Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?

115 replies

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:26

I've just read this post on another forum, it's from someone who works in a prison library, most of the replies are saying that it's ok to secretly sell this book and donate the cash to a trans charity to spite JK Rowling.
"Say if you work somewhere that sometimes gets items donated (not a charity) and you discover that one might possibly be worth a bit of money (hundreds, not thousands), however you have no way of finding out who originally donated it. Is it OK to sell said item and donate the money to a relevant charity?
I'm fortunate enough not to really need the money myself, although I have to admit I'm still tempted to keep some, I'm not the most morally watertight person.... it's a first edition Harry Potter book with apparently rare typos"

Even setting the JKR/trans thing to one side I think this is very dishonest and she shouldn't do it, most others are encouraging her to go ahead.
So, is it ok to sell something that doesn't belong to you as long as you give the proceeds to charity?

AIBU - Don't do it, the book isn't yours to sell

YANBU - Do it and hope nobody at work finds out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Iloveeverycat · 31/10/2026 11:14

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:37

It was donated to a prison library not a charity,

So they should do it above board and donate the money back to the prison library. I really don't get why anyone would think of doing anything else.

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 11:15

Boreded · 31/10/2026 10:58

In this made up scenario, the first edition should be identified to whoever is management, then sold with their consent, and the proceeds being used to buy more books for the library

Edited

The post I've quoted isn't made up, I mean the actual poster may just have invented the whole thing for shits n giggles. I hope so because if true then it's pretty dishonest behaviour from someone who works in a prison.

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?
To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?
OP posts:
Shteen · 31/10/2026 11:17

No it's completely indefensible. If you have to do it in secret you know it's not the right thing to do.

The book could be sold above board and the proceeds used to buy more stock for the library, equipment or whatever.

Friendlygingercat · 31/10/2026 11:18

All libraries are short of money nowadays. I used to work in a public library which serviced a prison . I would bring it to the attention of the prison authorities and help them sell the book to raise money for more stock.

ProudPearl · 31/10/2026 11:19

MNers are very law abiding so the answers you'll get here are not surprising. My thoughts are... taking this would be a completely victimless crime! I can't imagine many prisoners would want to read a kids book so you're hardly depriving them of anything.
Not fussed about JK or the trans stuff. Love her or hate her, she would not be in anyway impacted by this action.

I think I'd consider asking if I could have the book, without mentioning to my bosses why I wanted it. If they say yes, then it's mine.

The best morally acceptable position is to talk to your bosses, sell it and use it to but resources for the library. I might do that. Depends how skint I was.

I'm sure you're all going to come at me now for being a terrible person!

Grammarnut · 31/10/2026 11:21

I am amazed by the posters who think it is ok to steal a donated item and give the money to a charity of one's own choice. If the book is valuable, tell the organisation it was donated to and they can decide. Best option would be for the prison library to sell the book and use the money for more books.
Stealing is never ok, whatever the motive.

Whaleandsnail6 · 31/10/2026 11:24

ProudPearl · 31/10/2026 11:19

MNers are very law abiding so the answers you'll get here are not surprising. My thoughts are... taking this would be a completely victimless crime! I can't imagine many prisoners would want to read a kids book so you're hardly depriving them of anything.
Not fussed about JK or the trans stuff. Love her or hate her, she would not be in anyway impacted by this action.

I think I'd consider asking if I could have the book, without mentioning to my bosses why I wanted it. If they say yes, then it's mine.

The best morally acceptable position is to talk to your bosses, sell it and use it to but resources for the library. I might do that. Depends how skint I was.

I'm sure you're all going to come at me now for being a terrible person!

Why do you think not many prisoners would want to read Harry Potter?

I know many, many adult Harry Potter fans..myself included. I also work in a prison and I know there is a huge lack of distraction items and not that many books in our prison library. Many of our prisoners read whatever they can get their hands on, and if a Harry Potter fan, this would be a good find.

MellowSubmarine · 31/10/2026 11:27

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:37

It was donated to a prison library not a charity,

Then this is obviously not ok.

The person donated the book to the prison, not so someone could steal it and choose the charity to donate to.

Dollymylove · 31/10/2026 11:27

I'm not sure what I would do but I'm betting that anyone reading this who works in a prison library will be having a good ferret around 😆

FairKoala · 31/10/2026 11:28

Saturdaysfairies · 31/10/2026 10:41

Replace it with a copy of the same book.
Sell and hand the money in.

So if I came to your house and took an original piece of artwork, sold it for £50 and returned to you a poster of said artwork and the change you would be ok with that?

What is being discussed is theft pure and simple no matter how much they think it isn’t

They have to ask themselves why what they want to do with the book trumps who donated the book and who owns the book now.

I wonder what else they get up to that they don’t post about.

I think for some reason they think they are some how better than the people who use this library and the people who run it
Theft to them is something that other people do who end up using the prison library

Boreded · 31/10/2026 11:31

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 11:15

The post I've quoted isn't made up, I mean the actual poster may just have invented the whole thing for shits n giggles. I hope so because if true then it's pretty dishonest behaviour from someone who works in a prison.

Sorry I didn’t mean like you were lying…I meant as in it is just a hypothetical situation that was likely invented by the OP you found.

It doesn’t matter if it is real of fake, it’s a thought experiment at this point isn’t it. It’s not your situation so it can’t be anything other than a thought experiment.

Apologies if it sounded like I was saying you are lying.

thisismeithinkorisit · 31/10/2026 11:31

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 31/10/2026 10:33

I would say yes it’s ok as long as the money is given to the same charity as to which the book was donated

this. I think the money needs to come back into the prison. maybe to buy some more books or invest in education etc. I wouldn't do it secretly though, you open yourself up to being found out and accused of stealing.

MellowSubmarine · 31/10/2026 11:31

ProudPearl · 31/10/2026 11:19

MNers are very law abiding so the answers you'll get here are not surprising. My thoughts are... taking this would be a completely victimless crime! I can't imagine many prisoners would want to read a kids book so you're hardly depriving them of anything.
Not fussed about JK or the trans stuff. Love her or hate her, she would not be in anyway impacted by this action.

I think I'd consider asking if I could have the book, without mentioning to my bosses why I wanted it. If they say yes, then it's mine.

The best morally acceptable position is to talk to your bosses, sell it and use it to but resources for the library. I might do that. Depends how skint I was.

I'm sure you're all going to come at me now for being a terrible person!

It’s not about the law as far as I’m concerned.

It’s about the person who donated. I appreciate they’ll never find out, but if someone donates something to a specific cause, it should benefit that cause. If they can’t use it directly eg an unsuitable book, then it should be sold and the profits go to the same place.
It’s not for individuals volunteering/working at the kind of places that take donations to decide that some donations shouldn’t benefit that place, but should benefit something else instead.

RigsbysCat · 31/10/2026 11:34

I think regardless of the circumstances, an employee/volunteer stealing a donated book from a prison library is a pretty low thing to do. The person also has literally no moral compass if she thinks this somehow gives her any sort of moral high ground.

Surely the right thing to do would be to bring it to the attention of the prison governor, and sell the book with the proceeds going towards new prison library books. Then the wishes of the original donator would be being respected.

The original donator might well be appalled at their donation being used to fund a trans charity, I would.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 31/10/2026 11:34

spannasaurus · 31/10/2026 10:39

I think whoever is in charge of the prison library should be informed and the book should be sold by them and the funds raised used to buy more books

This is the only correct answer, in my opinion. Not making up flimsy excuses for stealing from your employer.

BirdLandedonmyHead · 31/10/2026 11:34

Selling to get money for more books for the library... fine.
Selling it to donate to an unrelated charity... wrong.

godmum56 · 31/10/2026 11:36

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:37

It was donated to a prison library not a charity,

then the prison governor should be told.

BillieWiper · 31/10/2026 11:38

Can you steal from a prison?! Erm no.

You'd be pretty damned thick to do so. Presumably there are cameras everywhere?

And surely a relevant charity would be one backing prison reform, prisoners rights, people falsely imprisoned etc. Not trans people. How is that a relevant charity?

Relevant because the author obviously wouldn't support such a charity? Seems a bizarre twisted logic. I can see you're not 'morally watertight' OP!

chirrupybird · 31/10/2026 11:40

Tell someone who has authority that you think the book is valuable and it would be better to sell it and buy a dozen other books.

PinkFrogss · 31/10/2026 11:42

Scenario aside it’s probably not as valuable as they think. Only very certain editions of the books are valuable, but many assume other editions are valuable too.

Oxfam may have it listed for £500 but is anyone actually buying it for that kind of money?

MoistVonL · 31/10/2026 11:44

It's theft. Anyone with half a moral compass would alert the prison governor and suggest it be sold to fund more prison library stock.

BackToLurk · 31/10/2026 11:48

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:37

It was donated to a prison library not a charity,

There are loads of charities that support inmates and their families. They could donate to that, but it seems a bit off tbh. Presumably someone wanted the prison library to have it. It’s not one person’s call that they can’t.

GrapeBaby · 31/10/2026 11:50

Boreded · 31/10/2026 10:58

In this made up scenario, the first edition should be identified to whoever is management, then sold with their consent, and the proceeds being used to buy more books for the library

Edited

This. It’s deeply unlikely anyone accidentally donated a first edition HP book to a prison library.

guinnessguzzler · 31/10/2026 11:57

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 11:15

The post I've quoted isn't made up, I mean the actual poster may just have invented the whole thing for shits n giggles. I hope so because if true then it's pretty dishonest behaviour from someone who works in a prison.

Yes, sorry, OP, I wasn't meaning I thought you had made it up but that the OP on the other forum might have. Who knows, people are weird, but I do enjoy reading different views and approaches to moral dilemmas whether theoretical or not (possibly one of the ways I am weird).

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 11:58

I'm interested in hearing from people who voted YANBU, why do you think selling a book donated to a prison library and giving the cash to an unrelated charity it the right thing to do? Is it because you support trans people or do you think it's ok irrespective of which charity gets the donationed cash?

Could the eventual recipient be investigated under AML legislation if the theft was discovered?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread