Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To comment on every single “Die de Muertos” pub party that’s its cultural appropriation?

381 replies

Stayinganontoday · 12/10/2026 19:36

I’ve seen so many parties popping up around my county that are using AI slop to advertise their “Day of the Death” parties when a) nobody who’s Mexican has been consulted b) the food has nothing to do with Mexican food c) it’s a solemn family occasion - not a fiesta! And no, we don’t do face painting.

Every single time I see one, my eye twitches! I’m sure if a random persons (that had nothing to do with Hinduism) decided to throw a “Diwali party” people wouldn’t stay quiet.

Sorry it’s been one of those days and needed a rant!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Dollymylove · 15/10/2026 08:14

DebbieSavage · 14/10/2026 09:55

Well enlighten me then, what is our culture? The only thing I can think of is slavery and colonialism, everything else we stole or appropriated from other cultures.

Christ almighty I bet you are a barrel of laughs at parties 😂😂

ObelixtheGaul · 15/10/2026 08:30

Stayinganontoday · 13/10/2026 06:50

I mean you can say whatever you like but Wicca as we know it was an invention by Gerard Gardner. Triumph of the Moon is an interesting book on that topic.

To be honest, most modern notions of 'paganism' are Victorian inventions. I know a few so-called Pagans and most of it is a mish mash of Victorian romanticism, folk tales/tradition and a massive chunk of Hollywood.

The problem is that English culture owes a lot to myth and legend. Unlike some other cultures, including Irish, Scottish and Welsh, we haven't preserved a lot of the culture surrounding our pre-Roman existence through active use. Many of the rituals, ceremonies and beliefs that would have been practised weren't written down, they were passed down. When they ceased to be passed down, that deeper understanding was lost, to be replaced by, yes, some genuine archaeological interpretation, but also an awful lot of conjecture and downright deliberate invention.

This is part of the evolution of culture for us, but it might explain, though not necessarily excuse, our tendency to bastardize other cultural concepts. We have spent centuries doing it with our own culture. Several people have mentioned Christmas. How many of those 'traditions' owe more to Queen Victoria than they do to early Christianity?

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2026 08:35

EdithBond · 15/10/2026 07:06

While I wholeheartedly agree with what you say (e.g. the Anglo-Saxons were mass migrants who changed the language and culture of England forever) this is not OP’s point.

There’s been no wave of incomers from Mexico. There are few people of Mexican heritage in Cornwall. So, why are pubs there putting on Dia de Muertos nights?

Surely, you can see it’s taking a deeply significant part of a culture and turning it into a cheap marketing theme for commercial gain.

It doesn't matter. People all over the world do this kind of thing. Look at the way all once-religious festivals are trivialised. If you're religious, you celebrate them in that way, but other people will join in the event at a more 'frivolous' level. It doesn't do any harm.

I'm always touched when people from other religions than mine (er...I mean culture really, because I'm an atheist) or other nations, join in with Christmas or Easter - it's lovely and brings people together, even if it's only the chocolate eggs!

I just don't take these things so seriously - that's the way wars start - because someone has 'offended your religion etc'.

The more the merrier at whatever level they want to join in.

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2026 08:41

sashh · 15/10/2026 05:58

Hang on didn't you invent Halloween?

Mexico took a Celtic festival and made it their own.

Firstly (and sorry for being pedantic), 'Celtic' is best seen as a linguistic, not an ethnic or cultural descriptor. It's used in a vague way to mean pre-Roman, or not Germanic, but it really doesn't mean that. It's best seen as referring to a family of Indo-European languages which were spoken by a range of people in Europe in prehistory. It doesn't tell us anything about their ethnicity or even their culture.

Secondly many cultures mark the onset of shorter days, darker nights in a variety of ways, just as they do the coming of spring and the other astronomical landmarks such as solstices and equinoxes. Religions have adopted these older festivals into their calendar - it's just a natural way of keeping everyone happy.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 15/10/2026 09:03

The Spanish took Dia de los Muertos and placed it over an old existing Christian festival honouring the dead, the thinning of the veil between the two worlds, All Saints Day and All Souls Day.

Just as Hallowe'en has been commercialised, so has Day of the Dead. Perhaps if the Spanish had not moved it then you would be able to celebrate it as intended during the summer months and I'm quite sure it would not be adopted or bastardized.

However, you cannot blame society for doing both festivals at the same time when Dia de los Muertos was moved on to a pre-existing Christian occasion and, lets be honest, the cultural appropriation was definitely on the part of the Spanish here.

NoHangoversToday · 15/10/2026 09:09

CoffeeCantata · 14/10/2026 10:06

OP - I apologise if I've misunderstood your post, but if you are complaining that people who aren't Mexican are holding parties to celebrate a Mexican tradition, I think you are a terrifying virtue-signalling cultural fascist.

Of course people are allowed to borrow from other cultures! How on earth do you think most art, architecture, literature, music has come into being?

I could have misunderstood - and if I have, I apologise, But are people still spouting this authoritatian rubbish? I remember when a couple who'd gone to watch the Chinese NY parade in Chinatown were condemned for 'cultural appropriaton'.

It's a healthy human activity, C A. Are you going to tell off all the Muslim boys at the school I worked at for telling me enthusiastically about their Christmas trees?

FGS - it's a way to make connections and to bring happiness and fun to us all. Long may cultural appropriation thrive.

This is basically what I wanted to say.

God, celebrating other cultures is what turned me into a committed Russophile ad led to me working for 10 years in former Soviet Union countries, my DS1 a devoted Francophile and is what made my father go back to university after retiring to study China and spend every spare bit of cash he has travelling all around China.

White English people, all of us.

friedaklein · 15/10/2026 09:26

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2026 08:35

It doesn't matter. People all over the world do this kind of thing. Look at the way all once-religious festivals are trivialised. If you're religious, you celebrate them in that way, but other people will join in the event at a more 'frivolous' level. It doesn't do any harm.

I'm always touched when people from other religions than mine (er...I mean culture really, because I'm an atheist) or other nations, join in with Christmas or Easter - it's lovely and brings people together, even if it's only the chocolate eggs!

I just don't take these things so seriously - that's the way wars start - because someone has 'offended your religion etc'.

The more the merrier at whatever level they want to join in.

Yes, that's right. I remember when years ago Gwen Stefani wore 'bindis'- the dot that Hindu women wear, which does have meaning- and my mum who is mildly religious was annoyed. Not furious, just a bit annoyed.

But all these years later, she's not bothered any more. Bigger problems in the world. It's better than stirring up hate against other religions. I think people are going to borrow, trivialise, adapt and mess with other cultures. Let them.

zingally · 15/10/2026 09:58

Off-topic, but I'm wondering where you are, because I'm in a large, multi-cultural town, and haven't seen a single place doing anything to celebrate this event. Halloween, yes, but not day of the dead.

Stayinganontoday · 15/10/2026 10:23

zingally · 15/10/2026 09:58

Off-topic, but I'm wondering where you are, because I'm in a large, multi-cultural town, and haven't seen a single place doing anything to celebrate this event. Halloween, yes, but not day of the dead.

They’re everywhere! There’s at least 3 around me. If you search on Facebook tons come up

To comment on every single “Die de Muertos” pub party that’s its cultural appropriation?
OP posts:
LazyCrazyAndStupid · 15/10/2026 10:35

Stayinganontoday · 12/10/2026 19:36

I’ve seen so many parties popping up around my county that are using AI slop to advertise their “Day of the Death” parties when a) nobody who’s Mexican has been consulted b) the food has nothing to do with Mexican food c) it’s a solemn family occasion - not a fiesta! And no, we don’t do face painting.

Every single time I see one, my eye twitches! I’m sure if a random persons (that had nothing to do with Hinduism) decided to throw a “Diwali party” people wouldn’t stay quiet.

Sorry it’s been one of those days and needed a rant!

I kind of understand that it grates to have your culture appropriated for the sake of entertainment when at the same time you face racism for the differences in your culture but I think unless a particular event of cultural appropriation is actually derogatory or racist I think it's very low I the priority list of things to complain about.

I am an atheist but from a Hindu family and for the life of me I can't imagine anyone in my family or among my Indian friends or anyone in India actually to have an issue with someone throwing a Diwali party. Though it's hard to speak for a billion people.

I think it's nice that people take on aspects of other cultures even if it's just the fun parts. As long as they aren't making fun of it. I think it helps with understanding and Tolerance. I do the same thing with Christmas. I am not religious and definitely not Christian but I love celebrating it. I don't think anyone should mind.

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 15/10/2026 10:41

friedaklein · 15/10/2026 09:26

Yes, that's right. I remember when years ago Gwen Stefani wore 'bindis'- the dot that Hindu women wear, which does have meaning- and my mum who is mildly religious was annoyed. Not furious, just a bit annoyed.

But all these years later, she's not bothered any more. Bigger problems in the world. It's better than stirring up hate against other religions. I think people are going to borrow, trivialise, adapt and mess with other cultures. Let them.

I thought it was cool that Gwen Stefani was making bindis cool!! I sometimes put them in party bags for my dd's birthday parties as her friends absolutely love them.

I remember a little Indian girl got teased a lot for wearing a tiny little red vermilion dot on her forehead every day to school as was tradition in her family. This was in reception. I think if the other kids had been more used to seeing diverse accessories (for want of a better word) in whatever context or for whatever occasion she wouldn't have felt so awkward and maybe wouldn't have been teased so much about it.

SpareMe · 15/10/2026 10:46

Yes you are being unreasonable. Grow up

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 15/10/2026 10:49

aliasfrog · 12/10/2026 19:44

I loved celebrating diwali in school. Most exciting day of the year!!

When my dd joined school I was really touched how seriously they took Diwali. They did diwali activities for the entire week and made diyas, drew pictures, spoke about the story behind it, etc. I think they do it for most major festivals of major religions / cultures and I think it helps massively not just with integration but also with opening up people's minds.

I remember a particular hospital I worked for where during the week of Indian independence day they hung up Indian flags all around the hospital and the canteen had Indian food specials every day on the menu. I thought that was amazing and everyone, including native British loved it. This was about twenty years ago. I'm not sure if that could still happen today.

friedaklein · 15/10/2026 10:54

LazyCrazyAndStupid · 15/10/2026 10:41

I thought it was cool that Gwen Stefani was making bindis cool!! I sometimes put them in party bags for my dd's birthday parties as her friends absolutely love them.

I remember a little Indian girl got teased a lot for wearing a tiny little red vermilion dot on her forehead every day to school as was tradition in her family. This was in reception. I think if the other kids had been more used to seeing diverse accessories (for want of a better word) in whatever context or for whatever occasion she wouldn't have felt so awkward and maybe wouldn't have been teased so much about it.

This is how I feel and my mum has cone around to my way of thinking.

Today's news: a teen gunman narrowly stopped from attacking a Hindu temple in Illinois. That kind of thing bothers me far more.

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2026 11:06

friedaklein · 15/10/2026 09:26

Yes, that's right. I remember when years ago Gwen Stefani wore 'bindis'- the dot that Hindu women wear, which does have meaning- and my mum who is mildly religious was annoyed. Not furious, just a bit annoyed.

But all these years later, she's not bothered any more. Bigger problems in the world. It's better than stirring up hate against other religions. I think people are going to borrow, trivialise, adapt and mess with other cultures. Let them.

Definitely. I understand that it might be irritating - especially when people do things without proper understanding - but in the big scheme of things, as long as they're not making fun of other cultures I agree that there are more serious problems to contend with.

I'd rather everyone in the UK felt they could join in with all kinds of festivals and events on some level, than fussily take offence because they 'have no right' to do certain things. Where would that end? Would you have to ensure you had no Germanic DNA in order to go to an Eisteddfod in Wales etc? It's all very silly, and worse - it's yet another way to try to divide us and set groups against each other.

I think some people are just born bossy and love to tell other people what they can and can't do.

Dollymylove · 15/10/2026 11:23

I think most people have more pressing issues to deal with than whinging about someone having a chilli con carne at the local restaurants "Mexican night"

TheKeatingFive · 15/10/2026 11:57

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2026 11:06

Definitely. I understand that it might be irritating - especially when people do things without proper understanding - but in the big scheme of things, as long as they're not making fun of other cultures I agree that there are more serious problems to contend with.

I'd rather everyone in the UK felt they could join in with all kinds of festivals and events on some level, than fussily take offence because they 'have no right' to do certain things. Where would that end? Would you have to ensure you had no Germanic DNA in order to go to an Eisteddfod in Wales etc? It's all very silly, and worse - it's yet another way to try to divide us and set groups against each other.

I think some people are just born bossy and love to tell other people what they can and can't do.

I totally agree with this. It just seems so short sighted to be policing who can and can’t engage with these kinds of cultural events. It is by opening our minds and engaging with new ideas that humans grow.

It never seems to be the people whose culture is being celebrated who do the policing. In the main, they seem happy that others are getting involved.

CoffeeCantata · 15/10/2026 12:08

TheKeatingFive · 15/10/2026 11:57

I totally agree with this. It just seems so short sighted to be policing who can and can’t engage with these kinds of cultural events. It is by opening our minds and engaging with new ideas that humans grow.

It never seems to be the people whose culture is being celebrated who do the policing. In the main, they seem happy that others are getting involved.

Oh my goodness - you are so right.

When there was a fuss years ago (mainly in the tabloid press) about possible objections from Muslim families to things like Nativity Plays or Hot Cross Buns, sure enough, it later emerged that the fuss was coming from virtue-signalling white British people, overthinking things in Town Halls. It was ever thus.

In one school I worked in the English Dept had a special week where we focused on children's literature and devised games and competitions for the new Y7 students. One involved giving them visual clues to the titles of books, in this case, The Peppermint Pig. We put down a mint sweet and a plastic toy pig, but one member of staff objected because she felt pigs might be offensive to some students. We had the devil of a job persuading her that they weren't - fgs, the BBC's main children's character is Peppa Pig! And pigs feature hugely in literature, from fairy tales to other children's stories (Charlotte's Web etc). Again this wasn't coming from any ethnic minority - but a very over-thinking white British person.

sashh · 16/10/2026 08:58

Stayinganontoday · 15/10/2026 06:42

Excuse me??? Day of the Dead is completely independent to Halloween. It’s thanks to the Catholic Church that it got moved to November. It was originally celebrated in August.

Halloween is also called 'All Hollow's Eve' or the 'Eve of All saints'. The 1st of Nov is 'All Saints' and the 2nd is 'All Souls'.

I don't think they were ever in August, are you thinking of Lammas?

Stayinganontoday · 16/10/2026 09:02

sashh · 16/10/2026 08:58

Halloween is also called 'All Hollow's Eve' or the 'Eve of All saints'. The 1st of Nov is 'All Saints' and the 2nd is 'All Souls'.

I don't think they were ever in August, are you thinking of Lammas?

No I’m saying that the pre Hispanic festival was in August and got moved by the Catholic Church.

OP posts:
NimbleTaupeTiger · 16/10/2026 09:02

sashh · 16/10/2026 08:58

Halloween is also called 'All Hollow's Eve' or the 'Eve of All saints'. The 1st of Nov is 'All Saints' and the 2nd is 'All Souls'.

I don't think they were ever in August, are you thinking of Lammas?

You've misunderstood. Day of the Dead was moved to November not the other way round.

TISSHA · 16/10/2026 09:26

Stayinganontoday · 12/10/2026 20:54

That didn’t use to exist. It was only created after the Bond film (Spectre). The next year some tourists arrived and asked about the parade (which obviously did t exist). So the Mexico City government started organising it as it was a way of bringing tourism and $$$$

Surely if the MEXICAN GOVERNMENT is creating a social event around the festival, then Mexico as a nation are supportive/at least tolerant of such celebrations, no?

TheKeatingFive · 16/10/2026 09:57

It’s interesting that very different cultures have festivals built around similar needs/desires (connecting with those who have passed).

It suggests that there are deep, universal human needs that find expressions across cultures. It also explains why these types of celebrations are interesting for people who live in cultures that don’t explicitly celebrate them.

All of which points to what @CoffeeCantata is saying. We should be focused on what unites us, not policing what separate groups can or can’t enjoy.

sashh · 16/10/2026 10:02

NimbleTaupeTiger · 16/10/2026 09:02

You've misunderstood. Day of the Dead was moved to November not the other way round.

I don't understand what you mean. What do you think I said had moved?

Whether the date was changed by the RC church or not, the day of the dead is comemorated at the same timme on the same days as RC commemorations of the dead.

Stayinganontoday · 16/10/2026 10:08

TISSHA · 16/10/2026 09:26

Surely if the MEXICAN GOVERNMENT is creating a social event around the festival, then Mexico as a nation are supportive/at least tolerant of such celebrations, no?

It’s a parade and it has been quite controversial, but it is what it is.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread