Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not encourage a friendship because parents are CFs.

155 replies

Icecreamandcoffee · 16/10/2026 17:28

DD (5) made a new friend last year in the summer term, let's call her Jane. We have just entered the era of unaccompanied playdates last summer. Summer holidays come round and DDs new friends mum messages about her DD coming for a playdate. I say yes that's fine. Playdate was supposed to only be a couple of hours but the night before I got a text from the mum asking for playdate to start at 9 as Dad was dropping off, then a text later saying she would collect but she was working till 3 so could she collect at 4? It was too late to really cancel it as DD was very excited. I did not agree to any other playdates for the rest of the summer and claimed we were busy. As it happened we ran into Jane having playdates at several other people's houses at various free and cheap activities going on during the summer. It seems Jane's mum and dad pretty much went round the whole class asking for playdates, then pretty much changed the times to 9-4 so neither had to use AL. It became a bit of a discussion between a lot of mums by the end of the summer holidays as quite a few mums felt very used - there are quite a few of us in DDs class on Maternity leave or have only just started going back to work so are not back working full hours yet (me included).

Anyway, since September when DD went into yr1 the friendship has drifted. They are sat on different tables it seems and DD has become closer to other friends. Earlier this week Jane's mum posted in the class Whatsapp about anyone wanting to do playdates over the holidays? She's had no takers. Those who responded have mentioned they are very busy over the holidays so will struggle to do a playdate, us included. We are genuinely busy catching up with friends, family and DD has a dance show at the end of November with a couple of rehearsals in the next few weekends.

Last night I got a text from Jane's mum asking if there was any possibility of a playdate at all in the holidays and that Jane misses DD since they are in different tables. DD isn't really bothered about Jane, also the last playdate they had in the summer was really hard work as it was 9-4 and they got fed up of each other and bickered. I'm kind of glad that the friendship has fizzled back a bit as it makes saying no to what are essentially cf childcare playdates easier as DD isn't good friends with Jane.

AIBU to let this fizzle out and not help. I have enough on with 2 small DC and don't want to be childcare for someone who cba to take AL and won't reciprocate a playdate and will effectively lie the night before to cover their working hours.

OP posts:
AmnesiacDream · 17/10/2026 08:06

"After the trick you pulled in the summer? Not a chance. You'll have to pay for childcare this time."

Edit to add, since so many posters are too literal: No, I don't think you should really send this. But it's so tempting...

DRose3 · 17/10/2026 08:23

This isn’t about CFs but about adults making sure that children are safe. Including all the parents that are aware of what is going on here - we all have a responsibility to ensure we are looking out for vulnerable children. This scenario points to a much wider issue at home.

In this instance I would be alerting the school and social services. She’s leaving her 5yo child with anyone that will have her all day long (is she not concerned about predatory adults?), and has made no formal childcare arrangements. This is now the second time it is happening.

It is a safeguarding issue. I would be concerned about the child’s wellbeing as a whole.

It is neglectful, and what happens if they don’t find anyone? Never mind the impact on their DDs ability to maintain friendships because of the manipulative mother’s behaviour. Seems like there is not even emotional concern, I would be worried about what goes on in their home. That poor child…

When I was 21 I lived abroad in an apartment building for a short time, and the mother in the apt below mine was constantly screaming abuse at her lovely young daughter. I hadn’t been there very long, but from what I recall on one of the days she had hit her daughter and it had escalated. I don’t quite remember all the details.

But as neighbours we were very concerned and spoke about what had happened in the hours after it happened, and the police were alerted. We all ended up providing statements to the police and things improved somewhat for the child. She moved out of home very quickly once she was old enough.

Mrcollinswave · 17/10/2026 08:29

FatMrsHoot · 17/10/2026 01:14

The fannying about is because no one wants to get into an escalating situation with a CF. Not everyone is confrontational, and you've got 7 years of seeing these people at primary school.

Do you really think this person is clever enough to manipulate people into giving her free childcare, but too stupid to know that she's likely upsetting or offending the other mums with her behaviour?

Honestly, what do you think get response will be?

Of course she knows. But she needs to know the other mums are not stupid either! She ought to think about the effect on her daughter too. That's the point in not fannying about. Ok?

Icecreamandcoffee · 17/10/2026 08:30

Daisymail · 16/10/2026 21:28

Ignore her message, you do not need to explain to her how you spend your time.

I am slightly baffled that you all previously agreed to 9-4 play dates! Surely the penny dropped that you were providing free childcare/ free meals for the day. They must have been congratulating themselves on how clever they were!

I think it's the way they did it. The original time playdate was arranged before they broke up from school. Very much as a "Jane would like to see x, we are quite busy but could do Wednesday x of August". We were also busy those first couple of weeks so didn't really notice what others were doing.

