Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it odd how quite a few posters here overlook things about Muslim Gulf states (UAE, Oman, Bahrain etc) which are usually criticised on threads about Islam?

155 replies

Jane3212 · 02/11/2026 00:37

I know MN's not a hive mind but I do think it's odd how you get plenty of posts on here rightly criticising aspects of Islam like attitudes to women or democracy, but then you also get posts lavishly praising Gulf states and ignoring or even denying the disadvantages Islam causes for women there.

I suspect part of it could be that some are only concerned if Islam affects non-Muslim women. Eg. On the recent thread about Oman, there were lots of posts saying how safe it is for women to walk around at night there (I always find this odd as women do risk assault here but most assault is by someone known, not a random stranger at night or otherwise) and downplaying the inequalities faced especially by Omani women behind closed doors (marital rape is legal and custody laws heavily favour men). You hear similar about Dubai often.

Or posts worrying about theocracy and Islam here yet threads on Dubai & similar others praise Muslim theocracies where only male royals rule and democracy is unthinkable. Yes, Dubai & others have a veneer of tolerance and are certainly much freer than many other Muslim countries but that freedom is still within the boundaries of religious laws and falls far more heavily on non-expat Muslim women.

AIBU?

OP posts:
GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 12:14

JHound · 03/11/2026 12:10

I’m a lone woman and feel fine in London.

Likewise.

croisette · 03/11/2026 12:21

GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 12:14

Likewise.

I feel fine too, but I have noticed changes around me over the years and I can understand why in certain bits of town or certain times of night, others don’t.

JHound · 03/11/2026 12:25

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 12:13

I'm curious as to why in a discussion on Dubai this poster is innocently concerned about bringing in a minority of a tiny minority - which compared to other religions really isn't that bad - and not, say, religions with billions of people which treat women far worse. Generally those who obsess about Jews are antisemites in my experience.

She wasn’t inviting a discussion about Orthodox Judaism. She was questioning the overt focus on the orthodox components of one Abrahamic faith and the impact on the others. Just like I questioned why people are fine with habits and shetls but outraged at hijab. And have an issue with muslims shunning pork but not jews and seven day adventists who do similar.

Her post clearly triggered you but it wasn’t anti-semitic if you read it in the context of the thread.

GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 12:27

croisette · 03/11/2026 12:21

I feel fine too, but I have noticed changes around me over the years and I can understand why in certain bits of town or certain times of night, others don’t.

And what are these 'changes' you notice and that other people don't notice?

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 12:42

JHound · 03/11/2026 12:25

She wasn’t inviting a discussion about Orthodox Judaism. She was questioning the overt focus on the orthodox components of one Abrahamic faith and the impact on the others. Just like I questioned why people are fine with habits and shetls but outraged at hijab. And have an issue with muslims shunning pork but not jews and seven day adventists who do similar.

Her post clearly triggered you but it wasn’t anti-semitic if you read it in the context of the thread.

Oh puleez. One abrahamic faith with 2 billion people where women are murdered because of the honour of their family, where there are countries where women are nto allowed to go to school versus about 15 million Jews, of whom only about 2 million are ultraorthodox (because they still don't have the same numbers before they were genocided in a real genocide)
Why not look at how women are treated in Catholicism with 1.5 billion people?
Just leave the Jews alone and stop obsessing over a tiny minority.

PurpleThistle7 · 03/11/2026 12:48

JHound · 03/11/2026 12:25

She wasn’t inviting a discussion about Orthodox Judaism. She was questioning the overt focus on the orthodox components of one Abrahamic faith and the impact on the others. Just like I questioned why people are fine with habits and shetls but outraged at hijab. And have an issue with muslims shunning pork but not jews and seven day adventists who do similar.

Her post clearly triggered you but it wasn’t anti-semitic if you read it in the context of the thread.

Actually I don’t like any gender based oppression. But the Orthodox Jews aren’t writing laws for how women dress and if they can go to school as happens in way too many religious muslim countries. Maybe because there just arent enough of them, maybe because being different is part of the reason they do all the faffing, maybe because… who knows really.

i would be just as likely to attend an orthodox synagogue as I would to go to Dubai. Neither are for me.

I am flabbergasted at how many people would choose to skip democracy and quite curious about it. Is it because whoever we vote for, the result seems much the same and they’re all corrupt anyway? Because you genuinely think dictators have your best interest at heart? I can’t see any reason I’d deliberately allow what feels like my basic right to a voice disappear like that for the sake of a bigger house and more stuff?

Smokeywater · 03/11/2026 12:52

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 11:43

It is done, it's so done. I've been here 50 years, not originally from the UK. Lived the most fortunate life in London and I've been very lucky have gone to Uni in London and work here and to buy property in the late 90s etc. Loved it here. But it's done, and I hate saying it.

What do you mean by done - though I do seem to agree with you a bit - as a 70 year old we have had many bad times but I can't see any way of getting out of this. Ridiculous wokeism skewing decision making, the green energy plans reducing chances of new industry and jobs. Buying everything from China and them making it hard for people to form businesses here. Immigration non stop but no houses. Constant demands for more pay, more benefits, more health care, more pension, more infrastructure but no income to pay for any of it. And a Gov that needs to keep everyone happy.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 03/11/2026 12:55

AmourPlastique · 02/11/2026 17:18

The gulf states aren't perfect. But I actually like going there. I know female family members who live there, work there and are quite happy.

I’ve lived in a Gulf State for almost 50 years and I’m very happy here. I’m married into the culture even though there’s nothing about my appearance that would make people aware of my reason for being here in the first place. I look very much like the almost 70 year old Scottish granny that I am.

Im not actually sure what you’re asking in your thread but I will say that the keyboard warriors who post such inaccurate information about life in these countries/certain laws always used as a (wrong) example regarding women only show themselves up to be the badly informed bigots they are. They obviously have very ugly ulterior motives for their posts but for me the good thing is they’re so obviously transparent it’s rather easy to put their gas at a peep as we say in Scotland.

Smokeywater · 03/11/2026 12:56

Eg. On the recent thread about Oman, there were lots of posts saying how safe it is for women to walk around at night there

It's amazing what a deterrent beheading is.
I felt very safe in China but there they also have draconian punishments.

And these countries do not want tourism discouraged.

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 03/11/2026 12:59

I think we shouldn't judge the morals of others based on a small snap shot of their opinion. There are some things that countries in the middle East are very good at and some things they suck at. I wouldn't want to live there or wouldn't my kids to live there but that doesn't meant that I will lie about how clean and efficient Dubai is, how fantastic their hotels are or that crime (as defined by THEIR laws) is very low. These are mostly facts. They don't undo the bad things but neither do the bad things mean that these facts are not true.

There is good and bad in every country. Some countries have by my values more bad than others but that doesn't mean that nothing positive about them exists or that we need to deny it.

E.g. it's like saying the US doesn't have amazing places of natural beauty because of ICE or because of a government that wanted to live stream an execution.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 03/11/2026 13:17

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 12:42

Oh puleez. One abrahamic faith with 2 billion people where women are murdered because of the honour of their family, where there are countries where women are nto allowed to go to school versus about 15 million Jews, of whom only about 2 million are ultraorthodox (because they still don't have the same numbers before they were genocided in a real genocide)
Why not look at how women are treated in Catholicism with 1.5 billion people?
Just leave the Jews alone and stop obsessing over a tiny minority.

Muslim majority countries where women can’t go to school? Really?

Well, according to UNICEF the only Muslim majority country in the world where women are not permitted to go to school is Afghanistan.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 03/11/2026 13:24

Smokeywater · 03/11/2026 12:56

Eg. On the recent thread about Oman, there were lots of posts saying how safe it is for women to walk around at night there

It's amazing what a deterrent beheading is.
I felt very safe in China but there they also have draconian punishments.

And these countries do not want tourism discouraged.

It is extremely safe.

Of course there is crime and I always think people are silly to say things like - there isn’t any crime when the fact is that where there are people there will always be crime. And what’s even sillier, stupid really, is when people say oh my god, I heard there was a crime committed and I thought there wasn’t any crime here. Idiots.

Oh and we don’t have beheadings here although we do have the death penalty for a few crimes. Rape is one of them. Within the law in Oman every woman has the right to safety - the death penalty for rape is an indication of how seriously rape would be taken.

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 13:27

TheRoyalEyeroll · 03/11/2026 13:17

Muslim majority countries where women can’t go to school? Really?

Well, according to UNICEF the only Muslim majority country in the world where women are not permitted to go to school is Afghanistan.

Ummm, I would say that's quite enough! If you're gonna bring in as some kind of comparison a tiny minority in a minority - where girls most certainly do go to school - then Afghanistan with tens of million where women are forbidden to learn in the name of Islam is pretty much spot on.

GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 13:36

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 03/11/2026 12:59

I think we shouldn't judge the morals of others based on a small snap shot of their opinion. There are some things that countries in the middle East are very good at and some things they suck at. I wouldn't want to live there or wouldn't my kids to live there but that doesn't meant that I will lie about how clean and efficient Dubai is, how fantastic their hotels are or that crime (as defined by THEIR laws) is very low. These are mostly facts. They don't undo the bad things but neither do the bad things mean that these facts are not true.

There is good and bad in every country. Some countries have by my values more bad than others but that doesn't mean that nothing positive about them exists or that we need to deny it.

E.g. it's like saying the US doesn't have amazing places of natural beauty because of ICE or because of a government that wanted to live stream an execution.

Oh, for Christ's sake. Crime figures are low because the poorest people are imports, kept in labour camps in the desert without access to residential areas, and have no opportunity to commit crimes, even should they be disposed to, and because there is a huge pressure on police not to record something as a crime, to keep those crime stats low.

Have you ever tried reporting a crime there? You frequently get a lengthy lecture from a police officer on how much trouble it would be to report it, and how you would have to be ready to go down to the station and do lots of time-consuming things, so better not. Because it's more important to maintain the image of Dubai as magically peaceful.

'Clean' is hilarious, given how poor the air quality habitually is, from a combination of car emissions, construction debris. Today, for instance, is '123 Poor (Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups)' on the AQI -- by 'sensitive groups', they mean children, older people, anyone with asthma or a heart condition, who should limit their exposure to the air. Pollution levels often exceed WHO safety guidelines.

Today, for comparison, the AQI in central London is '28-39, Good' -- 'satisfactory, with little to no risk'.

TheRoyalEyeroll · 03/11/2026 13:38

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 13:27

Ummm, I would say that's quite enough! If you're gonna bring in as some kind of comparison a tiny minority in a minority - where girls most certainly do go to school - then Afghanistan with tens of million where women are forbidden to learn in the name of Islam is pretty much spot on.

That’s some backtracking you’re doing. Mind you you’re not the first, and you certainly won’t be the last to start pedalling backwards when your posts are replied to with facts v

countries my royal backside.

SacredMorning · 03/11/2026 13:41

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 10:29

Each to their own, I've been here 50 years and like you in my 50s and probably when I was in my 20s to 40s, it was the best city in the world. It really is not anymore and it's a real shame. If you can't see it, then perhaps you are looking at things with rose tinted glasses. It's only going to get worse.

No rose-tinted glasses here. Maybe it depends on where you live. It’s a big city and I love it. It’s not perfect but I still think it has so much to offer. As do my young adult kids.

SacredMorning · 03/11/2026 13:44

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 12:00

GREAT Example! The last time I partied was in the mid 2010s just before settling down, and back then central London was already becoming a little dodgy....cant imagine what it's like these days at night!

Edited

Goodness. Have you not been out in central London since the 2010s? Not out for a late dinner or post-theatre drink?

SacredMorning · 03/11/2026 13:45

JHound · 03/11/2026 12:10

I’m a lone woman and feel fine in London.

Same. But Caps44 keeps saying ‘it’s done’ so that must be the case and we should all move away ;-)

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:50

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 13:27

Ummm, I would say that's quite enough! If you're gonna bring in as some kind of comparison a tiny minority in a minority - where girls most certainly do go to school - then Afghanistan with tens of million where women are forbidden to learn in the name of Islam is pretty much spot on.

I mean the fact they are unique and other muslim majority countries have some of the biggest gender gaps in education (such as Qatar which has one of the largest in the world favouring women) then saying it’s “in the name of Islam” seems weak.

But as has been pointed out - that comment triggered you for no rational reason.

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 13:53

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:50

I mean the fact they are unique and other muslim majority countries have some of the biggest gender gaps in education (such as Qatar which has one of the largest in the world favouring women) then saying it’s “in the name of Islam” seems weak.

But as has been pointed out - that comment triggered you for no rational reason.

The one who seems triggered is you - people point out how shit women are treated in Islam and you whine why no one is talking about orthodox Jews when you don't know even know the first tihng about orthodox Judasim and how women are treated. Stay in your lane and stop the whining and whataboutism.

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:56

PurpleThistle7 · 03/11/2026 12:48

Actually I don’t like any gender based oppression. But the Orthodox Jews aren’t writing laws for how women dress and if they can go to school as happens in way too many religious muslim countries. Maybe because there just arent enough of them, maybe because being different is part of the reason they do all the faffing, maybe because… who knows really.

i would be just as likely to attend an orthodox synagogue as I would to go to Dubai. Neither are for me.

I am flabbergasted at how many people would choose to skip democracy and quite curious about it. Is it because whoever we vote for, the result seems much the same and they’re all corrupt anyway? Because you genuinely think dictators have your best interest at heart? I can’t see any reason I’d deliberately allow what feels like my basic right to a voice disappear like that for the sake of a bigger house and more stuff?

“Way too many muslim countries” - one muslim majority country has laws prohibiting women / girls from accessing education.

Two muslim muslim majority have laws on female attire in terms of imposing certain forms of covering but then but so do European countries that prohibit the wearing of niqab in public (like some such as Tunisia and Azerbajian which places limits on veils in certain public spaces).

And like the other triggered PP you missed the point. Nobody was attacking Orthodox Jews. The point was about people who obsess over certain things (often ignorantly as your post demonstrates) when it comes to Islam but not other faiths. The orthodox / conservative representations of the abrahamic faiths aren’t particularly women friendly.

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:57

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 13:53

The one who seems triggered is you - people point out how shit women are treated in Islam and you whine why no one is talking about orthodox Jews when you don't know even know the first tihng about orthodox Judasim and how women are treated. Stay in your lane and stop the whining and whataboutism.

Come on now. Look at the hysterical post you made which completely missed the point about questioning the double standard accusing them of “anti-semitism”.

It’s clearly triggered you.

croisette · 03/11/2026 14:00

GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 12:27

And what are these 'changes' you notice and that other people don't notice?

That’s not what I said; it was an observation about the state of Piccadilly and the west end at night that I made in a post upthread.

I was saying that it was a bit of a dump with ebikes, groups of youths with faces covered, rickshaws harassing tourists, vape shops etc. It doesn’t make me feel unsafe per se, but I can see why it might make others feel that way.

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 14:02

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:56

“Way too many muslim countries” - one muslim majority country has laws prohibiting women / girls from accessing education.

Two muslim muslim majority have laws on female attire in terms of imposing certain forms of covering but then but so do European countries that prohibit the wearing of niqab in public (like some such as Tunisia and Azerbajian which places limits on veils in certain public spaces).

And like the other triggered PP you missed the point. Nobody was attacking Orthodox Jews. The point was about people who obsess over certain things (often ignorantly as your post demonstrates) when it comes to Islam but not other faiths. The orthodox / conservative representations of the abrahamic faiths aren’t particularly women friendly.

And yet Islam these days is the worst.
I mean, seriously, to minimise the depravity of Afghanistan with 'oh, it's only one Muslim majority country', Look at Qatar, women can go to university but they just can't travel without a male guardian. How lovely <3
ANd only two "muslim majority" countries force women to cover their faces (but not men -why?)
I don't know any "Jewish majority" country where that happens - women are legally allowed to wear what they like.
You are just showing you don't know what you're talking about. And every country where Islam is part of the legal system, women are treated badly. The only 'muslim majority' countries where women have any semblance of equal rights are the explicitly secular ones like Azerbaijan.

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 14:05

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:57

Come on now. Look at the hysterical post you made which completely missed the point about questioning the double standard accusing them of “anti-semitism”.

It’s clearly triggered you.

Come on now. Look at your hysteria (rather misogynistic but hey ho if the cap fits) when I question your motives in, out of all possible religious, choose the tiniest most inoffensive one - the one which has no desire to change how other people live. Plus you don't even know what you're talking about since orthodox Jewish women face nothing of the discrimiation and tyranny women face in Islam.

Swipe left for the next trending thread