No, its called realism and understanding the challenges of a young underage couple.
Your take appears to be that there is no hope of redemption for a child, and he is a child, who has been poorly guided and supported and has behaved badly! Really? It's that attitude that leads to many problematic adults in society.
From what the OP has described, there are several things that can all be true at once. He treated her appallingly. His father's behaviour sounds appalling too.
The girl and her mother have good reasons to be cautious. He may genuinely have changed and stepped up as a father. Supporting a young father can be important for the baby.
What I think people are guilty of, is freezing someone in time. If a 14-year-old boy was immature, selfish, frightened, influenced by a poor role model, and acted horribly when faced with a pregnancy, that doesn't automatically mean he will still be exactly the same person a year later. The key thing for me is the evidence. Not "he says he's changed", but "has he changed?". According to the OPs account he's helping with the baby. He's maintained the relationship.
The daughter believes they now have a loving relationship. He's remained involved despite receiving little support from his own family. Those are all positive indicators.
On the other hand, the tattooing-with-initials allegation and the daughter's previous fear are not small concerns. If those events happened as described, I'd be reluctant simply to dismiss them as teenage stupidity. They warrant continued vigilance, particularly because coercive behaviour can sometimes ease off and then return.
Where I differ from many of the posters on the thread is that I don't think a caravan holiday is automatically reckless. I'd actually view it as a test of responsible behaviour. Conditions I might expect would be contraception is being used reliably. They understand there won't be another pregnancy on the adults' watch. He helps with childcare during the holiday. Adults remain in charge. Separate sleeping arrangements if that's the family's rule. Any disrespectful or controlling behaviour results in consequences.
In many ways, he's not just "the boyfriend". He's the baby's father. That changes the calculation. The baby benefits if both parents are encouraged to develop healthy parenting habits and a cooperative relationship, whether they remain together as a couple or not.
What strikes me most is that some commenters seem to be focusing solely on punishing him for past behaviour. Whilst it shouldn't be ignored, the change should be acknowledged and encouraged or what hope is there for anyone who ever makes a mistake? But the adults' primary responsibility now is arguably the baby's welfare. If encouraging a positive co-parenting relationship helps that child, that's worth considering.
The only part where I'd hesitate is the OPs apparent unwillingness to speak to his father because of the "slag" comment. I completely understand her feelings, but a 15-year-old can't simply be taken away for a holiday without parental consent, and maintaining some level of civil communication between the adults may be necessary. Has there been a DNA test? She doesn't have to forgive him, but she probably does have to deal with him. So my own position would be: Would I automatically say yes? No. Would I automatically say no because of his past behaviour? Also no.
If he has genuinely been consistently involved, supportive, respectful, and responsible over several months, then allowing him to come with clear boundaries seems entirely reasonable. It may do more to encourage good fathering and responsible co-parenting than excluding him.
There is a difference between an abusive adult and an abusive child. Many readers are viewing him through the lens of "dangerous boyfriend", whereas I'm also viewing him as "a frightened child who became a father at 14 and appears to be trying to do the right thing now". Both perspectives have some validity.
The truth is probably somewhere in the middle, which is why supervision and boundaries matter more than either blind trust or outright rejection.