Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wishing DS was a little more like DD

154 replies

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:39

I have twins, not long turned 18, both in last year of sixth form. They are like chalk and cheese. I know neither of them are bad kids and I'm very lucky but sometimes I catch myself wishing DS was just a little more like DD.

Context

  • DD is predicted 4A* at A-Level, goes into school early most days to study and stays an hour late for supported study/independent study, she works her but off quite frankly
  • DD has a part time job, saves most of her weekly wage
  • DD keeps her room/car clean and tidy
  • DD is organised and responsible
  • DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)
  • DS is less motivated predicted BCC but claims he will get that up, needs AAB for his first choice uni!! He barely studies though so not sure how he's planning to get the grades up
  • DS had a job and quit, didn't like that his sister was earning more so thought the solution was to give up all together
  • DS is like a tornado, leaves a trail of destruction where ever he goes and can be quite lazy, not very organised either, relies on DD telling him his timetable everyday !!
  • On the other hand you won't meet a nicer funnier lad, he's great to be around just can't get his head screwed on!!

Now I know that being bitchy is an issue and we do call DD out but really I'm banking on the world putting DD in her place (DD has always been that kid that is good at everything and matched with her being very attractive by societies standards she can be quite a lot to handle, although her work ethic, drive, organisation and general ability to be on top of things can't be faulted). However I find DS much harder to parent now, we end up shouting over the mess he leaves (room is his problem but social space). While DD literally doesn't stop, always busy, DS never seems to start, some times it's like time moves slower in his world. Somehow DD has time for a job, study, sport, socialising and alone time, but DS seems to do none of that (I don't even know what he does seems to just sleep eat and go to school!!).

I guess it comes down to yes DD is a bit bitchy but she has a lot of respect for DH and I, and while the world seems to be on DDs side I'm not sure how I can help with that (other than calling her out whenever she makes a bitchy comment). She has friends, she works hard etc.
Where as for DS be needs a lot more parenting, and I was hoping by 18 he'd be a lot more self-sufficient than he is.

We never let on to the kids that this is how we feel but it does make me wish DS was a little more like DD.

AIBU for feeling this way? Anyone have any advice on how I can help either of them with the areas they need to work on?

OP posts:
Lemonyyellow · 01/02/2024 08:48

Your DS probably thinks what’s the point because DD is your golden girl and outshines him at everything.

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 01/02/2024 08:48

But you also say she can be a bully in addition to being bitchy and judgemental

I suspect she has a lot of (superficial) friends for that very reason - she's top bitch

I'd rather put up with thy a bit of messiness and lower grades personally

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 01/02/2024 08:51

And I also have boy girl twins too by the way. I see similar personality traits and they are 3 - son is messy a whirlwind emotional but loving and kind. Daughter is fiercely independent, driven, bossy and yes she also picks her on her brother

ohdamnitjanet · 01/02/2024 08:55

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 01/02/2024 04:49

Seems like you should be wishing your dd could be more like your ds.........believe me when I say it's people like your son that others choose to and want to be around. That will get him further than paper results.

Definitely, I know who I’d want to spend time with, or employ.

Iwasafool · 01/02/2024 08:56

AgentProvocateur · 01/02/2024 04:43

Being nice is a hugely important quality. Your DS will learn about time management etc as he gets older. On the other hand, bitchy judgmental people - in my opinion - never change.

Very true. I can't imagine valuing school grades of the character of my children. I'd find it hard to cope with the bitchiness.

gannett · 01/02/2024 09:01

Out of the OP and her kids the one with the biggest issue is the OP. She's taken comparing them to an unhealthy level and is very defensive about it; I hope her favouritism isn't as obvious in real life as it is on here.

Both kids sound like normal teenagers who need to shape up in different ways but who nonetheless have a lot going for them. Being a bit mean or a bit lazy at 18 is par for the course, though possibly OP should be working on improving those things rather than banking on life to do it for her. Most mean and lazy teenagers do grow out of it but we all know adults who never did.

aarghnotmeagain · 01/02/2024 09:01

You do realise your son is also comparing himself to DD? No wonder he’s not trying if he knows he will always fail in comparison to her.

I really feel for him.

Iwasafool · 01/02/2024 09:02

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:42

I love that everyone here seems to know my DD better than I do!!

Getting a feeling that people are hating on DD because DS is the underdog and no one likes a driven, assertive woman! Last I checked sarcasm isn't a sign of disrespect and I've clarified what I meant by the other comments!

We are going on your description. It comes across that you like the fact you can brag about your clever/popular/attractive daughter and poor son is just a nice person, nothing to report.

I hope he finds people who appreciate him.

OrlandointheWilderness · 01/02/2024 09:04

So one is judgemental, bitchy and mean and one is kind and funny?!? Yep think you need to reevaluate your values there OP! 😂

Iwasafool · 01/02/2024 09:06

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:54

@romdowa

Fear not, he has bullied her back in spades - pretty sure it's normal for siblings to pick on each other!!

That didn't come up in your original descriptions of them. Are you finding it hard that people aren't wowed by your amazing daughter?

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

OP posts:
Walking2024now30days · 01/02/2024 09:11

Josette77 · 01/02/2024 05:11

Some people think he's grumpy and insular according to your DD? The same one who's bitchy and judgemental?

Sorry but that line made me legit laugh.

@Josette77 that's what I was about to say!!

@Pheebee yes, you are being very unreasonable & judgemental, not difficult to see where DD gets it from.

its no wonder DS is the way he is. He will 100% know DD is your favourite, in your eyes better at everything & he'll be less motivated to be his best self until he's living independently.

MerryMarigold · 01/02/2024 09:13

Sorry your DD is getting a hard time. It's easy to latch o in to what everyone what is saying. OP, I have b/g twins and it's similar except DS is the naturally talented one (F currently rather wasted) and DD is the hardworking one.

With twins I think they do go 'opposite' as a way to build their own character. Try not to encourage that too much by 'typecasting' them. It's also true that often we start assuming a 'role' in certain situations and get trapped in that role. Family is a classic space where we take o km a role and end up stuck there. My older DS is like this, he can't take any initiative at home but outside home he calm, confident and amazing. It sounds like your twins have quite 'stuck' in these roles. It doesn't sound particularly pleasant for either of them. Hopefully as they leave home (and each other) your DD will learn how to relax, I'm sure seeing her bro being so good at it will give her ideas. And your DS will learn to work harder. It's all there for both of them. Your DDs lifestyle seems a bit unsustainable so I do hope she doesn't crash out.

Frankly, I would rather my children were happy than successful. I mean really happy, secure in who they are, not trying to prove anything to anyone.

CurlewKate · 01/02/2024 09:13

Maybe stop listening to what your dd tells you about ds?

Iwasafool · 01/02/2024 09:15

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

Retired HR manager here. I've found young people like your son can become excellent employees, fit into a team and develop. They often thrive working in a situation that is very different to school.

People like your daughter can be a nightmare and disrupt teams. If they survive that they can do well but they don't always cope well working with older people who won't care how attractive they are and who will frequently be irritated by the know it all new member of the team. It can be a steep learning curve although university will probably knock some corners off.

On top of that there are careers where being nice is important, the caring professions are obvious, anything that involves interaction with customers/the public are less obvious but being able to make people feel respected is a positive, making them feel judged less so.

Please stop comparing them and value your son.

ohdamnitjanet · 01/02/2024 09:19

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 09:06

@ohdamnitjanet

I'm sorry but why would you want to employ DS who

  • Quit because his sister was making more (and working more)
  • Doesn't know his own timetable 3 weeks into the 2nd term
  • Can't clean up after himself
  • Has no drive to succeed or study

Over DD who

  • Holds down a part time job and works overtime in holidays
  • Studies diligently
  • Is responsible and is able to plan her own time effectively
  • Is tidy and organised

If you are after a friend or someone to play Xbox with DS is your man.
If you want a good employee then it's DD hands down

Being nice doesn't make him a good employee and If you'd pick the lazy nice lad over the ambitious, driven hard working albeit a bit twatty at times girl then you're crazy!! I hope you don't have to hire anyone!

If I was interviewing him I wouldn’t know any of this though. I do hire, actually, and haven’t made a mistake yet. Personality and humour go a long way in my industry. There’s a place for everyone.

PerfectTravelTote · 01/02/2024 09:22

She studies, is motivated, is organised, is a hard worker, gets good grades.

He does none of the above.

This is not an unusual difference in girls and boys of the same age.

...and yet he will likely earn more than her.

You don't need to worry about him. It's a man's world.

anythinginapinch · 01/02/2024 09:22

Sounds v like my twins OP. It's bloody hard having twins and imo a disaster for a boy in boy/girl twins as the speed of development in children means girl twin outpaces boy twin at every stage not because she's "better" but because girls develop faster than boys. But to the pair and their parents it SEEMS like the girl is "better" at everything meaning her confidence grows while his declines.

My DS is just about finding his feet, sort of, at 25. My DD is still flying through life. Their relationship is ok but that's because my DD puts 99% of the sibling effort in.

MerryMarigold · 01/02/2024 09:25

Ps. Also, your DS sounds amazing. My DS1 is also 18. He hasn't got a job, he's predicted BCD if he works hard - currently CDE. He plays Xbox and watches football all the time. He has no friends and rarely goes out. He has no idea of what he wants to do except that he doesn't want Uni. He's very insecure, he suffers with many issues. I'm just glad he's not overly stressed about A levels and is in a happier space than 2 years ago.

My twins are quite different. But life is long. Who knows what is around the corner for each of them? I don't think I've ever wished he was like them, because he's very unique. It's not easy watching what he goes through but it's made him who he is. I do sometimes wish life was easier for him, but again that would mean he's not who he is and I wouldn't want him to be a different person. His Dad does wish him to be different and they have quite a hostile relationship now.

anythinginapinch · 01/02/2024 09:26

And I'd like to see people without twins have a go at not comparing them - it's almost impossible not to for the first decade or so. Oooh look, Jane's got that dummy all by herself. Ah, jimmy, still walking on his knees... Jane can count to 20! Jimmy god love him can't get beyond 5 yet. ...
My two absolutely wish they were not twins but siblings - as do their parents if being totally honest

PinkyFlamingo · 01/02/2024 09:27

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:28

I agree totally, luckily they have applied for all different unis so the independence will do them well. Issue is the one DS likes most would make sense for him to stay at home so I'm slightly hoping that changes, the independence would do him good.

I think people have misunderstood what I meant by bitchy and a bully. She's never actually bullied anyone, she's kind. However she has high standards for herself and can be bitchy when they aren't met (especially food quality or similar). The bullying is mainly towards her brother (infact I'd say entirely).
She's very well liked and her confidence and high standards will do her well in the world!
I also think it's funny people think DS can change but DD can't. I think all teenagers can be a little bitchy or atleast the once I've known but turn out mostly as decent adults!!

There is so much wrong with this, you say people have misunderstood what you mean by "bully". It's quite a straightforward word really. That she doesn't bully anyone. Well if she doesn't bully anyone why call her a bully? Then you say oh well apart from bullying her brother! So she is a bully, nothing to misunderstand there.
And you say her confidence and high standards will do her well in life. Not necessarily as there is a fine line between confidence and arrogance.

determinedtomakethiswork · 01/02/2024 09:32

It must be quite hard for your son living with such a paragon of virtue especially as he will know far more than you just how bitchy your daughter gets.

Moving away from home will probably be the making of him.

TimeIhadaNightCapwithSanta · 01/02/2024 09:54

My sibling sounds like your dd. Seems to have a lot of friends, yet fir some reason has always been jealous of my friendships. Has been horrendous to friends of my mum's, who only put up with her for mum's sake. Mum is scared of her and has damaged our relationship due to this.

Oh, and sibling is in her 50s. The world has yet to sort her out.

Rosesanddaisies1 · 01/02/2024 10:00

You're being absolutely awful to compare them like this. Your poor DS. it's the absolute worse thing you can do as a parent. They are individuals, and should be treated as such. He's probably already struggling with a high achieving sister. You need to support him to do what he enjoys, whether academic or not. If you keep going down this road, you are going to lose him very fast.

Venturini · 01/02/2024 10:04

Isn’t it parenting 101 not to compare your children like this? Good grief.