Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were previously on the fence about Lucy Letby’s guilt, have the Thirlwall findings swayed you either way?

539 replies

KwellsBells · 16/09/2026 14:53

I personally have always thought she is guilty, and even more so since the report findings were published.

YABU - still on the fence/ still believe she is innocent

YANBU - she’s guilty

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FrippEnos · Yesterday 19:27

Just when you think that the incompetence couldn't be any lower.
I am genuinely curious as to what will come out next.

TheFlandersPigeon · Yesterday 20:17

Does seem to be one thing after the other. It might not have made any difference to the jury being told this, but the point is it should really have been their decision.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 20:40

That's certainly damning. But somewhat familiar, which is odd.

That article is from today's Guardian, and they refer to having previously reported on this - in fact I remember a thread on here from some months ago saying something along those lines about that same expert.

Yes, this one:
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5498364-lucy-letby-case-expert-witness-was-under-fitness-to-practise-investigation

And that one is based on this article, from March 2026:
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/mar/03/lucy-letby-case-expert-witness-peter-hindmarsh-was-under-fitness-to-practise-investigation-during-trial

Today's article is more detailed, but not qualitatively different. So I wonder what has changed that has led to a whole new article on the same FTP issue? Is there some other development that sheds more light on this one? Or am I missing something massively significant that wasn't in the March article?

Lucy Letby case expert witness was under fitness-to-practise investigation during trial

Exclusive: Jury was never told about inquiry into key prosecution witness Peter Hindmarsh, which looked into allegations including of harm to patients

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/mar/03/lucy-letby-case-expert-witness-peter-hindmarsh-was-under-fitness-to-practise-investigation-during-trial

MistressoftheDarkSide · Yesterday 21:31

I think possibly the earlier article wasn't as specific about the area of concerns, there was if I recall some question over what those concerns actually were. Now it seems it was due to things relevant to the insulin cases and his expertise, not wider "hormone" related issues.

From a legal stand point I suppose it brings into question his level of expertise, plus rules around disclosure etc. Given the insulin cases were regarded as pretty much cast iron proof of harm, it doesn't look good that the proposer of this theoretical crime was possibly not as well qualified for the trial as it seems.

Be interesting to see if it moves things along at the CCRC.

kkloo · Yesterday 22:07

Emilesgran · Yesterday 20:40

That's certainly damning. But somewhat familiar, which is odd.

That article is from today's Guardian, and they refer to having previously reported on this - in fact I remember a thread on here from some months ago saying something along those lines about that same expert.

Yes, this one:
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5498364-lucy-letby-case-expert-witness-was-under-fitness-to-practise-investigation

And that one is based on this article, from March 2026:
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/mar/03/lucy-letby-case-expert-witness-peter-hindmarsh-was-under-fitness-to-practise-investigation-during-trial

Today's article is more detailed, but not qualitatively different. So I wonder what has changed that has led to a whole new article on the same FTP issue? Is there some other development that sheds more light on this one? Or am I missing something massively significant that wasn't in the March article?

The initial articles were vague, and a lot of people, particularly on the guilty side of the Letby case ran with the theory that the fitness to practice investigation had been related to him being critical of using hormones for transgender children because they may harm, and that the complaints were not related to his other work as a doctor.

This new article then clears that up, and also makes clears that some of the complaints against him were regards to his advice regarding insulin, which is very important considering the case.

XenaSharples · Yesterday 22:31

I wouldn't find her guilty.

Dolphin37 · Yesterday 23:47

Hodgson also said Hindmarsh had questioned the reliability of an insulin antibodies blood test result, sharing “his concern with the family that this was an erroneous, fallible test”

...yet neglected to share that at the trial around the same time?

Quitelikeit · Today 12:25

@XenaSharples

You we’re not at the trail - those in attendance found her guilty!

isitmadnessorwine · Today 12:27

Quitelikeit · Today 12:25

@XenaSharples

You we’re not at the trail - those in attendance found her guilty!

Edited

With rather a lot of salient information missing.

But if the stance is merely ‘she was found guilty, so she is, end of’ we won’t agree.

EyeLevelStick · Today 13:13

Dolphin37 · Yesterday 23:47

Hodgson also said Hindmarsh had questioned the reliability of an insulin antibodies blood test result, sharing “his concern with the family that this was an erroneous, fallible test”

...yet neglected to share that at the trial around the same time?

I don’t think that this test is the insulin/c-peptide immunoasssay. I think it’s a test for insulin antibodies.

XenaSharples · Today 13:37

Quitelikeit · Today 12:25

@XenaSharples

You we’re not at the trail - those in attendance found her guilty!

Edited

On faulty evidence that they assumed was reliable.

FinchiePink · Today 14:00

I'm actually shocked by the recent updates on Hindmarsh. In the circumstances I cannot see how his testimony can be relied upon.

It really seems to me that the case and all of the evidence MUST be re-tried. I cannot see how this conviction can be deemed safe.

Dolphin37 · Today 15:56

EyeLevelStick · Today 13:13

I don’t think that this test is the insulin/c-peptide immunoasssay. I think it’s a test for insulin antibodies.

Yes, sorry, I should've read it closer.

EyeLevelStick · Today 18:50

Dolphin37 · Today 15:56

Yes, sorry, I should've read it closer.

I did a double take too.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page