Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop MIL interfering with our nanny?

424 replies

marinym · 12/10/2026 14:45

My MIL comes over once a week to see the children and apparently help out. She lives about an hour and a half away and makes the journey herself. We have never asked her to do this. She actually said to DH that she doesn’t feel she’s getting the full grandma experience because she doesn’t help with the children enough so that’s now it started.

The thing is we really don’t need the help. I earn the same as DH, both quite high earners and we can comfortably afford childcare / afterschool clubs. We have a brilliant nanny who has become like a second grandma to the children. She genuinely goes above and beyond her job and we absolutely love her.

When MIL comes over the nanny is still there doing her job. MIL gets to take the baby out or bake banana bread with our eldest while the nanny does everything else and cleans up afterwards. So MIL gets the fun bits and the nanny deals with the aftermath. If the baking turns into a complete disaster the nanny is the one cleaning banana off the kitchen cupboards. If there’s a poonami the nanny changes it whilst MIL has a cup of tea. I don’t mind this arrangement at all. I think we all understand that we could manage perfectly well without her being there but there’s no need to point that out if it makes her feel better.

Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job. Not anything particularly serious but lots of little comments about how she should be doing things differently when the nanny is simply following our instructions. For example we expect our children to tidy up one activity (to the extent that they can at their ages) before getting another out. MIL will say things like “Oh don’t make her do that. Grandma’s only here for a little while so let her enjoy herself.” The nanny just says she’s following our instructions and carries on. I’ve told her not to get into a discussion about it. Just smile, say she’s following her employers’ instructions and carry on as normal. Same thing with the baby. We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food. The nanny is following our instructions. If MIL has a problem with what we decide for our children she can speak to us about it rather than telling the nanny what she should or shouldn’t be doing.

She also makes odd comments about that I feed her “little boy” (aka my over-40yo DH). If we’re having leftovers from the night before MIL will say things like “You’re not all eating leftovers, are you? I can come and cook for you if you’re struggling”. We’re not struggling, we’re using time effectively and cooking for 2 days.
Or “It’s salmon for dinner? He never used to like it as a fillet, I think he’d prefer it in fishcakes, do you need a recipe?” Well he’s not living at home now is he? He’s living with me and our children and I’m not running a restaurant where everyone gets a separate meal. I cook what works for the family. If we’re having curry twice because there’s enough left over then that’s what we’re having. If I know kids will eat salmon as a fillet better than in a fish cake, then we’ll have that. If I tell her this it’s “aw I understand, I just know how much he used to like his food” as if I’m malnourishing him. And for the record, we eat home cooked meals every day, it’s either myself or the nanny cooking (DH often finishes later than I do) and DH actually seems to enjoy it, will often have seconds after everyone has eaten or request a repeat of what we’ve previously made.

DH is much more diplomatic than I am. He’ll say something like “Maybe I like it now Mum” or “It’s just easier to cook something we’ll all eat” but also she rarely makes the comments in front of him, usually just to me and nanny. He does stand up for us and I don’t want to give the impression that he doesn’t but he’s very gentle with her and always tries to keep things pleasant. I’m not like that. I’m quite direct and perfectly happy to say “Look this is our house and this is how we do things. If you don’t like it you don’t have to come over.” I think some of it is probably cultural. I’ve lived here since I was 16 but I’m much more comfortable being blunt about things whereas DH would rather smooth everything over. It’s the same if we disagree with each other - he’ll be diplomatic and smooth things over, I’ll say exactly what I mean and likely in a spicy tone.

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward conversation.

Whilst I think it’s lovely that she wants a relationship with the children and I appreciate the effort of travelling 3hrs total once a week, we don’t actually need her help. I do think she needs to understand that being Grandma doesn’t make her the boss of our household. DH thinks we should keep things diplomatic and let the nanny carry on ignoring the comments. I think that’s fine up to a point, that point has been reached for me, and I’d like to say something. Our nanny already has the patience of a saint and I don’t see why she should put up with someone getting in the way of her doing her job.

AIBU to say that she either needs to stick to her role of being a guest or the visits will become a lot more rare?

OP posts:
marinym · 15/10/2026 11:46

@Sotiredimightreallydie
She visits / we visit her often enough - once every month or so overnight.

Well, of course I’m going to make my own life easier where I can, how is that embarrassing 😂 As far as I know, MIL isn’t pregnant or freshly postpartum, and there’s a reason whenever the nanny stays overnight. I have frequently had 3 kids solo, MIL fails with 2 every time (which is no problem in itself but it is the reason I know she can’t cope alone with them).

OP posts:
thepariscrimefiles · 15/10/2026 11:46

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 09:45

Which brings me back to my point, why would you not welcome advice from your MIL? Nobody gives advice with the intention of being malicious so why be so rude snd hurtful to her for daring to be helpful and kind.
I rest my case

My ex-MIL was a racist born-again Christian who disapproved of breastfeeding. Her advice was always very malicious.

OP's MIL may not be malicious but she certainly isn't helpful and kind. OP treats the nanny like one of the family while her MIL treats the nanny like an employee that she needs to reprimand which is a bloody cheek as she isn't the employer and isn't paying the nanny's wages. OP's MIL obviously feels superior to the nanny. She sounds unpleasant.

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 11:57

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 11:34

As advice is meant

what always????? really?????

BeUmberMember · 15/10/2026 12:06

Old trout ?? How's disrespectful does MN get ?

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 12:23

BeUmberMember · 15/10/2026 12:06

Old trout ?? How's disrespectful does MN get ?

oh WAY beyond that!!

thing47 · 15/10/2026 12:27

Sotiredimightreallydie · 15/10/2026 10:21

Grandparents never exactly follow the parents everyday rules. That's one of the fun things about spending time with grandparents.

Mil has has very limited opportunity to care for the kids alone because the OP doesn't allow it. We have no idea how mil would feel about nappies, only the ops assumption -and it's clear she really dislikes mil. This is literally a woman who deliberately hid in her own house so she could spy on and ambush mil.

Speak for yourself! When I am looking after my granddaughter I absolutely do follow her parents' rules exactly.

That is precisely why I am.completely trusted.to look after her for two full (9 hour) days every week when others are not. And that includes changing nappies (and now, potty training), clearing up messes, dealing with tantrums, doing meal.times, bath times, nap times and even standing on stools - while closely supervised by me.

It's completely ok if granny does not want to do any of the less.fun stuff, but then the parents need someone who will.

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 12:32

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 11:57

what always????? really?????

Do you know the MIL? If not you cannot possibly comment on if the advice was given maliciously, but as stated by OP the advice was given about the child's safety? Whether it was welcome advice or not, how on earth can anyone misconstrue or twist that advice to be malicious, you are making an assumption AND going off topic YET again.
This is the last time I will respond to your nonsense.

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 12:39

thepariscrimefiles · 15/10/2026 11:46

My ex-MIL was a racist born-again Christian who disapproved of breastfeeding. Her advice was always very malicious.

OP's MIL may not be malicious but she certainly isn't helpful and kind. OP treats the nanny like one of the family while her MIL treats the nanny like an employee that she needs to reprimand which is a bloody cheek as she isn't the employer and isn't paying the nanny's wages. OP's MIL obviously feels superior to the nanny. She sounds unpleasant.

Again, I will reiterate, and it will be the last time, we are not discussing your issues, you need to begin a different thread if you want me to comment on your personal experiences with Your ex MIL and it does sound horrendous, but what the current OP has stated about her MIL has no similarities to your experience with your MIL whatsoever.

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 12:43

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 12:39

Again, I will reiterate, and it will be the last time, we are not discussing your issues, you need to begin a different thread if you want me to comment on your personal experiences with Your ex MIL and it does sound horrendous, but what the current OP has stated about her MIL has no similarities to your experience with your MIL whatsoever.

but you are saying that all advice is meant kindly?

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 12:44

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 12:32

Do you know the MIL? If not you cannot possibly comment on if the advice was given maliciously, but as stated by OP the advice was given about the child's safety? Whether it was welcome advice or not, how on earth can anyone misconstrue or twist that advice to be malicious, you are making an assumption AND going off topic YET again.
This is the last time I will respond to your nonsense.

oh good.
What I can comment on is your frankly bonkers comment that advice is never malicious.

cakeisallyouneed · 15/10/2026 13:10

This whole issue seems to stem from whether your MIL is there to ‘help’ or not. Everyone is pretending (including your MIL) that her visits are helpful and she is providing much needed, vital childcare that you couldn’t manage without when really she is just visiting. telling the nanny what to do is most likely coming from a place of wanting to feel that she is in charge, as she is insecure about her role.
i understand your reasons for why she’s never had the kids on her own but I actually think her having the kids for an hour or 2 in your house would do some good. From what you’ve said your MIL isn’t actually a safety risk and if anything is actually risk averse. It would be interesting if you gave your nanny a task to go out somewhere or do some laundry upstairs so she’s not available to immediately rush in to help. It could be that your MIL rises to the challenge and can be trusted, or she is straight on the phone calling the nanny for help and has a renewed appreciation for what the nanny does. Either way is a win for you really. Otherwise youll all just keep playing this game of pretend.

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 13:40

cakeisallyouneed · 15/10/2026 13:10

This whole issue seems to stem from whether your MIL is there to ‘help’ or not. Everyone is pretending (including your MIL) that her visits are helpful and she is providing much needed, vital childcare that you couldn’t manage without when really she is just visiting. telling the nanny what to do is most likely coming from a place of wanting to feel that she is in charge, as she is insecure about her role.
i understand your reasons for why she’s never had the kids on her own but I actually think her having the kids for an hour or 2 in your house would do some good. From what you’ve said your MIL isn’t actually a safety risk and if anything is actually risk averse. It would be interesting if you gave your nanny a task to go out somewhere or do some laundry upstairs so she’s not available to immediately rush in to help. It could be that your MIL rises to the challenge and can be trusted, or she is straight on the phone calling the nanny for help and has a renewed appreciation for what the nanny does. Either way is a win for you really. Otherwise youll all just keep playing this game of pretend.

see I dunno....I mean yes risk averse bur sensible? Also I can't help feeling that she may have self defence down to a fine art as in "oh xxx would not have happened if yyy which was not my doing"
Addtionally (and I get that people will disagree) I am not sure about how right it would be to use the children in that way...like tools in a test IYSWIM

marinym · 15/10/2026 13:43

@cakeisallyouneed
We’ve tried MIL looking after the children while the nanny just popped into a cafe overlooking the park for a quick snack during her break. MIL was rushing her to come back and asking how much longer she’d be.

I’ve also tried numerous times to get the nanny to use her time more efficiently when MIL is visiting by doing child-related jobs elsewhere in the house. But inevitably MIL will shout upstairs asking her to come and change a nappy, saying one of the children has spilt juice on themselves, or saying she needs a break just as one of the children is having a tantrum. So it’s not as though the nanny is always hovering and jumping in before MIL has a chance. MIL just can’t do it. She needs someone to help.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 15/10/2026 14:22

marinym · 12/10/2026 15:09

@TinyBlueDent
Antipodean? No, just not British enough to pretend I’m delighted when someone tells me how to run my own household 😂
I do appreciate that she makes the effort to come and see the children, and I’m happy for her to enjoy being Grandma. I just think there’s a difference between being involved and having an opinion (and voicing it!) on absolutely everything. I’m sure I could be a bit more diplomatic at times, but equally, I don’t think being a DIL means I have to smile and nod at everything either.

But it’s ok for you to voice your opinion on things you believe are incorrect? Sounds like you just need to rub along with her, you both sound similar people.

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 15:05

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 12:43

but you are saying that all advice is meant kindly?

So you are saying that any advice youve ever imparted has been given with intent of being malicious toward the recipient?
Because no, id never share any advice that wasnt meant for the greater good, and never ever to hurt or harm someone.
I expect granny had the same intention.
What a strange assumption

Eightfor15 · 15/10/2026 15:18

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 15:05

So you are saying that any advice youve ever imparted has been given with intent of being malicious toward the recipient?
Because no, id never share any advice that wasnt meant for the greater good, and never ever to hurt or harm someone.
I expect granny had the same intention.
What a strange assumption

Then she should have given the advice to the relevant person, not an employee doing her job to the remit set by her employer.

The point here is not her grandmother role. It's her thinking that because she is OPs MIL, she has any authority over OPs employee. I repeat something I said earlier, how would you feel if a relative of your boss came to your work and started telling you what to do and how to do it - because that is what MIL as done and what OPs AIBU is about.

It's quite amazing how many people are so obtusely missing the point.

Malbecfan · 15/10/2026 15:44

My MiL would impart advice to us when the DDs were young. The problem was, she was in her very late 30s when DH was born and 75 when DD1 was born. She had forgotten most of what she knew when her own DC were tiny and couldn't even remember how to hold ours as babies. Her advice, whilst well-meaning, was mostly bollocks. Before anyone jumps on me, MiL had a difficult life, was uprooted from where she grew up during the war, moved country twice and struggled with DBil who is mentally handicapped. She forgot that we were intelligent adults in professional roles and capable of checking with health professionals. When DD1 was less than a week old, she had some heat rash - her birthday is late July and that year was particularly warm. The midwife commented on it, but said that all the babies in the hospital had it and as long as DD was feeding and producing wet nappies, not to worry. Stupidly DH told MiL and the next thing was her phoning us at midnight asking if we had considered meningitis. Yes, a sleep-deprived new parent really values a call at midnight when the midwife has recently seen the baby.

When the DDs were around 9 & 7, she wrote some "life advice" for them and proudly presented it to them in front of us. It said things like "in a thunderstorm, stay out in the open" and other such ideas. I may have rolled my eyes at DH but kept quiet, but he was really annoyed with her and told her so in front of the DC. Why am I relating this? Because not every MiL really does understand the modern world or the fact that medical advice has changed or been updated since they had young children themselves. My MiL's actions came from a good place, but actually had the potential to be harming.

I share OP's frustration. Her MiL has invited herself to see the DGC. OP has the right to be at home working or doing as she pleases. The nanny had mentioned things said by the MiL when the OP was not there. The OP was being a good employer by checking for herself how the interactions went.

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 15:47

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 15:05

So you are saying that any advice youve ever imparted has been given with intent of being malicious toward the recipient?
Because no, id never share any advice that wasnt meant for the greater good, and never ever to hurt or harm someone.
I expect granny had the same intention.
What a strange assumption

but you were not going to respond to my posts
"This is the last time I will respond to your nonsense."

Duck Dynasty GIF by DefyTV
Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 16:16

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 15:47

but you were not going to respond to my posts
"This is the last time I will respond to your nonsense."

🤣😂🤣 how lovely you are. Thank F#%k uou arnt related to me

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 17:29

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 16:16

🤣😂🤣 how lovely you are. Thank F#%k uou arnt related to me

well we agree on one thing....actually two things.....I am lovely.

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 15/10/2026 17:32

godmum56 · 15/10/2026 17:29

well we agree on one thing....actually two things.....I am lovely.

Edited

I mean you are patently right. Advice certainly does NOT always come from a good place.

thepariscrimefiles · 15/10/2026 19:19

Biddybobsleigh · 15/10/2026 12:39

Again, I will reiterate, and it will be the last time, we are not discussing your issues, you need to begin a different thread if you want me to comment on your personal experiences with Your ex MIL and it does sound horrendous, but what the current OP has stated about her MIL has no similarities to your experience with your MIL whatsoever.

FFS you obviously know that the only reason that I mentioned my ex-MIL who thankfully is long dead is that you said that 'nobody gives advice with the intention of being malicious' which is patently untrue. OP's MIL's advice is malicious because she is doing it to take the nanny down a peg or two and to demonstrate where she thinks the nanny stands in the pecking order.

BeAzureRaven · 24/10/2026 18:18

I'm old and no longer put up with any crap. I regret being 'diplomatic' with my interfering MIL. I'd tell your MIL quite bluntly that she needs to butt out and that her comments to the nanny will not be tolerated. And that if she can't manage to do this, she needs to not visit. She knows she's out of line, which is why she doesn't say it in front of her baby boy. And if her baby boy wants fish cakes or anything else, he's got two hands and is capable of making it himself. Ugh.

Rosemary8486 · 25/10/2026 19:04

It's just one visit a week and she is the granny. While I think all your objections are understandable, even reasonable, and I would find her behaviour infuriating, it is classic MIL stuff. The nanny sounds wonderful. You can have a good laugh about it together. Tidying up? You can surely relax that just a little bit? Get your husband to tell her to stop telling nanny what to do, nanny is your employee not hers and the children don't need to be aware of conflict between the adults looking after them. Besides which, she is a "guest" in your house after all. Can you not suck it up just once a week? Underneath it all is a loneliness and a longing to be involved in her grandchildren's lives. Swallow your annoyance and try to put some humour into the situation......

New posts on this thread. Refresh page