Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s rude that a girl’s mum is inviting her round to play with DD on a pre-existing play date?

255 replies

Unreaaass · 15/10/2026 21:36

DD is in year 4 and has a very set best friend since nursery school. They tend to have weekly play dates and monthly sleepovers. This friend is coming over on Saturday for a play and a sleepover.

Also there’s another girl in DD’s class that, previously, DD had said was a bit mean and she didn’t like. This other girl and DD were in the same summer holiday club in August and DD said the girl had changed and she liked her now. So they played a bit at our house and the girl’s house (no sleepovers). Anyway, a few weeks ago DD said she doesn’t like this girl anymore as she’s back to being mean. DD had apparently told her “if you’re mean like that, I don’t want to play” and the girl kept doing it.

Anyway I have just looked at my phone and this girl’s mother has messsged “Hi A, could B come round for a play date and a sleepover on Saturday? She’s been hearing about C and D talking about it and she doesn’t want to miss out!” With lots of laughing and praying emojis.

I have two older daughters so I thought I’d heard it all! (Also DD having older sisters means she’s quite good at holding her boundaries and understanding play dynamics etc).

Anyway, DH says it’s fine for this mum to ask. Just say no. But then I look like the bad guy!

AIBU?

(I am going to say no, btw, as DD won’t want her to come.)

OP posts:
ilovepuppies2019 · 16/10/2026 07:18

I would really put a stop to your daughter talking about this in the playground. From this other girl's perspective, the three girls are friends but the OP's daughter and her little bestie and leaving this other girl out. The OP's daughter and the bestie may well be telling the other girl that she can't play with them at lunchtime because she doesn't know the game they play at home with their teddies. From this mother's perspective, it may well be the OP's daughter doing the excluding and the bullying and she's trying to advocate for her very upset daughter. Obviously the mother is way out of line trying to get her daughter into an existing sleepover.

Moonnstarz · 16/10/2026 07:19

On the face of it it sounds rude but I bet there is more to this.
Girls can be particularly mean to each other, you said the other girl is apparently mean to your DD but this could also be a two way thing that you are unaware of and they are 'mean' to her too.
Maybe your DD and her friend have been openly talking about the sleepover and even using this as a bargaining tool. 'If you play our game then you can come'.
Maybe the other girl was under the impression she would be invited, and maybe this is the parents way of perhaps having a bit of a dig at you/your DD.

Girls are definitely harder in terms of friendship. Even in KS1 girls do the 'you're not my friend' or 'Have a secret but only Beth can know, we want to be alone' (leaving out another usual member of their group.

BreezyAzureHiker · 16/10/2026 07:22

A furious woman turned up on my doorstep once, complaining that my (nine year old) daughter had 'stolen' her daughter's best friend. I just said that these things happen, I never interfere, and yes, life is tough.

Sartre · 16/10/2026 07:24

LoveWine123 · 16/10/2026 07:15

But surely if you are trying to encourage a friendship then you would invite the child to your house for a play date? And then you can see who’s mean and who’s not. The solution can’t be that you invite yourself to someone else’s house or push in on someone else’s plans.

Hm perhaps. I think she recognises that other girls are having sleepovers and her DD doesn’t get invited but wants to experience one. She probably thinks they’re still friends, the summer holidays were only a few weeks ago after all.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 16/10/2026 07:26

Moonnstarz · 16/10/2026 07:19

On the face of it it sounds rude but I bet there is more to this.
Girls can be particularly mean to each other, you said the other girl is apparently mean to your DD but this could also be a two way thing that you are unaware of and they are 'mean' to her too.
Maybe your DD and her friend have been openly talking about the sleepover and even using this as a bargaining tool. 'If you play our game then you can come'.
Maybe the other girl was under the impression she would be invited, and maybe this is the parents way of perhaps having a bit of a dig at you/your DD.

Girls are definitely harder in terms of friendship. Even in KS1 girls do the 'you're not my friend' or 'Have a secret but only Beth can know, we want to be alone' (leaving out another usual member of their group.

I have a boy and a girl and boys do this too. “You can’t play with us - you’re rubbish at football” or whatever. I never understand why people think this is a “girl” thing. The boys in my kids primary school are particularly keen on “roasting” people at the moment. Calling people fat, insulting their appearance. Leaving people out and being unkind is not particular to girls. What I have noticed though is that the boys (some boys I guess I should say) tend to be mean to everyone - boys and girls. I don’t hear of girls being unkind to boys. Not saying it doesn’t happen at all, I just don’t hear it.

IStillHearTheWaves · 16/10/2026 07:28

Wow, astoundingly rude and I don't think it is OK to ask in this instance, actually. Kids need to learn that they're not always invited. It's not like it's a class party and one child was excluded, it's a sleepover between two best friends! I suspect this is also why this kid is mean - always gets her own way and parents give in to her demands.

'Sorry, don't think I can manage three! [Insert frazzled emoji]'.

ISpyNoPlumPie · 16/10/2026 07:28

OP, I think it’s outrageous to ask. I would have to give a short but factual no but I’d be so annoyed to be put it than position. As many others have said you can offer to host, you don’t impose.

TheBlueKoala · 16/10/2026 07:30

No matter how hard my son pushed I would NEVER try to get him invited somewhere. Wtf. This is when you as a parent explain to your child that it's not polite to invite oneself but we can invite A and C at another occasion.

@Unreaaass I would avoid this family altogether; girl has been mean to your DD and the mum is a CF lacking manners and is raising her dd to become an entitled CF as well.

localnotail · 16/10/2026 07:30

OP - you are not being unreasonable at all, I get the mum of the other girl might not understand the dynamic so I would just politely suggest another day and leave it at that.

As a side note - amount of people on MN not understanding the difference between, for example, Year 4 and a 4 year old! I guess they are not from UK?

Moonnstarz · 16/10/2026 07:31

ISpyNoPlumPie · 16/10/2026 07:26

I have a boy and a girl and boys do this too. “You can’t play with us - you’re rubbish at football” or whatever. I never understand why people think this is a “girl” thing. The boys in my kids primary school are particularly keen on “roasting” people at the moment. Calling people fat, insulting their appearance. Leaving people out and being unkind is not particular to girls. What I have noticed though is that the boys (some boys I guess I should say) tend to be mean to everyone - boys and girls. I don’t hear of girls being unkind to boys. Not saying it doesn’t happen at all, I just don’t hear it.

Because based on my experiences working in a primary school this is a thing that happens daily! Girls are always doing the your not invited to my party, you can only play with me if you..., I am not your friend any more.

Boys tend to engage in rough play when younger and then fall out over a game 'i wasn't tagged' and then the others complaining they aren't playing properly, but with boys it's resolved easily and quicky and doesn't have the same undercurrent as the girls (because the boys is directed at the game rather than the person generally).

It's interesting the dynamic as they do split off generally into same sex groups and we don't really get the nastiness of calling people fat so that's something at least!

Besidemyselfwithworry · 16/10/2026 07:33

Unreaaass · 15/10/2026 21:36

DD is in year 4 and has a very set best friend since nursery school. They tend to have weekly play dates and monthly sleepovers. This friend is coming over on Saturday for a play and a sleepover.

Also there’s another girl in DD’s class that, previously, DD had said was a bit mean and she didn’t like. This other girl and DD were in the same summer holiday club in August and DD said the girl had changed and she liked her now. So they played a bit at our house and the girl’s house (no sleepovers). Anyway, a few weeks ago DD said she doesn’t like this girl anymore as she’s back to being mean. DD had apparently told her “if you’re mean like that, I don’t want to play” and the girl kept doing it.

Anyway I have just looked at my phone and this girl’s mother has messsged “Hi A, could B come round for a play date and a sleepover on Saturday? She’s been hearing about C and D talking about it and she doesn’t want to miss out!” With lots of laughing and praying emojis.

I have two older daughters so I thought I’d heard it all! (Also DD having older sisters means she’s quite good at holding her boundaries and understanding play dynamics etc).

Anyway, DH says it’s fine for this mum to ask. Just say no. But then I look like the bad guy!

AIBU?

(I am going to say no, btw, as DD won’t want her to come.)

Sorry no is what I’d be saying - how utterly ridiculous

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/10/2026 07:33

FloorToCeilingWindow · 15/10/2026 23:35

Agree.

Just be honest OP. Say that her daughter has been upsetting your daughter and you think it’s best that they don’t have sleepovers for now. If the girls become friends in the future then it will be nice and you can arrange one.

Don’t do this. It’s not “passive aggressive” to behave diplomatically and manage your relationships appropriately. People who wade into their children’s friendships at the drop of a hat are signalling to them that they will always bail their child out emotionally. Its a bad precedent to set.

Friendships between children of this age are like the weather and they may be friends again next week.

Telling this woman “they are not friends” guarantees this comment will go straight back to the child and inflame the relationship between the children. Knowing this mum is a bit pushy she will probably also wade in with her opinions and generally make everything much worse.

You’re well within your rights to say no but you don’t need to overshare based on your child’s highly partial and probably temporary assessment of the friendship.

Just say it doesn’t work for you.

Cherrysoup · 16/10/2026 07:38

Fedupofthisgame · 15/10/2026 22:04

I had a similar situation but my DD was the one who was going to the sleepover at her BFFS house. The third mum just turned up with her DD and her overnight stuff. 🤣 Brazen as fuck.

wtf? That’s mad behaviour! What did the hosting parent do?

napody · 16/10/2026 07:45

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/10/2026 07:33

Don’t do this. It’s not “passive aggressive” to behave diplomatically and manage your relationships appropriately. People who wade into their children’s friendships at the drop of a hat are signalling to them that they will always bail their child out emotionally. Its a bad precedent to set.

Friendships between children of this age are like the weather and they may be friends again next week.

Telling this woman “they are not friends” guarantees this comment will go straight back to the child and inflame the relationship between the children. Knowing this mum is a bit pushy she will probably also wade in with her opinions and generally make everything much worse.

You’re well within your rights to say no but you don’t need to overshare based on your child’s highly partial and probably temporary assessment of the friendship.

Just say it doesn’t work for you.

Edited

Totally agree. It's a bad idea for so many reasons. Another poster suggested encouraging your child to broaden her friendship circle too, which is a good idea. It's very common for established 'best friends' to have a shake up around this age.

Just a "no sorry, not this weekend" is fine.

Ratcherinthepye · 16/10/2026 07:49

zanahoria · 15/10/2026 22:51

Not only rude

Plain weird

I don't get why a parent would do that if they did not know the other family really well

Yeah its quite worrying all these people think she’s not rude. Of course it’s rude and weird as well. I can see where this girl gets her attitude from.

My cousins daughter went to 4 different schools as a kid and was ND and found it hard to fit in every time. My cousin would get quite worried and would speak to the school about it, but she’d never dream of trying to force an invite with a parent.

diddl · 16/10/2026 07:51

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 16/10/2026 06:02

diddl

that is true but the fact that she’s done something this ‘extreme’ (because I’d never ask a parent can my daughter come over) maybe her daughter was so miserable because it does sound like they’ve decided they’re not playing either her any more, her fault but she is only 8, that she did this. Maybe it’s a desperate attempt to get them all back together/ talking

If her daughter is miserable though her mum needs to be looking at why.

If she is being excluded at school that is something.

What kids do outside of school is up to them & her mum can presumably organise things for her daughter rather than foist her daughter into what others are organising.

That won't help the daughter at all.

LoveWine123 · 16/10/2026 07:51

Sartre · 16/10/2026 07:24

Hm perhaps. I think she recognises that other girls are having sleepovers and her DD doesn’t get invited but wants to experience one. She probably thinks they’re still friends, the summer holidays were only a few weeks ago after all.

The easiest way for her child to experience a sleepover is for her mum to organise one at her own house.

allthingsinmoderation · 16/10/2026 07:52

Pyjamatimenow · 15/10/2026 21:41

Madness. Who the hell has sleepovers at 4? How well do you know the parents of the best friend?
Just say you can’t manage three of them overnight but you’ll arrange a play date soon.

The OP said year 4 which is 8-9 yrs old not 4 yrs old.

Comeinsideforacupoftea · 16/10/2026 07:53

'I've spoken to my daughter and she'd prefer it to just be the 2 of them' is all you need to say. Depending on the relationship between you and this mum you could also gently tell her about why dd isn't too keen. You could suggest to your daughter that it might be nice to offer up a playdate with the 3 of them or even just your dd and 3rd girl but only if she wants it.

Has 3rd girl's mum ever offered to have them over or take them out? I have a similar aged dd and what really pisses me off is that the parents who whine most about their kids being left out are the ones who literally never make any effort themselves to nurture their kid's friendships. It works both ways. If this mum is that desperate for a 3 way sleepover with 9YO girls and the inevitable drama that will come from this (trust me!) Then she can go ahead and organise this.

At 9 you definitely need to advocate for your daughter and help her nurture the friendships that she wants but it is way too old to be forcing unwanted playdates and she needs to learn through you how to assert herself.

VeronicaDean · 16/10/2026 07:55

I'd be completely honest...

No, sorry, and I feel you've put me in quite an awkward position by asking.

I'm also not sure about the exact dynamics between X, Y and Z but X tells me Z has been unpleasant to her, recently. I've no idea how much truth there is in that - we all know what 8/9 year old girls are like - but I thought I'd mention it in case you want to speak to Z about it. X tells me that's the reason she didn't invite Z.

Ratcherinthepye · 16/10/2026 07:55

ilovepuppies2019 · 16/10/2026 07:18

I would really put a stop to your daughter talking about this in the playground. From this other girl's perspective, the three girls are friends but the OP's daughter and her little bestie and leaving this other girl out. The OP's daughter and the bestie may well be telling the other girl that she can't play with them at lunchtime because she doesn't know the game they play at home with their teddies. From this mother's perspective, it may well be the OP's daughter doing the excluding and the bullying and she's trying to advocate for her very upset daughter. Obviously the mother is way out of line trying to get her daughter into an existing sleepover.

I am not convinced…If that’s what she genuinely thought surely a more logical approach would be to try and kill them with kindness and to ask when she’s free to come over for a sleepover at their house and invite the third girl too.

I think it’s a case of like mother like daughter. They both are self centred and only consider their own feelings. If OP’s daughter wanted to invite hers, she would’ve. And she knows this. She’s trying to get a yes by putting OPs mum in a difficult position.

I disagree about them not being able to talk about the sleepovers at school. It would be different if every girl in the class was invited and one was left out but that’s not the case here.

People really do have to teach resilience to kids. She’s 8/9, she should be okay at knowing there are two best friends who do their own thing. Especially in this case when she must know she’s been mean to one of them! But I’m sure she didn’t tell her mum that part.

theresnolimits · 16/10/2026 07:59

I was once taking DS and three friends away for a weekend to see a sporting event (about 13) and a woman who I’d never spoken to rang me and asked if I’d take her son too - for three nights. He didn’t want to miss out. I said I couldn’t fit him in the car and she said ‘I’ll drive him there and leave him with you’. That was a hard no. I explained I wasn’t comfortable having a child I’d never even spoken to be my responsibility for the weekend.

Some people have utter brass neck and you need to be just as blunt as they are.

Ratcherinthepye · 16/10/2026 08:04

theresnolimits · 16/10/2026 07:59

I was once taking DS and three friends away for a weekend to see a sporting event (about 13) and a woman who I’d never spoken to rang me and asked if I’d take her son too - for three nights. He didn’t want to miss out. I said I couldn’t fit him in the car and she said ‘I’ll drive him there and leave him with you’. That was a hard no. I explained I wasn’t comfortable having a child I’d never even spoken to be my responsibility for the weekend.

Some people have utter brass neck and you need to be just as blunt as they are.

I am so embarrassed for these people. That your child doesn’t want to “miss out” is not another parent’s concern!

Take them yourself and stay for the 3 nights if you want and if you can’t - just tell them.

Mamabear487 · 16/10/2026 08:05

That’s sooooo rude!

Ratcherinthepye · 16/10/2026 08:07

TheBlueKoala · 16/10/2026 07:30

No matter how hard my son pushed I would NEVER try to get him invited somewhere. Wtf. This is when you as a parent explain to your child that it's not polite to invite oneself but we can invite A and C at another occasion.

@Unreaaass I would avoid this family altogether; girl has been mean to your DD and the mum is a CF lacking manners and is raising her dd to become an entitled CF as well.

And another lesson to give to kids is go where you’re really wanted and celebrated. Not tolerated.

For their kids own self-respect if nothing else they shouldn’t try and force these invites when it’s clear they weren’t wanted.