The penny did drop for everyone about week 4 of the summer holidays. We have an active class WhatsApp and with quite a few of us on Maternity leave or only just going back to work and then several mums who work in schools or term time only jobs, a lot of us were putting messages in the group like "going to X if anyone wants to join". We all started noticing that Jane was tagging along to all of them with someone different and she was always at someone's house until 4. By then we had already had our "playdate". Also, Jane (been 5) was not subtle. When she visited our house she told me that she had already been to play for the day at Sally, Hannah, Sarah, Sam, Billy, Harry, Tom, Susan, Emily and Daniel's houses this holiday. She was telling everyone about her playdates. For example once we met a few mums in the park and Jane Piped up, Hi Harry, Tom, Sally, Susan and George, then I've been to all your houses this holiday. Remember when I played at yours x, we did this. She was doing this at nearly every meetup that was happening.

As PP have said, I'm not going to confront the mum about her behavior, just be unavailable and busy every time she asks. Our class parents are generally easy-going and friendly and I don't want to create an atmosphere as we have 5 more years of this. It seems other mums are thinking the same.

As I said, my DD's friendship has drifted but it may start back up again in later yeats. It's more that this holiday, we will probably attend a couple of casual meetups with the class - there are already several of us going to soft play with the new boy's mum. Even when friendships have drifted we had still done casual meetups when it suits and sometimes the kids strike up that friendship again. I wasn't sure if I was mean to actually not try to facilitate a meetup with Jane. Especially as when kids are younger a lot of friendships are facilitated by the parents seeing each other.

OP posts:
AralVorkosigan · 17/10/2026 08:35

Well if you want to facilitate at all you could go for “yes (DD’s name) would love to come and see Jane, we’re pretty busy but I could drop her to you at 9am on Wednesday and then collect her at 11 on our way to visit family?”

It (politely) makes clear that’s a normal length of play date, it’s Jane’s mum’s turn to host, and there is zero chance of extending the play date for longer hours or of you agreeing to have Jane for longer or take her with you for the rest of the day.

Obviously it’s fair enough if you’d prefer just to avoid them entirely! I feel a little sad for Jane who is going from constant daily play dates to none at all, but of course that’s not something you’re obliged to fix.

DRose3 · 17/10/2026 08:39

As per my post please alert to the school and ss - it’s a safeguarding concern.

And, safeguarding the vulnerable is everyone’s business.

AralVorkosigan · 17/10/2026 08:40

Adding to above - we had a mum like this at our school for a while (she’s now left to move closer to family).

Pretty quickly we all cottoned on, and if she asked for a play date I would just reply “we could do a couple of hours that day, but have to go out by x time, would that work for you? “ and then she’d have to admit that she was looking to drop her kid to me for the day and I already had a built in “ah sorry no, like I said we’re going out at x time, am sure you’ll get sorted!”.

But a few times she did say yes, and it was just a normal play date which was nice for the kids. I felt like I wanted to leave the door open for real playdates as my kid did like hers.

Poppingby · 17/10/2026 08:45

I think you should be blunt. 'We're busy Angela sorry. We take annual leave to cover holidays (or whatever you do), have you thought about doing that? We love Jane in our house but we can't offer free childcare. Hope you get sorted.'

IamnotSethRogan · 17/10/2026 08:52

You could say "yes, when should I drop DD to your house?"

Bikenutz · 17/10/2026 08:53

I would just say no, that doesn’t work for us, sorry.

Goldengirl123 · 17/10/2026 09:03

I would have to reply in the group WhatsApp that she is asking for childcare rather than a play date

HatStickBoots · 17/10/2026 09:08

This is an awkward one. The parents of Jane need a friendly talking to, nothing passive aggressive or confrontational but simply put across in a sincere firm but fair manner. My worry is that the various children will start thinking that Jane is a social pariah and nastiness will incur. The child is bound to feel the effects of having two cf parents. It’s not a play date when you are being a childminder for seven hours, so you can definitely point that out. When I was a child my mother might ask another mum if she would mind looking after me after school for an hour with their child who may or may not like me, it was never “Hat wants to have a play date with Em, can she stay with you after school?” It was “Would you mind looking after Hat for me after school for an hour? I’d be really grateful, I can’t get home from work until then.” Everyone knew where they stood. Nobody needs to make this sound like it’s Jane’s fault.

Daisymail · 17/10/2026 13:04

Yes, going forward, regardless of how friendly the girls are, you need to be unavailable, no explanation required. I would be furious that they made a conscious decision to deceive you.

There is a genuine safeguarding issue here in that both parents are happily sending their young child off to spend full days with adults they barely know along with multiple strangers who may also be visiting the house. If anything untoward happened, you would be held entirely responsible.

Wonkybaby · 17/10/2026 18:00

My kids are a bit older and I give zero fucks but I’d probably reply, no sorry were busy, good luck finding childcare.
let her know that you know what she’s up to. She needs to figure out childcare like the rest of us.

kisaki333 · 17/10/2026 18:25

Not to derail the thread but drop off playdate at the end of reception? Is that a thing? My dd has only just started reception but i can't imagine that not even 1 year from now I'll be able to just drop her off at a friend's house and pick her up a few hours later? Is that the done thing?

CorkedWellbeing · 17/10/2026 18:25

I'd say "That sounds lovely! I can't host again, but we could come to you or perhaps we could all meet at X café at X time?"

I feel sorry for Jane not being welcome back because of her mother's dodgy actions, but I can totally see why you might feel that you can't give an inch or they'll badger you relentlessly for a mile.

springtome · 17/10/2026 18:44

Being a working mum is hard but be open and honest with friends! I have a friend who I met through my kids (we are still friends even though kids are adults). She was a SAHM and maybe once on twice a year would have my kids while we worked. But she knew from the off that is was a full day while I worked (she offered if we ever needed it) and it was never framed as a play dates. Yes our kids were the same age but ultimately this helped me and DH more than the kids.

Jorge14 · 17/10/2026 18:47

How about when she asks say - sure, can the play date be at your house this time as I’m tied up with activities with my other kids. If/when she says no, just say - will have to be another time then, we are too busy. Honestly people are unbelievable

AralVorkosigan · 17/10/2026 19:32

kisaki333 · 17/10/2026 18:25

Not to derail the thread but drop off playdate at the end of reception? Is that a thing? My dd has only just started reception but i can't imagine that not even 1 year from now I'll be able to just drop her off at a friend's house and pick her up a few hours later? Is that the done thing?

It varies a lot. Some people did do drop off play dates during reception, and then more in year 1. By year 2 virtually all of the kids were fine doing drop off playdates.

Airyfairy77 · 17/10/2026 20:13

I wouldn’t be able to hold my tongue and would subtly tell CF know that word is going around that she’s after free childcare during school hols and see if she is still cheeky enough to carry on asking/hinting!

kisaki333 · 17/10/2026 20:16

@AralVorkosiganthank you, that is encouraging! Not that i would use other parents as childcare (lol at the CF in this thread!) But dd is very clingy atm. Nice to know this might change soon...

Grendel7 · 17/10/2026 22:33

Icecreamandcoffee · 16/10/2026 17:28

DD (5) made a new friend last year in the summer term, let's call her Jane. We have just entered the era of unaccompanied playdates last summer. Summer holidays come round and DDs new friends mum messages about her DD coming for a playdate. I say yes that's fine. Playdate was supposed to only be a couple of hours but the night before I got a text from the mum asking for playdate to start at 9 as Dad was dropping off, then a text later saying she would collect but she was working till 3 so could she collect at 4? It was too late to really cancel it as DD was very excited. I did not agree to any other playdates for the rest of the summer and claimed we were busy. As it happened we ran into Jane having playdates at several other people's houses at various free and cheap activities going on during the summer. It seems Jane's mum and dad pretty much went round the whole class asking for playdates, then pretty much changed the times to 9-4 so neither had to use AL. It became a bit of a discussion between a lot of mums by the end of the summer holidays as quite a few mums felt very used - there are quite a few of us in DDs class on Maternity leave or have only just started going back to work so are not back working full hours yet (me included).

Anyway, since September when DD went into yr1 the friendship has drifted. They are sat on different tables it seems and DD has become closer to other friends. Earlier this week Jane's mum posted in the class Whatsapp about anyone wanting to do playdates over the holidays? She's had no takers. Those who responded have mentioned they are very busy over the holidays so will struggle to do a playdate, us included. We are genuinely busy catching up with friends, family and DD has a dance show at the end of November with a couple of rehearsals in the next few weekends.

Last night I got a text from Jane's mum asking if there was any possibility of a playdate at all in the holidays and that Jane misses DD since they are in different tables. DD isn't really bothered about Jane, also the last playdate they had in the summer was really hard work as it was 9-4 and they got fed up of each other and bickered. I'm kind of glad that the friendship has fizzled back a bit as it makes saying no to what are essentially cf childcare playdates easier as DD isn't good friends with Jane.

AIBU to let this fizzle out and not help. I have enough on with 2 small DC and don't want to be childcare for someone who cba to take AL and won't reciprocate a playdate and will effectively lie the night before to cover their working hours.

What is a CF?

OriginalSkang · 17/10/2026 22:47

Grendel7 · 17/10/2026 22:33

What is a CF?

A cheeky fucker

Pieandchips999 · 17/10/2026 22:59

OriginalSkang · 17/10/2026 22:47

A cheeky fucker

Although I thought it stood for C*nt Face for quite a while which does but a different spin on things

Nearly50omg · 17/10/2026 23:06

Just be blunt and ask her if she’s asking for an actual play date or free childcare!

Swipe left for the next trending thread