 14:36

The deadliest terrorist attacks this century (and possibly ever) were carried out by men who grew up in, were radicalised in and organised themselves within Saudi Arabia. And who were following a fundamentalist version of Islam that originated in that country and was supported by the ruling authorities because it helped cement their own authority. (9/11 by the way).

I don't have a problem with the UK looking at extremism within it's own borders. We should be thinking about those regardless. But Saudi Arabia is in no place to make any comments quite frankly. And their issue with "radicalosation" applies just as much to democratic groups as to rival theologies/extremist theologies. Because usually theocracies don't like the competition. It doesn't mean they somehow have more of a handle on the situation because of their hardline positions. It would be like China lecturing the rest of the world on its wet markets/laboratory safety measures and saying China would never be so lax. I like China but I wouldn't take such expert criticism to heart. Likewise Saudi Arabia and there fears of British universities.

I didn’t mention Saudi Arabia.

I used the UAE to illustrate how it might be possible to both disagree and agree with a person / organisation / country on different issues. I certainly haven’t suggested we let another country lecture us. I might equally have said that it’s possible for me to appreciate my friend’s sense of humour, but not like her dress sense, accept her career advice, but not her parenting advice etc. The point is that you don’t have to be aligned on everything.

Newsenmum · 04/11/2026 18:50

They are not the same people.

Those who criticise aspects of islam also criticise those states (and very heavily!)

Those who love the UAE are very unlikely to then criticise islam.

AmourPlastique · 04/11/2026 18:52

I do love the UAE