Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD has suddenly asked if her bf can come on holiday - WWYD

161 replies

LighterDays · 18/10/2026 21:24

I’ve posted before about dd15, her boyfriend and their son now 8 months. I won’t go into detail as this will be long but long story short:

She started dating a boy and her behaviour changed, we argued all the time, she moved in with her dad and got pregnant. Her bf treated her horribly after they broke up including waiting for her at the bus stop and outside classrooms and getting his friends to aswell basically intimidating her. She was heavily pregnant and extremely anxious about this. She blocked him on everything for a bit then they started talking again

He was at the birth, and as grandson has got bigger he has surprised me by being involved, he does seem to have really grown up and i may be naive but i don’t see him as that bad kid anymore, i think a lot of it is down to parenting (lack of) as he lives with his dad and older brothers and doesn’t see his mum and when his dad found out dd was pregnant he called her a slag and basically said his son wasn’t the dad. They got back together a month or so after grandson was born and I welcomed him as much as possible as I knew being against their relationship would push them together again, like before. He stays over on weekends and gets up with grandson and plays with him etc, grandson adores him and her bf sort of admits he’s only changed for the baby.

He’s given up weed (so he tells dd but i have no evidence or reason to doubt him), it’s not all been plain sailing as he did tattoo his own initial onto dd but dd says he treats her well and they’re happy and i think i do believe her, she cried to me about him multiple times last time they were together when she was still pregnant so i think she’d be honest ( i hope)

Anyway now the reason im posting, we’re going on a caravan holiday tuesday, grandsons first holiday and dd is excited about it, we’re going with her dad and he’ll have some of my dc in his caravan. I can’t really discuss this with her dad though (we aren’t together) as he’d just say let him go as he is quite lax so i’m asking mn, she’s asked if her bf can come. If they were average 15 year olds, no parents then id say no of course not but they’re parents, im still in two minds whether it’s appropriate and also the fact i cant discuss with his dad. He says his dad doesnt care where he is and if he says he’s with us he doesnt care but i do feel abit uncomfortable

WWYD?

** She also asked back in summer. I said no and she stayed with her dad as he didnt come then but this time it’s not possible

OP posts:
PrettyPickle · 21/10/2026 17:01

Nolongera · 21/10/2026 15:52

Again,what on earth does your adult friends choosing to have tattoos as adults they later regret have to do with the crime against this child?

Still, as long as she wants being held down, that means she was ok with it?

You are all over the place.

You are taking it out of context. I was illustrating that people, no matter what their age have opinions about having their partners name tattoo'd on them and when they get them and things go wrong with the partner, they subsequently regret it, so stupidity is not limited to a specific age group. When I made that post there was one line about the tattoo on this thread.

But you are trying to derail her thread.

OP has obviously moved past all of that and so has her daughter. OP believes he has changed and her DD seems happier with him. The question is not our opinion on the tattoo, the OP has already made the decision on that one by allowing the relationship to re-establish post that and DD is no longer scared of him.

The question is, should he be allowed on the holiday and I think that given they are now attached to each other for life as they are parents, that they are co parenting and apparently back in a relationship, that he should go, but with his Dads permission.

InfoSecInTheCity · 21/10/2026 17:32

Nolongera · 21/10/2026 13:15

What possible correlation can there be between adult women who lawfully chose to have a tattoo then regret it and a child who is incapable of consent?

Or is it only wrong if he held her down to do it? You are aware other forms of control are available?

It is a criminal offence to tattoo a child wether they consent or not and it is clearly a massive red flag, yet the OP skimmed over it like it was a minor blip in the road.

She is marked for life.

Edited

We aren’t talking about a man tattooing a child, we are talking about 2 children one of whom did the tattoo, the other received it.

is it possible he coerced her - yes
is it possible she coerced him - yes
is it possible neither of them gave it much thought and they agreed to do it on a spur of the moment like kids do - yes

We know a tiny bit about his history, enough to know he’s probably not had much good parental support throughout his life and that he’s made some bad decisions which have resulted in him acting badly.

We don’t know anything really about OPs daughters upbringing, we know at the very least that she was having unprotected sex with her bad boy boyfriend as a 14/15 year old which raises some questions about parental supervision, involvement and how much she knew about contraception.

You appear to have come to the conclusion that the boyfriend is abusive to the extent that he forcibly (physically or psychologically) tattooed the OPs daughter and I’m not sure where you got that picture from based on the OPs posts in this thread.

WarmAleAndBlackLabrador · 21/10/2026 19:40

tripleginandtonic · 21/10/2026 13:21

That's shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted.
Of course as gdc dad he should cone if dd wants him there.

Yes, perhaps he'll intimidate her 15yo daughter again, tattoo his initials on her again and continue to have unprotected underage sex. He might even give her another baby. Great. And to think we look down on the the American bible belt, where girls are encouraged to marry the abusers who got them pregnant.

JanuaryLove · 22/10/2026 08:38

JimBobsWife · 19/10/2026 07:17

Well, I think that’s the point. They shouldn’t have been sleeping together at 13/14. Why encourage it now if it’s not necessary.

Get out of the Waltons era and back in the real world Janet

trockodile · 22/10/2026 09:17

Regardless of anything else at the moment-this is your longed for and probably well deserved holiday. Will bringing the boyfriend make your holiday easier or harder? Prioritise your enjoyment for the holidays. Everything else can wait.

Nolongera · 22/10/2026 09:26

InfoSecInTheCity · 21/10/2026 17:32

We aren’t talking about a man tattooing a child, we are talking about 2 children one of whom did the tattoo, the other received it.

is it possible he coerced her - yes
is it possible she coerced him - yes
is it possible neither of them gave it much thought and they agreed to do it on a spur of the moment like kids do - yes

We know a tiny bit about his history, enough to know he’s probably not had much good parental support throughout his life and that he’s made some bad decisions which have resulted in him acting badly.

We don’t know anything really about OPs daughters upbringing, we know at the very least that she was having unprotected sex with her bad boy boyfriend as a 14/15 year old which raises some questions about parental supervision, involvement and how much she knew about contraception.

You appear to have come to the conclusion that the boyfriend is abusive to the extent that he forcibly (physically or psychologically) tattooed the OPs daughter and I’m not sure where you got that picture from based on the OPs posts in this thread.

In the OPs original post she states he treated her horribly, waiting for her outside class rooms and bus stops and getting his friends to intimidate her. Suddenly he is Prince charming, with the minor blip of his criminal scarring.

A child cannot consent to this. He is old enough to be prosecuted for it.

I can just imagine the mess he has made of his home made tattoo.

Too many Mills and Boon readers in this thread desperate for a happy ending with no insight to the real world.

caringcarer · 22/10/2026 09:47

I'd let him come, he's your DGS's Dad. I'd try to support them as a family provided he is now more mature and good to your DD and DGS.

JimBobsWife · 22/10/2026 09:52

JanuaryLove · 22/10/2026 08:38

Get out of the Waltons era and back in the real world Janet

In my real world, kids of 13 and 14 aren't shagging and producing kids. They're living age appropriate lives.

Maybe you need to up your standards, Janet. Whoever she is.

NewDogOwner · 22/10/2026 10:01

He tattooed his initials on to your minor daughter? It seems like you are so embroiled with the dysfunction of this whole situation that you have lost sight of normal healthy behaviour. Yes, support your daughter and child. No, do not encourage this person to be in a relationship with your clearly vulnerable, minor daughter.

PrettyPickle · 22/10/2026 10:01

Nolongera · 22/10/2026 09:26

In the OPs original post she states he treated her horribly, waiting for her outside class rooms and bus stops and getting his friends to intimidate her. Suddenly he is Prince charming, with the minor blip of his criminal scarring.

A child cannot consent to this. He is old enough to be prosecuted for it.

I can just imagine the mess he has made of his home made tattoo.

Too many Mills and Boon readers in this thread desperate for a happy ending with no insight to the real world.

No, its called realism and understanding the challenges of a young underage couple.

Your take appears to be that there is no hope of redemption for a child, and he is a child, who has been poorly guided and supported and has behaved badly! Really? It's that attitude that leads to many problematic adults in society.

From what the OP has described, there are several things that can all be true at once. He treated her appallingly. His father's behaviour sounds appalling too.
The girl and her mother have good reasons to be cautious. He may genuinely have changed and stepped up as a father. Supporting a young father can be important for the baby.

What I think people are guilty of, is freezing someone in time. If a 14-year-old boy was immature, selfish, frightened, influenced by a poor role model, and acted horribly when faced with a pregnancy, that doesn't automatically mean he will still be exactly the same person a year later. The key thing for me is the evidence. Not "he says he's changed", but "has he changed?". According to the OPs account he's helping with the baby. He's maintained the relationship.
The daughter believes they now have a loving relationship. He's remained involved despite receiving little support from his own family. Those are all positive indicators.

On the other hand, the tattooing-with-initials allegation and the daughter's previous fear are not small concerns. If those events happened as described, I'd be reluctant simply to dismiss them as teenage stupidity. They warrant continued vigilance, particularly because coercive behaviour can sometimes ease off and then return.

Where I differ from many of the posters on the thread is that I don't think a caravan holiday is automatically reckless. I'd actually view it as a test of responsible behaviour. Conditions I might expect would be contraception is being used reliably. They understand there won't be another pregnancy on the adults' watch. He helps with childcare during the holiday. Adults remain in charge. Separate sleeping arrangements if that's the family's rule. Any disrespectful or controlling behaviour results in consequences.

In many ways, he's not just "the boyfriend". He's the baby's father. That changes the calculation. The baby benefits if both parents are encouraged to develop healthy parenting habits and a cooperative relationship, whether they remain together as a couple or not.

What strikes me most is that some commenters seem to be focusing solely on punishing him for past behaviour. Whilst it shouldn't be ignored, the change should be acknowledged and encouraged or what hope is there for anyone who ever makes a mistake? But the adults' primary responsibility now is arguably the baby's welfare. If encouraging a positive co-parenting relationship helps that child, that's worth considering.

The only part where I'd hesitate is the OPs apparent unwillingness to speak to his father because of the "slag" comment. I completely understand her feelings, but a 15-year-old can't simply be taken away for a holiday without parental consent, and maintaining some level of civil communication between the adults may be necessary. Has there been a DNA test? She doesn't have to forgive him, but she probably does have to deal with him. So my own position would be: Would I automatically say yes? No. Would I automatically say no because of his past behaviour? Also no.

If he has genuinely been consistently involved, supportive, respectful, and responsible over several months, then allowing him to come with clear boundaries seems entirely reasonable. It may do more to encourage good fathering and responsible co-parenting than excluding him.

There is a difference between an abusive adult and an abusive child. Many readers are viewing him through the lens of "dangerous boyfriend", whereas I'm also viewing him as "a frightened child who became a father at 14 and appears to be trying to do the right thing now". Both perspectives have some validity.

The truth is probably somewhere in the middle, which is why supervision and boundaries matter more than either blind trust or outright rejection.

Gossipisgood · 04/11/2026 16:46

I'd let him come with you. He stays with her on a weekend so what are you afraid of them being together on holiday with you there too? It's a bit late to be worried about them being underage isn't it? It'll give you the chance to see him around your DD & DGS & how he is 24/7 with them. If he really has changed for the baby's sake you'll see for yourself if he's being honest or not.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page