Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop MIL interfering with our nanny?

424 replies

marinym · 12/10/2026 14:45

My MIL comes over once a week to see the children and apparently help out. She lives about an hour and a half away and makes the journey herself. We have never asked her to do this. She actually said to DH that she doesn’t feel she’s getting the full grandma experience because she doesn’t help with the children enough so that’s now it started.

The thing is we really don’t need the help. I earn the same as DH, both quite high earners and we can comfortably afford childcare / afterschool clubs. We have a brilliant nanny who has become like a second grandma to the children. She genuinely goes above and beyond her job and we absolutely love her.

When MIL comes over the nanny is still there doing her job. MIL gets to take the baby out or bake banana bread with our eldest while the nanny does everything else and cleans up afterwards. So MIL gets the fun bits and the nanny deals with the aftermath. If the baking turns into a complete disaster the nanny is the one cleaning banana off the kitchen cupboards. If there’s a poonami the nanny changes it whilst MIL has a cup of tea. I don’t mind this arrangement at all. I think we all understand that we could manage perfectly well without her being there but there’s no need to point that out if it makes her feel better.

Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job. Not anything particularly serious but lots of little comments about how she should be doing things differently when the nanny is simply following our instructions. For example we expect our children to tidy up one activity (to the extent that they can at their ages) before getting another out. MIL will say things like “Oh don’t make her do that. Grandma’s only here for a little while so let her enjoy herself.” The nanny just says she’s following our instructions and carries on. I’ve told her not to get into a discussion about it. Just smile, say she’s following her employers’ instructions and carry on as normal. Same thing with the baby. We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food. The nanny is following our instructions. If MIL has a problem with what we decide for our children she can speak to us about it rather than telling the nanny what she should or shouldn’t be doing.

She also makes odd comments about that I feed her “little boy” (aka my over-40yo DH). If we’re having leftovers from the night before MIL will say things like “You’re not all eating leftovers, are you? I can come and cook for you if you’re struggling”. We’re not struggling, we’re using time effectively and cooking for 2 days.
Or “It’s salmon for dinner? He never used to like it as a fillet, I think he’d prefer it in fishcakes, do you need a recipe?” Well he’s not living at home now is he? He’s living with me and our children and I’m not running a restaurant where everyone gets a separate meal. I cook what works for the family. If we’re having curry twice because there’s enough left over then that’s what we’re having. If I know kids will eat salmon as a fillet better than in a fish cake, then we’ll have that. If I tell her this it’s “aw I understand, I just know how much he used to like his food” as if I’m malnourishing him. And for the record, we eat home cooked meals every day, it’s either myself or the nanny cooking (DH often finishes later than I do) and DH actually seems to enjoy it, will often have seconds after everyone has eaten or request a repeat of what we’ve previously made.

DH is much more diplomatic than I am. He’ll say something like “Maybe I like it now Mum” or “It’s just easier to cook something we’ll all eat” but also she rarely makes the comments in front of him, usually just to me and nanny. He does stand up for us and I don’t want to give the impression that he doesn’t but he’s very gentle with her and always tries to keep things pleasant. I’m not like that. I’m quite direct and perfectly happy to say “Look this is our house and this is how we do things. If you don’t like it you don’t have to come over.” I think some of it is probably cultural. I’ve lived here since I was 16 but I’m much more comfortable being blunt about things whereas DH would rather smooth everything over. It’s the same if we disagree with each other - he’ll be diplomatic and smooth things over, I’ll say exactly what I mean and likely in a spicy tone.

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward conversation.

Whilst I think it’s lovely that she wants a relationship with the children and I appreciate the effort of travelling 3hrs total once a week, we don’t actually need her help. I do think she needs to understand that being Grandma doesn’t make her the boss of our household. DH thinks we should keep things diplomatic and let the nanny carry on ignoring the comments. I think that’s fine up to a point, that point has been reached for me, and I’d like to say something. Our nanny already has the patience of a saint and I don’t see why she should put up with someone getting in the way of her doing her job.

AIBU to say that she either needs to stick to her role of being a guest or the visits will become a lot more rare?

OP posts:
Beingseenisneedy · 13/10/2026 20:03

Excited101 · 12/10/2026 15:07

I wouldn’t be at all happy with that as a nanny. If you want to accommodate MIL then get her to come at the weekend so they nanny doesn’t have to deal with her. It’s not her job.

Agree. Unfortunately some parents arrange difficult visits for when the nanny or housekeeper is around, so they can be the buffer.

It's not part of her job.

Grandma should be able to visit or be visited as a grandma, not just a helper.

Anonymouseposter · 13/10/2026 20:10

saraclara · 13/10/2026 20:02

Have I missed something? What has OP said that indicates that her children are not safe alone with their grandma?

That’s a quote from one of OP’s posts in response to a question from another poster. It suggests that OP is at least uneasy about leaving the children with their grandma. She cites issues like not really wanting to do jobs like changing nappies but doesn’t really explain why she’s uncomfortable with it.

pimplebum · 13/10/2026 20:16

Boost and support your nanny.

have words with mil

saraclara · 13/10/2026 20:59

pimplebum · 13/10/2026 20:16

Boost and support your nanny.

have words with mil

I'm glad that my DD just chats to me if she has a preference about what I do with her children, rather than "having words".
Likewise I just chatted amicably with my MIL if I needed to ask her to do/not to do something. There were no tellings-off.

OVienna · 13/10/2026 21:28

Beingseenisneedy · 13/10/2026 20:03

Agree. Unfortunately some parents arrange difficult visits for when the nanny or housekeeper is around, so they can be the buffer.

It's not part of her job.

Grandma should be able to visit or be visited as a grandma, not just a helper.

#teamgranny isnt paying any sttention to comments if this variety, sadly. It is pathetic..

BeUmberMember · 13/10/2026 21:34

In my experience this is just what mother in laws do ! They believe it is their duty to teach us how to bring our children the same way as they brought up theirs, and run our households the same way too. Some of it must have been successful as you married her son! Have you not heard all the comedians mother in law jokes? Just lighten up a little, if your Nanny can accept her visits so can you .

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 21:36

BeUmberMember · 13/10/2026 21:34

In my experience this is just what mother in laws do ! They believe it is their duty to teach us how to bring our children the same way as they brought up theirs, and run our households the same way too. Some of it must have been successful as you married her son! Have you not heard all the comedians mother in law jokes? Just lighten up a little, if your Nanny can accept her visits so can you .

its sounds like the Nanny is not happy though

TheSunIsAlwaysThere · 13/10/2026 21:52

There's a lot about how you don't need granny's help. How about think that granny just wants to spend time with her grandchildren?

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 13/10/2026 21:53

I don’t think the situation is fair on your nanny. She should be able to do her job in peace. I’d stop the visits or at least dh tells her to stop critiquing the nanny

ThatCosy · 13/10/2026 21:57

Awkwardisfunny · 13/10/2026 19:03

Share your ideas then. Easy to tear others down. And the OP seems to be about to say much worse(!) and frankly: this GM deserves it based on the OP.

I'll wait for your input though. I'm not reading every thread to check if you already did. Best to include it directly in your criticism next time.

I'm not tearing you down. I'm pointing out that in real life if you start an overt power play it doesn't end well. And these are real lives (as far as we know). I have commented elsewhere. You are free to respond to it if you want. I think you are taking my comment way too personally. It wasn't a judgement on you but on the wisdom of making someone feel like a naughty child especially if they are a loved (at least by the husband/son) family member.

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 21:59

TheSunIsAlwaysThere · 13/10/2026 21:52

There's a lot about how you don't need granny's help. How about think that granny just wants to spend time with her grandchildren?

then she should do it without correcting the Nanny and expecting her opinions on childcare to be seen as gospel.

NoSnakesHere · 13/10/2026 22:03

TinyBlueDent · 12/10/2026 14:55

I voted YABU based on this paragraph -

he’s very gentle with her and always tries to keep things pleasant. I’m not like that. I’m quite direct and perfectly happy to say “Look this is our house and this is how we do things. If you don’t like it you don’t have to come over.” I think some of it is probably cultural. I’ve lived here since I was 16 but I’m much more comfortable being blunt about things whereas DH would rather smooth everything over. It’s the same if we disagree with each other - he’ll be diplomatic and smooth things over, I’ll say exactly what I mean and likely in a spicy tone.

Do you have an Antipodean directness? Whatever your cultural background, rein in the rudeness otherwise you'll become the DIL from hell.

YANBU to feel the way you do but you would be unreasonable to express it rudely.

Nah, if advocating for your children, nanny and the rules of your own house means being rude then so be it! In fact i would be extra rude and tell her to mind her own business and it would not be with such polite words

Awkwardisfunny · 13/10/2026 22:13

ThatCosy · 13/10/2026 21:57

I'm not tearing you down. I'm pointing out that in real life if you start an overt power play it doesn't end well. And these are real lives (as far as we know). I have commented elsewhere. You are free to respond to it if you want. I think you are taking my comment way too personally. It wasn't a judgement on you but on the wisdom of making someone feel like a naughty child especially if they are a loved (at least by the husband/son) family member.

I disagree entirely. And I read back what I wrote and nothing was condescending at all. The GM literally started it with her repeated insults and undermining. Did you read her behaviours in full? She needs bringing down a peg or two. But my suggestion was still diplomatic. People are different so just because you wouldn't say it, doesn't make it condescending.

schtompy · 13/10/2026 22:49

And how would you deal with it if it was your DM..would you react the same. Do the children ever go over to granny's house? You sound a bit sensitive..try and be more more like yr DH

NaomiTroll · 13/10/2026 23:15

I used to be a nanny and read everything you wrote thinking it would’ve been quite easy to deal with - as a PP said we’re not so emotionally tied and have a clear boundary of ‘this is our employers instruction so we’ll follow it.’ But then I read your comment about your MIL having the kids for a bit so your nanny could take a break to work late and how your MIL came into the cafe she was in and asked if ‘she’d be long’ while taking a break… I would not have loved that as a nanny. That’s crossing a boundary into an actual legal break time, as opposed to little comments that I can brush off.

Besidemyselfwithworry · 13/10/2026 23:23

marinym · 12/10/2026 14:45

My MIL comes over once a week to see the children and apparently help out. She lives about an hour and a half away and makes the journey herself. We have never asked her to do this. She actually said to DH that she doesn’t feel she’s getting the full grandma experience because she doesn’t help with the children enough so that’s now it started.

The thing is we really don’t need the help. I earn the same as DH, both quite high earners and we can comfortably afford childcare / afterschool clubs. We have a brilliant nanny who has become like a second grandma to the children. She genuinely goes above and beyond her job and we absolutely love her.

When MIL comes over the nanny is still there doing her job. MIL gets to take the baby out or bake banana bread with our eldest while the nanny does everything else and cleans up afterwards. So MIL gets the fun bits and the nanny deals with the aftermath. If the baking turns into a complete disaster the nanny is the one cleaning banana off the kitchen cupboards. If there’s a poonami the nanny changes it whilst MIL has a cup of tea. I don’t mind this arrangement at all. I think we all understand that we could manage perfectly well without her being there but there’s no need to point that out if it makes her feel better.

Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job. Not anything particularly serious but lots of little comments about how she should be doing things differently when the nanny is simply following our instructions. For example we expect our children to tidy up one activity (to the extent that they can at their ages) before getting another out. MIL will say things like “Oh don’t make her do that. Grandma’s only here for a little while so let her enjoy herself.” The nanny just says she’s following our instructions and carries on. I’ve told her not to get into a discussion about it. Just smile, say she’s following her employers’ instructions and carry on as normal. Same thing with the baby. We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food. The nanny is following our instructions. If MIL has a problem with what we decide for our children she can speak to us about it rather than telling the nanny what she should or shouldn’t be doing.

She also makes odd comments about that I feed her “little boy” (aka my over-40yo DH). If we’re having leftovers from the night before MIL will say things like “You’re not all eating leftovers, are you? I can come and cook for you if you’re struggling”. We’re not struggling, we’re using time effectively and cooking for 2 days.
Or “It’s salmon for dinner? He never used to like it as a fillet, I think he’d prefer it in fishcakes, do you need a recipe?” Well he’s not living at home now is he? He’s living with me and our children and I’m not running a restaurant where everyone gets a separate meal. I cook what works for the family. If we’re having curry twice because there’s enough left over then that’s what we’re having. If I know kids will eat salmon as a fillet better than in a fish cake, then we’ll have that. If I tell her this it’s “aw I understand, I just know how much he used to like his food” as if I’m malnourishing him. And for the record, we eat home cooked meals every day, it’s either myself or the nanny cooking (DH often finishes later than I do) and DH actually seems to enjoy it, will often have seconds after everyone has eaten or request a repeat of what we’ve previously made.

DH is much more diplomatic than I am. He’ll say something like “Maybe I like it now Mum” or “It’s just easier to cook something we’ll all eat” but also she rarely makes the comments in front of him, usually just to me and nanny. He does stand up for us and I don’t want to give the impression that he doesn’t but he’s very gentle with her and always tries to keep things pleasant. I’m not like that. I’m quite direct and perfectly happy to say “Look this is our house and this is how we do things. If you don’t like it you don’t have to come over.” I think some of it is probably cultural. I’ve lived here since I was 16 but I’m much more comfortable being blunt about things whereas DH would rather smooth everything over. It’s the same if we disagree with each other - he’ll be diplomatic and smooth things over, I’ll say exactly what I mean and likely in a spicy tone.

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward conversation.

Whilst I think it’s lovely that she wants a relationship with the children and I appreciate the effort of travelling 3hrs total once a week, we don’t actually need her help. I do think she needs to understand that being Grandma doesn’t make her the boss of our household. DH thinks we should keep things diplomatic and let the nanny carry on ignoring the comments. I think that’s fine up to a point, that point has been reached for me, and I’d like to say something. Our nanny already has the patience of a saint and I don’t see why she should put up with someone getting in the way of her doing her job.

AIBU to say that she either needs to stick to her role of being a guest or the visits will become a lot more rare?

I think you should give your nanny that afternoon off while the MIL is there. If I was the Nanny I’d feel really uncomfortable with all this it’s not fair.

saraclara · 13/10/2026 23:46

A lot of people are ignoring the fact that OP has given the nanny the option of Grandma not coming, and she's said it's fine. That she just wants to know how OP wants her to respond.

The nanny is clearly mature, experienced and confident. Let's respect her professionalism and accept that she knows what she's doing. She seems less bothered about this than OP is. She's been given her stock of responses, so there's no need to do more unless the situation doesn't resolve.

Sensiblesal · 14/10/2026 00:50

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/10/2026 13:39

In what way are OP and her husband 'not allowing her to be a grandma'...

She is welcome to visit weekly, and does.
She bakes with the kids, she goes to the park with the kids, she plays with them, joins them for meals, she also comes to stay for weekends or the family go to stay with her for a weekend, regularly.

On the occasions she has been asked to help with messy/difficult things, she has declined and/or asked the Nanny to do it, including asking the Nanny to hurry up her break to do so!

This thread is rammed full of people frothing at the mouth with jealousy that OP has a really good Nanny and is evidently comfortably wealthy. So they're trying to find fault where there really isn't any!

The grandma is supervised on all her visits either by the Nanny or by the OP

The Op is actually the one putting the Nanny in a terrible position expecting her to supervise the MiL

ThatCosy · 14/10/2026 06:30

Awkwardisfunny · 13/10/2026 22:13

I disagree entirely. And I read back what I wrote and nothing was condescending at all. The GM literally started it with her repeated insults and undermining. Did you read her behaviours in full? She needs bringing down a peg or two. But my suggestion was still diplomatic. People are different so just because you wouldn't say it, doesn't make it condescending.

The comments would be heard that way. She will be just as adamant that she's right in her mind than you are that she's wrong in yours. And it means something to her.

Katypp · 14/10/2026 07:17

Awkwardisfunny · 13/10/2026 22:13

I disagree entirely. And I read back what I wrote and nothing was condescending at all. The GM literally started it with her repeated insults and undermining. Did you read her behaviours in full? She needs bringing down a peg or two. But my suggestion was still diplomatic. People are different so just because you wouldn't say it, doesn't make it condescending.

'Bringing down a peg or two' - that's the nub of this drama.
Despite it being cited as concern for the nanny, the OP and lots of the subsequent replies are nothing about the nanny and everything about proving who's boss.
I do find it sad that a lot of parents today seem hellbent on pushing their family as far away as they can and prefer hired help that they can control 100%.
It's as if they will never be grandparents themselves.

Calliopespa · 14/10/2026 07:18

TheSunIsAlwaysThere · 13/10/2026 21:52

There's a lot about how you don't need granny's help. How about think that granny just wants to spend time with her grandchildren?

🎯

The "not needing" is being used as a justification, as though the guiding principle should be the OP's needs and convenience at all junctures.

That came across very strongly right from the opening paragraph of the post.

Calliopespa · 14/10/2026 07:21

Katypp · 14/10/2026 07:17

'Bringing down a peg or two' - that's the nub of this drama.
Despite it being cited as concern for the nanny, the OP and lots of the subsequent replies are nothing about the nanny and everything about proving who's boss.
I do find it sad that a lot of parents today seem hellbent on pushing their family as far away as they can and prefer hired help that they can control 100%.
It's as if they will never be grandparents themselves.

And another 🎯

I saw a post above defending the op on the basis she wasn't yet "threatening" the MIL with not seeing the dc - as though "threatening" relatives was a standard relationship tool.

I am not a MIL, I'm a DIL but I definitely see loads of power plays on here by DILs, as if it is somehow a sassy and characterful card to play.

AlphaApple · 14/10/2026 07:30

YANBU. Your DH sounds wet. She’s not awful but the drip-drip-drip of negative comments are infuriating.

You clearly don’t need help, but it is lovely for the children to spend time with Granny. Don’t indulge her by pretending that it’s anything but that. The fact that she “always imagined” she’d help raise her grandchildren is Not Your Problem.

BountifulPantry · 14/10/2026 07:35

Frankly your husband needs to have a conversation with your MIL about the rules you have at home. When she makes comments about you not feeding him he needs to say “actually, mum, I’m very grateful to have a wife who cooks for me and she does a brilliant job.” So positively noting all the things you do for the family and defending you.

WildLeader · 14/10/2026 07:39

TheSunIsAlwaysThere · 13/10/2026 21:52

There's a lot about how you don't need granny's help. How about think that granny just wants to spend time with her grandchildren?

The word HELP is coming from the MIL, she’s labouring the point that she’s happy to come and help, that it’s so fulfilling for her to be able to come and help etc etc

but this isn’t the case, she isn’t helping.

op has said she’s welcome to come at weekends to spend time with the GC, and she does this, but her “helping” seems only for her benefit (the MIL)

shes pissing the nanny off, creating a heck of a lot of work for her, undermining her, insulting her, but crucially NOT doing anything to contribute to a better situation.

she isn’t helping. She doesn’t need to help, she just needs to spend time with the gc and NOT piss the nanny off.

this isn’t a power play by the op. Her H AGREES that MIL isn’t suitable to have the kids alone, she can’t cope, won’t change them, won’t care for them. This is the crux of the issue. The children’s needs have to come first in this.

there isn’t an easy fix to this. The conversation needs to go along the lines of “Mil, the kids love to see you and you’re welcome to come over at the weekends and spend time with us all, but the weekly visits aren’t going to be able to continue. Our nanny has said that it’s disruptive, creates a lot of work for her, and she’s really struggling with the visits. She’s been working with us for 7 years and she’s more than competent in following our instructions and recommendations, but you’re criticising her and challenging her, and undermining her to the kids. So let’s park the weekly visits in the week, come over at the weekends and just be a GM. We appreciate you offering “help” but you don’t need to, it’s not necessary and we’d prefer you to be part of our family rather than being someone working for us.”

I think she’s making this her hobby. She needs to find something else to do to fill her time.