Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?

115 replies

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:26

I've just read this post on another forum, it's from someone who works in a prison library, most of the replies are saying that it's ok to secretly sell this book and donate the cash to a trans charity to spite JK Rowling.
"Say if you work somewhere that sometimes gets items donated (not a charity) and you discover that one might possibly be worth a bit of money (hundreds, not thousands), however you have no way of finding out who originally donated it. Is it OK to sell said item and donate the money to a relevant charity?
I'm fortunate enough not to really need the money myself, although I have to admit I'm still tempted to keep some, I'm not the most morally watertight person.... it's a first edition Harry Potter book with apparently rare typos"

Even setting the JKR/trans thing to one side I think this is very dishonest and she shouldn't do it, most others are encouraging her to go ahead.
So, is it ok to sell something that doesn't belong to you as long as you give the proceeds to charity?

AIBU - Don't do it, the book isn't yours to sell

YANBU - Do it and hope nobody at work finds out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
butterfliesandrainbows2022 · 31/10/2026 14:10

To me as it was donated to a specific place, the money made should go back to the same place.
I think selling is ok as that could end up helping them more than just having 1 book to read.

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 14:12

5128gap · 31/10/2026 13:50

I've read it and don't believe it. Too many unlikely events would have been required to make it credible.
The donor didn't realise the value.
The donor handily gave it to a prison thus avoiding the moral issue stealing from a charity would provoke.
The prison worker decided to examine the loathed book, and did recognise the value.
Despite being sufficiently sympathetic to the cause to loathe JKR, they don't know of any trans charities to donate to.
I guess anythings possible, but having all those things align to make it genuine, the odds are against it.

You could be right about the original post, still it's made for an interesting discussion
is it really theft if you donate some or all of the proceeds to your preferred charity?
Apparently 26% who voted think it's ok

OP posts:
Ethelspagetti · 31/10/2026 14:21

No you cannot do that. It’s technically theft. Give the book to someone in charge and explain the situation and see if they can do this or not. But it’s not down to you to judge what to do with donations.

5128gap · 31/10/2026 14:23

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 14:12

You could be right about the original post, still it's made for an interesting discussion
is it really theft if you donate some or all of the proceeds to your preferred charity?
Apparently 26% who voted think it's ok

Yes it has. Suspending disbelief for a second, my view is that it's quite obviously theft. However, the bigger question is, is theft always immoral? For example, if a person stole a valuable item from a mass murderer and used it to help his victims families, then most would say not.
Where this story falls down is that for there to be any morality to off set the theft, the person stolen from would need to be the person who has harmed the prospective beneficiaries of the theft.
Even if one believes JKR has harmed trans people, then it's moot, given she isn't the victim of the theft. The victims are the donor and the users of the prison library.

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 14:30

I agree @5128gap I also think that not selling the book for as much as possible would be wrong, just use the proceeds to benefit the users of the prison library not some random trans charity

OP posts:
FairKoala · 31/10/2026 14:36

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 14:30

I agree @5128gap I also think that not selling the book for as much as possible would be wrong, just use the proceeds to benefit the users of the prison library not some random trans charity

Ultimately though this book belongs to the prison and it is up to who ever is in charge to decide what to do. Not some random volunteer/worker to decide what to do with someone else’s property

PaperPanama · 31/10/2026 14:38

Surely that's just theft? Even if you don't intend to keep the proceeds for yourself, you've still stolen the book from the prison library.

5128gap · 31/10/2026 14:57

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 14:30

I agree @5128gap I also think that not selling the book for as much as possible would be wrong, just use the proceeds to benefit the users of the prison library not some random trans charity

Exactly.

YankSplaining · 31/10/2026 17:04

PigletJohn · 31/10/2026 13:01

The value of the item you steal does not determine if you stole it.

Did I say it did?

PigletJohn · 31/10/2026 17:39

Your answer one is sufficient.

Your answer two is superfluous.

Bubstar · 31/10/2026 18:29

Same kind of people who steal from elderlies with dementia and justify it by saying they won't know anyway 🙄

Who are these scumbags voting yanbu?

HeadteachersPet · 02/11/2026 17:38

Update from the OP, she hasn't fessed up and is thinking of hiding the book until she has a better idea of how much it's worth.

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?
OP posts:
Isitmyluckyday · 02/11/2026 17:40

The book belongs to the prison and they should decide whether to sell it and what to do with the proceeds. Hopefully to benefit the prisoners. This library employee shouldn't be taking charge of this.

HeadteachersPet · 02/11/2026 18:01

Isitmyluckyday · 02/11/2026 17:40

The book belongs to the prison and they should decide whether to sell it and what to do with the proceeds. Hopefully to benefit the prisoners. This library employee shouldn't be taking charge of this.

Edited

She's being egged on by others who think
A) JK Rowling is a transphobe so prisoners shouldn't be reading HP
B) Secretly selling the book & donating all or some of the proceeds to a trans charity to spite JKR is the right thing to do

I'm a bit surprised that 26% of MN voters on this thread agree with A and/or B

OP posts:
Isitmyluckyday · 02/11/2026 18:06

HeadteachersPet · 02/11/2026 18:01

She's being egged on by others who think
A) JK Rowling is a transphobe so prisoners shouldn't be reading HP
B) Secretly selling the book & donating all or some of the proceeds to a trans charity to spite JKR is the right thing to do

I'm a bit surprised that 26% of MN voters on this thread agree with A and/or B

Strange. There must other ways to annoy JKR that don't involve stealing from a hard pressed public service .

New posts on this thread. Refresh page