Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s rude that a girl’s mum is inviting her round to play with DD on a pre-existing play date?

255 replies

Unreaaass · 15/10/2026 21:36

DD is in year 4 and has a very set best friend since nursery school. They tend to have weekly play dates and monthly sleepovers. This friend is coming over on Saturday for a play and a sleepover.

Also there’s another girl in DD’s class that, previously, DD had said was a bit mean and she didn’t like. This other girl and DD were in the same summer holiday club in August and DD said the girl had changed and she liked her now. So they played a bit at our house and the girl’s house (no sleepovers). Anyway, a few weeks ago DD said she doesn’t like this girl anymore as she’s back to being mean. DD had apparently told her “if you’re mean like that, I don’t want to play” and the girl kept doing it.

Anyway I have just looked at my phone and this girl’s mother has messsged “Hi A, could B come round for a play date and a sleepover on Saturday? She’s been hearing about C and D talking about it and she doesn’t want to miss out!” With lots of laughing and praying emojis.

I have two older daughters so I thought I’d heard it all! (Also DD having older sisters means she’s quite good at holding her boundaries and understanding play dynamics etc).

Anyway, DH says it’s fine for this mum to ask. Just say no. But then I look like the bad guy!

AIBU?

(I am going to say no, btw, as DD won’t want her to come.)

OP posts:
VeronicaDean · 16/10/2026 12:09

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:50

Agreed - and it does sort of sound like a response descending into or over involved in playground squabbles

I'd see it as more of a teaching opportunity.

If this girl is never invited to things, and her Mum has no idea why, how can she help her?

It's generally helpful for people of all ages to understand the importance of being likeable (not to be confused with being a people pleaser). That doesn't mean changing who you are but it does mean being aware of how you make others feel. If others don't like the way you make them feel, then they're not going to include you.

Now, once you are aware of your behaviours that others dislike, you can choose whether to continue in that way, and accept you will likely be excluded, or adapt your behaviour to something people find more pleasant. Alternatively, you may feel others are unreasonable in not liking your behaviour, in which case, those aren't relationships to foster.

Cakeandslippers · 16/10/2026 12:33

A similar thing happened to me. My dd was having a friend round after school, it isn't something we do often as I am normally at work. Another mum found out and text me that day asking for her daughter to be included as she would be sad if I left her out. Her daughter is absolutely lovely and I did feel bad, I didn't want to 2 kids round but I caved and said yes even thought I felt it was rude of her to put me on the spot.

What I feared might happen did - the two girls spent the whole time playing while my dd played on her own. She was fine, she enjoys her own company or being 1.1 so it wasn't a surprise and she still had fun but I really kicked myself and felt I'd let her down.

It has never happened since! She asked again a few months later and I said something like 'no sorry, I think it's better we just do 1.1 play dates, we can meet up another time though?' and it was fine. I am glad I learned my lesson with a minor incident like this where no one got upset.

I think what happens sometimes is that people cannot bear the idea of their child experiencing any form of disappointment.

Calliopespa · 16/10/2026 12:38

Constantrunner · 15/10/2026 22:33

Don't do this kind of passive aggressive stuff. It's horrible.

Also it only works until the other mum clarifies - and then you are in a right pickle.

Ilovemyfam · 16/10/2026 12:54

Pleatherandlace · 15/10/2026 22:08

I would avoid making excuses like, there’s too many or we have other plans etc as people have suggested as that will just open the door to more invites which your daughter clearly doesn’t want at present. I think an honest response that you believe the girls are not getting on well currently is probably best.

This for sure is the best response.

MMUmum · 16/10/2026 17:55

Unreaaass · 15/10/2026 21:36

DD is in year 4 and has a very set best friend since nursery school. They tend to have weekly play dates and monthly sleepovers. This friend is coming over on Saturday for a play and a sleepover.

Also there’s another girl in DD’s class that, previously, DD had said was a bit mean and she didn’t like. This other girl and DD were in the same summer holiday club in August and DD said the girl had changed and she liked her now. So they played a bit at our house and the girl’s house (no sleepovers). Anyway, a few weeks ago DD said she doesn’t like this girl anymore as she’s back to being mean. DD had apparently told her “if you’re mean like that, I don’t want to play” and the girl kept doing it.

Anyway I have just looked at my phone and this girl’s mother has messsged “Hi A, could B come round for a play date and a sleepover on Saturday? She’s been hearing about C and D talking about it and she doesn’t want to miss out!” With lots of laughing and praying emojis.

I have two older daughters so I thought I’d heard it all! (Also DD having older sisters means she’s quite good at holding her boundaries and understanding play dynamics etc).

Anyway, DH says it’s fine for this mum to ask. Just say no. But then I look like the bad guy!

AIBU?

(I am going to say no, btw, as DD won’t want her to come.)

Nbu, just say child and your Dd are not getting on together at the minute, so it's not a good idea

Khayker · 16/10/2026 18:01

Pyjamatimenow · 15/10/2026 21:41

Madness. Who the hell has sleepovers at 4? How well do you know the parents of the best friend?
Just say you can’t manage three of them overnight but you’ll arrange a play date soon.

Shes not 4, shes in year 4.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 16/10/2026 18:26

BeardieWeirdie · 15/10/2026 21:40

No, Sarah says that Jenny has been unkind to her - laughing at her glasses, calling her fat, saying she smells - so she doesn’t want Jenny to come and play.

Do not apologise or suggest that she can come in future if she behaves herself!

This is ideal

Sickdissapointed · 16/10/2026 18:43

Similar situation that escalated.
For her birthday offered to pay for dds friend to come to water park. My treat of course.
On the day whole family turned up - ok just one other child to pay for.
But then another family appeared( friends of theirs not ours) and hung around. I paid for us and friends we had invited and made a shap exit to the slides.
I had thoughts ice creams drinks etc for those I had invited. Children from other family turned up at ice cream kiosk - no parents and were asking me for food drinks ice cream. It was the most awkward situation. I didn’t buy for the other family. But felt bad for the children.
Im on a pension and don’t work due to serious ill health. I was stunned.
Cant believe people sometimes.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · 16/10/2026 18:46

Wonder if it's the same cf dm who requests playmates to cover her working hours in the holidays?

exaltedwombat · 16/10/2026 19:29

Nothing terribly wrong about asking. Nothing terribly wrong about you saying no.

Wildefish · 16/10/2026 19:48

Pyjamatimenow · 15/10/2026 21:41

Madness. Who the hell has sleepovers at 4? How well do you know the parents of the best friend?
Just say you can’t manage three of them overnight but you’ll arrange a play date soon.

I think it’s year 4. In uk I believe that would be maybe 9

Brokentoes85 · 16/10/2026 20:00

Nomdeplumeforthis1 · 15/10/2026 21:44

I’m on your husbands side as of course people can ask anything- and you can say no. Advocating for you own child’s needs and opinions is not being a bad guy.

🤣😂🤣😂

That doesn't negate away from them being cheeky.

JMSA · 16/10/2026 20:02

Beyond cheeky. She can host her own bloody sleepovers!

BeardieWeirdie · 16/10/2026 20:06

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:27

Where does OP say that?

OP says her daughter calls the other girl “a bit mean”. My list of examples was hypothetical for OP to swap out with real-life examples of how the other child has behaved to her daughter - I thought that was obvious.

Unreaaass · 16/10/2026 20:55

An update! I’ve had a busy day so missed a lot of these. But thank you for your advice! And I’m glad a lot of people agree with me that it was v cheeky of the mum.

I replied “I’m really sorry B feels like she’s going to miss out! But we’re only at one friend at a time for sleepovers at the moment. But hopefully all the girls can sort out a play date soon. Have a lovely weekend!” Wanted to keep it a bit vague. The mum just thumbs up’d my message, no reply.

Anyway I told DD this morning to try and keep sleepover chat to a minimum if others are around so they don’t feel sad and left out. And also asked her if she wanted B for a play date or a sleepover soon and she said no. (Even though I obviously implied to B’s mum that we could organise something soon. I’m not great at disappointing people!)

DD said B was playing with other children today and seemed fine, so who knows!

OP posts:
Unreaaass · 16/10/2026 21:04

HoppingPavlova · 16/10/2026 01:13

DD is in year 4 and has a very set best friend since nursery school. They tend to have weekly play dates and monthly sleepovers. This friend is coming over on Saturday for a play and a sleepover

This is great but I’d really look to expand your daughters close friend set and not rely on a ‘set best friend’.

I’m several decades old but still recall having the same set up as you describe (but we did sleepovers every weekend alternating houses). Then in Year 4, she moved with her family, nearly 900 miles away. We had been best friends since before starting school from 3yo, so we continued the ‘best friend’ set up at school so when she left I was completely lost. I joined another ‘group’ but it was like a fifth wheel, completely on the periphery. I still recall having to sit by myself in class for the rest of the year and even the following year (Year 5), I was the odd one out in class and had to sit with a boy as everyone else was paired up. Then one day an extra desk showed up in the classroom and mid-morning a new girl started and I offered to sit with her😁, then we became friends but went to different secondary schools.

Given my experience, I always discouraged my kids from having a ‘set best friend’ when younger but instead a range of closer friends and that worked out well for all of them.

I totally get that! DD is always encouraged to make new friends - and did make friends with B at holiday club.

DD has two older sisters and is always around lots of children because of that, but she likes the company of this girl so much. They have the exact same very sweet play style.

I don’t know how things will go in the future, hopefully this family won’t move away (I know they don’t plan to as we know each other quite well, but life happens!). And, as the girls get older, of course they could drift. But I certainly don’t discourage DD from playing with lots of different children. But she doesn’t want to be friends with B right now as B can get a little bit mean.

OP posts:
Unreaaass · 16/10/2026 21:32

nunamenuyear · 16/10/2026 09:35

Of course you can say no but when I was 7 or 8 ( now in my 60s) I still remember begging my mother to phone another mum as 2 girls in my class I considered my friends ( though with hindsight one was in fact my bully - hello Iona Michael) were having an after school play date which they talked about endlessly and I just felt so left out. My mum did phone ( reluctantly) and I went along and can’t remember anything about it- but I still remember that feeling of being excluded.

As I’m sure you know Year 4 is a prime age for meanness in small girls. I would talk to your daughter about sharing and being kind to all her class mates and ask how she feels about having the excluded girl over to play or sleepover by herself .

Since your daughter got on fine with the other girl over the summer when best friend was absent, I would also wonder whether best friend is actually bullying the other girl and dictating who your daughter can play with out of jealousy - in which case it would be a very good idea for your daughter not to solely dependent on her for friendship as former best friends can become bullies.

That sounds awful!

Yes you’re right about year 4 friendships. There was some drama with my middle daughter and finding a group.

In this case, I am sure DD is right that B has a tendency to be unkind (it’s not the first time someone has told me - I’ve heard it from the mum of a boy in the class). I’m also sure that B wasn’t mean at holiday club as they weren’t around their usual classmates. And yes, DD was in the market for a friend then! I also wonder if B being mean again at the beginning of term was because DD was back with her friend and B was jealous, which I don’t blame her for. The trouble is, when B is mean, she’s really not nice (name calling, pushing). I do feel sorry for B. I know she’s frustrated and lonely and not sure what else to do. But I don’t want to tell DD to put up with all that. If she doesn’t want to be friends with her, that’s her choice.

And DD said B was playing with other children today and having a nice time.

OP posts:
Zerosleep · 16/10/2026 22:38

”thanks for reaching out but DD doesn’t want to invite her so it’s a no”

Ratcherinthepye · 16/10/2026 23:41

That was a great response IMO, Op. I liked how you didn’t actually take responsibility for organising a future play date - you being vague kind of threw the ball back into her court since there’s nothing to say she can’t set one up. And the good thing is Bs mum probably won’t bother to set up a play date so you’re likely all off the hook. But obviously if she does your daughter can just decline.

The fact she just replied by emoji instead of saying something like “great thanks for letting me know, hope the girls have fun and I’ll see about organising a play date for them soon” is very telling but not surprising.

Idk maybe she’ll reply properly later, but I suspect her and her daughter are both quite entitled and don’t like the word no she’s a bit irked right now.

AmnesiacDream · 16/10/2026 23:41

Unreaaass · 16/10/2026 20:55

An update! I’ve had a busy day so missed a lot of these. But thank you for your advice! And I’m glad a lot of people agree with me that it was v cheeky of the mum.

I replied “I’m really sorry B feels like she’s going to miss out! But we’re only at one friend at a time for sleepovers at the moment. But hopefully all the girls can sort out a play date soon. Have a lovely weekend!” Wanted to keep it a bit vague. The mum just thumbs up’d my message, no reply.

Anyway I told DD this morning to try and keep sleepover chat to a minimum if others are around so they don’t feel sad and left out. And also asked her if she wanted B for a play date or a sleepover soon and she said no. (Even though I obviously implied to B’s mum that we could organise something soon. I’m not great at disappointing people!)

DD said B was playing with other children today and seemed fine, so who knows!

Hopefully B's mum has suggested she widen who she plays with, which would probably be better for DD and B.

Jadebanditchillipepper · 17/10/2026 01:32

Never criticise another person's child (unless you absolutely have to), with bullying etc, get the school to deal with it

For this, I would just say "I'm afraid that doesn't work for us" and repeat as infinitum if she comes back with further questions/demands

Olu123 · 17/10/2026 05:38

I must be the only one that doesn’t see anything wrong in the mum asking! She obviously has a different view of the dynamics of the relationship and doesn’t know her daughter is seen as mean.
Of course you should say no as your daughter doesn’t really get on with her but don’t see why she couldn’t have asked

Opine · 17/10/2026 07:10

@Olu123 Would you ask? Would you not realise that choices were made and inviting your child wasn’t one of them? Why would you want them to be somewhere they weren’t wanted?

Ratcherinthepye · 17/10/2026 07:13

Olu123 · 17/10/2026 05:38

I must be the only one that doesn’t see anything wrong in the mum asking! She obviously has a different view of the dynamics of the relationship and doesn’t know her daughter is seen as mean.
Of course you should say no as your daughter doesn’t really get on with her but don’t see why she couldn’t have asked

I am surprised you don’t see anything wrong in this. It’s a principle I’ve grasped at a basic level since I was a child. Even as a year 4 student I’d never have asked my mum to ask a classmate if I could come to something I’d not been invited to.

It’s more something I’d expect of a 6 year old and certainly not from an adult .

Inviting yourself/your kid is rude and unwise because the person may accept only because they feel awkward saying no, plus you/your child is going where their presence is just merely tolerated rather than their presence genuinely desired.

If they wanted her daughter there - they obviously would have asked her! This applies to anything be it a play date, a party or a sleepover, a girls trip!

Ratcherinthepye · 17/10/2026 07:29

I remember these 2 girls I was best friends with from age 17 to late 20s. They had both met through me and were now best friends too. A few years after i relocated to another part of the UK I noticed increasingly I was being pushed out of plans and I noticed on social media they were organising a trip to another city.

I was pretty stung, especially when the pictures came out and I saw them happily posing on girls trip. But I respected their choice and took a step back from both of them.

I never saw either of them again and eventually the friendship faded to nothing, and we unfollowed each other on socials.

As hurt as I was at the time I am glad I let it go with dignity and didn’t chase them or force myself into their social plans.

Maybe it was a case of out of sight, out of mind or maybe they just grew to dislike me!

Who knows, but either way no way was I going to rock up and be an unwanted third wheel. I just focused on my other friendships as thankfully I had many other close friends and I moved on.

I am really glad I learnt that lesson early
in life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread