Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A Christmas/AIBU/what do you do about Santa presents

311 replies

Rubyreds45 · 14/10/2026 11:38

Who do your children think their presents come from- parents or Santa?

The situation is that our eldest child attends a nursery and last week the nursery put a message out essentially asking parents to tell their children that the majority of their presents are from their parents, and to choose just one present specifically something low cost (the examples they gave were PJ’s, chocolates, socks or a book) to be the present from Santa. Their explanation for this was that it prevents a situation they say they have had in previous years where all of the children come back in January chatting about Christmas presents and some children have had lots and lots of toys from Santa and other children have had a bar of chocolate & some socks from Santa, the children with less ended up confused and upset.

Growing up all of our presents were always from Santa (other than ones from family/friends), both of our kids are young enough that we’ve never really said who they are from yet and we are just wondering really is this what parents say now?

It has caused uproar among the nursery parents with strong opinions either side, lots saying that the magic of Christmas is piles from Santa and that they won’t change that, also lots saying its not fair on the children with parents who can’t afford huge piles and so they only get chocolate from Santa but find out at nursery that that friend got piles of toys and so they argue we all need to be saying those expensive things are from parents.

I don’t particularly have an opinion either way, so really just wondering what other parents do? Just one present from Santa? All from Santa? Particular low cost from Santa? All from parents? We are fortunate in that we can afford to buy for Christmas whatever our children want really, but I would hate to think that another child will hear ours talking about her toys and wonder why Santa didn’t bring him the same so I can definitely see the point in just having something low cost from Santa- but that only really works if everyone does it.

My only gripe with the nursery about the whole thing really is that as an activity the week before last they did a “lets do Christmas lists for Santa” activity so all kids sat round and produced lists of toys with help from staff obviously to bring home to parents. For me, if I was concerned about children feeling disappointed over Christmas presents I probably wouldn’t be encouraging them all to sit and write lists of toys together knowing that some of those children will get every item on their list and some will get none. Maybe that activity prompted a parent to complain and led to their message being sent out, who knows.

OP posts:
dahliadream · 16/10/2026 06:37

My little one is only four but we do exactly this - one present from Santa, plus a stocking, and the rest are from us.

Actually I was really glad of it only last week, we were walking past a window where they were collecting those little shoeboxes that you fill with gifts for children, and my little girl asked what they were for. I explained they were to send to boys and girls who might not be getting lots of Christmas presents, and she asked 'why isn't Father Christmas giving them presents?'. This way I was able to remind her that she only has one present from Father Christmas and mummy and daddy buy the rest with their money.

I absolutely hate the thought of some poor children thinking that Father Christmas is leaving them out, and anything I can do to mitigate that I will.

SnowflakesandSlippers · 16/10/2026 06:40

GeorgieBot · 16/10/2026 06:35

Stocking from FC, under the tree gifts from the actual givers.
For people saying it's none of the nursery's business - they are the ones there on the ground when the children are comparing! How are they supposed to explain to the children who got less?

They don't need to explain anything. Most children of nursery age are fairly unlikely to differentiate between who gave them what anyway. They will probably conoare the gift and not the giver. The same could be said if one child is given a fancy Barbie house or bike and another gets a colouring book, it really doesn't make much difference who it is from. Some people spend a lot on Christmas, others don't, people just do things differently.

NerWayGerAway · 16/10/2026 06:42

I see this kind of virtue signalling all over social media. I genuinely don’t think it makes much difference to the child who gets nothing or very little for Christmas to hear that Jack got a stocking of low value items from FC as well as a pile of presents from Mum and Dad. In my experience if a child got a bike/doll/slide/crayons or whatever was their most memorable thing for Christmas they’ll talk about that rather than who brought it anyway.
The nursery could do their bit by avoiding talking about Christmas gifts or who brought them as activities. I’ve always thought it odd that schools get involved with Father Christmas and elves etc, people keep traditions in so many different ways or don’t do them at all it’s impossible to get it right for every child. We ended up doing the stupid elves because of pressure from school.

