Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how to respond to inevitable comments from MIL on holiday?

293 replies

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 21:36

Shamelessly posted in aibu for traffic sorry! I don't think iabu but I have a question. I am going abroad with dh and in-laws at the weekend. Mil is lovely but shes bringing her sister - she is is generally a nice person and we get on ( as I am very tolerant! ) but she is if a generation who are obsessed with people's weight, she constantly goes on about people's weight and looks, diet, who has put weight on, who hasn't ( even people I don't know! ) and she will comment on peoples food and portions sizes every time they eat and makes patronising comments to fully grown adults like 'make sure you eat your veg'. I'm pregnant currently and everytime I see her all she goes on about is how hard she found it to lose her baby weight once hers were born over 40 years ago and I am feeling self conscious about a trip I should be looking forward to and probably my last before the baby - especially the all inclusive part! I am very small, it's not that she is triggering any actual insecurities I have but I don't feel very attractive at the moment, I've had really awful sickness and not taken much care of myself for a good few months, my skin is dry and my hair needs dying and I'm going to look rubbish. What do I actually do or say when MIL's sister makes these comments? She will likely say something to DH too who equally feels insecure to the extent he said he wouldn't go swimming around her! Any advice on what to say or how to enjoy the holiday anyway? I'm a bit annoyed MIL invited her tbh, but I guess it's her sister but I probably wouldn't have gone for these reasons if I'd known before hand.

OP posts:
Gassylady · 16/10/2026 09:00

@AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou I would tell your MIL that you would appreciate it if she had a word with her sister before the holiday. However I think she (the sister) has made the rules of engagement quite clear ie its acceptable to be rude.

The first remark do the exaggerated bet thing actually hand over the money too. Any subsequent ones, maybe two or three, refer to the virtual BINGO card you are completing in your head. I would then say this obsession is tedious please drop it. The very next remark after that drop the ultimate rude bomb “ I see your own daughters relationship with food is fucked any thoughts on why that might be?”

Only escalate to that if your DH’s cousin is not present obviously! Think of taking action now as a way of protecting your baby from being caught in the crossfire later. Im sure she didnt only start when her daughter was an adult after all.

onmylastnerveseriously · 16/10/2026 09:01

You must call her out OP, because you cannot allow her to talk like this in front of your future DC. My mum is like this and she now gets her head ripped off if she says anything whatsoever in front of my DDs.

CoffeeAndACroissant · 16/10/2026 09:01

I'd own it.

"Yes I love bread, so much I'm going to have more."

"Absolutely I'm having dessert. Best part of the meal".

"Oh that's a shame you don't feel able to enjoy yourself around food. Personally I don't worry about it - life is too short".

"Oh I never discuss other people's weight, it's quite rude don't you think?"

wildnwilde · 16/10/2026 09:11

As soon as you see her say god you've put weight on have not you it suits you 😉 if you can't beat them join them

FairKoala · 16/10/2026 09:11

Ask her to choose another topic of conversation as it gets boring only talking about people’s weight and eating habits all the time.

ThatCyanCat · 16/10/2026 09:17

I have people like this in my family. Someone braver than I am once just went with, "Why don't you just fuck off and die?"

I'm torn because the fallout was exactly as you would expect and not everyone could handle it. On the other, it did put an end to literally decades of this behaviour that had long upset many people. On balance, while I could never have done it myself, I'm in favour.

Awkwardisfunny · 16/10/2026 09:20

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 21:48

Thank you, I find it SO awkward to call it out infront of MIL but really she should be anyway. It's also difficult when she is desperate to make a comment but disguises it more innocently- rather then directly saying something she will look at the food options and say something like 'no bread for me! I had bread at lunch' then as you're halfway through eating she will say 'do you eat bread at lunch and dinner?'. It honestly stresses me out being around her as it's truly constant.

It sounds like you had an overly critical parent or maybe you experienced weight issues in your past. Happy to talk to you about this some day and see if I can help. My partner and I don't want to develop your obsession with food and weight so would you please change the subject and refrain from bringing it up around us. Thank you.

SpryCat · 16/10/2026 09:22

The dynamics of that family is to be agreeable in the face of toxicity, pretend MIL’s sister is a nice person and make you victims of being polite. You can’t even say to MIL no we don’t want to go on holiday with your sister as she is horrific. You are enabling your MIL comfort around her sister by all being bullied. How are you going to protect your child when everyone is playing dumb to toxicity? You need to show you won’t play the game, you’re pregnant and this is your holiday too. You can call her out without being aggressive and shrug off any blame that you made the holiday awkward for anyone by owning up to the fact that you spoke your truth. You won’t be putting up with vicious digs from someone who has a full blown eating disorder and pretending overwise.

PussyGaylore · 16/10/2026 09:24

I find the asking someone to repeat what they just said when they are being unreasonable to be an effective tool. If you want to do power play then if she repeats it just say ‘ oh I thought that’s what you said . . . .( long pause) then answer dismissively then say - why you asking and then turn your back on her and talk to someone else before she can answer.

tokennamechange · 16/10/2026 09:25

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 22:03

I do get that but honestly how could I? If MIL has said sis is coming that ok with you? How can I really say no it's not because she notices what people eat? It's inevitable she will upset people but I can't really say no she can't come on a family holiday because I have a feeling she will without causing a lot of upset can I? I agree re MIL, not sure she will actually address it though. Last time we all went on holiday she just about snatched a tape measure from her sisters hand when she was off to suggest DH's younger female cousin checked how much weight she had put on🙄

Yes, of course you can!
Its ironic you are accusing MIL of being weak when you and your DH are doing exactly the same thing!
Tbh you dont even have to give a reason, its YOUR holiday, MIL was in the wrong for inviting her, just say "no, its not okay."
If its "oh ive already invited her sorry I didn't think you'd mind" say "well i do mind,"

MIL doesnt care about being rude and inviting people to your holiday. Aunt in law doesnt care about being rude and a complete bitch so why are you the only one who has to care about everyone's feelings?

I know you cant go back in time now but you can address it firmly as soon as it starts, stick your hand up and say "No, Kath, not a word about food, diets, weight or appearance on this holiday, nobody wants to hear it." If she gets annoyed she can leave. If MIL gets into a snit you can tell her its her fault for inviting her.

Now is the ideal time to do this - you can blame pregnancy hormones and being shattered as an excuse for "rudeness" and everyone will be so desperate to see the baby when it comes they won't hold a grudge.

I know its easy to say from behind a screen and I'm actually quite a laid back person in real life who lets a lot of things go - but someone insulting me or make sly digs in my own house or on my precious holiday (when they weren't even invited) is where I firmly draw the line.

Woodfiresareamazing2 · 16/10/2026 09:26

If this woman has never been called out for her comments about what people are eating or their weight, she may not realise that she is actually being rude.

None of you are comfortable with her comments but you're all afraid to speak up.

One of you has to, or she will ruin this holiday for you, and eventually be a toxic influence on your DC.

I would suggest at the first gathering one of you says something like 'right, let's get one thing straight right away - we don't want any comments on diet, food choices, or weight - it's rude, can be upsetting, and it's actually very boring.'
If she says something like 'but I'm just trying to be helpful', stop her with a hand up 'No buts!'.
And keep doing it.

If she does comment during a meal, put a hand up and say 'remember we said no comments like this'.

If she still continues, I'd eat at a different time, or sit at a different table.

So she's upset - so what? She's upset everyone else for years.

Comtesse · 16/10/2026 09:30

NoHangoversToday · 16/10/2026 08:05

I understand so well where you are coming from. My mother is completely obsessed with weight. She personally was delighted when she had to have open heart surgery and then got an infection as all she could talk about happily was how much weight she lost. I'm not joking. When I visit her I cut out all the tags in my clothes because she will turn my collar or waist band over to see then tut at me. I am 52 and have had eating disorders all my life including bulimia that hospitalised me. I refuse to go swimming when we are on holiday also.

Last time I visited her she started up again and I commented 'It's sad that all you see is weight. It's not what determines a person's worth you know'. And she flew off the handle big time and started screaming at how sensitive I am and what a fucking horrible person I am and such a disappointment to be 'showing her up'. . Shades of her behaviour when I was growing up.

So I don't know the answer. But I certainly sympathise.

Holy moly this is dreadful. It’s amazing you still speak to her at all Flowers

BeGreySnail · 16/10/2026 09:31

I wouldn't bother going. Pull out of the trip. It's actually really rude of MIL to add her DSIS on, and THEN ask you if it's ok! She should have asked you FIRST.

Happyjoe · 16/10/2026 09:41

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 21:48

Thank you, I find it SO awkward to call it out infront of MIL but really she should be anyway. It's also difficult when she is desperate to make a comment but disguises it more innocently- rather then directly saying something she will look at the food options and say something like 'no bread for me! I had bread at lunch' then as you're halfway through eating she will say 'do you eat bread at lunch and dinner?'. It honestly stresses me out being around her as it's truly constant.

If someone said that to me I would get a bit of bread, look them straight in the eye with an unfriendly look and take a bite, then another, then another.

Then ignore.

AelitaQueenofMars · 16/10/2026 09:41

It’s amazing how many people are like this. I sympathise with you all; had a MIL who did exactly this. The topic of conversation always, always turned to food, and weight, and disparaging comments on others appearance and eating habits. I tried many of the suggestions here. The least successful was the ‘don’t you know it’s upsetting to others?’ one. Water off a duck’s back.

The worst one was when I was told I was never to allow my prepubescent, clearly underweight DD (she had an autoimmune condition) to ever put an ounce on, ever, because being so thin was ‘perfect’. Response to my spluttering outrage? Blithe dismissal.

The only successful tactic - ever - was not seeing her any more. Just saying…

Somerford · 16/10/2026 09:42

I think it's madness that you're all granting this woman so much power. What would she do if you told her to shut the fuck up and keep her nasty, horrible shit to herself? I'd imagine she'd pull a face, make a big deal of being offended and expect everyone to pander to her. Tell her that you meant it and she'll get no apologies, and it's up to her how things go from now on. Her behaviour is the cause of this conflict and if she can't do better she can fuck off.

If MIL has a problem with it, she can spare herself this aggro by not inviting awful people on your holidays.

ThatCyanCat · 16/10/2026 09:48

AelitaQueenofMars · 16/10/2026 09:41

It’s amazing how many people are like this. I sympathise with you all; had a MIL who did exactly this. The topic of conversation always, always turned to food, and weight, and disparaging comments on others appearance and eating habits. I tried many of the suggestions here. The least successful was the ‘don’t you know it’s upsetting to others?’ one. Water off a duck’s back.

The worst one was when I was told I was never to allow my prepubescent, clearly underweight DD (she had an autoimmune condition) to ever put an ounce on, ever, because being so thin was ‘perfect’. Response to my spluttering outrage? Blithe dismissal.

The only successful tactic - ever - was not seeing her any more. Just saying…

And this is why, on balance, I think I have to support my "why don't you just fuck off and die" relative. I could never have said it myself, but all the civil appealing to politeness or better nature or kindness or just plain it not being any of their business just doesn't work with these people. If they cared about any of that, they'd keep their thoughts to themselves. The only thing that worked with this person was coming at her like a tank like that. She was relying on people being more polite and nice and kind and gentle than she was; being hit with something that didn't depend on appealing to virtues she doesn't have, and essentially just telling her that what she was doing made people hate her, just took the wind out of her sails. She was shocked and furious and there was a lot of "how could you, you are so amoral and evil" stuff, but ultimately... she finally stopped doing it!

Bringflowersofthefairest · 16/10/2026 09:55

Oh God here we go again.
Give it a rest Edna.

Every time she starts.

BabyHandsRobin · 16/10/2026 09:59

I’d definitely keep a reply as light and casual as possible (not easy, hopefully the right energy will come at the right moment!), and something that playfully puts the spotlight back on to her and her weird need to comment on other people and eating. Like “ooh you just come right out with it don’t you?!” Or “oh Xx, you do worry about these things don’t you”. Anything too strong/grumpy and you’ll probably be accused of upsetting her (unfairly!!)

FiveEightNine · 16/10/2026 10:08

Sounds like an opportunity to be very clear (even demonstrative and blunt) that you two don't appreciate this kind of talking. Before you get heavily pregnant and before the baby arrives.

If it blows things up, fine, it will have some time to settle.
If it doesn't blow things up, good, you'll have time to reinforce your position before she can harm your child with the talking.

Lobelia123 · 16/10/2026 10:16

People like this are so tedious because there's so much sly judgement, negging and cutting down of others involved in their comments. They equate personal virtue with restraint, self denial, hunger and thinness, and having a normal appetite as greed and self indulgence....so every little dig has a subtext of 'look at me, Im so special and superior because I dont have bread with meals'....and 'youre so gross and disgusting because you do'. Its incredibly damaging....have a long think about what happens when your perfect and innocent baby is born....will you allow this frightful damaging woman to comment on the little one and chip away at their self esteem in the same way she has at yours and your husbands????

Either speak up, tell her her comments are not welcome and to shut her beak, or make a point of removing yourself from her orbit. sit at opposite ends of the table, if she comments about you develop sudden deafness, if she approaches you get up and move away. Tell her shes a blight on the enjoyment and happiness of the group and dont accept this treatment!!!

godmum56 · 16/10/2026 10:16

AllAlongIHaveLaughedWithYou · 15/10/2026 22:03

I do get that but honestly how could I? If MIL has said sis is coming that ok with you? How can I really say no it's not because she notices what people eat? It's inevitable she will upset people but I can't really say no she can't come on a family holiday because I have a feeling she will without causing a lot of upset can I? I agree re MIL, not sure she will actually address it though. Last time we all went on holiday she just about snatched a tape measure from her sisters hand when she was off to suggest DH's younger female cousin checked how much weight she had put on🙄

"How can I really say no it's not because she notices what people eat? It's inevitable she will upset people but I can't really say no she can't come on a family holiday because I have a feeling she will without causing a lot of upset can I? "

yes. Yes you can.
"Mil I love you but your sister is a bloody nightmare and you know it. Her constant nitpicking about what people eat is annoying and hurtful and I for one have had enough of it."

godmum56 · 16/10/2026 10:18

ThatCyanCat · 16/10/2026 09:48

And this is why, on balance, I think I have to support my "why don't you just fuck off and die" relative. I could never have said it myself, but all the civil appealing to politeness or better nature or kindness or just plain it not being any of their business just doesn't work with these people. If they cared about any of that, they'd keep their thoughts to themselves. The only thing that worked with this person was coming at her like a tank like that. She was relying on people being more polite and nice and kind and gentle than she was; being hit with something that didn't depend on appealing to virtues she doesn't have, and essentially just telling her that what she was doing made people hate her, just took the wind out of her sails. She was shocked and furious and there was a lot of "how could you, you are so amoral and evil" stuff, but ultimately... she finally stopped doing it!

Edited

This!

Comtesse · 16/10/2026 10:18

Frrrout · 16/10/2026 08:51

Honestly, maybe I’m just too old for this shit, but you’ll look back in 20 years at what you look like now and realise how good you actually looked, so it isn’t right she’s stopping you from enjoying your break.
People like your MILs sister are barnacles on the arse of humanity. Instead of spending one second of your time being worried and anxious about this old bag, I’d simply say ‘HAVE A DAY OFF SUE’ on repeat.
Or my personal favourite - ‘oh well. In a hundred years time we will all be dead and no-one will give a shit’.
On repeat.

Like this one! Have a day off Sue ❤️

godmum56 · 16/10/2026 10:18

Somerford · 16/10/2026 09:42

I think it's madness that you're all granting this woman so much power. What would she do if you told her to shut the fuck up and keep her nasty, horrible shit to herself? I'd imagine she'd pull a face, make a big deal of being offended and expect everyone to pander to her. Tell her that you meant it and she'll get no apologies, and it's up to her how things go from now on. Her behaviour is the cause of this conflict and if she can't do better she can fuck off.

If MIL has a problem with it, she can spare herself this aggro by not inviting awful people on your holidays.

also this