Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wishing DS was a little more like DD

154 replies

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:39

I have twins, not long turned 18, both in last year of sixth form. They are like chalk and cheese. I know neither of them are bad kids and I'm very lucky but sometimes I catch myself wishing DS was just a little more like DD.

Context

  • DD is predicted 4A* at A-Level, goes into school early most days to study and stays an hour late for supported study/independent study, she works her but off quite frankly
  • DD has a part time job, saves most of her weekly wage
  • DD keeps her room/car clean and tidy
  • DD is organised and responsible
  • DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)
  • DS is less motivated predicted BCC but claims he will get that up, needs AAB for his first choice uni!! He barely studies though so not sure how he's planning to get the grades up
  • DS had a job and quit, didn't like that his sister was earning more so thought the solution was to give up all together
  • DS is like a tornado, leaves a trail of destruction where ever he goes and can be quite lazy, not very organised either, relies on DD telling him his timetable everyday !!
  • On the other hand you won't meet a nicer funnier lad, he's great to be around just can't get his head screwed on!!

Now I know that being bitchy is an issue and we do call DD out but really I'm banking on the world putting DD in her place (DD has always been that kid that is good at everything and matched with her being very attractive by societies standards she can be quite a lot to handle, although her work ethic, drive, organisation and general ability to be on top of things can't be faulted). However I find DS much harder to parent now, we end up shouting over the mess he leaves (room is his problem but social space). While DD literally doesn't stop, always busy, DS never seems to start, some times it's like time moves slower in his world. Somehow DD has time for a job, study, sport, socialising and alone time, but DS seems to do none of that (I don't even know what he does seems to just sleep eat and go to school!!).

I guess it comes down to yes DD is a bit bitchy but she has a lot of respect for DH and I, and while the world seems to be on DDs side I'm not sure how I can help with that (other than calling her out whenever she makes a bitchy comment). She has friends, she works hard etc.
Where as for DS be needs a lot more parenting, and I was hoping by 18 he'd be a lot more self-sufficient than he is.

We never let on to the kids that this is how we feel but it does make me wish DS was a little more like DD.

AIBU for feeling this way? Anyone have any advice on how I can help either of them with the areas they need to work on?

OP posts:
MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 01/02/2024 10:11

Issue is the one DS likes most would make sense for him to stay at home so I'm slightly hoping that changes, the independence would do him good. would you be happy with dd staying at home?
Also just because there's no formal acknowledgement she's been a bully at school, doesn't mean she's not!

Futb0l · 01/02/2024 10:12

The time to be working on your DS attitude to work was about a decade ago

I think often we overlook certain traits in childhood that can be a bit more common in boys, from my experience with my kids a lot of little girls seem rather industrious and intrinsically motivated with school work. However boys usually get more motivated when the results start to matter and pull it out of the bag for GCSEs.

My DS can be a bit bone idle, but he's primary school age and to be honest, we are not letting him be.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 01/02/2024 10:16

The 'nice but dim' vs 'cruel but charismatic and capable' dichotomy people are getting stuck on rather assumes that what one cares about is the effect your kids have on the world, rather than how good their own lives are.

Fact is, people who are selfish, self-focused, determined and capable will do better by and large than someone kind, because that's the way the wicked world works. It would be nice to think that employers, friends etc will make choices that are just and give the charismatic bully their comeuppance at some point; but in reality this rarely happens.

Employers may say they want someone who will gel with the team, be nice and easy to get along with etc, but in reality even more than that they want someone capable and efficient who puts the hours in and gets the job done - it's a company not a commune. We all have those senior colleagues who are abrasive and even downright unpleasant at times, but everyone tolerates them because 'that's just what so and so is like', but they keep getting raises/promotions because, fundamentally, they get the job done. And everyone pussyfoots around them because they're untouchable.

People may say they value kindness and humour above physical attractiveness and charisma (and money) but in reality this rarely plays out. Think how many women on here are bewailing their awful husbands but can't leave because they gave up their job as he was such a 'high earner'. How many abused women who say they feel like they're going mad because everyone else thinks their husband is 'so clever, so funny, so charming, the perfect guy'. These people are seldom thrown on the relationship scrapheap for their shortcomings. They may go through friends and partners but they'll always have them.

So OP seems to be of the view that she wants her kids to be happy themselves, rather than make others happy. Either that or, from a purely self-interested perspective, she wants her kids to be successful and thus reasonably self-sustaining. At the moment she sees DD on track for that, whereas DS gives her more worry, is 'harder to parent' (i.e. he still seems to require some) and is more likely to not leave home or to boomerang back rather than getting on with ploughing his own furrow like DD. This is why she is more worried about his lack of practical skills and get up and go than her daughter's lack of compassion or kindness.

RaptorTruck · 01/02/2024 10:24

She is charismatic and charming.

Shes not. You’ve said she’s bitchy, mean and a bully. If this is how her own parent sees her, I imagine she’s much worse in real life. People will try to keep on her good side, but in the end, no one will really like her. Why are you so in awe of a mean, bullying bitch? I’d be so disappointed if my children were like that. There’s a huge difference between being assertive, which is a good thing, than what you’re describing, which is most definitely not.

I feel for your son, his own parent thinks a bitchy, mean bully is preferable to him.

You’ve backtracked a lot too since your first post.

Sort yourself out before you lose your son, although this is so awful, is it even true? If it is, you’ll be here in 10 years complaining your son doesn’t bother with you...and your ‘assertive’ daughter sounds like she’ll look out for herself so maybe she won’t either.

Some parents. 🙄

Flatulence · 01/02/2024 10:49

You have the children you have and it's your job to nurture them and help them be the best they can be. That's not about grades - it's about being good, decent, people who find a path in life that makes them content.
With that in mind though, I'd rather have a child like your son than your daughter. Being a bitch about someone's looks is horrible.

RosyappleA · 01/02/2024 10:54

I would be more more encouraging with DS and try to figure out ways with helping him find another job, pointing out his qualities and helping him save. We are all built very differently. He needs more support and the world needs very different people.
You sound just like my mum. It was the same with me and my brother, he is still very messy and struggled with school and money but he has since fought a decade of illness and ill-fate but has turned his life around and earns more than me and is overall the best guy you could meet. He has proven to be the most mentally and physically resilient person ever much to my parents disbelief. We all have different qualities and strengths. Try to support him he may well surprise you one day.

BotanicalGreen · 01/02/2024 10:56

Just because someone is hard working, highly academic and successful, conventionally good looking and socially popular it doesn't mean that you should condone a mean streak. My DD is all those positive things you describe but to me, first and foremost, she is a genuine, loyal, compassionate and kind person who doesn't look down on others, naturally champions the underdog and stands up for her values. I place far more importance on these character traits and I feel that they are what is her very essence. Nobody is totally perfect of course but from what you have written your son's imperfections are more palatable than your daughter's. As an aside, when I am employing someone, a key factor is how they will treat others in my team. That might not be something that would be initially evident at interview but it would show itself in time and would certainly influence progression.

Bedroomconfig · 01/02/2024 11:02

I feel like this thread is a reflection of what the lad's life must be like. It all seems to have become about his sister.

I say the op needs to forget the sister for a minute. She's fine, she's sorted.

The son is who he is. He is not going to morph into a male version of his sister as much as you may wish it. Focus on helping him with the stuff he's struggling with. It sounds like he struggles socially - can you help and encourage him with that? He says he plans on getting his grades up - can you help and encourage him with that? It says something that he wants to stay close to home - does his confidence need building? Don't try and force him to be his sister but try and help him to have the best life he can - as himself.

gannett · 01/02/2024 11:03

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

I would hope that any parent would be able to see that their children's value is far greater than just their worth to an employer.

"Who would I rather hire" is such a messed-up way to assess your own children.

Becomingolder · 01/02/2024 11:11

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

I realise that it might feel like there has been a bit of a pile on to your dd and its natural to want to defend her. However read this post back and think what your son would feel if he were to read it. Then hand on heart have a long hard think about whether this attitude shows through in your interactions with him

Urgenthelplease · 01/02/2024 11:18

You sound quite unpleasant. I'd be devastated if my mum called me twatty and bitchy in your dds case and lazy in your dss. I get you're feeling defensive but your kids aren't stupid, they will know exactly how you feel about them and that will hurt.

Devilshands · 01/02/2024 12:20

AgentProvocateur · 01/02/2024 04:43

Being nice is a hugely important quality. Your DS will learn about time management etc as he gets older. On the other hand, bitchy judgmental people - in my opinion - never change.

This tbh.

You're so blinded by your DD's achievements that you fail to realise that, actually, her issues are a fundamental personality flaw that cannot easily be fixed.

All the issues with your son are likely ones he will grow out of.

CurlewKate · 01/02/2024 12:25

I don't know which I would employ-but I know who I wouldn't want to be friends with- the person who calls her own dd bitchy, a bully, mean and twatty. That's who.

RawBloomers · 01/02/2024 12:57

TimeIhadaNightCapwithSanta · 01/02/2024 09:54

My sibling sounds like your dd. Seems to have a lot of friends, yet fir some reason has always been jealous of my friendships. Has been horrendous to friends of my mum's, who only put up with her for mum's sake. Mum is scared of her and has damaged our relationship due to this.

Oh, and sibling is in her 50s. The world has yet to sort her out.

That doesn’t sound anything like the dd OP has described.

RawBloomers · 01/02/2024 13:04

ohdamnitjanet · 01/02/2024 09:19

If I was interviewing him I wouldn’t know any of this though. I do hire, actually, and haven’t made a mistake yet. Personality and humour go a long way in my industry. There’s a place for everyone.

But you’d know his qualifications and previous experience weren’t nearly as good. And when you asked him questions you’d find out he wasn’t as well prepared. That’s if he managed to turn up for the interview.

okayokokay · 01/02/2024 13:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

lieselotte · 01/02/2024 13:08

This is why being an only child is good. You don't get compared with your sibling!

Although you can get compared with your "perfect" friends instead...or your parents' friends' "perfect" children.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 13:14

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

It's beyond sad to see a mother writing this about her children. I hope he finds people who list his good points and encourage him to develop, instead of telling him he's not as good as his sister. You should be ashamed.

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/02/2024 14:27

@Pheebee

“I think people have misunderstood what I meant by bitchy and a bully. She's never actually bullied anyone, she's kind. However she has high standards for herself and can be bitchy when they aren't met (especially food quality or similar)”

can you give an example op?

Bogofftosomewherehot · 01/02/2024 14:38

So you say this....

  • "DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)"

but also that people are being mean as they don't like a strong assertive woman and that she's not a bully at school.

Hhhhmmmmm - based on your first comment I doubt that she's all sweetness and light at school. She also sounds shallow and horrible if she is a bully when it comes to peoples looks. Maybe nice to her friends but horrible to those that don't meet her acceptable criteria.

I knew a girl like this - straight A student, popular, sporty and a nasty little madam who, unbeknownst to her adoring mother was a covert bully - putting down other girls who she regarded as less clever, less good looking, less popular, less successful. Like your daughter, she might go far in life but will she be truly liked???....... I doubt it. I feel sorry for your son.

onlythebrave3 · 01/02/2024 16:09

OP you sound horrid, calling your own daughter bitchy multiple times. I'm almost inclined to believe this is made up stereotypes to get us going. Girls that clever and with their life together so much are rarely the ones bitching about others appearance. Usually people unhappy with themselves are the ones who are unkind. If your daughter is as ' bitchy' , horrible misogynistic word, as you say then you've let her down and you need to focus your parenting there, do you always model speaking kindly of others? Is she unhappy about something?

FarmGirl78 · 01/02/2024 17:20

If I didn't have to have any contact with them whatsoever, not meetings, not emails, not water cooler moments, not anything, as a work colleague I'd pick your DD as a fellow employee. Because I could rely on them try get their job done.

As an employer who was purely looking at results, not the wellbeing and happiness of my employees, I'd pick DD.

Every single other thing I'd pick your DS instead.

As for expecting the world to bring her down a peg or two..... in the meantime there'll be at least one or two friends, colleagues, etc who will feel massively crushed and depressed due to her nastiness and bullying. There will be people who suffer for many, many years from her jibes and bitchiness over their looks. She might be popular, fun and have plenty friends but being a high maintenance diva mean girl overrides all of that.

How can you help her apart from calling her out every time she makes a bitchy comment? You sit her down calmly, and tell her you are mortified at this aspect of her personality, ask her who the hell she thinks she is to dig at people because of their LOOKS, and what a massive effect this can have on someone mental health. You tell her that grades, results, salary etc don't matter to you compared to her stopping with the nastiness. Spell it out to her that being the office bitch is not a label she will want in the real world. You are still a parent even though she's 18 - you do the job you're hoping the world might do. You spell it out to her.

sl0th · 01/02/2024 17:38

I hope you don't show your clear favouritism of your DD around your poor DS!

Your DS sounds lovely and I know who I'd rather be friends with. Do you stop your DD when she's bullying your DS?

Doone22 · 02/02/2024 07:56

It's too late to change them. Only thing that matters is their happiness and they can only make that happen for themselves, your job is only to offer support and advice now when asked. Leave them both alone.

motheronthedancefloor · 02/02/2024 07:57

Your DS will find his own way. He could end up more successful than your DD but in his own thing. Leave him be. His grades still seem good and even if he doesn't get into his first choice, there will be other choices. Uni and the world of work will teach them loads. PS is your DS dyslexic? Everyone I know with dyslexia is shit at time management and punctuality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread