Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is sending nice buns into school showing off?

301 replies

Luce1234 · 12/10/2026 22:18

Possibly very much overthinking here, but it is my daughters birthday on Wednesday (turning 9) her class normally take a sweet treat/cake in on on their birthdays, this is fine with the parents and no one has allergies (know this from several parties). I love baking but never really do it much, last year I made and took in some cupcakes, I'm a home baker but can turn out a decent cupcake, planning to do it this year again but my husband has said that I shouldn't, that it is very much attention seeking and very 'look at me" This isn't my intention at all, I have most of the ingrediants in the cupboard all ready, it'll only cost me about £4 to make 36 buns, I only have to buy the butter and some icing sugar. I have boxes already that I bought in bulk from Temu and tbh I just like baking. But I would hate to be talked about by any of the mum's, or for people to think that I'm attempting to show off, parents would see them as they are normally given out last thing. Should I just buy some shop bought cake or buns, which would cost me more money and not be as nice? I'm inclined to think that my husband is been harsh, they will look nice when done, but I reckon people will still be able to tell that they are homemade and that I haven't spent loads of money buying them. Thanks.

OP posts:
ithinkilikethislittlelife · 13/10/2026 07:14

Fabulous idea but I would check with the school first as they may have a child/children with allergies.

LemonPenguin · 13/10/2026 07:16

Sweets are the norm in my kids’ school but there are a few who always do a homemade cake or biscuit (the ones who are excellent home bakers), it never occurred to me to think anything about it beyond a ‘aw that’s a nice thing to do!’ DD eats it and we move on. I can’t imagine rolling my eyes at the mum or thinking she’s a try hard- I think anyone that does can be safely on your list of people to avoid OP! If you think your DD would like it, and you would enjoy doing it- do it!

ISpyNoPlumPie · 13/10/2026 07:20

Cupcakes are not showing off. What a strange take from your undermining DH. They are one of the simplest things to bake with only four ingredients and a bit of icing.

However, our school has a very strict policy on birthday treats, essentially they are not allowed at all. This is on allergy grounds and on health grounds. There are certain standards around health that they have to adhere to for school lunches and they also ask that children do not bring chocolate, sweets, or fizzy drinks in their packed lunches. There are 60 children in a year in our Primary School and I guess they don’t want 60 treats - nearly 2 treats a week in every year going home. I think there’s also an issue of not everyone being able to afford to hand out a birthday treat so it is just banned. I’m glad of that, I would hate the expectation to have to do something. I’m surprised all schools aren’t like this now, but since your school isn’t OP, do whatever you want.

Chromm · 13/10/2026 07:21

Sleepyjeancheeredup · 12/10/2026 23:42

Moves sealions out of the way.

So anyway, OP, as I said, I wouldn't eat anything prepared by a stranger in their own home, it's a perfectly standard reasonable hygiene concern and nothing to do with you personally. I wouldn't say a word, I just wouldn't eat it, and would try to stop my child from eating it.

But if they did, oh well, such is life, they used to eat dirt from time to time so they'll likely be fine.

However to be clear, this is not an uncommon boundary hygiene, it's very common indeed.

To return to your question however, I would not say it looked like showing off, and the sort of people who think that will be impossible to please anyway.

As you can see from this thread, a lot of women are just barking mad and desperate to have a go if they possibly can, they will pick any and no reason at all for starting a fight in an empty house.

You will find as you go through school there are a lot of deeply unpleasant people out there (and they're all on Mumsnet 😅)

I'd just buy something from a shop, but that's your choice obviously.

The thought behind it is kind.

There's not a single other word I need to write to clarify anything, and I have covered all the bases here so I will leave you to the barking sealions :)

Often in kids’ parties, the parent (mum) makes the birthday cake. Do you warn your child not to eat it?

it is just a straightforward question and it would be great to have a straightforward answer.

OneFunBrickNewt · 13/10/2026 07:22

God no kid will care and if the teachers hands them out at the end of the day no parent will see them as they'll be eaten straigtt away.

Bestfootforward11 · 13/10/2026 07:24

I think just make the buns! They sound lovely. Life is too short. If people gossip, that’s says a lot about them. Write the ingredients on the box for allergy awareness. And check with the school they are ok with it. People can choose for their child to eat/not eat it as they would with any food.

Chromm · 13/10/2026 07:25

DoNotComply · 13/10/2026 00:01

I never thought twice about stuff like this until I started reading Mumsnet! I and my kids have survived many years of PTA cakes stalls, church coffee mornings and the like with no ill effects.

I suppose I tend to assume that people who can be bothered to go to the trouble of baking some nice cakes will also bother to take basic hygiene precautions.

ETA: not showing off, ignore your grumpy husband and go for it!

Edited

Same. My kids are at uni and graduated, and we have had many home-made cakes and other items. At parties and fairs, and never had food poisoning or ill effects. Though, I have never been around people that I ever suspected of being ‘dirty’. (The only rare cases of food poisoning I have had have been from a restaurant, and it is actually not that easy to report it.).

OP, my kids would have loved your homemade cupcakes. Don’t overthink it. People who are going to be difficult about it are probably
difficult in all sorts of ways and would probably turn down any offering. Make it with good intentions and I’m sure many people will appreciate it.

TheRealSmurfette · 13/10/2026 07:26

Not being unreasonable at all op go for it!!

Not sure what you mean by buns. I’m imagining burger buns or hot cross buns…?

TheRealSmurfette · 13/10/2026 07:28

ithinkilikethislittlelife · 13/10/2026 07:14

Fabulous idea but I would check with the school first as they may have a child/children with allergies.

She literally said there are no allergies 🙄

Chromm · 13/10/2026 07:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Do you think you are being clever or amusing? Is this your usual style of debate? Because you are coming across as quite rude to many people on here.

Ladyymuck · 13/10/2026 07:30

Sorry I clicked on yabu mistakenly but you are definitely not being unreasonable. Bake your buns and take them into school, what a lovely treat for everyone.

Chromm · 13/10/2026 07:30

TheRealSmurfette · 13/10/2026 07:26

Not being unreasonable at all op go for it!!

Not sure what you mean by buns. I’m imagining burger buns or hot cross buns…?

I think it’s a regional thing. Some people call cupcakes, buns.

ParsonMaybold · 13/10/2026 07:30

Definitely not showing off, but I’m another odd bod that wouldn’t eat something homemade due to hygiene (unless I knew the person well enough). Also, I’m not sure kids love buns? Small cakes would be better.

InterestedDad37 · 13/10/2026 07:33

Make your cakes/buns and be proud of them 😊 🍰 Your DH is being weird, and if some are paranoid about hygiene, sod 'em, that's their choice. It's a lovely thing to do, and your daughter will also be proud of you 😊

Chromm · 13/10/2026 07:33

I think the paranoid madness about home-made food is another symbol of our sick modern society. The overwhelming anxiety. The helicopter parenting. The germ phobia. The having to wash bath towels every day. Not letting kids go on playdates. Not opening the door when the bell rings etc. I work in mental health and think we are getting it so wrong as a society now. I don’t blame individuals. Anxiety is contagious.

EdithBond · 13/10/2026 07:34

Sorry, voted YABU. But in response to you questioning whether to do it.

Your DH is being silly. Homemade cup cakes sound lovely. If it’s your DC’s birthday, you’re hardly showing off.

Billy47 · 13/10/2026 07:35

I wouldnt even give it a second thought
Its a cake. My kids would have eaten it before we get out of the school gates.

Strawberrryfields · 13/10/2026 07:38

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 12/10/2026 22:58

Making your own buns is a lovely thing to do.
You will earn the "try-hard" label if the decorations look too polished. Aim for an aesthetic of "I decorated these in 5 minutes flat with my left hand while doing my hair with my right hand, sorry they are a bit slapdash" rather than "I made Paul Hollywood weep with pleasure at the sight of these buns"

I think it’s a nice idea but so many people seem to think this way if you make the slightest effort to do anything! I find the competitive self-deprecation tedious. Everyone has their strengths and things they enjoy doing. We shouldn’t have to pretend that we’re really half-arsing everything.

durdledoris · 13/10/2026 07:39

Sounds lovelybut as a shool we'd need to know all the ingredients for allergy purposes.

Sprogonthetyne · 13/10/2026 07:39

Your husband is being ridiculous but my kids school specifically ban home made cakes. Any food to be shared must be shop bought and in sealed original packet.

Absolutely not saying there would be any issue with your kitchen, but the school cannot judge the hygiene standards of every kitchen. So have this rule to cover all bases. Might be worth checking if it's allowed.

RikthePoet · 13/10/2026 07:40

To be clear, this is not an uncommon madcap opinion, it's very common indeed.

Genevieva · 13/10/2026 07:40

I’d far rather my child had a homemade bun with real butter than some shop bought crap.

Owlbookend · 13/10/2026 07:44

My DD is in Y10. Recently, a friend brought biscuits they had made to share with the friend group on her birthday. Everyone thought it was lovely, not showing off & no 'hygiene concerns'.
OP it is nice thing to do. Anyone who thinks it is 'showing off' has their own issues. As for those with 'hygiene issues' surely that would be a small minority (Do they never eat in others houses? Would they stop their child eating homemade cake at a party?). I'd just check with the teacher first that they are happy for your DD to give them out. You dont want to go to the effort of making them for your DD to.be disappointed. There may be a blanket rule because of potential allergies etc.
& a bun is a fairy cake/cupcake in this context.

NetZeroZealot · 13/10/2026 07:48

It’s a lovely thing to do OP.

ignore the weird hygiene freaks who would prefer to stuff themselves with upf enriched crap from the supermarket.

PussyGaylore · 13/10/2026 07:51

Unless you have a food hygiene certificate, I’d probably send in some shop bought cakes and save your baking skills for when you host parties etc.