Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To comment on every single “Die de Muertos” pub party that’s its cultural appropriation?

381 replies

Stayinganontoday · 12/10/2026 19:36

I’ve seen so many parties popping up around my county that are using AI slop to advertise their “Day of the Death” parties when a) nobody who’s Mexican has been consulted b) the food has nothing to do with Mexican food c) it’s a solemn family occasion - not a fiesta! And no, we don’t do face painting.

Every single time I see one, my eye twitches! I’m sure if a random persons (that had nothing to do with Hinduism) decided to throw a “Diwali party” people wouldn’t stay quiet.

Sorry it’s been one of those days and needed a rant!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 14:45

tartyflette · 12/10/2026 21:36

My DH is London Irish, born of Irish immigrant parents, and raised in a very Irish part of north London, totally within the Irish community, and went to Catholic schools which were about 90 percent Irish.
You can’t tell him he is anything other than Irish. His heritage is very important to him, his older brother and our DS (who considers his Irish background rather more important than his admittedly scrappy English one.)
DH would spend the entire summer holidays from school back with the family in Ireland every year and is still close to his cousins there.
Paddy’s day was very important for celebrating Irishness, and feeling part of that community when he lived in north London but is sadly less so to him these days since we moved away. However both he and DS are heartily and genuinely welcomed back into the fold whenever they visit the old country.
St Patrick’s day epitomises all of that to them, not so much religion any longer but Ireland and a real Irish sense of community.

What is a 'scrappy' English background? How is it 'scrappier' than your DH's Irish heritage, given that he was born in England?

I have no issue with him feeling very connected to his Irish roots, but I don't understand why you and your son would want to to belittle or dismiss your own Englishness in comparison.

Your son is every bit as English as he is Irish, (and probably more so) surely, given that his father wasn't even born in Ireland and is a Londoner through and through.

CoffeeCantata · 16/10/2026 14:54

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 14:45

What is a 'scrappy' English background? How is it 'scrappier' than your DH's Irish heritage, given that he was born in England?

I have no issue with him feeling very connected to his Irish roots, but I don't understand why you and your son would want to to belittle or dismiss your own Englishness in comparison.

Your son is every bit as English as he is Irish, (and probably more so) surely, given that his father wasn't even born in Ireland and is a Londoner through and through.

Edited

This reminded me of a couple of those 'Who Do You Think You Are?" programmes some years back .

Certain celebs (John Hurt and Jeremy Irons, to be precise) were hugely disappointed to find that stories of Irish ancestry in their families turned out not to be true.

It's great to be Irish. It's also great to be English, Welsh or Scottish. But being silly about it and seeing one as better than another is dodgy.

I love that all these nations cherish their heritage, traditions and language - but I roll my eyes when this leads to disparaging other cultures.

CoffeeCantata · 16/10/2026 14:57

I think festivals should be inclusive and are a way of bringing people together, sharing cultural knowledge and connecting with other people. They often show how much people from different countries and cultures actually have in common.

I feel really strongly that no-one should be turned away from taking part in any festival they wish to so long as they do so respectfully.

mathanxiety · 16/10/2026 17:21

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 14:45

What is a 'scrappy' English background? How is it 'scrappier' than your DH's Irish heritage, given that he was born in England?

I have no issue with him feeling very connected to his Irish roots, but I don't understand why you and your son would want to to belittle or dismiss your own Englishness in comparison.

Your son is every bit as English as he is Irish, (and probably more so) surely, given that his father wasn't even born in Ireland and is a Londoner through and through.

Edited

A passport doesn't make you British in the same way as a sense of community identity does.

I have three passports. I really only consider myself part of one country/ one heritage/ one culture, and probably equally foreign to the other two, even though I'm very familiar with both of them and have lived in one 'foreign' place longer than anywhere else so far.

mathanxiety · 16/10/2026 17:30

NoHangoversToday · 15/10/2026 09:09

This is basically what I wanted to say.

God, celebrating other cultures is what turned me into a committed Russophile ad led to me working for 10 years in former Soviet Union countries, my DS1 a devoted Francophile and is what made my father go back to university after retiring to study China and spend every spare bit of cash he has travelling all around China.

White English people, all of us.

YYY to all of that.
Nothing like a bit of polyphony in Old Church Slavonic.

mathanxiety · 16/10/2026 17:41

EdithBond · 15/10/2026 07:06

While I wholeheartedly agree with what you say (e.g. the Anglo-Saxons were mass migrants who changed the language and culture of England forever) this is not OP’s point.

There’s been no wave of incomers from Mexico. There are few people of Mexican heritage in Cornwall. So, why are pubs there putting on Dia de Muertos nights?

Surely, you can see it’s taking a deeply significant part of a culture and turning it into a cheap marketing theme for commercial gain.

All Saints Day is a holy day of obligation (to attend Mass) if you're an observant Catholic. Whether Hallowe'en (i.e. All Hallows Eve) came first or All Saints Day and the theory behind it did, the feast day has been swamped by the current incarnation of Hallowe'en.

Doesn't stop millions of observant Catholics from participating in both aspects of the season.

And the Irish and Scots have had to stand by and watch what Hollywood has done to their quaint rural customs involving turnips, teen boys dressed as old women, and traditions of soothsaying using items baked into fruit cakes.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread