Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?

115 replies

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:26

I've just read this post on another forum, it's from someone who works in a prison library, most of the replies are saying that it's ok to secretly sell this book and donate the cash to a trans charity to spite JK Rowling.
"Say if you work somewhere that sometimes gets items donated (not a charity) and you discover that one might possibly be worth a bit of money (hundreds, not thousands), however you have no way of finding out who originally donated it. Is it OK to sell said item and donate the money to a relevant charity?
I'm fortunate enough not to really need the money myself, although I have to admit I'm still tempted to keep some, I'm not the most morally watertight person.... it's a first edition Harry Potter book with apparently rare typos"

Even setting the JKR/trans thing to one side I think this is very dishonest and she shouldn't do it, most others are encouraging her to go ahead.
So, is it ok to sell something that doesn't belong to you as long as you give the proceeds to charity?

AIBU - Don't do it, the book isn't yours to sell

YANBU - Do it and hope nobody at work finds out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
daisychain01 · 31/10/2026 11:59

I've voted you're unreasonable for posting this click bait about giving the money to a trans charity to spite JKR.

why are you perpetuating made up shit?

5128gap · 31/10/2026 12:00

The person who wrote the origional post just wants likes from TRAs. If there's a valuable book, a prison or an 'ethical dilemma' anywhere in their life, then I'm JKR.

MrDobbs · 31/10/2026 12:03

Surely this is made up or if true, it's quite surprising that someone would be simultaneously be stupid enough to write all this publicly yet t still have enough about them to be able to work out what it is is and why it's special. I imagine first edition books with "rare typos" are indeed rare so there can't be many on the market and if you're posting about selling it secretly on the internet on multiple forums there's quite a high chance you'll get found out eventually?

IzzyLeng · 31/10/2026 12:03

They could sell the book and use the money to buy books for the prison library which would be more In Line with the spirit of the donation. To be honest I doubt the book is worth that much. I have a first edition with typos and I have been told it’s worth a bit but I think these things are often over inflated and in reality don’t fetch much.

brownbootsandhats · 31/10/2026 12:06

It’s not ok to steal

I can’t imagine JK being upset if money went to a charity even a trans one

MellowSubmarine · 31/10/2026 12:07

MrDobbs · 31/10/2026 12:03

Surely this is made up or if true, it's quite surprising that someone would be simultaneously be stupid enough to write all this publicly yet t still have enough about them to be able to work out what it is is and why it's special. I imagine first edition books with "rare typos" are indeed rare so there can't be many on the market and if you're posting about selling it secretly on the internet on multiple forums there's quite a high chance you'll get found out eventually?

If it was a real scenario, they can’t be talking about an actual 1st edition of the 1st book with the typo listing “1 wand” twice in the school equipment list, because those actually do sell for thousands. And they’ve said it’s not worth thousands.

This was a hardback, there are more paperback versions so they sell for less but still a lot! https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx273wnvw9go?app-referrer=deep-link

FIrst edition Harry Potter book on a wooden table

Rare first edition Harry Potter book sells for £36k

The rare book was originally bought for about £10 during a family holiday in 1997.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx273wnvw9go?app-referrer=deep-link

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 12:10

daisychain01 · 31/10/2026 11:59

I've voted you're unreasonable for posting this click bait about giving the money to a trans charity to spite JKR.

why are you perpetuating made up shit?

I really don't think it's made up, or if it is then they've invented quite a lot of detail about it.
And if they just want approval for their actions then what's wrong with giving them a wider audience?
I deliberately didn't mention JKR or trans in the title so bog off with your "click bait"

To secretly sell a valuable donated book & give the cash to charity?
OP posts:
Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 31/10/2026 12:12

if you work for say the British heart foundation and someone donates a valuable book, you price it accordingly or speak to management so it gets auctioned you don't take it home and sell it
if however you are browsing in the british heart foundation shop and notice a valuable item priced at £3 you can buy it at £3 and sell it on, you are under no obligation to point out to management that it is under priced in a way an employee would be and you do not need to donate profits above £3 back to Bheart F etc

so if book is donated to prison library it stays in prison library or you tell the governor it is valuable and then they decide whether it is sold to further aims of prison library or whether it stays as a book to read, I do not think either the Prison governor or the person spotting the book are entitled to sell it and donate money to any other cause whether it is transrights/ cancer children in need famine relief etc the actual charity is irrelevant

Toodarktooearly · 31/10/2026 12:14

HeadteachersPet · 31/10/2026 10:37

It was donated to a prison library not a charity,

Then the prison governor should be informed and the money used in the library. Stealing is not ok no matter how you dress up up

Wadsworthy · 31/10/2026 12:15

The poster admits to not being “morally watertight” which is a devious way to say “thief.”

milveycrohn · 31/10/2026 12:15

No it's not OK.
It is stealing something that dies not belong to you, regardless of what happens to the money.

barofsoap · 31/10/2026 12:29

need to be completely open about -speak to whoever runs the library, sell the book and use the money to buy lots more books

PoliteGreyDreamer · 31/10/2026 12:31

How do you know the book is valuable?

Harry Potter books are notoriously unvaluable, as so many millions were printed. There were a couple hundred in the first print run of The Philosopher's Stone, but after that the print runs were HUGE.

AutumnOakTree · 31/10/2026 12:34

Should discussed with line manager, and if sold, any proceeds goes back to the library. Maybe to buy more books for the prison?

Happyjoe · 31/10/2026 12:35

Well, it's not their book to sell so it's stealing. However if really want to sell it, use the money to buy better books for the inmates.

YankSplaining · 31/10/2026 12:37

Whaleandsnail6 · 31/10/2026 11:24

Why do you think not many prisoners would want to read Harry Potter?

I know many, many adult Harry Potter fans..myself included. I also work in a prison and I know there is a huge lack of distraction items and not that many books in our prison library. Many of our prisoners read whatever they can get their hands on, and if a Harry Potter fan, this would be a good find.

I write to a woman in an American prison, and she loves Harry Potter. Read it as a kid and used to read it to her young daughter on visiting days.

PinkFrogss · 31/10/2026 12:42

If it’s the order of the phoenix misprint edition (which oxfam are selling for £500) it’s really not worth a lot at all. No idea why oxfam are selling it for that price, they’ve clearly been misinformed.

PigletJohn · 31/10/2026 12:43

"I work at X

I saw a valuable item on their premises that nobody has noticed.

I'm thinking of taking it, selling it, and using the money however I wish.

Am I a thief?"

Lorrymum · 31/10/2026 12:43

A few years ago while working in a junior schoolI was asked to throw away a collection of Reading scheme books which were regarded as out of date. It seemed a huge shame to just chuck them in a skip and out of curiosity I looked for similar books on EBay. I was astonished to see that several of them were sought after and selling for several hundred pounds, despite school logo and the odd scribble.
I pointed this out to several teachers who were not really interested and eventually spoke to the Head. It was decided that I would sell them and give the money to the school but I could keep £50 as a "finders fee"
I managed to sell them for over £1000 and the money went towards paying for the new reading scheme.
I would draw the attention of your librarian to the real value of the book and play it by ear.

Wadsworthy · 31/10/2026 12:45

PinkFrogss · 31/10/2026 12:42

If it’s the order of the phoenix misprint edition (which oxfam are selling for £500) it’s really not worth a lot at all. No idea why oxfam are selling it for that price, they’ve clearly been misinformed.

Oxfam routinely overprice their “collectible” books. Always worth checking on AbeBooks.

YankSplaining · 31/10/2026 12:45

One, I think this would be morally wrong to do. Two, unless the book is one of the first 500 copies printed, it’s not as valuable as this person thinks it is. If it is one of the first 500 printed, that would make it one of the rarest books in publishing, and I can’t believe anyone who owned it would be so ignorant of that fact that they’d put it in a box with other books and donate it to a prison library.

(And if it happens to be a first American edition, it’s pretty much worthless. I’ve got one downstairs and you can find them in used book stores on the US for around fifteen bucks.)

MyLifeInBooks · 31/10/2026 12:50

🤣 that made my day! Someone testing the moral waters with something clearly not that valuable at all!

PinkWaffleMaker · 31/10/2026 12:54

spannasaurus · 31/10/2026 10:39

I think whoever is in charge of the prison library should be informed and the book should be sold by them and the funds raised used to buy more books

This is the right thing to do. Sell the book and feed the money back into the prison library.

NewGoldFox · 31/10/2026 12:56

Odd there is no mention of replacing the book with a less valuable copy.
Also sounds like they are keen to pop some of the ill gotten money into their own pocket which is pretty low behaviour.

mondaytosunday · 31/10/2026 12:59

Exactly as @LiquoriceAllsorts2days - same charity as the book was donated to. In fact why not tell the charity the book may be valuable and have them deal with it? And what has Rowling got to do with it? The book has nothing to do with her after it’s sold.

Swipe left for the next trending thread