Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is sending nice buns into school showing off?

301 replies

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:18

Possibly very much overthinking here, but it is my daughters birthday on Wednesday (turning 9) her class normally take a sweet treat/cake in on on their birthdays, this is fine with the parents and no one has allergies (know this from several parties). I love baking but never really do it much, last year I made and took in some cupcakes, I'm a home baker but can turn out a decent cupcake, planning to do it this year again but my husband has said that I shouldn't, that it is very much attention seeking and very 'look at me" This isn't my intention at all, I have most of the ingrediants in the cupboard all ready, it'll only cost me about £4 to make 36 buns, I only have to buy the butter and some icing sugar. I have boxes already that I bought in bulk from Temu and tbh I just like baking. But I would hate to be talked about by any of the mum's, or for people to think that I'm attempting to show off, parents would see them as they are normally given out last thing. Should I just buy some shop bought cake or buns, which would cost me more money and not be as nice? I'm inclined to think that my husband is been harsh, they will look nice when done, but I reckon people will still be able to tell that they are homemade and that I haven't spent loads of money buying them. Thanks.

OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · 13/10/2026 04:30

thirdfiddle · 13/10/2026 01:21

What do school let you do OP? Ours said if you wanted to hand out anything for birthdays, you did it in the playground after school so parents were responsible for what the child was allowed or not allowed and they didn't try to eat them in school and make a mess. Not many did, but we'd think it was a lovely thing when someone did give the kids something and certainly not judge anything except your kindness.

I'm here for the bun/cupcake debate though. I don't think even cake style buns are the same thing as cupcakes. Cupcakes are deeper, more decorative, and have a high proportion of buttercream to cake which I personally find pretty inedible. Buns are made in more like a mince pie tin. Fancy when I was little was cutting the top off your buns and setting it in buttercream like little wings to make a fairy cake. Like this:
https://www.tesco.com/recipes/en-GB/recipe/fairy-cakes?srsltid=AU7gw4UcA-meZ7pdxzuKIr11OvrWRZq0IFNB4HPZyeawEH9KyZRWVcoB
And that was considered a lot of icing. This cupcake thing is Too Much.

It's not incorrect, it's usage in different parts of the country.

To me a muffin is bread, an oven bottom muffin, and not a cake.

SquirrelGG · 13/10/2026 04:44

TofuTuesday · 12/10/2026 22:28

I don’t know if this is true - having seen some people’s houses I avoid home made unless I know the person and their cleanliness really well.

Oh for goodness sake! In my whole working life if anyone brought in home baking we all fell on it. Guess what, no-one ever got sick. Honestly, how do some of you get through life? Home made is usually vastly superior to commercial baking.

It's a lovely idea OP. Ignore your miserable DH.

Edited to say I am jealous - I'm not a good baker!

MsSmartShoes · 13/10/2026 05:03

I’d rather home made. Bought cake is full of UPF rubbish.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 13/10/2026 05:18

If it's not unusual to take a cake or cupcakes in for the class then bake away.

Bjorkdidit · 13/10/2026 05:28

SquirrelGG · 13/10/2026 04:44

Oh for goodness sake! In my whole working life if anyone brought in home baking we all fell on it. Guess what, no-one ever got sick. Honestly, how do some of you get through life? Home made is usually vastly superior to commercial baking.

It's a lovely idea OP. Ignore your miserable DH.

Edited to say I am jealous - I'm not a good baker!

Edited

This. We have cake at work and the home made ones always get devoured the same day and the shop bought ones linger on for days. MN is utterly weird with it's fear of perceived bad hygiene and the non existent risk of illness - exactly how many people have been made ill from eating baked goods made in less than sterile conditions?

However, threads like this always make me wonder why we have so many people that are now deathly allergic as it's only in the last couple of decades that this has arisen. I know there have always been people with allergies and some of them will have died due to consuming allergens but there has been a significant increase over the last couple of decades and it seems that it's quite likely that hygiene obsession is a strong factor in this.

The Rise in Allergies and Asthma: Understanding the Epidemic | LACK Clinic

So if we hadn't had all these people bleaching everything in sight for no reason at all and throwing away anything home made, we probably wouldn't have so many people allergic in the first place.

The Rise in Allergies and Asthma: Understanding the Epidemic | LACK Clinic

Learn why allergies and asthma have increased dramatically in recent decades. Explore the latest research on causes and what Professor Lack's groundbreaking studies reveal.

https://www.londonallergy.com/knowledge/understanding/allergy-epidemic

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 13/10/2026 05:36

This is a warm up event for the annual bunfight (no, I'm not sorry) that ensues when someone posts asking if she should give home-made food as Christmas gifts. A small number of paranoid people explain at length that they throw all home-made food in the bin because of hygiene concerns. I would really like to know how many people fall ill each year from food poisoning after eating home-made fudge, cake, chutney etc as compared with food poisoning traced to takeaways, restaurant meals or poorly cooked home meals featuring meat, fish or other higher risk foods.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/10/2026 05:42

Sleepyjeancheeredup · 12/10/2026 22:51

Oh, we're doing the sealion dance I see.

Sealioning is "a bad faith rhetorical strategy or form of online harassment, rather than a strict logical fallacy. An interlocutor feigns polite ignorance and relentlessly demands evidence or explanations to exhaust the target. The goal is not to learn, but to wear down the opponent through an endless series of seemingly reasonable questions until they lose their temper or disengage, at which point the "sealion" claims victory by portraying the victim as unreasonable or closed-minded."

So, with that, are we trying to pretend shops don't have hygiene standards that they are required by law to follow? And that this is nothing at all like a stranger preparing food in their own home?

Here, let me throw you a fish.

You have clearly never worked in the food industry. 😂

OP. I bloody love a homemade cake or bun - I'd check that the school are happy for you to do this first (I suspect some might not be) and if so go for it.

Sleepyjeancheeredup · 13/10/2026 06:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hotdoughnut · 13/10/2026 06:00

I'm struggling to imagine how cupcakes could look like showing off? Surely everyone can make a decent cupcake with piped buttercream or similar? They sound lovely. But it's weird calling them buns!

justaddittothelist · 13/10/2026 06:04

I'm confused whether OP is making buns or cupcakes?
I presume it's cupcakes given the mention of icing? And it would be pretty weird to me to give out a bun to kids in a class....do other people call cupcakes buns? Genuinely never heard this before.

TattieSconeEggAndBacon · 13/10/2026 06:09

Make the cakes. I don’t understand all the people worried about the hygiene. The cakes are for the kids? Unless the cakes are actually going to make them ill (they won’t) what 8 year old cares if the baker didn’t have her hair tied back or double dipped a finger?

IStillHearTheWaves · 13/10/2026 06:14

Don't let your husband put you off!

My mum is a brilliant cake maker and decorator and made homemade birthday cakes every year and I still remember it today.

Wingingit73 · 13/10/2026 06:16

Your husband is negging you! Its a lovely idea.

TheBlueKoala · 13/10/2026 06:30

@Luce1234 I would definitely not think you were trying to show off. In my children's school there is a strict rule about no homebaked goods though so check in beforehand. It has to do with tracability. On storebought cake all ingredients and allergenes are listed so one can make sure there is no nuts/whatever if someone has allergies. It might be school watching their back as well. If someone with poor hygiene send in baked goods and all the kids get sick school will be held responsable. You are allowed to sell homebaked goods for pta infront of school because then it's the parents that buy so school is not responsible.

I am comforted seeing that there are others who are hesitant eating homebaked goods for hygiene reasons. I'm quite embarrassed about feeling that way and I thought it was me being a bit ott and a bit weird so happy to see I'm not the only one. I know that the risk of being sick from eating a homebaked cake is very low even if the person hasn't washed their hands (unless the person happens to be ill) so for me it's more of a psychological feeling of disgust. Thankfully I haven't passed it on to my kids who would happily eat cake the whole class had touched 😅🤢

runnerducky · 13/10/2026 06:43

Skipping past every tedious mention of sea lions and fish, I don’t think it is a ‘common boundary’. Certainly I’ve never seen it, homemade cakes are always devoured at work, at school events, when I run volunteer events, when I go to village events, kids parties, by adults and kids. So I don’t think it’s really a consideration worth spending time on, one person’s foibles generally aren’t, but the allergy thing might be - I don’t know about school but DD2’s nursery only accepts shop-bought cake with a list of allergens.

