Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop MIL interfering with our nanny?

424 replies

marinym · 12/10/2026 14:45

My MIL comes over once a week to see the children and apparently help out. She lives about an hour and a half away and makes the journey herself. We have never asked her to do this. She actually said to DH that she doesn’t feel she’s getting the full grandma experience because she doesn’t help with the children enough so that’s now it started.

The thing is we really don’t need the help. I earn the same as DH, both quite high earners and we can comfortably afford childcare / afterschool clubs. We have a brilliant nanny who has become like a second grandma to the children. She genuinely goes above and beyond her job and we absolutely love her.

When MIL comes over the nanny is still there doing her job. MIL gets to take the baby out or bake banana bread with our eldest while the nanny does everything else and cleans up afterwards. So MIL gets the fun bits and the nanny deals with the aftermath. If the baking turns into a complete disaster the nanny is the one cleaning banana off the kitchen cupboards. If there’s a poonami the nanny changes it whilst MIL has a cup of tea. I don’t mind this arrangement at all. I think we all understand that we could manage perfectly well without her being there but there’s no need to point that out if it makes her feel better.

Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job. Not anything particularly serious but lots of little comments about how she should be doing things differently when the nanny is simply following our instructions. For example we expect our children to tidy up one activity (to the extent that they can at their ages) before getting another out. MIL will say things like “Oh don’t make her do that. Grandma’s only here for a little while so let her enjoy herself.” The nanny just says she’s following our instructions and carries on. I’ve told her not to get into a discussion about it. Just smile, say she’s following her employers’ instructions and carry on as normal. Same thing with the baby. We give him vitamins and MIL has told the nanny that she shouldn’t be doing that because babies should get everything they need from food. The nanny is following our instructions. If MIL has a problem with what we decide for our children she can speak to us about it rather than telling the nanny what she should or shouldn’t be doing.

She also makes odd comments about that I feed her “little boy” (aka my over-40yo DH). If we’re having leftovers from the night before MIL will say things like “You’re not all eating leftovers, are you? I can come and cook for you if you’re struggling”. We’re not struggling, we’re using time effectively and cooking for 2 days.
Or “It’s salmon for dinner? He never used to like it as a fillet, I think he’d prefer it in fishcakes, do you need a recipe?” Well he’s not living at home now is he? He’s living with me and our children and I’m not running a restaurant where everyone gets a separate meal. I cook what works for the family. If we’re having curry twice because there’s enough left over then that’s what we’re having. If I know kids will eat salmon as a fillet better than in a fish cake, then we’ll have that. If I tell her this it’s “aw I understand, I just know how much he used to like his food” as if I’m malnourishing him. And for the record, we eat home cooked meals every day, it’s either myself or the nanny cooking (DH often finishes later than I do) and DH actually seems to enjoy it, will often have seconds after everyone has eaten or request a repeat of what we’ve previously made.

DH is much more diplomatic than I am. He’ll say something like “Maybe I like it now Mum” or “It’s just easier to cook something we’ll all eat” but also she rarely makes the comments in front of him, usually just to me and nanny. He does stand up for us and I don’t want to give the impression that he doesn’t but he’s very gentle with her and always tries to keep things pleasant. I’m not like that. I’m quite direct and perfectly happy to say “Look this is our house and this is how we do things. If you don’t like it you don’t have to come over.” I think some of it is probably cultural. I’ve lived here since I was 16 but I’m much more comfortable being blunt about things whereas DH would rather smooth everything over. It’s the same if we disagree with each other - he’ll be diplomatic and smooth things over, I’ll say exactly what I mean and likely in a spicy tone.

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward conversation.

Whilst I think it’s lovely that she wants a relationship with the children and I appreciate the effort of travelling 3hrs total once a week, we don’t actually need her help. I do think she needs to understand that being Grandma doesn’t make her the boss of our household. DH thinks we should keep things diplomatic and let the nanny carry on ignoring the comments. I think that’s fine up to a point, that point has been reached for me, and I’d like to say something. Our nanny already has the patience of a saint and I don’t see why she should put up with someone getting in the way of her doing her job.

AIBU to say that she either needs to stick to her role of being a guest or the visits will become a lot more rare?

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 13/10/2026 15:14

InterIgnis · 13/10/2026 15:13

“Recently MIL has started telling our nanny how to do her job. Not anything particularly serious but lots of little comments about how she should be doing things differently when the nanny is simply following our instructions. For example we expect our children to tidy up one activity (to the extent that they can at their ages) before getting another out. MIL will say things like “Oh don’t make her do that. Grandma’s only here for a little while so let her enjoy herself.” The nanny just says she’s following our instructions and carries on.”

“The arrangement works fine until she starts telling our nanny how to do her job, which is where I draw the line.”

as per the OP.

I was commenting on the "fair share of nappies" comment with another pp until you leapt in. That was the comment I was referring to as normal conversation.

InterIgnis · 13/10/2026 15:19

saraclara · 13/10/2026 15:14

No-one is saying that leaving a mess in the kitchen for nanny to clear up is acceptable. Nor is questioning baby giving the vitamins that OP wants her children to have. But that's already being addressed, and nanny now knows how to respond if it happens again.

Those are relatively small things, and given that there are now strategies in place, and the nanny appears genuinely okay with the visits , I don't think those 'sins' are any reason to deprive the grandma of her visits.

Edited

OP isn’t threatening that as a first resort. She wants to tell MIL to stop, or else the visits will have to reduce. MIL could quite easily avoid that by stopping.

InterIgnis · 13/10/2026 15:22

Calliopespa · 13/10/2026 15:14

I was commenting on the "fair share of nappies" comment with another pp until you leapt in. That was the comment I was referring to as normal conversation.

If I was directly replying to you I would have quoted you, as I would have quoted the PP that accused the nanny of having nefarious intentions when she ‘snitched’ to OP. I used both terms to make a general comment about the criticisms OP is receiving in this threads from multiple posters.

Calliopespa · 13/10/2026 15:23

InterIgnis · 13/10/2026 15:22

If I was directly replying to you I would have quoted you, as I would have quoted the PP that accused the nanny of having nefarious intentions when she ‘snitched’ to OP. I used both terms to make a general comment about the criticisms OP is receiving in this threads from multiple posters.

You quoted the phrase I used: "normal conversation."

InterIgnis · 13/10/2026 15:36

Calliopespa · 13/10/2026 15:23

You quoted the phrase I used: "normal conversation."

Indeed I did. I also quoted ‘snitched’ from another PP I wasn’t directly replying to. As I said:

I used both terms to make a general comment about the criticisms OP is receiving in this threads from multiple posters.

BCSurvivor · 13/10/2026 15:45

I think you're being quite unfair to the nanny.
It seems to increase her workload quite a lot when MIL is there, particularly with the cleaning up after her.

itsgettingweird · 13/10/2026 15:48

Yanbu overall in that she shouldn’t be treating your employee that way or interfering.

However your attitude overall towards MIL YABU. Nams aren’t just for helping out. They are the grandparents of your children. She obviously wants a relationship and drives a long way weekly to maintain that.

Id guess some of her pushiness also comes from the fact she feels your coldness.

Just sit and talk to her. Explain that you appreciate she did a great job raising her DS - you married him after all. But when it comes to yours and DHs children you’ll make the rules and she can come and spend fun time with them within those boundaries.

Calliopespa · 13/10/2026 16:03

itsgettingweird · 13/10/2026 15:48

Yanbu overall in that she shouldn’t be treating your employee that way or interfering.

However your attitude overall towards MIL YABU. Nams aren’t just for helping out. They are the grandparents of your children. She obviously wants a relationship and drives a long way weekly to maintain that.

Id guess some of her pushiness also comes from the fact she feels your coldness.

Just sit and talk to her. Explain that you appreciate she did a great job raising her DS - you married him after all. But when it comes to yours and DHs children you’ll make the rules and she can come and spend fun time with them within those boundaries.

However your attitude overall towards MIL YABU. Nams aren’t just for helping out. They are the grandparents of your children. She obviously wants a relationship and drives a long way weekly to maintain that.

I think this is what it comes down to for me. The MIL is trying to have a relationship with her DGC and driving that far each week is making a significant effort.

Yes, there have been a few comments about vitamins etc, but surely all that requires is a short request to please not do that as "it puts nanny in an awkward position - wanting to not ignore you, but also trying to do what we have asked."

There isn't any need for all this rhetoric about how much better the nanny is and how there really is no call for MIL to ever even enter the picture: she isn't needed, she isn't wanted, the dc have an alternative "grandmother." The OP makes quite a point of that and it is just disrespectful, hurtful and actually quite a belittling way to discuss her. I find it hard not to think MIL will have picked up on that attitude. Let's hope not. It is unnecessarily unkind.

To me the bigger issue here is the GM should be being asked over when the nanny isn't there.

DaringlyDizzy · 13/10/2026 17:13

You keep banging on about not needing Granny for childcare. That isnt the point. The granny wants to be a granny and be part of family life! Thats a given. Society is so insular now. Cripes

Summertimesadnessishere · 13/10/2026 17:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

coronafiona · 13/10/2026 17:51

You sound like hard work and uncompromising and she sounds like she is jealous and feels left out,

CoatsforGoats · 13/10/2026 18:24

Tough for your nanny here - she is basically babysitting an additional charge once a week!

I don't think you're being unreasonable. MiL sounds like she is deliberately undermining your nanny and yourselves.

The black spot here is your DH's relationship with his mum, it sounds like it isn't particularly strong?

Mapletree1985 · 13/10/2026 18:24

thepariscrimefiles · 13/10/2026 13:18

So why doesn't she change any nappies then? In her first post, OP says

'If there’s a poonami the nanny changes it whilst MIL has a cup of tea.'

OP's MIL could easily offer to change the nappy but she doesn't. She makes a mess when baking with OP's children and leaves the mess for the nanny to clear up.

None of this really bothered OP until her MIL started criticising the nanny. MIL obviously looks down on the nanny as the 'help' and doesn't realise that the nanny is indispensable to OP, her MIL less so.

Because the nanny is paid to change the nappy.

independentfriend · 13/10/2026 18:29

I might try saying to your mother in law that:

  • undermining the nanny in front of the children is confusing and makes her job harder for the rest of the week
  • regardless of her help you need the nanny to provide childcare that accommodates your work. If the nanny leaves you'll have to replace her (ie. not lots of extra Grandparent time) so she must stop with the comments.
  • there's room for her as a grandparent (and for the other grandparents) but the nanny is part of the family too (I know boundaries wise that might not be how you see each other, I'm thinking of how to convey to your MIL that the nanny is important)
  • the best way she can help is to collaborate with the nanny and follow her lead - they can have a child each / do an activity that's better with two grown ups etc

Grandparents operating looser rules only works well when it's occasional not when grandparents are doing very frequent care.

Would it work for the nanny to drive the children half way towards where she lives to a National Trust type place or similar so they can have a bit of a day out together?

It's probably more work for you but can you / the nanny create and leave a task for your MIL to do - making fish cakes could be an option?

OutAndAbouting · 13/10/2026 18:40

Your thread has made me feel incredibly sad OP. It seems to be more an opportunity to discredit your MIL than to ask for advice for your nanny, who from what you've stated seems to be coping pretty well, perhaps, who knows, even with a good understanding of the situation and the importance of the role of a grandparent.

There is no support, love or understanding anywhere in what you've said, actually for anyone from what I can see. it comes across as rather heartless, particularly towards a woman who just wants to provide what she believes to be assistance for your family and grandchildren, and indeed to spend some time with them.

gratefulmezze · 13/10/2026 18:45

Do you think the nanny is fuelling the fire by feeding back every little comment? If I was her I'd just let it go (I'd think...'oooh she's a bit of a meddler' and leave it at that).
Surely putting up with her charges families is par for the course?

Awkwardisfunny · 13/10/2026 19:03

ThatCosy · 13/10/2026 02:06

Jesus. Don't say any of that. Can you imagine being on the receiving end of a condescending dressing down like that?

Share your ideas then. Easy to tear others down. And the OP seems to be about to say much worse(!) and frankly: this GM deserves it based on the OP.

I'll wait for your input though. I'm not reading every thread to check if you already did. Best to include it directly in your criticism next time.

saraclara · 13/10/2026 19:04

gratefulmezze · 13/10/2026 18:45

Do you think the nanny is fuelling the fire by feeding back every little comment? If I was her I'd just let it go (I'd think...'oooh she's a bit of a meddler' and leave it at that).
Surely putting up with her charges families is par for the course?

I doubt that's it. OP had given the nanny chance to say if she doesn't want Grandma there, but she says it's fine. She just wants to know how to respond when these comments are made

I also don't agree that Grandma is adding significantly to the nanny's workload. She shouldn't be needing to clear up baking mess, but Grandma is entertaining the children for the afternoon, which presumably lightens the nanny's load somewhat.

This is all pretty much small fry. Grandma just needs a) reminding that nanny is employed by the OP so has to follow her rules, and b) asking to clear up if she bakes with the children. That should sort the problem without any drama

Elsieandme · 13/10/2026 19:12

I’m writing this through gritted teeth on your behalf . Do you think it would be possible to take her out for the day, lunch , afternoon tea…. And put your most diplomatic head on and explain that the children love to see her and you’re happy they’ve got a close relationship and that your nanny is brilliant , she never questions your instructions and that you run a happy organised home but you also appreciate that it’s very different from when she was raising her son. You really don’t want to upset nanny as she feels uncomfortable when you’re not on board with certain things. Could you just let everything go and let nanny carry out our family rules and just enjoy being grandma .

i know you’d like to tell her to butt out but at times you have to kill them with sweetness .

Anonymouseposter · 13/10/2026 19:17

Why is it that you don’t trust your MIL’s judgment to the point that you don’t want her to be alone with the children? I would be giving the Nanny a half day off. It sounds a bit uncomfortable for both of them particularly as you’re referring to the Nanny as a second grandmother.

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 19:28

Anonymouseposter · 13/10/2026 19:17

Why is it that you don’t trust your MIL’s judgment to the point that you don’t want her to be alone with the children? I would be giving the Nanny a half day off. It sounds a bit uncomfortable for both of them particularly as you’re referring to the Nanny as a second grandmother.

where did the Op say that?

Anonymouseposter · 13/10/2026 19:36

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward @godmum56 .
Although now I read in more detail I can see a few possible reasons.

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 19:52

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 19:28

where did the Op say that?

i meant about the second grandmother?

Anonymouseposter · 13/10/2026 19:58

godmum56 · 13/10/2026 19:52

i meant about the second grandmother?

We have a brilliant nanny who has become like a second grandma to the children. She genuinely goes above and beyond her job and we absolutely love her.

saraclara · 13/10/2026 20:02

Anonymouseposter · 13/10/2026 19:36

I’ve also told DH that I’m not comfortable leaving MIL alone with the children. He agrees that’s fair so the nanny is always there. I don’t particularly trust MIL’s judgement and I’m not going to pretend otherwise just to avoid an awkward @godmum56 .
Although now I read in more detail I can see a few possible reasons.

Edited

Have I missed something? What has OP said that indicates that her children are not safe alone with their grandma?