Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wishing DS was a little more like DD

154 replies

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 04:39

I have twins, not long turned 18, both in last year of sixth form. They are like chalk and cheese. I know neither of them are bad kids and I'm very lucky but sometimes I catch myself wishing DS was just a little more like DD.

Context

  • DD is predicted 4A* at A-Level, goes into school early most days to study and stays an hour late for supported study/independent study, she works her but off quite frankly
  • DD has a part time job, saves most of her weekly wage
  • DD keeps her room/car clean and tidy
  • DD is organised and responsible
  • DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)
  • DS is less motivated predicted BCC but claims he will get that up, needs AAB for his first choice uni!! He barely studies though so not sure how he's planning to get the grades up
  • DS had a job and quit, didn't like that his sister was earning more so thought the solution was to give up all together
  • DS is like a tornado, leaves a trail of destruction where ever he goes and can be quite lazy, not very organised either, relies on DD telling him his timetable everyday !!
  • On the other hand you won't meet a nicer funnier lad, he's great to be around just can't get his head screwed on!!

Now I know that being bitchy is an issue and we do call DD out but really I'm banking on the world putting DD in her place (DD has always been that kid that is good at everything and matched with her being very attractive by societies standards she can be quite a lot to handle, although her work ethic, drive, organisation and general ability to be on top of things can't be faulted). However I find DS much harder to parent now, we end up shouting over the mess he leaves (room is his problem but social space). While DD literally doesn't stop, always busy, DS never seems to start, some times it's like time moves slower in his world. Somehow DD has time for a job, study, sport, socialising and alone time, but DS seems to do none of that (I don't even know what he does seems to just sleep eat and go to school!!).

I guess it comes down to yes DD is a bit bitchy but she has a lot of respect for DH and I, and while the world seems to be on DDs side I'm not sure how I can help with that (other than calling her out whenever she makes a bitchy comment). She has friends, she works hard etc.
Where as for DS be needs a lot more parenting, and I was hoping by 18 he'd be a lot more self-sufficient than he is.

We never let on to the kids that this is how we feel but it does make me wish DS was a little more like DD.

AIBU for feeling this way? Anyone have any advice on how I can help either of them with the areas they need to work on?

OP posts:
TheVintageMum · 01/02/2024 05:33

RawBloomers · 01/02/2024 05:26

Not sure why people think the lad is kind. He won’t look after shared spaces and he dropped his job because he doesn’t like his harder working sister being able to earn more than him. Those aren’t the action of someone who’s particularly kind.

Surely that's just being a teenager? I remember my Mum constantly having to remind me to pick up after myself. I'm now a 36 year old woman, I went on to get a degree, have a fulfilling career, get married and have my own family. I did not fail in life because as a teenager I was a bit absent minded and forgot to tidy up after myself. Not sure why the OP is focusing all her concerns on her DS whilst praising her DD who by her own words is prone to being judgemental and bitchy.

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:34

SusanSHelit · 01/02/2024 05:30

On the other hand you won't meet a nicer funnier lad, he's great to be around just can't get his head screwed on!!

DD has her flaws too though, she can be quite bitchy and a bit mean, definitely have issues with her being judgmental and a bit of a bully (especially when it comes to how people look)

This implies he's much kinder than his sister

I guess it's subjective. DS keeps himself to himself so while he isn't ever bitchy he also doesn't exactly have many opportunities to show kindness. He is a nice lad though, in that he is respectful of other people etc. but so is DD. He's also extremely funny - DDs sense of humour is all wit and sarcasm where DS is genuinely funny. They both have their pros and cons, DD is just easier to parent and realistically has the characteristics required to go far in life (we can hate on this and say it's not fair but it's true!!)

OP posts:
RantyAnty · 01/02/2024 05:34

Aren't you being judgmental by calling her a terrible gendered slur?

She sounds pretty amazing and assertive, and that why she'll go far in life.

Did you coddle and not expect much from your son? Many mothers coddle their male children.
They get away with being lazy and shiftless as long as they're charming. And being lazy and messy isn't kind.

SusanSHelit · 01/02/2024 05:35

Bullying her brother, apparently under your watch is even worse. You're not making this look any better op.

Bullying is abhorrent, no matter who is doing it or who is on the receiving end.

RawBloomers · 01/02/2024 05:35

No. It implies he likes a laugh and and a joke.

If he were several years older he’d be the loser bf everyone is telling a poster not to have kids with.

Tink2345 · 01/02/2024 05:36

Perhaps the fact she can be bullying towards has affected his behaviour, what is the point in trying hard if he’ll never be up to her standards? I’m not casting aspersions and it may be unintentional but what may seem a small comment to DD may be a huge criticism to DS.

IkeaMeatballGravy · 01/02/2024 05:37

Your DS doesn't deserve these feelings from you OP. Your focus should be on helping your DD be a kinder person and not a bitchy, judgemental bully.

It honestly reads like your DD is your golden child and the golden child does tend to become more charismatic.

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:38

RantyAnty · 01/02/2024 05:34

Aren't you being judgmental by calling her a terrible gendered slur?

She sounds pretty amazing and assertive, and that why she'll go far in life.

Did you coddle and not expect much from your son? Many mothers coddle their male children.
They get away with being lazy and shiftless as long as they're charming. And being lazy and messy isn't kind.

Interesting, hadn't through of bitchy being gender specific but suppose it is.

We never expect more or less from either but from a young age DD had more drive.
She learnt to read first, was keen to do her hobbies all the time etc. DD has just always liked being busy and working hard.
DS on the other hand like to take things slow. We never made him go to clubs if he didn't want to and let him spend his time as he wished.
Upon reflection I wish we pushed him harder at times. He has a quitters attitude (not going my way so I can't be bothered) where as DD has more of a I find this challenging which motivated me even more to achieve it attitude.

The expectations were the same though.

OP posts:
SusanSHelit · 01/02/2024 05:38

Your DD isn't respectful of other people if she is judgmental and sarcastic fyi.

Easier to parent doesn't make her better or preferable to her brother but they will both be fully aware of who the golden child is.

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:40

SusanSHelit · 01/02/2024 05:35

Bullying her brother, apparently under your watch is even worse. You're not making this look any better op.

Bullying is abhorrent, no matter who is doing it or who is on the receiving end.

Oh give off, he gives just as much back as he gets. They are twins they pick at each other. My siblings and I always did and always haves
DD has a much tougher skin though while DS will take it to heart.
We tell her off and when under 18 we punished her. Now it's harder to punish her as she pays for her own phone etc. so we won't take something that is hers off her.

OP posts:
Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:42

SusanSHelit · 01/02/2024 05:38

Your DD isn't respectful of other people if she is judgmental and sarcastic fyi.

Easier to parent doesn't make her better or preferable to her brother but they will both be fully aware of who the golden child is.

I love that everyone here seems to know my DD better than I do!!

Getting a feeling that people are hating on DD because DS is the underdog and no one likes a driven, assertive woman! Last I checked sarcasm isn't a sign of disrespect and I've clarified what I meant by the other comments!

OP posts:
BananaSpanner · 01/02/2024 05:45

How do you deal with DD bullying DS?

I feel for him, he’s not stupid. He will be fully aware of his shortcomings compared to her. I can almost see his logic of giving up his pt job so he doesn’t have to deal with the reality of earning less than hjs sister for presumably owning roughly the same hours. Just another stick to beat himself up with.

How do you make him feel good about himself? I would imagine if she is this star pupil with loads of friends then she gets loads of validation. It’s so sad that she is unkind to him. Does anyone in the house big him up and make him feel good about himself or is it all about pointing out his shortcomings.

Your daughter bullying her twin brother even though she has all these social advantages (charisma,looks, aptitude etc) is really not great.

Like pp says, separate unis and finding his own place in the world could be the making of him.

I think you need to work harder to recognise his good qualities. Make a list here if you like. Then focus on them in real life.

BananaSpanner · 01/02/2024 05:47

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:42

I love that everyone here seems to know my DD better than I do!!

Getting a feeling that people are hating on DD because DS is the underdog and no one likes a driven, assertive woman! Last I checked sarcasm isn't a sign of disrespect and I've clarified what I meant by the other comments!

To be fair all people have got to go on his your own description of DD. Bitchy, judgemental and a bit of a bully. Most of us are women who will have known those teenage girls remember.

Ladyj84 · 01/02/2024 05:48

Erm having twins what the heck has that got to do with anything. I would never compare mine or any of my other children I think that's horrible and you wonder where the bitchiness comes from. Children are like animals they feel vibes off you. I feel heart sorry for your son tbh fancy growing up around this and parents that he apparently doesn't meet there expectations. You say you don't stand in one's corner yet it comes across loud and clear that the daughter is a fav. Horrible I will love every one of my kids for themselves not because there twins,singles,brainy or whatever

WandaWonder · 01/02/2024 05:49

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:42

I love that everyone here seems to know my DD better than I do!!

Getting a feeling that people are hating on DD because DS is the underdog and no one likes a driven, assertive woman! Last I checked sarcasm isn't a sign of disrespect and I've clarified what I meant by the other comments!

"driven, assertive woman" female (or male) this is not code for being a nice a person, it weird you never used this in you op unless I missed it but only when people picked you up on how you expressed your own daughter

BananaSpanner · 01/02/2024 05:50

Yeah, I know several driven assertive women who are also nice people.

romdowa · 01/02/2024 05:51

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:28

I agree totally, luckily they have applied for all different unis so the independence will do them well. Issue is the one DS likes most would make sense for him to stay at home so I'm slightly hoping that changes, the independence would do him good.

I think people have misunderstood what I meant by bitchy and a bully. She's never actually bullied anyone, she's kind. However she has high standards for herself and can be bitchy when they aren't met (especially food quality or similar). The bullying is mainly towards her brother (infact I'd say entirely).
She's very well liked and her confidence and high standards will do her well in the world!
I also think it's funny people think DS can change but DD can't. I think all teenagers can be a little bitchy or atleast the once I've known but turn out mostly as decent adults!!

I'm sure being bullied his whole life by his sister hasn't helped your ds 😔

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:54

@romdowa

Fear not, he has bullied her back in spades - pretty sure it's normal for siblings to pick on each other!!

OP posts:
Tink2345 · 01/02/2024 05:55

He may give back as good as he gets, but if he sees her succeeding him and being supported where he isn’t it will still affect him. We can all be bitchy and shout when needed, doesn’t mean we have the confidence to back it up, and it does sound like you have an overachieving confident sibling who you’ve admitted likes to bully her brother and a more mild mannered twin who isn’t as sure of themself.

thebestinterest · 01/02/2024 05:57

AgentProvocateur · 01/02/2024 04:43

Being nice is a hugely important quality. Your DS will learn about time management etc as he gets older. On the other hand, bitchy judgmental people - in my opinion - never change.

THIS!!!!

GaryLucyusedtobemycrush · 01/02/2024 05:57

i have boy girl twins of a similar age. They are also chalk and cheese although not necessarily in the same way your two seem to be (neither are expecting those kind of high grades and neither work amazingly hard.). However DD is definitely a lot more judgy and DS is a lot more chilled. I think you need to realise your DS sounds like a decent lad who will hopefully do well in life. Most boys of this age aren’t super motivated to be the best of the best. As long as he’s attending college, keeping himself away from illegal substances, has some friends and is respectful I’m sure he’ll turn out ok.

Noicant · 01/02/2024 05:59

I like driven assertive women, thats not the same as women who say unpleasant things about other people or bully people. I don’t consider that assertive, assertive people can project themselves on the world in a calm and measured way without lowering themselves to being horrible to other people. I actually see bitchiness and bullying as a character flaw, it’s difficult to take people like that seriously.

Honestly I think you need to work on your DD, your son will probably be fine once he isn’t at home being bullied by your DD or compared to her.

SusanSHelit · 01/02/2024 06:04

Noicant · 01/02/2024 05:59

I like driven assertive women, thats not the same as women who say unpleasant things about other people or bully people. I don’t consider that assertive, assertive people can project themselves on the world in a calm and measured way without lowering themselves to being horrible to other people. I actually see bitchiness and bullying as a character flaw, it’s difficult to take people like that seriously.

Honestly I think you need to work on your DD, your son will probably be fine once he isn’t at home being bullied by your DD or compared to her.

Edited

This.

Assertive and bitchy /bully are two very different things.

TheVintageMum · 01/02/2024 06:09

Pheebee · 01/02/2024 05:42

I love that everyone here seems to know my DD better than I do!!

Getting a feeling that people are hating on DD because DS is the underdog and no one likes a driven, assertive woman! Last I checked sarcasm isn't a sign of disrespect and I've clarified what I meant by the other comments!

No, I quite like driven and assertive women. I worked my way up to a senior role in my chosen field so I like to think I am one.

Quirrelsotherface · 01/02/2024 06:09

Girls like your daughter are 'popular' at this age because none of her peers want to be bullied by her.

Geberal life will be a different story. I can see you or maybe an upset MIL posting here in year to come about a narc dil causing problems..

Swipe left for the next trending thread