Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A Christmas/AIBU/what do you do about Santa presents

311 replies

Rubyreds45 · 14/10/2026 11:38

Who do your children think their presents come from- parents or Santa?

The situation is that our eldest child attends a nursery and last week the nursery put a message out essentially asking parents to tell their children that the majority of their presents are from their parents, and to choose just one present specifically something low cost (the examples they gave were PJ’s, chocolates, socks or a book) to be the present from Santa. Their explanation for this was that it prevents a situation they say they have had in previous years where all of the children come back in January chatting about Christmas presents and some children have had lots and lots of toys from Santa and other children have had a bar of chocolate & some socks from Santa, the children with less ended up confused and upset.

Growing up all of our presents were always from Santa (other than ones from family/friends), both of our kids are young enough that we’ve never really said who they are from yet and we are just wondering really is this what parents say now?

It has caused uproar among the nursery parents with strong opinions either side, lots saying that the magic of Christmas is piles from Santa and that they won’t change that, also lots saying its not fair on the children with parents who can’t afford huge piles and so they only get chocolate from Santa but find out at nursery that that friend got piles of toys and so they argue we all need to be saying those expensive things are from parents.

I don’t particularly have an opinion either way, so really just wondering what other parents do? Just one present from Santa? All from Santa? Particular low cost from Santa? All from parents? We are fortunate in that we can afford to buy for Christmas whatever our children want really, but I would hate to think that another child will hear ours talking about her toys and wonder why Santa didn’t bring him the same so I can definitely see the point in just having something low cost from Santa- but that only really works if everyone does it.

My only gripe with the nursery about the whole thing really is that as an activity the week before last they did a “lets do Christmas lists for Santa” activity so all kids sat round and produced lists of toys with help from staff obviously to bring home to parents. For me, if I was concerned about children feeling disappointed over Christmas presents I probably wouldn’t be encouraging them all to sit and write lists of toys together knowing that some of those children will get every item on their list and some will get none. Maybe that activity prompted a parent to complain and led to their message being sent out, who knows.

OP posts:
Dryrobe45 · 16/10/2026 13:28

We’ve always said Santa fills the stockings (e.g. small, inexpensive gifts) and all other gifts (the main ones) under the tree are from us. Friends & relatives have then passed their gifts directly to the DCs so they know Santa didn’t provide those. For me it was always important to do it that way as I think children need to know that a real life person has bought them a gift (with real life money!) rather than them thinking everything is provided by some mythical benefactor who creeps down the chimney. Plus they can then say thank you.
I know lots of household do it differently though, and I have heard of friends-of-friends who tell their DC that everything is from Santa.
I don’t blame the nursery for trying to tackle this the best way they can, as they’re obviously dealing with the fall out of the different Santa situations. But I think they’re in a super tricky spot and it will be a struggle for them to get all parents on board.

(edited for typo)

SJM1988 · 16/10/2026 13:42

I wouldn't be changing my stance or opinion or tradition on the ask of nursery. Every setting (childcare or otherwise) is going to have a different ask and you might find ourself in an awkward position with either friendship group or other setting if you change to what nursery ask. I think you just need to decide what you want to do and stick with it.
I'm shocked a nursery has even asked...ours wouldn't and never raised it as an issue when mine 2 DC were little. Its also never been an issue at school since they have started.

Every family has different traditions and some will have stronger opinion on those traditions than others.

We do 5 presents from santa and stocking. Then one present from parents or maybe 2 depending on the year. We have friends that do all from santa, none from parents and others that do all from parents, stocking only from santa. It's never raised a question with my children and I think by the time they are old enough to understand.....they wont believe in santa anymore!

dh280125 · 16/10/2026 14:12

Santa just does the stockings. The rest are from us, family.

Secretsanta168 · 16/10/2026 14:17

I say that I give the money to Santa for the presents. This way my kids know how much they can spend, and it explains why some get more from Santa than others. Each to their own though

This

Dontlletmedownbruce · 16/10/2026 15:33

Toys from Santa. A big present that they asked for (or 2 or 3 smaller ones) then stocking items are a surprise, often chocolates or little things. Mum and Dad get kids a more practical gift, clothes or bedlinen or something they like but don't really care about.

Fwiw I very strongly disagree with what the nursery have asked and would just ignore it and do what you want. They do not get to tell you how to follow your own culture, because that's what it is. Parents have always differed in how they celebrate Christmas and part of that is what Santa does. Even those with the same presents, one will be wrapped one won't, one will be delivered to the bedroom, another under the tree. I work with kids and we tell them all the time that every family is different and they accept this without question. They also dont know the value of money. Their Summer holidays differ, some kids go on long haul flights, some drive for a sleepover at Grans. Some have 2 dogs 5 cousins, some just have Mum. Diversity in all forms should be respected and that includes how you want to approach festivals. Sorry I sound like I'm ranting but this kind of shit really annoys me.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 16/10/2026 15:47

The more I think of it the more I think someone is a bit unhinged at the nursery and I'd seriously be doubting their judgment going forward. Kids with bigger families get more gifts, plus everyone has different ground rules. We always said that Santa can't bring pets or book tickets. He also can't buy tech unless parents agree. Then we hear so and so got an Xbox or a puppy or a trip to Disney land. I work with nursery kids and honestly half them think they are going to be mermaids when they grow up, they are absolutely clueless with the odd exception. You could explain anything away with any old bullshit and they will believe it. Explaining that different people have different experiences is not difficult to do, they accept it and move on, just show them a digger outside or put on K pop.

T1Dmama · 16/10/2026 16:29

I think it’s wrong of nursery to dictate to parents what they do with their kids at Christmas!
mall presents were from Santa but we had to send him payment. That’s how I explained how some kids got less or more than her…
I have a friend who’s kids got one main present from Santa that was wrapped in amazing poer and had lovely bows etc, everything else was from the parents …. But santas present was a big one…
sorry but kids don’t write to Santa asking for something crappy like a chocolate bar or book!!
Talk about kill the fun and magic of Christmas - if Santa can’t bring amazing gifts you might as well tell kids he doesn’t exist!
what next?? Nursery/school dictating how much the tooth fairy leaves? How many Easter eggs kids are allowed??

RaraRachael · 16/10/2026 17:08

DilemmaDelilah · 16/10/2026 08:11

For those families where all the presents come from Santa, does that mean that none of the actual present-givers ever get thanked then? That seems very ungrateful... My relatives were spread out over the country and some of them I didn't see very often - so after Christmas was a period of letter-writing to all my aunts and uncles. Nowadays I just get texts if not in person - but I'm always very glad to know my gifts have been received and appreciated.

More importantly... does that mean none of the presents appear until Christmas day?! Ours go under the tree as they arrive. They look lovely and build up the anticipation. It also quite fun to try to disguise the weird shaped ones... and I love to make them all look pretty and they make the tree look special.

Lastly... what about presents people bring themselves and give direct to the giftee? Doesn't that ever happen?

Edited

All the presents from mum and were in a sack from "Santa "
Presents from relatives went under the tree and they got Thank You letters written to them.

Ilovewatchingthedrama · 16/10/2026 17:26

We did the whole lot were from Santa apart from a few friends gifts that they saw being brought over. Godam Santa got a lot of kudos for all the effort we put in. When she got a bit older we used to say “auntie xxxx sent this to Santa for you “ to try and at least give the gift giver some credit. If I was able to do it again I would definitely say who the presents were actually from and have either 1 mystery present or the stocking from Santa .

SnowflakesandSlippers · 16/10/2026 17:46

DilemmaDelilah · 16/10/2026 08:11

For those families where all the presents come from Santa, does that mean that none of the actual present-givers ever get thanked then? That seems very ungrateful... My relatives were spread out over the country and some of them I didn't see very often - so after Christmas was a period of letter-writing to all my aunts and uncles. Nowadays I just get texts if not in person - but I'm always very glad to know my gifts have been received and appreciated.

More importantly... does that mean none of the presents appear until Christmas day?! Ours go under the tree as they arrive. They look lovely and build up the anticipation. It also quite fun to try to disguise the weird shaped ones... and I love to make them all look pretty and they make the tree look special.

Lastly... what about presents people bring themselves and give direct to the giftee? Doesn't that ever happen?

Edited

No, only pur gifts are from FC, dd writes a thank you letter to him as well as to any family members who have given her something. We only put gifts for others under our tree, not those from FC until they appear on the morning.

DancingCactusFlower · 16/10/2026 17:51

DD was scared of Santa and didn’t want him in the house. So our story was that I would tell Santa want to get, give him the money, he’d buy it, then on Christmas Eve, I’d meet him at the end of the road to pick up the presents. I’m not sure what he added to the process but worked for years.

LordVoldetort · 16/10/2026 19:37

We say that Santa brings all the gifts but we pay for them. Sometimes we pick them up and send them to the North Pole to be wrapped and other times he find the gifts for us. And that we supply the wrapping paper!
We say that when you become a parent, Santa asks you how you want to do Christmas for your kids which is why some people only have toys from Santa, others have some and also why some children (because of religion) don’t get gifts because they celebrate at other times

everynamewastaken · 16/10/2026 23:10

Personally I agree with your nursery and this is what we do for my daughter. We still talk about Santa but when I was little my parents were very transparent that we had a budget for Christmas and we chose our gifts accordingly. Santa just collected them all and wrapped them up - he also collected them from family members so we always knew who to say thank you to. I always remember us putting lots of thought into my cousins gifts (5 year age gap) and being a bit upset when they would talk about these amazing gifts Santa has brought them...and they never said thank you. It stuck with me and also we are now very fortunate but I don't want my daughter to grow up any different to how I did where we knew the value of things and really appreciated them because we knew it was a struggle for my parents. I also don't want to make any child feel less valued by a fictional character because that was also tough.

gonedancing · 17/10/2026 03:32

It was never discussed really. It was a running down the stairs and we just announced "he's been" and there was a presumption it all came from the big man. Their faces, full of joy and happiness, are all the thanks we need. Never understood the whole Santa isn't getting all the thanks thing. And never had any issues regarding someone else got more or less than me.

Lessismoree · 17/10/2026 04:16

All gifts from parents are Santa presents in my house. Just like Santa brought all my present when I was little

Natsku · 17/10/2026 06:50

Not the nursery's place to make demands like that, though I can see why they would like parents to agree.

In my house the presents under the tree are from us and family, the stocking is filled by the elves and Father Christmas brings round a few presents each later on (he visits in person in Finland), not anything too outrageous but something they've specifically asked for plus chocolates and suchlike. He also brings us adults chocolates Smile
By the time the kids go back to school I doubt they remember which presents were under the tree and which came from Father Christmas.

Greengage1983 · 17/10/2026 10:03

Everyone does it differently, often based on what they had growing up and that’s fine. The issue here I think is the nursery telling people what to do. They can make a suggestion, and say “some families choose to do this for this reason so perhaps you might like to do it too”, but actually asking families to change their traditions is very much none of their business.

I also think no adults besides the parents should be encouraging children to write Christmas lists!!! For one thing, in your case, it directly contradicts what they’re asking families to say! And parents need to be overseeing these things so they can manage expectations! When my DD was in reception we inadvertently visited a small local museum that had “writing and posting Christmas lists” as an activity, and she took it very seriously, wrote a letter and posted it to Santa in their little post box (with a real Royal Mail stamp that they were giving out!) before I’d even had a chance to look at it, and then refused to tell me what was written on it! I then had to spend a stressful 3 weeks trying various approaches to coax it out of her so that I had a chance of getting what she’d asked for (or managing expectations as necessary) and not ruining Christmas. Just… don’t. Just leave that to the parents, please!

Timeforachange26 · 17/10/2026 11:52

RaraRachael · 16/10/2026 17:08

All the presents from mum and were in a sack from "Santa "
Presents from relatives went under the tree and they got Thank You letters written to them.

So mum wasn't thanked then

Ilovesunshine22 · 17/10/2026 12:09

The stocking is from father christmas that they open first thing in the morning and the main presents under tree are from us, family friends etc

SnowflakesandSlippers · 17/10/2026 12:16

Timeforachange26 · 17/10/2026 11:52

So mum wasn't thanked then

Dd sends a thank you to FC, she is grateful for what she gets and that's what matters to me. I don't need any fuether thanks or 'credit'.

Timeforachange26 · 17/10/2026 16:49

SnowflakesandSlippers · 17/10/2026 12:16

Dd sends a thank you to FC, she is grateful for what she gets and that's what matters to me. I don't need any fuether thanks or 'credit'.

Glad that works for you. I'm not sure I'd want my kids to think I was the only one who didn't get them gifts.

And I did expect my kids to thank everyone ( myself included) who gave them gifts or did something for them.

It's basic manners. I may be their mother but that doesn't mean that I should do everything and get not so much as a thank you

SnowflakesandSlippers · 17/10/2026 17:18

Timeforachange26 · 17/10/2026 16:49

Glad that works for you. I'm not sure I'd want my kids to think I was the only one who didn't get them gifts.

And I did expect my kids to thank everyone ( myself included) who gave them gifts or did something for them.

It's basic manners. I may be their mother but that doesn't mean that I should do everything and get not so much as a thank you

Edited

I consider the thank you in general to be good manners. Dd also understands that we don't buy her anything as she has enough from FC and the rest of her family. She understands that she doesn't need more and actually she doesn't really want more, she's happy helping us choose what to get for others.

elh1605 · 17/10/2026 18:07

Father Christmas brings a stocking with things like choc coins, socks, wind up Santa, snowman pens, bath bomb etc then either 2 cheaper priced presents from list or 1 expensive item. Everything else is from us,family and friends. Why should he get all the credit😂🤣 My DD has just announced that Father Christmas is really me and hubby💔😭😭😭

LikeASoulWithoutAMind · 17/10/2026 18:25

Rubyreds45 · 14/10/2026 12:01

The communication from the nursery is what has irritated me the most really! Especially as the week before this email they had spent the afternoon doing a “christmas list for Santa” activity with clippings from catalogues of toys etc- a great craft activity for sure, they had been cutting them out, sticking them on, decorated, I bet the kids all really enjoyed it! BUT if you already know some of the kids are going to get every item on their list and others will likely get none or only 1, why bring that activity into nursery anyway.

They all came out with a A3 piece of paper, ours had about 20 little clippings stuck to it of toys she wants from Santa. If I were a parent who knows I only have a very small budget for Christmas this year then I’d be more annoyed by nursery having sat my child down to pick out hundreds of pounds worth of toys to ask Santa for than what other people were saying about where presents came from.

Omg that would have really annoyed me. Why on earth would they be encouraging the children to ask for 20 presents? 😯 Also it's way way too early to be talking to such small children about Christmas surely?

I was very very grateful that my children's infant school encouraged the children to think about one thing they would really really like when writing to Father Christmas. We've never done huge piles - they have stockings (chocolate and sweets, a Christmas decoration, some small toys when younger - more grown up these days 😀), books and then one main gift or 2-3 smaller ones.

Our house was always overflowing with toys so I don't think they went without. I've never done that thing of "padding it out" with PJs etc - they're not considered gifts in our house.

Ime families all do things differently and children are very accepting of that. One thing I would say is that as they get older they might notice that they get gifts from other family members but not you so you might want to include a least a small gift that's from Mummy and Daddy.

Timeforachange26 · 17/10/2026 21:06

SnowflakesandSlippers · 17/10/2026 17:18

I consider the thank you in general to be good manners. Dd also understands that we don't buy her anything as she has enough from FC and the rest of her family. She understands that she doesn't need more and actually she doesn't really want more, she's happy helping us choose what to get for others.

Edited

In my case it would stand out as just me not having bought anything. Their dad bought them gifts.as did all grandparents. So me, who had earned the money, bought and wrapped the gifts cooked and decorated the house is suddenly the mean mum for not buying any gifts

Why should I not get a thank you?