Bigreddog25 · 16/10/2026 06:56

Santa leaves a stocking in their room full of cheap little bits
Then downstairs they have their pile from us plus a Santa sack with bigger cheap presents (that wouldn't find in their stocking)

Expensive stuff comes from us, exactly for the reason you described. My eldest has just started school and I don't want her telling people Santa got her expensive gifts. If she comes home saying Santa got someone else an expensive gift, I'll just tell her that's because Santa knows we can afford them.

CrabAppleTree1 · 16/10/2026 06:58

I ageee with the nursery. That’s exactly what we do. The list generated ‘for santa’ is used to make a list for us and family members to buy from. We have a deliberately small stocking from santa with a couple of small toys, chocolates, socks etc in.

A friend always told her kids she gave all the presents to santa to look after and he delivered them on xmas eve, maybe you could do that.

The kids can either get upset or stop believing very early if they behaved well but got very little and another kid is a bit if a terror but got something massive.

christmassaurus · 16/10/2026 07:00

We do stocking from santa (small bits - including a small toy, book, toothbrush, something edible, maybe one or two other things), then rest of the presents are from whoever got them (us, grandparents etc)

I'd actually be annoyed if nursery/school tried to dictate it tbh.

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 16/10/2026 07:01

One gift from Santa, we let them choose a toy but it had to be a small toy (£30 max). We tell them Santa is busy and has to get a toy for every child in the world.

I heard a thing similar to you when my eldest was little and it made sense, some parents can afford a hat and scarf so that’s what kids get from Santa and other kids get a PlayStation from Santa. The kid who gets the hat and scarf thinks they have been naughty as they only got a hat and scarf and other kids got a PlayStation,

More expensive presents are from us. They still get loads of present, but only one is from Santa. As other has said, if they think everything is from Santa then the concept of ‘that’s expensive, you can’t have a Lego set that is £130 and a Nintendo switch’ is complete lost on them. Mine understand Mummy and Daddy will buy you one big present, or two medium sized one, you need to decide which you want and then you can chose some smaller things too.

SeeMeRun · 16/10/2026 07:05

We had a vague story that we buy everything, but Santa takes them away and brings them back if they’ve been good. We never ever woke up on Xmas morning and said specifically that Santa brought every present, just that he’d been.
but I do agree with their point. I’m sure Santa just always used to be 1 thing, or a stocking. But for sone reason now a lot say everything is from him, which makes some kids feel like crap if their parents can’t afford much.

Myselforsomeonelikeme · 16/10/2026 07:17

I do a mix as actually I want my son to know his main presents came from mum and not Santa! But I would be really annoyed by the nursery's statement, to be frank it's nothing to do with them how families chose to do Christmas.

badboss2020 · 16/10/2026 07:17

Stocking from Father Christmas. (And one gift if you must).
This country is strange for the “piles” of presents. Have never and would never do that.

Iloveeverycat · 16/10/2026 07:23

I don't really think that they take a lot of notice of who the presents are from especially when younger they just enjoy opening them.

ByOliveDreamer · 16/10/2026 07:41

Father Christmas brings the stocking and maybe something handmade. Previous years he's brought personalised cardigan or handmade clothes for her doll.
We say the rest are from us and other family! X

AgileMentor · 16/10/2026 07:42

They know we buy the presents but Santa inspects them builds them and wraps them.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/10/2026 07:44

I’m shocked that nursery age children remember who got them what by the time they go back in January. I think for older kids it’s better to have the expensive things from mum and dad, also so that the parents get some credit and gratitude too!

Kerri44 · 16/10/2026 07:46

Santa delivers all the presents but they only get 1 from him, the rest we send him a list and money for as they need to know the budget isn't unlimited!!!

Timeforachange26 · 16/10/2026 07:52

Lauzg90 · 16/10/2026 06:11

I follow a similar philosophy for the same reason.
So we write lists to Santa, he will bring more than pjs though. Stocking are from santa. He will then leave 2/3 presents (different wrapping paper to ours, obviously!) on the kitchen table where his milk and mince pie was. It is usually things they specifically asked for, not big because ‘santa has limited room on the sleigh’. Last year the main santa presents were a crate of peppa bubbles for the 2 year old and a wicked barbie type doll for the 5 year old.
The rest of the presents are from us. As others have said, it helps keep the lists realistic. My husband pointed out Santa shouldn’t get all the credit for our (my 🤣) hard work! I also think that it seems strange that loads of random friends and family buy you presents but your parents get you nothing!
When I was a child my Mum use to ‘send’ my presents to santa to stop me looking for them! However as an adult I don’t get this. Why would he need a workshop then?!

Lol got visions of drop shipping Santa now

RaraRachael · 16/10/2026 07:55

I taught little ones and by the time January came round a lot of them couldn't remember what they'd got from whoever.

QuiteUnbelievable · 16/10/2026 08:01

One year the pile came from free places and charity shops so why can't the parents do that for small DC ?
My DC had cast off clear out toys and they were well...toys and dc didn't notice ?

We do all main gifts from father Christmas and anyone else who gives gives seperatly

QuiteUnbelievable · 16/10/2026 08:02

Also our lists have always been sold as a guide ...may get one or two things ...may get nothing ...it's a guide no issues or problems with that here

Humblebumbley · 16/10/2026 08:04

Santa brings the gifts that are in their stockings - a handful of small toys and accessories for them to open. Main gifts are from us.

Three reasons;

  1. The reason the nursery pointed out.
  2. I think it looks weird that everyone in your family is supposed to have bought you gifts except your own parents? Also we worked hard to buy them and spent time and effort choosing them. I want my kids to know and appreciate that.
  3. I think it lessens the blow when they find out Santa isn’t real. Some kids find out younger than they should and it can be extra upsetting to them to know they’ve been lied to for years. Removing some of his importance as the one who brings all the big gifts makes it less harsh.
DilemmaDelilah · 16/10/2026 08:11

For those families where all the presents come from Santa, does that mean that none of the actual present-givers ever get thanked then? That seems very ungrateful... My relatives were spread out over the country and some of them I didn't see very often - so after Christmas was a period of letter-writing to all my aunts and uncles. Nowadays I just get texts if not in person - but I'm always very glad to know my gifts have been received and appreciated.

More importantly... does that mean none of the presents appear until Christmas day?! Ours go under the tree as they arrive. They look lovely and build up the anticipation. It also quite fun to try to disguise the weird shaped ones... and I love to make them all look pretty and they make the tree look special.

Lastly... what about presents people bring themselves and give direct to the giftee? Doesn't that ever happen?

IsThistheMiddleofNowhere · 16/10/2026 08:21

When my children were young, everything - stockings at the end of the bed and sacks at the Christmas tree (apart from gifts from relatives) came from Father Christmas - it was more magical for them. Then when they were around 6 years old, they asked why they didnt get anything from their parents like the other kids at school so then we wrapped a couple of things in different paper and said they were from mum and dad and then by the time they were 7 or 8 they knew Father Christmas didnt exist and it was all orchestrated by the parents, although they played along with it for another 2 or 3 years.

VeronicaDean · 16/10/2026 08:21

In my family it's always been a, seemingly, complex narrative that we all managed to easily understand from a very young age...

Father Christmas makes and brings the presents but only when asked to, and sent the money, from the person / people wanting to give the present. Children know who the gifts are from and can be grateful to those people whilst still having the magic of Father Christmas bringing all the gifts on Christmas Eve.

Our stockings were always from Father Christmas (pants, socks, colouring books, chocolate) and occasionally we'd have a small gift that he'd left for us (which always came out later in the day and may have been one that "fell off his sleigh"!).

StrawberryPie83 · 16/10/2026 08:22

Always said all the presents were from us.
we have a budget so she wont get everything she wants
Never anything from Santa. - to many kids at school said "well your naughty then" if they dont get everything they want. & not putting up with that! - This was reception class btw, not older years!

Told her Santa is the delivery guy thats all he's there for.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 16/10/2026 08:33

I don't understand the nursery's reasoning at all. Kids surely talk about what they got for Christmas, not who they got it from.
For what it's worth, my kids (now 40+) had a stocking to open in bed/our bed/ grandparents' bed, depending where we were, and bigger/other presents downstairs. We didn't refer to Santa but I assume they believed they came from Father Christmas while they were tiny and real people later (say post-6).