Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s rude that a girl’s mum is inviting her round to play with DD on a pre-existing play date?

255 replies

Unreaaass · 15/10/2026 21:36

DD is in year 4 and has a very set best friend since nursery school. They tend to have weekly play dates and monthly sleepovers. This friend is coming over on Saturday for a play and a sleepover.

Also there’s another girl in DD’s class that, previously, DD had said was a bit mean and she didn’t like. This other girl and DD were in the same summer holiday club in August and DD said the girl had changed and she liked her now. So they played a bit at our house and the girl’s house (no sleepovers). Anyway, a few weeks ago DD said she doesn’t like this girl anymore as she’s back to being mean. DD had apparently told her “if you’re mean like that, I don’t want to play” and the girl kept doing it.

Anyway I have just looked at my phone and this girl’s mother has messsged “Hi A, could B come round for a play date and a sleepover on Saturday? She’s been hearing about C and D talking about it and she doesn’t want to miss out!” With lots of laughing and praying emojis.

I have two older daughters so I thought I’d heard it all! (Also DD having older sisters means she’s quite good at holding her boundaries and understanding play dynamics etc).

Anyway, DH says it’s fine for this mum to ask. Just say no. But then I look like the bad guy!

AIBU?

(I am going to say no, btw, as DD won’t want her to come.)

OP posts:
rosagarten · 16/10/2026 09:33

Be clear about it but just say no because it doesn't work for YOU and your husband. No need to get into any discussions about the child's character or their on/off friendship, it just isn't necessary.

nunamenuyear · 16/10/2026 09:35

Of course you can say no but when I was 7 or 8 ( now in my 60s) I still remember begging my mother to phone another mum as 2 girls in my class I considered my friends ( though with hindsight one was in fact my bully - hello Iona Michael) were having an after school play date which they talked about endlessly and I just felt so left out. My mum did phone ( reluctantly) and I went along and can’t remember anything about it- but I still remember that feeling of being excluded.

As I’m sure you know Year 4 is a prime age for meanness in small girls. I would talk to your daughter about sharing and being kind to all her class mates and ask how she feels about having the excluded girl over to play or sleepover by herself .

Since your daughter got on fine with the other girl over the summer when best friend was absent, I would also wonder whether best friend is actually bullying the other girl and dictating who your daughter can play with out of jealousy - in which case it would be a very good idea for your daughter not to solely dependent on her for friendship as former best friends can become bullies.

godmum56 · 16/10/2026 09:39

user1464187087 · 15/10/2026 22:31

It's a bit 'My daughter isn't talking to your daughter'. A bit like school ground nonsense.
Surely there is nothing wrong with just saying 'no, not this time'

but that isn't nonsense, its a statement of fact. Childhood friendships do change.

Oakdodger · 16/10/2026 09:50

It's a great opportunity to say
"Sorry Jemima, Arabella hasn't been very kind to Gertrude lately so she isn't keen to play with her at present."

ohbygolly · 16/10/2026 09:53

What a crock of shit.

No. People can't ask anything and not be a bad guy. People can't ignore other people's boundaries, and ask whatever they want. That's not how decent people behave.

Also, playdates and sleepovers are not 'needs'. They fit squarely in the 'wants' bucket. Presenting trying to strong-arm another family into doing what you and your child wants, as 'advocating for their needs and opinions' is self-centred tripe that undermines the true work done by far too many parents who are forced to advocate for their child's genuine needs.

The lack of respect for others in thinking it's okay to ask can your child go to a play date and sleepover is astounding. The idea that is 'rude' is based on a societal acceptance that you shouldn't push other people's boundaries for entirely you own gain.

The OP, her daughter, and the other invited child, have nothing to gain from this child going there. No one was forgotten. No child forgets to invite a friend over. Choices were made. Just because this Mum and her child don't like those choices, doesn't mean they get to force others to explain those choices. They are the only people to gain from this message being sent. Their wants don't give them a carte blanche to try to force someone else's hand. And trying to do so, very definitely makes them the bad guy.

As for others suggesting the Mum may have been forced into it by the child? Learn to parent. No 9 year old forces you to do anything. Deploy the old Mumsnet stock response of 'no'. Apparently it's a complete sentence.

My kids are older now, and the best approach I've found to situations like this and parents like this is: questions that shouldn't be asked needn't be answered. Don't engage. Don't explain.

ohbygolly · 16/10/2026 09:56

ohbygolly · 16/10/2026 09:53

What a crock of shit.

No. People can't ask anything and not be a bad guy. People can't ignore other people's boundaries, and ask whatever they want. That's not how decent people behave.

Also, playdates and sleepovers are not 'needs'. They fit squarely in the 'wants' bucket. Presenting trying to strong-arm another family into doing what you and your child wants, as 'advocating for their needs and opinions' is self-centred tripe that undermines the true work done by far too many parents who are forced to advocate for their child's genuine needs.

The lack of respect for others in thinking it's okay to ask can your child go to a play date and sleepover is astounding. The idea that is 'rude' is based on a societal acceptance that you shouldn't push other people's boundaries for entirely you own gain.

The OP, her daughter, and the other invited child, have nothing to gain from this child going there. No one was forgotten. No child forgets to invite a friend over. Choices were made. Just because this Mum and her child don't like those choices, doesn't mean they get to force others to explain those choices. They are the only people to gain from this message being sent. Their wants don't give them a carte blanche to try to force someone else's hand. And trying to do so, very definitely makes them the bad guy.

As for others suggesting the Mum may have been forced into it by the child? Learn to parent. No 9 year old forces you to do anything. Deploy the old Mumsnet stock response of 'no'. Apparently it's a complete sentence.

My kids are older now, and the best approach I've found to situations like this and parents like this is: questions that shouldn't be asked needn't be answered. Don't engage. Don't explain.

Quote fail on my part there. This was in response to a previous reply:

Nomdeplumeforthis1 · Yesterday 21:44
I’m on your husbands side as of course people can ask anything- and you can say no. Advocating for you own child’s needs and opinions is not being a bad guy.

mcmooberry · 16/10/2026 09:57

MadnessInMyMethod · 16/10/2026 08:50

Fine to say no, but you need to teach your DD that you don't discuss events with other invitees in front of people who aren't invited to them - it's rude.

Totally agree with this, have taught my children from birth that you never, ever, EVER talk about an event to which someone is not invited in front of them.
If this were me I would apologise to the mother that her child has felt excluded and let her know I would be reminding my child of rule above, and decline her request in a friendly way.

patate10 · 16/10/2026 09:58

Agree with pp on talking about the girls talking about their play date in front of others.

Just say you can't have three little ones to get to sleep on a sleepover? More than 1 guest is always a sleepover nightmare so it's not a lie!

TheSmellOfSea · 16/10/2026 10:06

Fedupofthisgame · 15/10/2026 22:04

I had a similar situation but my DD was the one who was going to the sleepover at her BFFS house. The third mum just turned up with her DD and her overnight stuff. 🤣 Brazen as fuck.

Omg that's so brass necked. Did they let the dc stay? I suppose they'd have to?

Edited as realised it was a different house.

GoodGirlFaith · 16/10/2026 10:09

No. Because you don't invite yourself (or your child) to someone else's house!

FckThisShit · 16/10/2026 10:11

5128gap · 16/10/2026 08:39

"Sorry C, I think three 4 year olds overnight is going to be a but much, especially as they keep falling out! Maybe best to wait and see if they get on without the arguments, and keep it open as an option for the future."

Year 4, the kids are 9 ish. But yes, that's not a bad message.

TheSmellOfSea · 16/10/2026 10:15

rosagarten · 16/10/2026 09:33

Be clear about it but just say no because it doesn't work for YOU and your husband. No need to get into any discussions about the child's character or their on/off friendship, it just isn't necessary.

Exactly

Comeinsideforacupoftea · 16/10/2026 10:43

I think there's an important point that's being lost in this thread... Your dd deserves to be given the space to maintain a special friendship with her friend and she deserves to be able to set boundaries with people that (for whatever reason) she isn't getting along with. Your number one job OP is to advocate for your dd and help her command these things for herself. It's the other girl's mum's job to advocate for their daughters. They can organise a 3 way playdate or playdates with whoever else they want. By all means talk to your daughter about kindness and inclusivity and see if she'd like to do something additionally with both girls but kindness shouldn't be at the expense of her boundaries. You really don't need to apologise for nurturing a positive friendship and it needs no jusitifcation. A playdate with your close friend without complications really isn't much for a child to ask for.

5128gap · 16/10/2026 11:10

FckThisShit · 16/10/2026 10:11

Year 4, the kids are 9 ish. But yes, that's not a bad message.

Ah, my mistake. Read as 4 years old.

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · 16/10/2026 11:15

Unreaaass · 15/10/2026 22:06

Oh wow!! That is very brazen! How did it all go?!

Omg I want to know that too

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:27

BeardieWeirdie · 15/10/2026 21:40

No, Sarah says that Jenny has been unkind to her - laughing at her glasses, calling her fat, saying she smells - so she doesn’t want Jenny to come and play.

Do not apologise or suggest that she can come in future if she behaves herself!

Where does OP say that?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:29

Dohraymefar · 15/10/2026 21:41

Fine for her to ask. Fine for you to say no.

She can invite your DD to a sleepover for the girls if she doesn’t want her DD to miss out.

Agree - fine to ask, fine to say no

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:30

MwaHaHa99 · 15/10/2026 21:40

Just apologise and say no as your daughter and hers don't seem to be getting on well at the moment. You could add, hopefully it will all wash over soon, or whatever that expression is.

I wouldn't even mention the not getting on unless the mother asks 'why not?'

lottiegarbanzo · 16/10/2026 11:32

She’s not inviting her, she’s fishing for an invitation from you. Confusing title.

Anyway, sorry no, they’ve had this planned for a while.

Maybe suggest to dd that she keeps her social plans quieter at school. Time to start learning why tact works well for her, as well as for others.

Be prepared for pushy mum to start trying to capture dd’s friend for her dd.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:33

Dancingsquirrels · 15/10/2026 21:56

Bright and breezy approach is best

"No problem to ask but I think best not thus weekend. Maybe another time "

But why even 'Maybe another time' when that's a lie?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:40

Constantrunner · 15/10/2026 22:33

Don't do this kind of passive aggressive stuff. It's horrible.

Yeah - like the recommendation of just not replying (though I don't think anyone's yet suggested to block the mother)

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:50

Moonnstarz · 16/10/2026 08:08

I wouldn't get drawn into this.
It will just end up in an argument. The other parent may respond with how the sleepover was suggested by the OPs DD, her own DD is not mean and that actually it's the other child who blocks the play.

I think it's interesting that the girl who was supposedly mean was fine over the summer....presumably as the other friend was not available? Sounds like the OPs DD may be the one the other two girls both want to be friends with and that she can pick and choose (potentially unfairly).

If you are going to say no, just say no and leave it to school to sort if there are issues.

Agreed - and it does sort of sound like a response descending into or over involved in playground squabbles

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 16/10/2026 11:51

Newsprint · 16/10/2026 08:36

If you think a child’s sleepover is equivalent to a wedding, I can’t help you, I’m afraid!

🤣

FunnyOrca · 16/10/2026 11:53

Oakdodger · 16/10/2026 09:50

It's a great opportunity to say
"Sorry Jemima, Arabella hasn't been very kind to Gertrude lately so she isn't keen to play with her at present."

Yeah, but we also would need to talk to Gertrude about how talking about this in front of Arabella might also come off as mean.

I think it’s brazen of the mother to ask, but can see she was probably pushed into it. If I were her, I would have invited OP’s daughter for a play date at mine as a compromise with the child.

Jk987 · 16/10/2026 12:07

Why does saying no make you look bad? Just say 3 is too much to manage! It’s common for young kids to have niggles with each other, your child may done similar but it’s all forgotten quickly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread