Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to respond to inevitable comments from MIL on holiday?

293 replies

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 21:36

Shamelessly posted in aibu for traffic sorry! I don't think iabu but I have a question. I am going abroad with dh and in-laws at the weekend. Mil is lovely but shes bringing her sister - she is is generally a nice person and we get on ( as I am very tolerant! ) but she is if a generation who are obsessed with people's weight, she constantly goes on about people's weight and looks, diet, who has put weight on, who hasn't ( even people I don't know! ) and she will comment on peoples food and portions sizes every time they eat and makes patronising comments to fully grown adults like 'make sure you eat your veg'. I'm pregnant currently and everytime I see her all she goes on about is how hard she found it to lose her baby weight once hers were born over 40 years ago and I am feeling self conscious about a trip I should be looking forward to and probably my last before the baby - especially the all inclusive part! I am very small, it's not that she is triggering any actual insecurities I have but I don't feel very attractive at the moment, I've had really awful sickness and not taken much care of myself for a good few months, my skin is dry and my hair needs dying and I'm going to look rubbish. What do I actually do or say when MIL's sister makes these comments? She will likely say something to DH too who equally feels insecure to the extent he said he wouldn't go swimming around her! Any advice on what to say or how to enjoy the holiday anyway? I'm a bit annoyed MIL invited her tbh, but I guess it's her sister but I probably wouldn't have gone for these reasons if I'd known before hand.

OP posts:
RBowmama · 16/10/2026 10:23

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 21:48

Thank you, I find it SO awkward to call it out infront of MIL but really she should be anyway. It's also difficult when she is desperate to make a comment but disguises it more innocently- rather then directly saying something she will look at the food options and say something like 'no bread for me! I had bread at lunch' then as you're halfway through eating she will say 'do you eat bread at lunch and dinner?'. It honestly stresses me out being around her as it's truly constant.

You kind of need to grey rock her in those moments. Yes I do have bread with all my meals (with a big smile) and I suspect she might say something like good luck with your weight then...to which you could reply don't worry, I'm not worried about it ha ha!

Thanksforyourlackofthought · 16/10/2026 10:31

Rip the plaster off and get it over with. The first time she says something
"I don't want to cause bad feeling or fall out with you but you make a lot of comments about appearance and food and thats not something we want to continue with on this holiday thanks."

And thats it. Let her sit with it. Let her get the face on, whatever. You've said it, you meant it.

And if she tries it again, "I don't want to keep having this conversation thanks".

ladyofthemanor24 · 16/10/2026 10:39

If she asks if you eat bread twice a day, say ‘I eat what I want, when I want and I don’t give it a second thought’.

If she tries to engage in conversation, tell her you’re busy making a whole new human and could she kindly fuck off, you’re too busy gestating to talk.

TossingTurner · 16/10/2026 10:52

You might be going on holiday with my mum, OP. She's terrible for this and just commenting on how people look in general.

I was at an event where I met and had my picture taken with Katalin Karikó (Nobel Prize winner and generally lovely person). I sent my mum the picture and all she did was comment on her hair, her glasses and the outfit she had on.

Fucking bitch.

Whenever my mum starts up, I just blankly stare at her and say "OK".
Then she'll ask "Don't you think so, don't you think Jane's put on loads of weight?"
I just respond with "I have no opinion on Jane's weight" ad infinitum.

DoubleBusy2026 · 16/10/2026 10:53

“Ohhhhhhhh for goodness sake, Linda! Why must you always have to bang on & on & on about people’s weight, size and what they bloody eat?! If you don’t stop it, I will personally make sure that when you pass away, all that is on your headstone is simply a drawing of a weighing scales - nothing else, just your name above a set of scales! ⚖️
Now please, before you give us ALL an eating disorder like <name of her poor daughter>, just sodding well GIVE IT A REST will you?!”

MrsChiquitaBananas · 16/10/2026 10:57

I think in this type of situation where you don’t want to create an atmosphere as you’re all on holiday together (and I’m the same, so conflict avoidant it’s unreal!) I wouldn’t necessarily react to her comments but they when talking to her say something like, yes my friend who’s really slim feels insecure but I would never bring it up, it’s just so incredibly rude and invasive to comment on someone’s weight don’t you think? I mean she sounds as subtle as a brick so may be wasted but you never know!

blondeseaside · 16/10/2026 11:03

"How are you feeling lately? I heard that becoming obsessed with something can be a sign of dementia, and you are in that age bracket"

godmum56 · 16/10/2026 11:05

I want to add a general comment to this thread. Right through my adult life, I have been someone who takes no shit and won't hesitate to call people out or stand up for myself and others.
People have described me as "strong" "forthright" even "scarey" although I think the last ones were joking (maybe)
I know that when people say on here that a poster should not tolerate the kind of behaviour described on this thread or similar, there will be people who say or think that they could not do that, that its easy or easier for the person suggesting pushback because and then reasons.
Speaking as a non tolerator, its NOT easy for me or probably for others who do it. It is stressful but for me its similar to going to the dentist. Neither is pleasant but its a better option than putting up with the continual and worsening outcomes of not taking action. You CAN do it. Also it gets easier.
Just saying.

CruCru · 16/10/2026 11:09

Elsvieta · 16/10/2026 08:17

Bloody hell. I feel like the answer for you might be to stop seeing the cow.

OP, try "It's very old-fashioned, you know, being obsessed with weight and diets and stuff. Very AGEING".

I was going to say something like this. This is one of those times when it is actually more polite to be direct. Say something like “Do you know that you mention food portions and dress sizes whenever we meet?” and don’t say anything. Be extremely unemotional and matter of fact.

When she says something like Well I think everyone could stand to lose a few pounds / be healthier, say something like “There was a time when commenting on what people ate might have been acceptable. But now it’s considered very weird and rude”. Look directly at her and be as neutral as you can. Pretend to be an English speaking Dutch or German person.

Really important that you don’t exaggerate (even slightly).

When / if she carries on at a later date, say “I am an adult and I am going to eat this hamburger. I don’t need permission”. Do not wobble or say things about being on holiday. Food is not virtuous or naughty.

WhatterySquash · 16/10/2026 11:14

My mum's like this. I tolerated it for decades but in my 40s I hit a wall and realised I wasn't saying anything because I was scared to upset her, but she didn't give a crap about upsetting me!

I started calmly and kind of innocently saying things like:
"That's really rude and hurtful. Why did you say that?"
"Don't you know that making nasty personal remarks like that is not OK?"
"I don't like having my weight, food and appearance picked apart like that. It's upsetting, If you don't stop I will have to leave the room."

You could tell she was totally taken aback at being pulled up on it. She framed it as me being "hostile" and "oversensitive", but she stopped because she knew every single time she would be told to her face that she was rude and out of order, and she didn't like it.

Of course you have to be prepared to create a bit of a bad atmosphere, and that's what people like this rely on - you not wanting to rock the boat. But I found it worked surprisingly fast.

stillawip · 16/10/2026 11:18

You could always try, in a caring voice “I’ve noticed how conscious you are about other people’s weight X - is it because concerned about yours at all?” She’ll probably say no, & then you can say “Oh sorry, I think it’s just what everyone assumes, when someone is so obsessed with something!”

Winter2020 · 16/10/2026 11:19

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 21:48

Thank you, I find it SO awkward to call it out infront of MIL but really she should be anyway. It's also difficult when she is desperate to make a comment but disguises it more innocently- rather then directly saying something she will look at the food options and say something like 'no bread for me! I had bread at lunch' then as you're halfway through eating she will say 'do you eat bread at lunch and dinner?'. It honestly stresses me out being around her as it's truly constant.

Hi OP,
I have read all your posts and seen that this woman’s daughter has an eating disorder. I would say this woman herself also has an eating disorder, even if she is a normal weight. It is absolutely not normal to be obsessed not only with what you are eating but what others are eating and wanting to weigh and measure them.

I think recognising that this woman has an eating disorder helps you to manage how you react to her and how her behaviour makes you feel.

If someone had serious health anxiety and always has had you aren’t going to take them overly seriously if they are panicking about the latest symptom - you would probably just try to be kind and reassuring or might even be dismissive after a while.

e.g. If she asks you about eating bread several times I would just say “I eat bread when I fancy it” or “if I want to yes” if she goes on perhaps “I think life’s too short to be stressing over every calorie”, “food is one of the joy’s of life” etc etc. Even “Why don’t you have a day off?”

This is definitely a her problem.

theresnolimits · 16/10/2026 11:27

Sadly I have a couple of friends like this. They have both lost a considerable amount of weight and are messianic in their anti food crusade. I can predict what they will order (the lowest calorie item on the menu and water), the raised eyebrows when I order something else, the comments like ‘I don’t eat lunch. But you go ahead’. It is relentless and makes me avoid sharing social occasions with them. Even a cup of coffee has to be americano, no milk.

I know it plays into my own insecurities but I think food and drink are great pleasures and I don’t want to feel bad about enjoying them.

I don’t know the answer other than wishing that these people would dial it down and realise the impact they have. Fine if that makes them happy but keep the comments to themselves.

stillawip · 16/10/2026 11:35

Another good tactic is always to turn it back on them or turn what they are saying into positive rather than negative…
”I found it hard to lose my baby weight “…”Oh did you? Bad luck! I think I’ll be fine”
”don’t forget to eat your veg”….” Oh no, I never forget, do you?”
”ooh, someone’s been overdoing the cake”…...”Haha, I know! I love cake!“
”do you eat bread for lunch & dinner”…..” only when I want to, isn’t it great being a grown-up?!”
And my favourite comebacks, always in a jokey tone “yes, thanks, I’m happy with my choice!” And “luckily, I’m a grown up too so & I can make that decision myself” !!

Somerford · 16/10/2026 11:59

BabyHandsRobin · 16/10/2026 09:59

I’d definitely keep a reply as light and casual as possible (not easy, hopefully the right energy will come at the right moment!), and something that playfully puts the spotlight back on to her and her weird need to comment on other people and eating. Like “ooh you just come right out with it don’t you?!” Or “oh Xx, you do worry about these things don’t you”. Anything too strong/grumpy and you’ll probably be accused of upsetting her (unfairly!!)

Honestly I wouldn't waste my energy playing games with someone like this. She is the sole, direct cause of the conflict and she's choosing to do it. That should not place obligations on anybody else to find convoluted ways to handle her horrible shit without upsetting anybody.

Tell her to go fuck herself and be done with it.

powershowerforanhour · 16/10/2026 12:09

DoubleBusy2026 · 16/10/2026 10:53

“Ohhhhhhhh for goodness sake, Linda! Why must you always have to bang on & on & on about people’s weight, size and what they bloody eat?! If you don’t stop it, I will personally make sure that when you pass away, all that is on your headstone is simply a drawing of a weighing scales - nothing else, just your name above a set of scales! ⚖️
Now please, before you give us ALL an eating disorder like <name of her poor daughter>, just sodding well GIVE IT A REST will you?!”

Edited

That's my favourite so far. Your husband hasn't defended you from comments, but his mum didn't protect him. He had a bit of exposure to the toxic waste that drips out of her mouth and now won't go into the pool in his swimming togs in front of her. His cousin had a lot more exposure and has a full blown eating disorder. Your MIL panders to this shit and has probably internalised it and her sister probably didn't pick that attitude (and her own eating disorder) off the ground either. It's a pound to a penny that their own mother - or a very close relative- was obsessed with very closely tailored suits in the 40s, or cinched in , handspan waists in the 50s or Twiggy in a miniskirt in the 60s or whatever era they grew up in. Probably talked about fattening foods and slimming foods and smoked to suppress their appetite.

You can try just blanking the comments and smoothly changing the subject, as if she has just farted and you're being polite, but this approach probably needs all 3 of you on board. The giggling bingo is a good idea too, but if none of that works you'll probably have to drop the bomb, for the sake of your future daughter or son (she has managed to cause body insecurities in both sexes in the generation below hers already) and you'll have to make it clear that it's her problem not hers. As in:
"Stop inflicting your eating disorder on me please and thank you".
If you get accused of being touchy , causing upset or whatever you can calmly say " Well this is absolutely nothing compared to what will happen if this sort of nonsense is breathed anywhere near my child as soon as they are old enough to understand English. I will go through you for a shortcut and if you happen to be in my house at the time, you will be thrown out. Anywhere else , at any time, and I will take my child and leave. I am not risking my child ending up with bulimia because the adults around them can't control themselves. I care more about this baby than I do about you."

godmum56 · 16/10/2026 12:25

powershowerforanhour · 16/10/2026 12:09

That's my favourite so far. Your husband hasn't defended you from comments, but his mum didn't protect him. He had a bit of exposure to the toxic waste that drips out of her mouth and now won't go into the pool in his swimming togs in front of her. His cousin had a lot more exposure and has a full blown eating disorder. Your MIL panders to this shit and has probably internalised it and her sister probably didn't pick that attitude (and her own eating disorder) off the ground either. It's a pound to a penny that their own mother - or a very close relative- was obsessed with very closely tailored suits in the 40s, or cinched in , handspan waists in the 50s or Twiggy in a miniskirt in the 60s or whatever era they grew up in. Probably talked about fattening foods and slimming foods and smoked to suppress their appetite.

You can try just blanking the comments and smoothly changing the subject, as if she has just farted and you're being polite, but this approach probably needs all 3 of you on board. The giggling bingo is a good idea too, but if none of that works you'll probably have to drop the bomb, for the sake of your future daughter or son (she has managed to cause body insecurities in both sexes in the generation below hers already) and you'll have to make it clear that it's her problem not hers. As in:
"Stop inflicting your eating disorder on me please and thank you".
If you get accused of being touchy , causing upset or whatever you can calmly say " Well this is absolutely nothing compared to what will happen if this sort of nonsense is breathed anywhere near my child as soon as they are old enough to understand English. I will go through you for a shortcut and if you happen to be in my house at the time, you will be thrown out. Anywhere else , at any time, and I will take my child and leave. I am not risking my child ending up with bulimia because the adults around them can't control themselves. I care more about this baby than I do about you."

I really like the "protecting my family" vibe on this one.

Netcurtainnelly · 16/10/2026 13:28

Ask her to tell you some jokes instead?

Ponoka7 · 16/10/2026 13:36

ILoveKits · 15/10/2026 21:55

I'd take two or three Mary Beard books and wax lyrical about how successful she is because she put her brain before her appearance.

She's a massive rape appologisist, who feels sorry for male rapists who are forced into a position of power, which forces them to commit rape. I'd imagine she's kept quiet about a lot that's gone on in the BBC and done well out of it.

ILoveKits · 16/10/2026 14:06

That's a misrepresentation and wholly out of context. Academically she has discussed morality and norms in a different era thousands of years ago. It's actually defamatory.

Ormally · 16/10/2026 14:17

Could you try turning the subject round to something where she will want to stop the conversation as soon as possible (and think twice about how much she would want to get onto similar ground again?) E.g.
"Oh, well, I'm just grateful to be able to eat most things again now I'm past the first 12 weeks, get my strength back. Couldn't keep anything down, I might as well just have assumed the position in the bathroom at 5 o clock on the dot. I had to eat slices of banana and a ginger nut at 10 at night because I'd be up again and making a run for it at 2. My craving was for piccallili but, oh, Pam, it's just awful on the way back up, and the wind, Pam, can you imagine, Pam? So my midwife says it's really important I get more used to the carbs digesting now."

Zucker · 16/10/2026 14:26

With someone like your MIL's sister I would love to have a sheet of gold star stickers on hand and when she says something that is clearly a put down, award her with a gold star for being so virtuous and so much better than the rest of us mere mortals.
I hate the "I hope I didn't offend anyone" because they know for sure they're being offensive but enjoy it as they know no one will say anything in the moment.
Enjoy your trip away and if she starts on the bread thing just say with your full chest YES I LOVE BREAD and grab another slice.

rwalker · 16/10/2026 14:26

I don’t think she’s a twat she is someone with serious MH issues with regards to food and weight
and you should factor this in when dealing with her

Differentforgirls · 16/10/2026 15:30

TossingTurner · 16/10/2026 10:52

You might be going on holiday with my mum, OP. She's terrible for this and just commenting on how people look in general.

I was at an event where I met and had my picture taken with Katalin Karikó (Nobel Prize winner and generally lovely person). I sent my mum the picture and all she did was comment on her hair, her glasses and the outfit she had on.

Fucking bitch.

Whenever my mum starts up, I just blankly stare at her and say "OK".
Then she'll ask "Don't you think so, don't you think Jane's put on loads of weight?"
I just respond with "I have no opinion on Jane's weight" ad infinitum.

Did you just call your mother a "fucking bitch"?

Foodwench66 · 16/10/2026 17:53

Tell her to stop making comments on your appearance, that it's rude. That's it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread