Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A Christmas/AIBU/what do you do about Santa presents

311 replies

Rubyreds45 · 14/10/2026 11:38

Who do your children think their presents come from- parents or Santa?

The situation is that our eldest child attends a nursery and last week the nursery put a message out essentially asking parents to tell their children that the majority of their presents are from their parents, and to choose just one present specifically something low cost (the examples they gave were PJ’s, chocolates, socks or a book) to be the present from Santa. Their explanation for this was that it prevents a situation they say they have had in previous years where all of the children come back in January chatting about Christmas presents and some children have had lots and lots of toys from Santa and other children have had a bar of chocolate & some socks from Santa, the children with less ended up confused and upset.

Growing up all of our presents were always from Santa (other than ones from family/friends), both of our kids are young enough that we’ve never really said who they are from yet and we are just wondering really is this what parents say now?

It has caused uproar among the nursery parents with strong opinions either side, lots saying that the magic of Christmas is piles from Santa and that they won’t change that, also lots saying its not fair on the children with parents who can’t afford huge piles and so they only get chocolate from Santa but find out at nursery that that friend got piles of toys and so they argue we all need to be saying those expensive things are from parents.

I don’t particularly have an opinion either way, so really just wondering what other parents do? Just one present from Santa? All from Santa? Particular low cost from Santa? All from parents? We are fortunate in that we can afford to buy for Christmas whatever our children want really, but I would hate to think that another child will hear ours talking about her toys and wonder why Santa didn’t bring him the same so I can definitely see the point in just having something low cost from Santa- but that only really works if everyone does it.

My only gripe with the nursery about the whole thing really is that as an activity the week before last they did a “lets do Christmas lists for Santa” activity so all kids sat round and produced lists of toys with help from staff obviously to bring home to parents. For me, if I was concerned about children feeling disappointed over Christmas presents I probably wouldn’t be encouraging them all to sit and write lists of toys together knowing that some of those children will get every item on their list and some will get none. Maybe that activity prompted a parent to complain and led to their message being sent out, who knows.

OP posts:
Nottodaybob · 15/10/2026 22:06

Santa does a socking and a main gift here. We then get them a gift and family/ friends as well

I'd have simply ignored the email from nursery. I understand the sentiment but they are massively overstepping.

RaraRachael · 15/10/2026 22:06

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 15/10/2026 21:43

Wow, it is mad all the different traditions! With us Santa brings everything, we don’t do stockings or Christmas Eve boxes. Most people I know do the same

That's exactly what I had as a child and did with my own kids.
Presents from relatives went under the tree.
Right up until we no longer believed in Santa, nobody questioned the fact that there were no presents from your parents.

InterestedDad37 · 15/10/2026 22:09

I'd question the school bringing up Christmas in early October! 🤯

Swanfeet · 15/10/2026 22:17

It sounds like nursery are getting overly involved in parental decisions. They might have the best of intentions but how you do Christmas is entirely up to you! Also why are they doing it so bloody early?!

in our family the children have stockings with lots of low value things and a couple of more exciting bits like Lego. I don’t want Father Christmas taking credit for my hard work thinking of presents for them! 😂

EmmaB1309 · 15/10/2026 22:23

I think nursery are overthinking this. Nursery age children tend not to talk about how who gave them what. And they certainly don’t have the cognitive awareness to compare who got what or much care really. If asked what they got for Christmas they’ll just say ‘a dolly’ or ‘a trampoline’ . Three year olds don’t think ‘Joe got an Xbox and I got a colouring book from Santa, poor me’, based on how the parents decide to explain it all, do they?
My daughter, when she believed in Santa, always got a couple of gifts from Santa and knew that most of the gifts were from us. It was the same for me when I was a child. It makes the transition to not believing easier too. So while I do agree with the approach the nursery are suggesting, it’s not really for them to insist.

WineIsMyMainVice · 15/10/2026 22:26

We told ours that we set a budget for Santa and then he sent us the bill! That’s why some kids get tech and some don’t!

MaryLuu · 15/10/2026 22:27

The nursery sound like they have messed this up- writing lists at nursery is wrong. When writing lists with parents/ carers the kids can be gently advised I don’t think Santa could bring a real unicorn as they’re so heavy but I bet he could bring you a cuddly one to fit on your bed… To let 3-5 year olds go wild is unfair when some can’t afford much.

Also it makes me wonder if they do a big WHAT DID YOU GET FOR CHRISTMAS as generally I’ve never heard of little ones comparing.

As for Santa, when I was a kid it was all from Santa. Then some gifts from family and friends. I never even realised there were none from mom.
Naturally when dc came along I did the same. No issues until eldest was about 6 and asked what I had got her for Christmas, I was obviously confused at first like WHAT? Then when she repeated and explained how Santa brought everything, what did I get her?! Thankfully in the moment I was able to respond with a good gift she liked and said Santa put it with his so she didn’t realise!
Now it’s always a big pile from Santa and a sack from me.

I wish I’d have done it differently but hey ho.

Zerosleep · 15/10/2026 22:56

Santa brings all the presents but I tell them that I have helped to choose them so Santa gets them right.

RedLorryYellowLorry75 · 15/10/2026 23:05

When I was a child we were told that my parents sent all the presents they'd bought off to Santa and he delivered them. There was always one gift labelled from Santa. With my own kids Santa fills their stockings and also leaves them one present each under the tree, nothing expensive, usually board games when they were small. Everything else is from us / family / friends and labelled as such.

Smudgesmith · 15/10/2026 23:20

If all gifts are from santa then do children not ever say thank you to anyone? We do 1 main gift from santa. Last year it was a medium sized present and then we leave the stocking vague. Our 7 year old never delves further. We say santa delivers everything but that we post our presents and family presents to him. He has a stocking, sack and presents under the tree. Some of them have tags from family. Realistically we introduced this part past nursery age and it helps explain any slips or anything he sees re passing presents over.
I'd absolutely ignore nursery guidance if you want to do different as it's none of their business....but for us the above works as I don't want my son not saying thank you to his grandparents, aunties, uncles etc. Ive found the whole child will compare what they have got from santa and comment on someone getting bigger or smaller gifts just doesn't happen. But then my son never asks for the world. Last year he asked santa for a space projector. It was £20. The year when he was 5 he wanted a cleaning set. He's not asking for an ipad, a phone, a remote control car you ride on etc.

caringcarer · 15/10/2026 23:51

I've always given the main expensive gift from DH and me wrapped up under the Xmas tree along with gifts from Aunties, Uncles and dgp's and the rest of their gifts in stockings from Santa. That's how my parents did it and my sisters and I all did the same. My DD does this with her DC too. Lots of the things in their stockings were small things or things they needed anyway like new slippers or PJ's, chocolate reindeer, bath bomb, colouring pencils, water bottle, etc. They usually had a new game each, and a couple of reading books.

Onbdy · 16/10/2026 00:28

Katylouise88 · 15/10/2026 20:41

In our house Santa fills the stockings and brings one main present (whatever they have asked Santa for when they visit/in the letter), the rest are from us

This was the same in my house, both when DDs were small and when I was too.

GabriellaFaith · 16/10/2026 00:28

Everyone I know does gifts from friends, family etc, but either a stocking or a special gift from Santa. We always do something you dont see in the shops or something santa related (like elf on the shelf pet) with a letter and book from Santa. This also covers why naughty kids still get gifts because they know friends and family buy things too, and at primary school our kids and my sisters kids made gifts.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 16/10/2026 00:35

Growing up, our Santa presents were the main presents. So I carried that on with giving the main presents from Santa, and just a normal regular present from us.

To be honest, the nursery are overstepping here. They have no right to dictate or try to control how parents do Christmas in the privacy of their own homes.

I'd be ignoring them. I'd want to tell them to go fuck themselves, but as that would have the children chucked out then I'd have to bite my tongue sadly!

Dawnb19 · 16/10/2026 00:52

We say that Santa brings all the presents. We put out a carrots, cookie and milk for Santa on Christmas eve and the next morning when the children come downstairs he's left all the presents. We visit his family in the afternoon and they give them presents that they have bought and they say it's from them. It's the way both me and my partner was brought up. It's all part of the magic.

Moo31 · 16/10/2026 01:43

CatNE · 14/10/2026 11:47

I say that I give the money to Santa for the presents. This way my kids know how much they can spend, and it explains why some get more from Santa than others. Each to their own though

We do this in our house too.

TheDevilWears · 16/10/2026 02:21

When my DDs were small everything was from Santa. I didn’t actually agree with that but was coerced by DM and exH…I’d have preferred to be somewhat honest but apparently I would be depriving them of the magic of Christmas 🤷🏼‍♀️

TableRoller · 16/10/2026 02:28

I struggle with this every year too.

nikkianns · 16/10/2026 03:00

In our house we buy the presents, then Santa comes and takes them once we’ve wrapped them and brings them back for Christmas ‘if they’re good’, obviously they always get brought back, but it does help towards getting them to behave half the time 😂

MrsBTeaches · 16/10/2026 04:02

I’ve seen this type of warning or discussion on social media in previous years so I would guess nursery are either responding to a complaint or just jumping on something they’ve seen.

But what I can say for sure is that it makes absolutely no difference because children do not return to school detailing to each-other what they got from Santa or what they got from parents or relatives, they just say what they’ve got for Christmas.

So sadly no amount of thought into this changes the fact that some children get much more than others. In my experience they rarely mention who the gifts actually come from, just the what the gifts were. So honestly wouldn’t overthink it.

In my house growing up, we knew gifts were from parents with some odd smaller ones from Santa, but any from parents were either ordered with Santa or sent off to Santa to be packaged and delivered on Christmas Eve.

EdithBond · 16/10/2026 04:47

Rubyreds45 · 14/10/2026 12:41

Totally agree the Christmas list activity was just a crazy decision from the nursery- especially given they are now saying they have in previous years had children upset coming back after the break and hearing about what other children received from Santa.

I assume (for the purpose of the activity) that they were encouraging the kids to choose lots of toys to cut out and stick on, which is great, but I can imagine if I was a parent who knew I wasn’t going to be able to get even 1 present from that list I would have been complaining to the nursery for putting those thoughts in my child’s head anyway.

Agree, it’s extremely poor practice for a nursery to do this activity.

First, under no circumstances, should they be encouraging children to ask parents for toys. It’s the wrong values, encouraging children to be demanding and materialistic.

Second, they shouldn’t assume all children celebrate Xmas. Or, if they do, how they celebrate. Some deeply religious Christians shun the commercial side of Xmas. Plus, I know one family who are atheist and (while they give presents) don't encourage a belief in Santa, as they feel it’s lying to their children.

Third, setting them up for disappointment. Lots of parents don’t but everything their child asks for (e.g. entire Argos catalogue!), even if they can afford it. It’s fairly typical to give one main present and a few cheaper (e.g stocking) items.

Fourth, it’s blooming mid October!!

The letter home (instructing parents what to tell their children) is further poor practice. As you say, OP, likely an awful response to a complaint about, or child upset by, the activity.

My kids had a stocking from Santa (small, cheap items, like books and confectionery) and a sack (which Santa delivered) with their main present from us, plus gifts from family and family friends. But, we didn’t elaborate on what Santa did or didn’t do (the kids rarely asked questions anyway). If they did, I always just said ‘because he’s magic’. And certainly would never equate presents with good behaviour, as conscious some kids (e.g. who get very little) will think it’s their fault.

junebirthdaygirl · 16/10/2026 04:54

I have been a teacher with the younger years for a long time. Few things l have noticed.
If l asked them what they got fir Christmas they say one random thing which is definitely not their main present but the first thing that came into their head. By the time school reopened after the break they had forgotten who gave what and we put very little emphasis on it..just moved on with the new term. The richer the parents the less they got. Families with less money tend to go overboard while the well off Families got one thing ..usually something practical like a bike. It's a country school and ..while obviously l don't know everyone's affairs l have a fairly good idea .
I am in my 60s and even when l was in school l could never understand how Santa was so mean that he gave different children different size presents..it seemed very unfair and l was very aware of it. Kids got far less in those days . And we usually only got stuff at Christmas never during the year. But l was still very conscious of differences although as a child l said nothing.
As a family ourselves our children always knew Santa was a fantasy and it never took away from the excitement and they never discussed that with their friends. I definitely wouldn't give Santa credit for everything but have a different time for opening Santa presents and leave the others until a bit later. But Families gave traditions so do you and its not up to the nursery to dictate.

Kiwi09 · 16/10/2026 05:12

The nursery should keep out of this entirely! Every family will have different traditions and not all nursery families will even necessarily celebrate Christmas! I did use to hate how school got the
kids to write a letter the week before Christmas listing the presents they wanted. There was nothing left in the shops by then.

Lauzg90 · 16/10/2026 06:11

I follow a similar philosophy for the same reason.
So we write lists to Santa, he will bring more than pjs though. Stocking are from santa. He will then leave 2/3 presents (different wrapping paper to ours, obviously!) on the kitchen table where his milk and mince pie was. It is usually things they specifically asked for, not big because ‘santa has limited room on the sleigh’. Last year the main santa presents were a crate of peppa bubbles for the 2 year old and a wicked barbie type doll for the 5 year old.
The rest of the presents are from us. As others have said, it helps keep the lists realistic. My husband pointed out Santa shouldn’t get all the credit for our (my 🤣) hard work! I also think that it seems strange that loads of random friends and family buy you presents but your parents get you nothing!
When I was a child my Mum use to ‘send’ my presents to santa to stop me looking for them! However as an adult I don’t get this. Why would he need a workshop then?!

GeorgieBot · 16/10/2026 06:35

Stocking from FC, under the tree gifts from the actual givers.
For people saying it's none of the nursery's business - they are the ones there on the ground when the children are comparing! How are they supposed to explain to the children who got less?