FiveEightNine · 13/10/2026 06:43

YABU to buy anything food adjacent from Temu.

NeelyOHara · 13/10/2026 06:48

RikthePoet · 12/10/2026 22:29

There's always one!

Make that two.

runnerducky · 13/10/2026 06:49

Bjorkdidit · 13/10/2026 05:28

This. We have cake at work and the home made ones always get devoured the same day and the shop bought ones linger on for days. MN is utterly weird with it's fear of perceived bad hygiene and the non existent risk of illness - exactly how many people have been made ill from eating baked goods made in less than sterile conditions?

However, threads like this always make me wonder why we have so many people that are now deathly allergic as it's only in the last couple of decades that this has arisen. I know there have always been people with allergies and some of them will have died due to consuming allergens but there has been a significant increase over the last couple of decades and it seems that it's quite likely that hygiene obsession is a strong factor in this.

The Rise in Allergies and Asthma: Understanding the Epidemic | LACK Clinic

So if we hadn't had all these people bleaching everything in sight for no reason at all and throwing away anything home made, we probably wouldn't have so many people allergic in the first place.

It’s interesting because there is also evidence that too much cleanliness is also one of the reasons behind a rise in childhood leukaemia. Children’s immune systems need to be challenged in the early months and years of their life.
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/dec/30/children-leukaemia-mel-greaves-microbes-protection-against-disease

‘For 30 years I’ve been obsessed by why children get leukaemia. Now we have an answer’

Newly knighted cancer scientist Mel Greaves explains why a cocktail of microbes could give protection against disease

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/dec/30/children-leukaemia-mel-greaves-microbes-protection-against-disease

FlatCatYellowMat · 13/10/2026 06:49

I have a friend who does lovely cakes and this is her go-to - we all think it's brilliant.

She has a bit of a side-hussle doing birthday cakes too, and the school already does a couple of bake sales a year where the children are encouraged to cook something (although buying is also fine) so hygiene really isn't a problem - people are fine with home baking still here.

UnintentionalArcher · 13/10/2026 06:51

It is in no way ‘look at me’. Your husband is being ridiculous. People who don’t want to eat it because they don’t eat things that aren’t shop-bought can just say no.

JustGoogleIt15 · 13/10/2026 06:52

Your husband isn't being nice. Why does he put you down? When does he do this? Regularly?

I wouldn't eat your cakes because I don't eat home cooked food unless I know the kitchen. But that's ME being weird

Your husband, however, has tiny dick energy

IamnotSethRogan · 13/10/2026 06:53

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:42

Thanks for your replies, I didn't even think of people thinking of hygiene 😟 We have been to several village hall parties where the parents have done buffets though and no one seemed to turn their nose up at the food, my kitchen is clean and it's not like she's the smelly child or anything.

I don't think it's a particularly normal attitude to have those level of hygiene concerns. Any nose picking, cock fiddling with minger can work in a factory.

JayJayj · 13/10/2026 06:53

Is it showing off? Maybe. But who cares!! My daughter started nursery this September, I was gutted I could only take sweets in due to things needing to be free from nuts, eggs and milk.

I am a home baker also, I do some amazing cakesickles and cupcakes. Make them and show off your talent!!

Theonethatlurks · 13/10/2026 06:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Gravygranules · 13/10/2026 07:13

I guess this depends on what's the norm in your class. In both my DC classes it's usually a small bag of haribo so someone turning up with a homemade cupcake would be trying way too hard. If it's usually cakes/baked goods then yes it's absolutely fine.

I would check the new allergy policy with the school, DD has a nut allergy and I've just had to do a new form & plan for her due to the changes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread