Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wishing DS was a little more like DD

154 replies

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:39

I have twins, not long turned 18, both in last year of sixth form. They are like chalk and cheese. I know neither of them are bad kids and I'm very lucky but sometimes I catch myself wishing DS was just a little more like DD.

Context

  • DD is predicted 4A* at A-Level, goes into school early most days to study and stays an hour late for supported study/independent study, she works her but off quite frankly
  • DD has a part time job, saves most of her weekly wage
  • DD keeps her room/car clean and tidy
  • DD is organised and responsible
  • DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)
  • DS is less motivated predicted BCC but claims he will get that up, needs AAB for his first choice uni!! He barely studies though so not sure how he's planning to get the grades up
  • DS had a job and quit, didn't like that his sister was earning more so thought the solution was to give up all together
  • DS is like a tornado, leaves a trail of destruction where ever he goes and can be quite lazy, not very organised either, relies on DD telling him his timetable everyday !!
  • On the other hand you won't meet a nicer funnier lad, he's great to be around just can't get his head screwed on!!

Now I know that being bitchy is an issue and we do call DD out but really I'm banking on the world putting DD in her place (DD has always been that kid that is good at everything and matched with her being very attractive by societies standards she can be quite a lot to handle, although her work ethic, drive, organisation and general ability to be on top of things can't be faulted). However I find DS much harder to parent now, we end up shouting over the mess he leaves (room is his problem but social space). While DD literally doesn't stop, always busy, DS never seems to start, some times it's like time moves slower in his world. Somehow DD has time for a job, study, sport, socialising and alone time, but DS seems to do none of that (I don't even know what he does seems to just sleep eat and go to school!!).

I guess it comes down to yes DD is a bit bitchy but she has a lot of respect for DH and I, and while the world seems to be on DDs side I'm not sure how I can help with that (other than calling her out whenever she makes a bitchy comment). She has friends, she works hard etc.
Where as for DS be needs a lot more parenting, and I was hoping by 18 he'd be a lot more self-sufficient than he is.

We never let on to the kids that this is how we feel but it does make me wish DS was a little more like DD.

AIBU for feeling this way? Anyone have any advice on how I can help either of them with the areas they need to work on?

OP posts:
Pheebee · 01/02/2024 06:10

Quirrelsotherface · 01/02/2024 06:09

Girls like your daughter are 'popular' at this age because none of her peers want to be bullied by her.

Geberal life will be a different story. I can see you or maybe an upset MIL posting here in year to come about a narc dil causing problems..

Just to clarify - she has never bullied anyone at school!!!

OP posts:
JustMarriedBecca · 01/02/2024 06:11

The fact someone is popular at school, where there is to some extent a cycle of fear of going against the popular kids, does not prepare them for real life. By 23-25, most young people have figured out they don't NEED to suck up to these formerly popular kids and gravitate elsewhere.

I'd say you need to focus on making your DD a kinder and more understanding person - because bullying isn't just physical - it's mental too and "comments and being bitchy" are going to bite her in the arse.

GoodO · 01/02/2024 06:25

Frankly your emphasis on grades and constantly comparing them is awful.
Love the children you have (all of them) not the children you wish you had.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 01/02/2024 06:27

Is he wanting to go to university? Is he wanting to go to university in September? It sounds like he might possibly consider a year out. I would maybe try going out for coffee with him and having a chat about what he is wanting to do. It can be very easy in sixth form to get caught up in the flow of A levels, straight to uni etc. He needs to know that it is a choice and if he wants to earn and go travelling in a gap year first then that is fine too. Do encourage him to do some work, however it sounds like your dd is pushing herself really hard with the studying and that might not be needed either. It must be very hard having such an immediate comparison in the same house. He can never live up to her so he may as well not try.

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/02/2024 06:44

OP, you sound, frankly, dazzled by your dd's 'driven', 'ambitious', 'successful', 'high standards' personality and you're getting very defensive indeed when people voice how she comes across in your words. Did you come here to reflect on an issue that does have the potential to become quite serious and damage your relationship with your son and their sibling relationship, or did you just want confirmation that it's fine for you to feel like this? I'm not entirely sure I believe the backtracking on the bullying., tbh. She's critical of 'how people look'. Not just her brother, 'people'. That's bloody awful, actually, and will not endear her to anyone later in life - and suggests that for all her drive and ambition etc etc, she's quite shallow underneath. Perhaps she embodies, in your mind, the energy and success you don't feel you had, and your ds has qualities you struggle with in yourself? Or perhaps you're one of these 'driven' people and are loving seeing your mini-me? I don't know, but I do know your uncritical adoration of your dd despite what sounds like some quite serious flaws (and it is uncritical - you've listed them expecting people to tell you they don't matter and how marvellous she is and now they haven't, you're basically trying to minimise them or turn them into positives), and the negative comparison to your ds who may just be a little behind in the maturing stakes and need some time to find his way, are not healthy.

ArtificialElephants · 01/02/2024 06:47

AIBU for feeling this way? Anyone have any advice on how I can help either of them with the areas they need to work on?

Yes you are BU and that needs to change, I think.

Wishing your son was a bit more hardworking is one thing. Wishing he was more like his sister is quite another - and is very toxic.

My own brother got that a lot (not from my parents thank god, but from schools etc). Always being told it would be good if he were a bit more like me. Always being seen as the less driven, less clever one.

All it did is show how wrong everyone else is. He is the far more driven and clever one. He is phenomenal and that fact that so many people were blinded to it just because I was more 'traditional' just shows them all to have been stupid and shallow.

30 years later and he is more obvious in these traits. And he is the more successful of us.

Champion who he is and love him for who he is. Do not compare him to his sister - even in your mind. It is a damaging way to conduct a relationship and likely to bite you in the arse, in time.

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/02/2024 06:48

Tink2345 · 01/02/2024 05:36

Perhaps the fact she can be bullying towards has affected his behaviour, what is the point in trying hard if he’ll never be up to her standards? I’m not casting aspersions and it may be unintentional but what may seem a small comment to DD may be a huge criticism to DS.

I think this is very insightful, especially if, as you indicate, OP, she's always been competitive and wanting to be 'first'. She's certainly claimed the lion's share of your positive attention.

goingrouge · 01/02/2024 06:52

@Pheebee you've massively backtracked about your daughter and her personality. You've said she's kind but a bully especially about people's looks. Both things can't be true, she's not a kind person.

You've called her bitchy but said she's popular. I agree with others that she sounds like the school 'mean girl' that people keep on side because they don't want to go against her.

She may well be very successful in life but she needs a shift in attitude and behaviour if she wants genuine friendships and relationships.

I feel really sad for your son as it sounds like he's in his sister's shadow and whatever he achieves won't be as good as her.

Maray1967 · 01/02/2024 06:53

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 01/02/2024 04:49

Seems like you should be wishing your dd could be more like your ds.........believe me when I say it's people like your son that others choose to and want to be around. That will get him further than paper results.

Agreed. I have boys - and yes, both could put more of an effort in, but the eldest did get a first and his chosen graduate job, and neither are bitchy/cruel. Basically DS1 got his act together when it counted, having coasted a bit in earlier years, and I think that DS2 is getting there earlier.

I would not be expecting the world to sort out your DD, I would be tackling that head on now. It’s great that she shows you respect, but she needs to extend that to others.

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/02/2024 06:54

I also think the poster who said teen boys aren't necessarily motivated to be the best is onto something. I have two teen boys. They are very different in a number of ways, and one is more effortlessly able academically than the other -. and does get top grades - but neither of them are after those grades for the sake of it. They are also close, and I'm sure that wouldn't be the case if we constantly compared them rather than taking them each for the individuals they are.

NewYearNewCalendar · 01/02/2024 07:00

People are defending your son because you’ve described how much you prefer his sister!

You’ve massively backtracked on your daughter. So can she be a bully about people’s looks or not? You don’t have to bully people directly to be a bully - is she the type who would take the piss out of how someone on TV looks? Do you dismiss that as “victimless”. I’m sure she will be successful and popular, I just doubt that you or she really care about how many people she steps on to get there.

Hopefully, both of your kids will grow out of their immaturity. But your role is to celebrate both of their strengths, as well as pulling them up on their weaknesses. Stop thinking your son needs to be more like his sister and start thinking about what version of himself he can become.

goingrouge · 01/02/2024 07:03

Also, parents who say their kids don't know how they feel are deluded. They know and it will be very clear where the preference lies.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 07:10

Your DS sounds like a nicer person tbh.
You have to accept they're different people though, stop comparing them!

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 01/02/2024 07:11

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:55

Before I start - not saying it's ok for DD to be bitchy ofcourse it isn't.

But DD has a lot more friends than DS, she always has, very popular. She is charismatic and charming. In my experience charismatic, charming, driven, dedicated people tend to both have more friends and go further in life than the nice guy. I'm not saying it's fair but it's definitely true in my experience.

Charismatic, charming and.....bitchy?
Not the sort of person I'd choose.

distinctpossibility · 01/02/2024 07:12

Are you not just parenting an introverted male and an extroverted female? So why would the two be similar?!

My kids are all so different and it's actually very little to do with their sex, though that does play a part too. One of my kids came out absolutely dissatisfied with the world, she's a striver and works so hard. One of my other kids is so laid back but seems to get through life on a smile. Sometimes I wish they'd rub off on each other but then they wouldn't be them! Yet another is one of those kids who knows facts - this is wonderful party trick but they're also the kindest and most thoughtful person, though prone to temper tantrums. Finally I have a class clown who is fun to be around and very engaging but a big, messy, non-academic labrador really.

It's ok. They all turn out ok As long as you love and support them for who they are. It's common for boys to be less mature than girls and neither of yours are perfect. Neither of them are the devil, either.

FaiIureToLunch · 01/02/2024 07:13

My children are very bright but have it drummed into their heads that treating people well and having a moral compass is the most important thing.

your daughter ain’t all that.

Bedroomconfig · 01/02/2024 07:16

Do you think he's known from a fairly young age that he will always be compared and can't compete so he's given up? It might not have come from you but other adults and kids might have made him feel that he's the 'lesser' twin.

I think the post upthread from the person with twins is probably right. He needs to be away from her to flourish.

I also think us parents aren't as good as hiding our feelings as we think so you need to get out of the mindset of 'i wish he was more like his sister'. He sounds like he has some great qualities. Focus on those and encouraging him to get the grades he needs for the unis he wants to go to.

Shoppingfiend · 01/02/2024 07:21

Children take after their DPs even though it’s not obvious when young.
So who are they inhertiting their less likeable characteristics - obviously you don’t think it’s you -DH must have a lot of conflicting characteristics! Also neither you nor DH went through life with a popular, admired ,preferred twin - not conducive to bringing out the best in you.
DS is leaving home soon but you seem exasperated by his behaviour -surely you can hand on a few more months.

Shydelta · 01/02/2024 07:24

You can wish it all you like, but you won’t change them. They are now old enough that they will have to deal with the consequences of their own actions in working or not working and so on. It’s not uncommon for girls to do better at school and even university.

My third child has Asperger’s and performed poorly at school and when he was very young, I used to compare his performance and feel sad. But he is a lovely boy, wonderfully easy to get on with and now he’s left school and doing something he actually wants to do, rather than something he can’t see any point in, he’s thriving and doing much better.

I wouldn’t try to change your son. You’ll just be bashing your head against a wall. Support him if he doesn’t get his first choice university. You have to wait really until he finds his own way, which he will, but it may not be until he’s a good bit older,

makeanddo · 01/02/2024 07:35

I think it's easy to say you've treated them equally and I'm sure you've tried however it sounds as though your DD is much more extrovert so perhaps gets a lot of attention from everyone and is constantly praised?

Your DS clearly needs to find his own way and perhaps it's difficult when everything he does is 'out done' by his sister. That said given up his job because she earns more is pathetic!

Anyway he'll either get his act together and do well, likely better than your DD because he has male privilege or he'll claim that life is unfair and not even try. Either way it sounds as though he has every opportunity- you can lead a horse to water and all that.

Lastly you mention your DD has to remind him if his timetable. Do you all 'mother' him? If so stop it, you're doing him no favours, treat them the same.

velvetstars · 01/02/2024 07:42

I feel for your DS. From what you've said it looks entirely like he's grown up in his sister's shadow. Whatever he did she did faster, better and it likely seemed easier for her (right from learning to read which boys are often naturally later at doing). I can see why it would out him off trying?

Worse still, he seems to have parents who idolise this 'perfect' sibling, even though you admit she bullies him.

You say he quit a job because he got paid less than his sister but you don't appear to see that it's likely an embodiment of every other aspect of the two of them growing up.

I agree he needs to move away from the family home for uni, so he can break this 'less than' dynamic that's he's spent the last 18yrs becoming comfortable with. The expectation is he'll never be as good so lo and behold he now isn't. He needs people who just see him, not him next to his perfect sister.

For what it's worth though, I'd take your DS over an unkind DD any day.

RawBloomers · 01/02/2024 08:06

TheVintageMum · 01/02/2024 05:33

Surely that's just being a teenager? I remember my Mum constantly having to remind me to pick up after myself. I'm now a 36 year old woman, I went on to get a degree, have a fulfilling career, get married and have my own family. I did not fail in life because as a teenager I was a bit absent minded and forgot to tidy up after myself. Not sure why the OP is focusing all her concerns on her DS whilst praising her DD who by her own words is prone to being judgemental and bitchy.

Yes. I think the “faults” OP describes for both her children are pretty typical of teens and given some space and time they’ll probably both become great adults.

But I was talking about the fact several posters are calling him kind when there’s nothing in OP’s post that details anything her DS does that’s kind. His actions that she has described, while totally common and not necessarily anything like the way he’ll be in 10 years time, are not kind. He’s lazy. He gets his sister to pick up slack for him. He leaves others to pick up after him. This may be typical and not a reflection of the man he will be but none of it is kind. It’s not like the OP has said he’s all these other things but he helps people out all the time. He’s just fun to be around (which many people who don’t concern themselves about responsibilities often seem to be).

GingerScallop · 01/02/2024 08:22

Apart from your ds quitting his job cos his sis earns more than him I think you have ok kids. They both have their strengths and flaws. Few days ago I saw the phrase: Parent the child you have not the one you want/wish for.
Because your post show that you favour your dd so much, its hard to say whether your son's laziness is the kind that turns him into a cocklodger or the one that is because of boredom, fear of failure, fear of being compared to a more successful sibling or another reason. But people are different. Work with that.
I was considered bright but lazy, unmotivated, kind, extremely chaotic, unable to groom myself. At 46, I have a good job, am terrible with money (don't over spend on luxury or nonsense but long story), chaotic, and still trying to figure out social cues, don't have friends. Yesterday I found myself wondering if I should be writing down what society expects of a 46 year old woman and try more to be like that (I know I won't stick to it as I never stick to anything). I was often compared to others and found wanting. Found different. Found weird. The thing is, am different. Every kid (and adult) should be loved and celebrated for who they are. Stop comparing your kids. It's very damaging

Cleo09 · 01/02/2024 08:32

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:57

I don't want it to come across like I'm defending DDs bitchiness I'm not.
But for those that think it makes her not very likeable etc. I'd say it's much the opposite, she has loads of friends, very well liked and fantastic at making new connections.
DS is friendly but shy and not very driven so has hardly any friends and some people seem to think he's grumpy/insular according to DD.

“I’d say it’s much the opposite” - yes probably because all the children would rather be “friends” with the “bitchy bully” than not. We’ve all been to school/watched films with the nasty/beautiful horrible ring leader. The children that follow around them do it to keep them onside/out of fear. Your daughter sounds arrogant and being mean about how others look have no place in society

MonsteraMama · 01/02/2024 08:43

Interesting how the golden child has gone from "bitchy, judgemental bully" to "driven, assertive woman" now the thread hasn't gone how you expected it to.