Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?

115 replies

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:26

I've just read this post on another forum, it's from someone who works in a prison library, most of the replies are saying that it's ok to secretly sell this book and donate the cash to a trans charity to spite JK Rowling.
"Say if you work somewhere that sometimes gets items donated (not a charity) and you discover that one might possibly be worth a bit of money (hundreds, not thousands), however you have no way of finding out who originally donated it. Is it OK to sell said item and donate the money to a relevant charity?
I'm fortunate enough not to really need the money myself, although I have to admit I'm still tempted to keep some, I'm not the most morally watertight person.... it's a first edition Harry Potter book with apparently rare typos"

Even setting the JKR/trans thing to one side I think this is very dishonest and she shouldn't do it, most others are encouraging her to go ahead.
So, is it ok to sell something that doesn't belong to you as long as you give the proceeds to charity?

AIBU - Don't do it, the book isn't yours to sell

YANBU - Do it and hope nobody at work finds out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PigletJohn · 31/10/2026 13:01

YankSplaining · 31/10/2026 12:45

One, I think this would be morally wrong to do. Two, unless the book is one of the first 500 copies printed, it’s not as valuable as this person thinks it is. If it is one of the first 500 printed, that would make it one of the rarest books in publishing, and I can’t believe anyone who owned it would be so ignorant of that fact that they’d put it in a box with other books and donate it to a prison library.

(And if it happens to be a first American edition, it’s pretty much worthless. I’ve got one downstairs and you can find them in used book stores on the US for around fifteen bucks.)

The value of the item you steal does not determine if you stole it.

NetZeroZealot · 31/10/2026 13:07

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:37

It was donated to a prison library not a charity,

Sell the book & use the proceeds to buy more books for the prison library, surely?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:11

Whaleandsnail6 · 31/10/2026 11:24

Why do you think not many prisoners would want to read Harry Potter?

I know many, many adult Harry Potter fans..myself included. I also work in a prison and I know there is a huge lack of distraction items and not that many books in our prison library. Many of our prisoners read whatever they can get their hands on, and if a Harry Potter fan, this would be a good find.

I had not realised that. Are prisons a good place to donate surplus books? We downsized recently and had to give a lot away, but likely still need to give away more in future.

Auroraloves · 31/10/2026 13:11

Well, it’s theft from the place it was donated to , so unreasonable

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:15

mondaytosunday · 31/10/2026 12:59

Exactly as @LiquoriceAllsorts2days - same charity as the book was donated to. In fact why not tell the charity the book may be valuable and have them deal with it? And what has Rowling got to do with it? The book has nothing to do with her after it’s sold.

The book wasn't donated to a charity it was given to a prison library which I'm sure isn't funded by charitable donations.
The forum this was originally posted on hates JKR, it was always quite bloke-y but has become really unpleasant recently. (there were hundreds of post joking about the gruesome details of Ann Widdecombe's murder) I used to post on the book & music threads but rarely visit it now

OP posts:
BluebellBeth · 31/10/2026 13:19

Is this about the book or trans and JK? Not sure why you needed to bring the latter onto it other than to stir or see if it affects peoples decisions?

Its not their book to sell imo and they should leave it in the library it was donated too.

5128gap · 31/10/2026 13:21

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 12:10

I really don't think it's made up, or if it is then they've invented quite a lot of detail about it.
And if they just want approval for their actions then what's wrong with giving them a wider audience?
I deliberately didn't mention JKR or trans in the title so bog off with your "click bait"

I believe its entirely made up. I mean, what are the odds of a trans ally finding a valuable book by JKR that no one is aware of but them, and needing to ask about trans charities? Like they can't Google?
This isn't a neutral 'think piece'. Its a deliberate attempt to stir up hostility against JKR again. A made up scenario to serve as a in for people to vent their spleen about the woman. As far as I'm aware she hadn't said or done anything of late to give them an excuse for a spite fest, so someone's made something up.

FKAT · 31/10/2026 13:21

Aren't prison libraries run by the inmates anyway? My DF was a prison librarian when he served time. (This was a long time ago though - 60s/70s)

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:22

BluebellBeth · 31/10/2026 13:19

Is this about the book or trans and JK? Not sure why you needed to bring the latter onto it other than to stir or see if it affects peoples decisions?

Its not their book to sell imo and they should leave it in the library it was donated too.

If they leave it in the library they will need to stamp it which may devalue it, it may also get damaged

OP posts:
Whaleandsnail6 · 31/10/2026 13:22

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:11

I had not realised that. Are prisons a good place to donate surplus books? We downsized recently and had to give a lot away, but likely still need to give away more in future.

I'd say so. Books are always well received where I work.

You'd be best contacting your local prison if you wanted to donate and having a chat about whether they accept donations and how to go about it. Where I work, even as staff, we can't just bring things in to donate, we need to discuss with security first so they can be checked before going into the actual prison environment.

alcovecupboards · 31/10/2026 13:25

I'm sure this definitely happened and isn't just yet another goady post with the sole aim of letting people on Mumsnet attack trans people.

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:26

5128gap · 31/10/2026 13:21

I believe its entirely made up. I mean, what are the odds of a trans ally finding a valuable book by JKR that no one is aware of but them, and needing to ask about trans charities? Like they can't Google?
This isn't a neutral 'think piece'. Its a deliberate attempt to stir up hostility against JKR again. A made up scenario to serve as a in for people to vent their spleen about the woman. As far as I'm aware she hadn't said or done anything of late to give them an excuse for a spite fest, so someone's made something up.

Here's the original post, you can decide for yourself how true it is
Original post about the book

OP posts:
Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 31/10/2026 13:29

Wadsworthy · 31/10/2026 12:45

Oxfam routinely overprice their “collectible” books. Always worth checking on AbeBooks.

Ironically, I bought a first edition in my local Oxfam bookshop for a tenner. Sold it for over £300 (got less than that because of auction house fees).

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:30

alcovecupboards · 31/10/2026 13:25

I'm sure this definitely happened and isn't just yet another goady post with the sole aim of letting people on Mumsnet attack trans people.

I can't see anyone attacking trans people on this thread, We're just discussing the ethics of selling something that doesn't belong to you.
Do you think that's an ok thing to do?

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:33

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:30

I can't see anyone attacking trans people on this thread, We're just discussing the ethics of selling something that doesn't belong to you.
Do you think that's an ok thing to do?

Not to mention that the original post wasn't on MN. I suspect someone didn't bother reading the thread before having their tuppenceworth. FWR really does live rent free in a few people's heads.

Quartzfairy · 31/10/2026 13:35

It’s up to the prison to decide what to do it with it as it was donated to them.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:36

Whaleandsnail6 · 31/10/2026 13:22

I'd say so. Books are always well received where I work.

You'd be best contacting your local prison if you wanted to donate and having a chat about whether they accept donations and how to go about it. Where I work, even as staff, we can't just bring things in to donate, we need to discuss with security first so they can be checked before going into the actual prison environment.

Thank you. I was wondering if it was common enough that prisons had a scheme or something that I hadn't come across. I'll contact the local prison.

Everydayimhuffling · 31/10/2026 13:38

If I was them, I'd be inclined to sell it and use the money to buy a lot more books for the prison library. That seems like a better use of the donation. Taking it for yourself or a chosen different cause isn't reasonable.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:45

Slightly off topic, but it does amaze me that TRAs and Genderists think JKR somehow changed her values from what is in the books. I mean, right from the start, she was showing how the social pressure that stopped people naming Voldemort also increased their fear, and within a few books showing how vested interests capture and control institutions and educators to suppress dissent and alternative views. By the end book (I think, it's been a while), she has the Taboo curse whereby speaking Voldemort's name literally marks you as a dissenter and calls his allies down upon you. She's always clearly warned against the mechanics of control.

5128gap · 31/10/2026 13:50

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:26

Here's the original post, you can decide for yourself how true it is
Original post about the book

I've read it and don't believe it. Too many unlikely events would have been required to make it credible.
The donor didn't realise the value.
The donor handily gave it to a prison thus avoiding the moral issue stealing from a charity would provoke.
The prison worker decided to examine the loathed book, and did recognise the value.
Despite being sufficiently sympathetic to the cause to loathe JKR, they don't know of any trans charities to donate to.
I guess anythings possible, but having all those things align to make it genuine, the odds are against it.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:52

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:45

Slightly off topic, but it does amaze me that TRAs and Genderists think JKR somehow changed her values from what is in the books. I mean, right from the start, she was showing how the social pressure that stopped people naming Voldemort also increased their fear, and within a few books showing how vested interests capture and control institutions and educators to suppress dissent and alternative views. By the end book (I think, it's been a while), she has the Taboo curse whereby speaking Voldemort's name literally marks you as a dissenter and calls his allies down upon you. She's always clearly warned against the mechanics of control.

OH! Replying to myself...

Unless what those people took from the book wasn't the political warning, but instead a story about how a bullied little boy who felt very different found a world full of special people who were much much better and more interesting than the people who rejected him, and ended up with lots and lots of magic powers and just basically won? That would explain a lot I guess, they thought JKR was giving them a story where the underdog came out on top and could laugh at the people who had laughed at him, not a story about where thinking you have a moral right to power ends up.

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 13:54

FlirtsWithRhinos · 31/10/2026 13:33

Not to mention that the original post wasn't on MN. I suspect someone didn't bother reading the thread before having their tuppenceworth. FWR really does live rent free in a few people's heads.

Quite
I'm surprised @alcovecupboards is still posting. Revealing that they're an important TV producer and disclosing the Traitors result on FWR before it aired was an amazingly silly way to show off

OP posts:
TorroFerney · 31/10/2026 13:56

ProudPearl · 31/10/2026 11:19

MNers are very law abiding so the answers you'll get here are not surprising. My thoughts are... taking this would be a completely victimless crime! I can't imagine many prisoners would want to read a kids book so you're hardly depriving them of anything.
Not fussed about JK or the trans stuff. Love her or hate her, she would not be in anyway impacted by this action.

I think I'd consider asking if I could have the book, without mentioning to my bosses why I wanted it. If they say yes, then it's mine.

The best morally acceptable position is to talk to your bosses, sell it and use it to but resources for the library. I might do that. Depends how skint I was.

I'm sure you're all going to come at me now for being a terrible person!

The prisoners will want to read a kids book, some will will be unable to read an adults book due to low literacy levels so reading something they may have seen as a film probably helps.

Is it a men's prison? Perhaps she should ask the inmates whether they are pro men saying they are women and wearing a frock. I feel I can guess the answer. Obviously unless said men are the criminals who do it to get put in a womens prison. You'd think someone who worked in a prison and understood the trauma that the majority of inmates have been through (not excusing any crimes they have committed) and the shit chilhdhoods nearly all of them will have had wouldn't be interested in scoring points on a personal agenda but would be wanting the money to go somewhere more relevant.

Purplepinkandpaper · 31/10/2026 14:06

Clear breach of the civil service code, which could result in disciplinary action/dismissal if discovered.