Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it odd how quite a few posters here overlook things about Muslim Gulf states (UAE, Oman, Bahrain etc) which are usually criticised on threads about Islam?

155 replies

Jane3212 · 02/11/2026 00:37

I know MN's not a hive mind but I do think it's odd how you get plenty of posts on here rightly criticising aspects of Islam like attitudes to women or democracy, but then you also get posts lavishly praising Gulf states and ignoring or even denying the disadvantages Islam causes for women there.

I suspect part of it could be that some are only concerned if Islam affects non-Muslim women. Eg. On the recent thread about Oman, there were lots of posts saying how safe it is for women to walk around at night there (I always find this odd as women do risk assault here but most assault is by someone known, not a random stranger at night or otherwise) and downplaying the inequalities faced especially by Omani women behind closed doors (marital rape is legal and custody laws heavily favour men). You hear similar about Dubai often.

Or posts worrying about theocracy and Islam here yet threads on Dubai & similar others praise Muslim theocracies where only male royals rule and democracy is unthinkable. Yes, Dubai & others have a veneer of tolerance and are certainly much freer than many other Muslim countries but that freedom is still within the boundaries of religious laws and falls far more heavily on non-expat Muslim women.

AIBU?

OP posts:
AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:13

GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 13:36

Oh, for Christ's sake. Crime figures are low because the poorest people are imports, kept in labour camps in the desert without access to residential areas, and have no opportunity to commit crimes, even should they be disposed to, and because there is a huge pressure on police not to record something as a crime, to keep those crime stats low.

Have you ever tried reporting a crime there? You frequently get a lengthy lecture from a police officer on how much trouble it would be to report it, and how you would have to be ready to go down to the station and do lots of time-consuming things, so better not. Because it's more important to maintain the image of Dubai as magically peaceful.

'Clean' is hilarious, given how poor the air quality habitually is, from a combination of car emissions, construction debris. Today, for instance, is '123 Poor (Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups)' on the AQI -- by 'sensitive groups', they mean children, older people, anyone with asthma or a heart condition, who should limit their exposure to the air. Pollution levels often exceed WHO safety guidelines.

Today, for comparison, the AQI in central London is '28-39, Good' -- 'satisfactory, with little to no risk'.

So the people who tend to be most likely to commit crime are kept in a structure that prevents them from committing crime?

Isn't that a good thing?

Secretseverywhere · 03/11/2026 14:18

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:13

So the people who tend to be most likely to commit crime are kept in a structure that prevents them from committing crime?

Isn't that a good thing?

It all depends on your perspective if you are the one enjoying a lovely, safe lifestyle Im sure it’s lovely. Less so if you are living in conditions many would describe as modern day slavery.

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:20

SacredMorning · 03/11/2026 13:44

Goodness. Have you not been out in central London since the 2010s? Not out for a late dinner or post-theatre drink?

Every chance you come across a man who decides you're his next victim. Be it in the pub or club where you spiked, in public transport who decides to grope you or being attacked in the streets.

PurpleThistle7 · 03/11/2026 14:22

JHound · 03/11/2026 13:56

“Way too many muslim countries” - one muslim majority country has laws prohibiting women / girls from accessing education.

Two muslim muslim majority have laws on female attire in terms of imposing certain forms of covering but then but so do European countries that prohibit the wearing of niqab in public (like some such as Tunisia and Azerbajian which places limits on veils in certain public spaces).

And like the other triggered PP you missed the point. Nobody was attacking Orthodox Jews. The point was about people who obsess over certain things (often ignorantly as your post demonstrates) when it comes to Islam but not other faiths. The orthodox / conservative representations of the abrahamic faiths aren’t particularly women friendly.

I didn't bring up orthodox Jews on a post about Dubai. That was an odd jump.

But anyway, I hope people find a way to live whatever life they want to live. Am genuinely still curious about what is worth giving up democracy for. I have obviously never been to Dubai, so ready to learn (aware this sounds sarcastic typed out, it's not).

Portugal1987 · 03/11/2026 14:35

I mean, two princesses (Latifa and Sheikha), daughters of the main ruler and PM of the UAE, have been trying to escape due to domestic abuse allegations and oppression.

That says enough to me. It's not "safe", or "evolving", it's just good at marketing that to people who can afford to live there. I'm sure you'll be treated like royalty.

Portugal1987 · 03/11/2026 14:37

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:13

So the people who tend to be most likely to commit crime are kept in a structure that prevents them from committing crime?

Isn't that a good thing?

No, what that person was writing is that if a crime is committed, you are prevented from reporting it. So people can keep just keep doing crimes, while keeping the crime rate low.

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:39

Portugal1987 · 03/11/2026 14:37

No, what that person was writing is that if a crime is committed, you are prevented from reporting it. So people can keep just keep doing crimes, while keeping the crime rate low.

I don't think that's actually true

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:42

If people actually were going around commit crime that actually hurts the UAE so they take things seriously and have a no nonsense policy

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 14:44

PurpleThistle7 · 03/11/2026 14:22

I didn't bring up orthodox Jews on a post about Dubai. That was an odd jump.

But anyway, I hope people find a way to live whatever life they want to live. Am genuinely still curious about what is worth giving up democracy for. I have obviously never been to Dubai, so ready to learn (aware this sounds sarcastic typed out, it's not).

Literally the post says Muslim gulf states and you say 'but what about orthodox jews'
Luckily there is no non-democractic Jewish majority countries. Nearly all Jews were expelled from most of the non-democratic Muslim countries already so at least they don't live under those regimes any more.

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:23

SacredMorning · 03/11/2026 13:44

Goodness. Have you not been out in central London since the 2010s? Not out for a late dinner or post-theatre drink?

I was referring to Piccadilly Circus area, that the previous poster mentioned. Indeed, we drive in the evenings and tend to park outside the restaurants, be it Baker St, Marylebone High St. etc.....But when one has settled down with kids, one tends to stay in a lot more and tends to be home earlier for kids bedtimes. Back then I would be leaving my flat at 10pm to go out!

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:25

Smokeywater · 03/11/2026 12:52

What do you mean by done - though I do seem to agree with you a bit - as a 70 year old we have had many bad times but I can't see any way of getting out of this. Ridiculous wokeism skewing decision making, the green energy plans reducing chances of new industry and jobs. Buying everything from China and them making it hard for people to form businesses here. Immigration non stop but no houses. Constant demands for more pay, more benefits, more health care, more pension, more infrastructure but no income to pay for any of it. And a Gov that needs to keep everyone happy.

London is a completely different vibe now in 2026, than it was in 2016. I recall in the early 2010s, it was the place to be, everyone wanted to live here....it simply is no longer...be it the crowd, the crime, the cost of living....it's done as in I can't see it improving in the next 5 years....same for France, Germany etc....Europe is done.

nomas · 03/11/2026 15:26

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 13:27

Ummm, I would say that's quite enough! If you're gonna bring in as some kind of comparison a tiny minority in a minority - where girls most certainly do go to school - then Afghanistan with tens of million where women are forbidden to learn in the name of Islam is pretty much spot on.

Islam doesn't deny girls an education, in fact, it encourages both men and women to seek 'knowledge' - aka education.

And the Taliban were armed, trained, and financed by the USA.

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:28

Secretseverywhere · 03/11/2026 14:18

It all depends on your perspective if you are the one enjoying a lovely, safe lifestyle Im sure it’s lovely. Less so if you are living in conditions many would describe as modern day slavery.

There are issues in the world everywhere...but dictatorships and slave labour is not going to stop me living in a country where I feel we will prosper.

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:29

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 14:42

If people actually were going around commit crime that actually hurts the UAE so they take things seriously and have a no nonsense policy

I believe they kick you out of the country if you commit a crime.

AmourPlastique · 03/11/2026 16:22

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:29

I believe they kick you out of the country if you commit a crime.

Which is a good thing

Secretseverywhere · 03/11/2026 16:25

nomas · 03/11/2026 15:26

Islam doesn't deny girls an education, in fact, it encourages both men and women to seek 'knowledge' - aka education.

And the Taliban were armed, trained, and financed by the USA.

Edited

I think the teachings of Islam are often used to justify child marriage. It’s rare that a girl once married is able to continue her education. It’s not restricted to Muslim majority countries, India, for example, has a terribly large number of child brides and is predominantly Hindu. It’s really an issue of poverty combined with gender inequality but rather than being recognised as problematic it’s justified by religious teachings. so whilst Islam doesn’t prohibit girls being educated it can create a culture that effectively prevents it.

Its not universal there are Muslim majority countries that have issued fatwas against child martiage as both participants should be mature (18). Also in the west there is also a shocking amount of underage marriage in the U.S.A in some (admittedly rare) cases involving girls young as ten. It has the same negative effects for education.

Speaking of historical shitty things C.I.A. alongside the Brits also ousted the democratically elected leader of Iran leading to the current shitshow of a regime. Chickens coming home to roost feels apt these days.

CandidLurker · 03/11/2026 16:42

I always find it strange on these threads that we are about to have laws in this country about Islamophobia and people are like “Muslims are all lovely people etc” but suddenly when you are talking about Muslims in the Gulf it’s all “terrible people, awful religion”.

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 03/11/2026 16:52

GiantSuit · 03/11/2026 13:36

Oh, for Christ's sake. Crime figures are low because the poorest people are imports, kept in labour camps in the desert without access to residential areas, and have no opportunity to commit crimes, even should they be disposed to, and because there is a huge pressure on police not to record something as a crime, to keep those crime stats low.

Have you ever tried reporting a crime there? You frequently get a lengthy lecture from a police officer on how much trouble it would be to report it, and how you would have to be ready to go down to the station and do lots of time-consuming things, so better not. Because it's more important to maintain the image of Dubai as magically peaceful.

'Clean' is hilarious, given how poor the air quality habitually is, from a combination of car emissions, construction debris. Today, for instance, is '123 Poor (Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups)' on the AQI -- by 'sensitive groups', they mean children, older people, anyone with asthma or a heart condition, who should limit their exposure to the air. Pollution levels often exceed WHO safety guidelines.

Today, for comparison, the AQI in central London is '28-39, Good' -- 'satisfactory, with little to no risk'.

But that's the thing isn't it? You can always find caveats and pick selected partial truths for every statement to twist it to fit your opinion.

E.g. You are using air quality as an argument against cleanliness which surely you must realise is totally cherry picked as air quality isn't the only or even the main factor when people usually talk about how clean a place is.

countribution · 03/11/2026 20:18

Caps44 · 03/11/2026 15:29

I believe they kick you out of the country if you commit a crime.

That would be better than ending up in prison!

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 20:22

MrsShawnHatosy · 02/11/2026 11:36

I find it odd that many people criticise Muslim attitudes to women while completely ignoring how women are treated in Orthodox Judaism.

Orthodox Judaism only concerns an absolutely tiny population, and also Orthodox Jewish men's attitudes to non-Jewish women is not a problem for those women. Very very different from Islam.

Persephonia1966 · 03/11/2026 20:41

CandidLurker · 03/11/2026 16:42

I always find it strange on these threads that we are about to have laws in this country about Islamophobia and people are like “Muslims are all lovely people etc” but suddenly when you are talking about Muslims in the Gulf it’s all “terrible people, awful religion”.

I can't speak for all those people but for me it's more the inevitable consequences of theocracy. I wouldn't want to live in a Christian theocracy either and think the rise of "Christian nationalism" or the Christian far right (not saying all Christians are far right, not saying all right wing people are far right) in America and elsewhere is stupid and ultimately damaging. I don't think it's much of a coincidence that some of the people sympathetic to the idea of a more autocratic less tolerant "West" are also big fans of Saudi Arabia. That doesn't mean that all the people in Saudi Arabia are bad people at all. And I can be glad that the UK is not a Methodist theocracy without worrying that my Methodist neighbour or Muslim neighbour are both just waiting to destroy UK democracy.

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 23:43

nomas · 03/11/2026 15:26

Islam doesn't deny girls an education, in fact, it encourages both men and women to seek 'knowledge' - aka education.

And the Taliban were armed, trained, and financed by the USA.

Edited

Talk about ignoring and minimising what's going on.The taliban say that girls education is against Islam so clearly they don't agree with your interpretation

The fact that back in the 80s the US funded the taliban to fight the old USSR haa no bearing on how they rule Afghanistan now.

Islam also apparently doesn't allow women and children to be intentionally killed in war and yet hamas did exactly that in the name of Islam on 7/10.

Fruitfliesexterminator · 04/11/2026 08:38

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 03/11/2026 16:52

But that's the thing isn't it? You can always find caveats and pick selected partial truths for every statement to twist it to fit your opinion.

E.g. You are using air quality as an argument against cleanliness which surely you must realise is totally cherry picked as air quality isn't the only or even the main factor when people usually talk about how clean a place is.

It's also sand. The air quality rating is issue even far away from cities because of the desert dust. So 80-90 in no car zone, 120 in Dubai is 40-30 point difference which can easily be found in uk as well between countryside where traffic is high.

nomas · 04/11/2026 09:46

ginkhao · 03/11/2026 23:43

Talk about ignoring and minimising what's going on.The taliban say that girls education is against Islam so clearly they don't agree with your interpretation

The fact that back in the 80s the US funded the taliban to fight the old USSR haa no bearing on how they rule Afghanistan now.

Islam also apparently doesn't allow women and children to be intentionally killed in war and yet hamas did exactly that in the name of Islam on 7/10.

Wtf? The Palestinian cause is to do with their stolen land, what does that have to do with Islam?

Israel has killed 70,000 Muslims, was that in the name of religion?

MrsShawnHatosy · 04/11/2026 10:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m absolutely not a “dirty little anti semite” as you so charmingly put it. And yes I do know what Orthodox Judaism is. I just don’t think any religion is, or should be, exempt from criticism in respect of treatment of women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread