Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended that SIL told me to return a gift I got for her?

335 replies

chicosmommy · 10/01/2024 19:50

I try to buy my Christmas gifts early in the year, during sales and times when there might be discounts.

I was in Harvey Nics in September and I spotted a gorgeous jumpsuit in SIL's size and in a brand that she loves and wears a lot. It was 50% off. I bought it for her and kept it until Christmas Day to give it to her as her gift.

When Christmas Day came around, she opened the gift, scrunched up her nose at it and said these exact words, "urgh. I wouldn't wear that. Can you return this and get me a voucher instead".

I just took it back, said very little and today, I went in to try get the value of the jumpsuit in a voucher. The store told me that because it was bought in September, it is too far back and they can't give me a voucher.

Clearly, I don't want SIL to know that I'm buying her gift on discount so I ended up buying a voucher for her for £150 & I'm stuck with the jumpsuit, which I'll have to ebay or put on Depop (doesn't fit me).

What are people's thoughts on this? Is it very rude not to accept a gift and if you don't like it, just exchange it yourself? Should you expect the buyer/gifter to exchange it for you?

OP posts:
Spirallingdownwards · 10/01/2024 21:10

To be fair buying a jumpsuit was rather weird. They don't look good on anyone.

Sunflwer · 10/01/2024 21:10

She was rude but buying something as personal as clothes for someone is very risky. I'd have just thanked you and taken it into a charity shop.

tiktokontheclock · 10/01/2024 21:11

Don't buy people clothes, it's much too personal.

She is rude. My in laws are like this - will tell you straight up that they already have something etc. as someone brought up v differently I've been shocked by this. Also why I strongly encourage DD to always just say thank you no matter what the gift is.

Sell the jumpsuit on eBay/Vinted/depop and chalk up the loss.

horseyhorsey17 · 10/01/2024 21:12

Yeah she's rude but wow, how much do some people spend on Christmas? My gift to my SIL was about £20, and same in return!

justasking111 · 10/01/2024 21:15

I've given up being grateful for stuff husband buys. He did the Christmas week dash in TK MAXX . He'd gone in for a bag I nudged him for then got carried away. I now have a dress watch that catches on jumpers , dressing gown, a pair of mule slippers. I can't keep mules on so did ask him to exchange. He can't find the receipt.

I also asked him to send back a Fitbit he bought me. I loathe them and asked for a tree instead. This was back in the summer. I'm still waiting for the tree 🤷‍♀️

You've learnt something OP just do the Xmas week dash and keep the receipt safe

EasterIssland · 10/01/2024 21:15

mottytotty · 10/01/2024 21:05

How did OP not put thought in that gift? Did you read the OP?

People are entitled to not liking something even if they have similar things.

Goldbar · 10/01/2024 21:16

Just tell her you couldn't return it and give her a box of biscuits instead.

Wexone · 10/01/2024 21:17

like why did you get a voucher for 150e?
I totally agree you were a bit "huh" buying a jumpsuit. no matter how Well you knwo someone I don't think you should ever buy clothes for anyone unless they are with you and have tried it on etc.
clothes for kids is OK however always include gift receipts.
For all the people saying why buying for sis in law at all we don't buy for adults. some families different. we have kris kindle for adults both sides of family so you buy for two adults each and the value was 100e..I got a voucher off my sis in law for a spa hotel which going to get a nice massage soon thanks to her.
however I do think she was very very rude in her reaction to you. if it had of been me would have smiled said thanks and quietly tried to bring it back or put it up for sale if it was a designer

Butchyrestingface · 10/01/2024 21:18

Clearly, I don't want SIL to know that I'm buying her gift on discount so I ended up buying a voucher for her for £150 & I'm stuck with the jumpsuit, which I'll have to ebay or put on Depop (doesn't fit me).

Sorry, you're worse than she is.

Supersimkin2 · 10/01/2024 21:19

SIL Rude.

Keep the voucher and get her Milk Tray.

Please.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 10/01/2024 21:20

what did you spend on the jumpsuit? That should have been the value of the voucher.

She was rude but you were wrong buying clothes. I’d never buy clothes for anyone without it being within a return period and I’d include a gift receipt.

kisstheblarney · 10/01/2024 21:21

Get your DH to but his family presents.... sorted

TellySavalashairbrush · 10/01/2024 21:21

She was very rude but I’d never buy clothes for anyone as a gift. A voucher is always a winner. I’d have got her a £50 voucher , maximum though.

ZiriForGood · 10/01/2024 21:22

I understand the "polite thank you no matter what" on small gifts and more distant relationships. If it is something more expensive and closer relationship, it would feel weird to gratefully thank for it and than pretend it didn't happen/sell at loss. It would feel like lying to me.

Buying specific expensive clothing means a big risk the recipient might need to exchange it. You didn't have to buy a new gift voucher, but it would be better to think about this aspect beforehand.

EasterIssland · 10/01/2024 21:23

kisstheblarney · 10/01/2024 21:21

Get your DH to but his family presents.... sorted

Where does the op say she’s dhs sister? She could be her brothers wife

Dillane · 10/01/2024 21:23

How could she have returned or exchanged it herself OP? You didn’t give her a receipt.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 10/01/2024 21:29

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 20:54

But the OP says she didn’t want the SIL to know the gift was bought ages ago in a half-price sale. If she’d told the SIL to return it herself, that cat would have been out of the bag.

If SIL follows fashion and is a regular on Harvey Nics, Selfridges etc websites, and this is a brand she knows/likes/follows, she probably already knows it was on sale. 🤷‍♀️ So OP is being especially U to think she was ever going to get one over on her and actually that might have been why DSIL wrinkled her nose (who does that IRL though?) because she'd already seen it and chosen not to buy it.

OP is BU in the first place because of that inappropriate edit in her reply on P1.

And in the second place because £75 on a gift is batshit and £225 (the £75 jumpsuit and the £150 voucher) is triply batshit (put it in a calculator, it's literally three times the batshit).

Crazycrazylady · 10/01/2024 21:31

Honesty buying someone clothes particularly a jump suit which. An fit differently was always very risky. I would always rather that someone ask for. A gift receipt than simply bin it .

uncomfortablydumb53 · 10/01/2024 21:34

Clothes are always a risk, unless specifically requested
She was rude, but why did you give her £150 when you didn't even pay that for it?!

Cas112 · 10/01/2024 21:35

It's never a good idea to buy someone clothes as gifts

Awrite · 10/01/2024 21:39

As previous posters have said - don't reward bad behaviour.

If you became more assertive then you wouldn't be so out of pocket, resentful and in need of turning to Mumsnet for validation. Or just to vent I suspect.

BayCityCoaster · 10/01/2024 21:40

She was extremely rude.

But - you never buy people clothes, let alone clothes they can’t return. It’s a fool’s errand. Lesson learnt the hard way.

But given your editing of your second post, I guess you will abandon this thread, so 🤷🏻‍♀️

Hayliebells · 10/01/2024 21:41

She was very rude. But it's a really daft idea buying people clothes they haven't asked for, and even dafter to buy clothes that can't be taken back to the shop.

Falkenburg · 10/01/2024 21:46

She was right to say it wasn't something she could wear and would you be able to exchange it but her manner was downright rude and unpleasant.

It was a risk you took buying an outfit and outside of the returns time frame.

You shouldn't have bought a £150 gift voucher if you can't afford it.

Sell the item on Vinted and next year give her a token gift.

SecondUsername4me · 10/01/2024 21:49

What brand is the jumpsuit? What about popping into a branch of the make of the jumpsuit, rather than a dept. store counter and feigning that someone had gifted it you but it was too small, and ever so sorry they didn't keep the receipt, and see if they are amenable to you swapping for either a different item for you or a gift card?